Short non-spoiler review. 3.5 stars.
I must say, this was a lot more enjoyable on the second read. I hope this duology ends well, so that I can say for certain I am happy to have read it. I’m leaving my original review intact, because it’s still a decent summary of my thoughts.
So the Progeny revolves around Emily, who is really Audra, who in the first two pages of the novel undergoes a procedure which completely wipes her episodic memory. That is to say, she has no idea who she is, everyone she ever met is once again a stranger, and she has a blank slate. Except not really, and yes that is as frustrating as it sounds. Because Audra is Progeny, Utod, whatever you prefer. Which basically means she is a descendant of Elizabeth Bathory (aka the Blood Countess), and - unlike in real life - has the persuasive abilities that all Progeny are blessed with. The problem is that all Progeny are hunted by the Scoins - basically a group of fanatic murderers who are dedicated to wiping out all of Bathory’s descendants, because, you know, vengeance? Whatever. Point is there are currently more Scoins than Progeny and they’ve infiltrated like every organization. Bad bad bad. So, naturally, Audra gets to live freely for about five minutes before she’s promptly discovered and tossed back into her old, very dangerous life, without the benefit of her memory of what to do in life threatening situations or the names of anyone she used to trust.
Frustrating. Highly stressful.
The thing is that the whole memory thing is actually quite an interesting premise. And this book worked so hard to make it seem like life goes on, even without memory. But, in the end, it really doesn’t. Memory and experiences make up who a person is. You lose your memory, the person you were would be - for nearly all intents and purposes - pretty much dead. And I just couldn’t get that out of my head while reading, even though I knew I was supposed to.
However, writing a novel about the descendants of such a well-known serial killer was extremely interesting, all elements of urban fantasy aside. The conspiracy theories and segments of history were basically my favorite parts.
I don’t really have much to say personally. I enjoyed the book. I definitely plan to read the next one, if only because I now need answers. I want to make one thing clear, though. The blurb we have on here compares this book to, like, the Da Vinci Code, Orphan Black, etc. It is neither, none of those things. It was good, enjoyable enough, but it’s certainly no Orphan Black.