Dennis "Denny" O'Neil was a comic book writer and editor best known for his work for Marvel Comics and DC Comics from the 1960s through the 1990s, and Group Editor for the Batman family of titles until his retirement.
His best-known works include Green Lantern/Green Arrow and Batman with Neal Adams, The Shadow with Michael Kaluta and The Question with Denys Cowan. As an editor, he is principally known for editing the various Batman titles. From 2013 unti his death, he sat on the board of directors of the charity The Hero Initiative and served on its Disbursement Committee.
I think this is basically a story about the different levels of corruption in society. It kind of could take place anywhere. It's not a political treatise; it's more existential than political. So I guess I'd call it an existential crime story--now that's not something you come across every day. In fact, this is the first time for me in a comic format.
O’Neil you crazy son of a gun, what did I just read! That was great! The question is getting a bit of a darker refresh as he now makes his home in hub city. And while he’s here during the day he is tv host Vic Sage who has been running reports on the corruption in the city government, all while at night the blank faced question works to investigate and bolster the reporting of Vic Sage. This issue opens with one of those nights and a promise that in exactly 25 hours and 15 minutes Charles Victor Szasz will die. But on this night the question is waiting in anticipation to break down a door and get what he needs. The time comes and he is off, with some brutal combat. All while a woman watches. At one point the guys get the upper hand on him and try to rip off his blank face, but are completely unsuccessful. Once he has given them enough of a beating, they give him the tape located in safe that he came for. Then he leaves them his card. A blank card that smokes and forms a question mark. Once he gets back to his car that looks like a Volkswagen bug he deploys the special mist that allows him to remove the blank face mask and change his suit color back. But this isn’t just some random car, a few cops clocked it going around 100.
But where does Vic need to go so fast? Well to the news station of course, he’s on in a few minutes to deliver one of his weekly reports on corruption. He may be late but he delivered a hot story with the tape. Once he goes on he gives the signal for the tape to be played and shows all of his viewers, for a moment before the chief rips it off air, a portion of a blackmail tape used against the school commissioner. We get a glimpse at the parties behind the scenes that don’t like the reporting raining on their parades. Seems the reverend is the focal point behind any operations in hub city and has the daft mayor right in his pocket. But they are also joined by the woman who watched as the question took the tape earlier. It is none other than lady Shiva…and to hear that she hates violence is quite surprising. But what’s not surprising is hearing that she only acts when she is paid. And it seems that she will be getting called in very soon, as the boss is not happy. The guy who opened the safe for the question was made an example of and disposed of. But honestly I cannot see how they can’t put the question and Vic together as the same person. Come on, they would have shown up around the same time and Vic Sage wears a very similar suit while on air. It doesn’t even look like this version of the question has his hair change.
The next day the countdown for Charles Victor Szasz continues, and Vic pays a visit to Tot. It seems Tot is the one who designed his suit and special gas and formula he has in his after shave and woven into his suit to allow the mask to stick and clothes to change colors. Vic has a problem, during the fight from earlier he felt his mask slip. One thing that I also noticed is Tot may have memory issues. When Vic first arrived Tot called him Charlie…wait like the Charlie who is going to die soon? Either way, Vic said it doesn’t go by that anymore and they’ve had that convo multiple times. Tot notices that Vic started to smoke again, more than likely that is reacting with the chemicals and causing the bonding to slip. During this time Tot also brings up a pretty important question, can Vic handle this anymore? He’s going on thirty it has to be wearing him thin. “Tot, the question can do things. Vic save can’t. Things that have to be done. I need the question—“
Later on Vic Sage meets up with his on the street contact. That homeless man ended up getting into an altercation with a cop, and Vic put a stop to it. But while having a “civil” discussion the cop is shot by a bullet intended for Vic. Vic chases the man down as it’s one the men from the other night, and this was actually the man we as point blank killed earlier. But I think this is very important for answering a future question. The man survived and murder was attempt by a special air gun. He then thought he could get even by going back after Vic, but he just ended up in police custody. Right as Vic is turning the guy over, Vic runs into Reverend Dr Jeremiah Hatch. The man behind the scenes we have seen so much of, and who has learned a lot about Vic. Including his real name, Mr, Szasz! Vic doesn’t try and deny it and after a quick encounter they part ways. Later we catch a glimpse at one of his sermons, and learn that he fought in Vietnam and has quite brutal memories of it.
Later that night, Vic’s homeless informant gets a tip for a deal going down at the empty docks tonight. And I gets passed on to Vic, it’s an obvious trap but he has to go. He arrives as the question and is immediately confronted with Lady Shiva. But this time she is not holding back. In one page without any dialogue she puts him down. Her job is done and now the other goons go to work breaking every bone in his body. Until eventually the air gun guy comes in, delivers the final blow and they throw him over the side. We see as Vic sinks to the bottom of the water that his mask lifts off and floats away. But I mentioned a question that helped to be answered earlier. How does he survive? In part, that air gun has been established as pretty non lethal. The guy from earlier survived and Vic can to. The problem is Vic is also unconscious at the bottom of the ocean.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I have been hearing a lot about this character and wanted to know more about it, so I got the Kindle version that said (1986-2010) thinking it was going to be lengthy, but it's just 27 pages or so. Regardless, I thought it was someway interesting and very pulpy.
I haven't read this since back when it was originally published (in the olden days of paper) as a monthly comic. There's a lot going on in this introductory issue. Behind that beautiful Bill Sienkiewicz cover, writer Dennis O'Neil delivers a solid crime noir story that feels far ahead of its time. With the moody artwork of Denys Cowan and Rick Magyar delivering a solid tale from the opening page to the very brutal and unexpected ending. Just this one issue alone reminds me of SO many of the more modern crime comics I've read. I'm sure this series must have been an inspiration to many current creators of crime comics. So far, it definitely deserves to have a new audience. This title doesn't require any previous knowledge of comics or DC super hero mythos to enjoy.
I adore this series and character - and will always adore this series and character. The Question feels like a weird mix between Batman and Superman. It's definitely a weird story that's not for everybody but I love it and I hope however reads it does too. This series is pretty violent so watch out for that.
My first introduction to The Question was through the DCAU TV series, Justice League Unlimited. I loved him. So, when I saw the ebook of this was fairly cheap, I realized it was high time I actually read some of his origins. I was not disappointed. It was fairly standard comic book fair, but it was done well enough that I'll be grabbing volume two in the near future.