Shy farm girl Joni’s new friendship with animal rights activist Chess unravels when Chess’s views push Joni too far in this layered coming-of-age story about two girls and their love for horses.
Joni’s world revolves around her beloved horse, Archie, and her family’s Vermont sheep farm. When outspoken, sophisticated Chess moves nearby, Joni is drawn to her, even though Chess questions everything Joni loves—working horses, eating cheese, having pets, and even the farm itself. Torn between desperately wanting a friendship and resenting Chess’s assumptions about horses and farms, Joni mostly keeps her opinions to herself. But when Chess steals their neighbor’s miniature horses to “rescue” them, Joni finds the courage to stand up for her beliefs. With quiet intensity, this timely novel tackles the complex issue of bridging the political divide and building friendships while staying true to yourself.
Jessie Haas has written over 35 books for children and adults, many about horses--a lifelong passion. She currently owns a Morgan mare, Robin, who is being clicker-trained to be a trail and pasture-dressage horse. She lives in a small, off-grid house in the woods with husband Michael J. Daley, two cats and a dog. When not writing or riding or reading she likes to knit, cook, and write, or ride, or read.
Read as a read aloud with my 9 year old daughter at night. Started some interesting conversations about animal activists. Great horse story about feisty ponies and learning about what animals need rescuing, friendship, and speaking up about what you know/believe.
Thanks to the MA youth services review blog for the free book! (#partner) Joni lives on a sheep farm in rural Vermont and can't wait for summer; she's planning to ride her pony Archie every day to get ready for horse camp and spend lots of time with the new kittens on her family's farm. Then a new girl moves next door right before the end of school. Francesca, Chess, is from California. She is vegan and has strong opinions about how animals should be treated. Chess doesn't believe in owning animals and is especially offended by a neighbor, Mrs. Abernathy, who has her mini ponies pull her around in a cart. Joni and Chess start a complicated friendship; sometimes they have fun together, but Joni is uncomfortable with many of Chess' ideas. This is not the summer Joni expected. When Chess's ideas lead to action, she ends up putting animals in even more danger. Will Joni and Chess ever see eye to eye?
I just loved this book! I'm not even a horse person usually, but the ethical dilemma of animal rights versus the reality of farming life is so perfectly portrayed here. Readers will be fascinated by the implications of Chess's ignorance and the danger of misinformation. Both girls grow and change by the end of the book and the conflict resolves in a very realistic way. This is a must-buy for all elementary and middle school libraries; so many kids will find this one interesting and engaging.
To whom would you recommend this book? Animal lovers, horse lovers and students who want to learn more about animal rights will all like this book
Gr - 4-6 12yo Joni lives on a sheep farm with her family and her spirited horse, Archie. Joni’s family lives a simple life, shearing sheep, making cheese and taking care of their farm. Joni has school friends who live further away and she sometimes feels left out, even at horse camp. When Chess moves in next door, it seems like Joni will have a built in friend. Chess, however, is different from anyone Joni has ever known. Her family won’t be ‘farming’ their land. Chess is a vegan and an animal rights activist. When Chess questions Joni about eating cheese, whether the sheep are happy, if Archie wants to be ridden, Joni must think about things in an entirely new way. When Chess goes a step too far in her activism, letting out a neighbor’s miniature horses, one of the horses becomes injured. Joni has to decide how to stand up to her new friend and still maintain the friendship. Haas is an expert on all things horse and farm, and this makes the book very readable. Joni is a relatable character who is struggling with issues kids will be familiar with such as animal rights and sustainable farming. Joni must figure out what she believes, while remaining sensitive to her friend’s beliefs. A great read for kids who like horses and who are environmentally conscious. Recommended to fans of Riding Freedom, by Pam Munoz Ryan -Terry Ann Lawler, Phoenix Public Library, AZ
12-year-old Joni lives on a sheep farm, and even has her own horse. When a new self confident girl Chess, moves into their rural Vermont neighborhood, Joni finds her attitude and California ways intriguing. Yet as she gets to know her she is surprised at how judgmental she is about animal owners care of their pets. Even though Chess is confrontational, and haughty about her strong opinions on animal rights, she has very little background knowledge to back them up. This coming of age story covers topics such as animal rights, fake news, and lots of fascinating information on horse care, and types of horses. A great pick for horse lovers, and readers who prefer realistic fiction with convincing brave characters, who think for themselves.
I really like horse books and I like this book a lot. I can relate to Joni because she loves horses. When a new girl, Chess moves in, she becomes Joni's friend. Chess wants to help animals and keep the world a green place. She was a little dramatic for me and she felt a little preachy, so I didn't like that part. Chess takes some horses from a neighbor because she thinks the horses aren't treated right. Joni is scared to stand up to her friend. They have to work out their problems with each other. If the book had more horse things I would have rated it higher, but I liked it. (review by 5th grader, Elizabeth)
Rubbish. I’m not a horse person, but I know plenty of kids who enjoy reading about horses, so I though I’d give it a try. Terrible writing with flat characters who speak with lots of exclamations!!!!!
The author managed to make vegans look like nothing more than ignorant, bitter killjoys. The character of Chess was unbearable. She did a great job promoting negative stereotypes, I’ll give her that.
I wasn't sure how I was going to like this book with an Animal Rights theme but I ended up enjoying it. This is a Juniors book and I felt it was a good introduction for kids about being good animal stewards (respecting the animals we have care of and given them good lives) and about the (I'm going to call it DANGERS) of Animal Rights activism.
This was a very nice children's book about horses. A new girl from CA moves to Vermont and has strange ideas about having pets and the place people have in their lives. She soon learns that she needs to enlarge her understanding of animals.
Friendship is difficult between Joni and Chess. Chess is an animal rights activist and believed that all animals should be free, while Joni and her family keep goats and sheep to milk them. They work together to help each other understand each other's different points of view.
I did not really like it is sounded so interesting on the back but when i read it it was barely about that and it was dumb and it made it long for no absolute reason
Twelve year old Joni has lived her whole life around animals on her parent’s sheep farm in rural Vermont and has no reason to question her life until she meets a new neighbor named Chess from California. Chess is a vegan who doesn’t believe animals should be pets, work or be food for humans and this is diametrically opposed to all Joni has been raised to believe. Chess immediately zeros in on another neighbor’s treatment of her cart ponies and her insistence that they must be “rescued”. This confuses Joni as she respects the owner’s horse knowledge and she can’t see any signs of abuse which Joni knows about from her volunteer job at a horse rescue. When Chess takes a drastic step without Joni’s help or knowledge, it puts the ponies in serious danger that shakes the foundation of their new friendship.
This middle grade novel examines both animal rights and relationship issues when friends don’t agree on something. It will appeal to middle school readers who like a real life animal and horse story with a dramatic ending. I would recommend this book for purchase by any school or public library.
This book was provided by the publisher for professional review by SWON Libraries.