This novel is the eighth book in the Collins Burke series but is actually a prequel to “Sign of the Cross”, the first book Emery crafted about a hard drinking, music loving Irish priest named Father Brennan Burke and criminal defense lawyer Monty Collins set in Halifax Nova Scotia. This story takes readers back to 1989 when Father Burke was still in New York City and called to London by his older sister Molly who was in Halloway prison, accused of being a member of a banned terrorist organization. Brennan can tell by the sound of her voice Molly is trying to stay strong as she describes her incarceration, terrorized by both the staff and the inmates in a old building overrun by filthy rats. She has been threatened with anything from a fine to ten years in prison for her suspected crime. Brennan quickly contacts their brother Terry a commercial airline pilot and both quickly arrange to make the trip to London to help their sister.
After two days Molly is released, but that is not the end of her troubles. Special Branch is following her, believing that although she may not be directly involved, she may know something about the death of Detective Richard Heath, a policeman recently shot in the line of duty. It happened close to the time the police received a warning call about explosive devices planted in Westminster Abbey and the police believe the two events may be connected.
The Burke family has always been closely involved in Ireland’s fight for independence and Molly, a professor of history at the University of London, had recently delivered a paper at an academic conference that criticized Oliver Cromwell, the man well known for helping the English fight the Irish. He was responsible for the destruction of many Catholic churches and abbeys, destroyed villages and towns and massacred thousands during the English Revolution. Following the conference, the London police uncovered a plot to bomb the statue of Cromwell during a ceremony honoring his achievements and that discovery led them to arrest Molly. Unable to make the case against her, they released her, but since then Special Branch have been following her and have stationed a car outside her home to intimidate her.
Conn, the sibling's cousin is arrested and sent to Brixton prison, suspected in the shooting death of Detective Heath and for his part in the plot to blow up Westminster Abbey. In order to free him, Molly, Terry and Brennan search for the truth about the shooting and the plan to blow up the abbey, learning more and more about their family’s deep dark history with the republican cause along the way. Meanwhile Conn, who they believe knows more about the murder of the policeman than he is letting on, isn’t talking and is languishing in prison.
As Emery unfolds the story of the republican Burke family, played out in conversations in Molly’s flat, bars and a huge English estate, she also recounts a detailed history of the English/Irish conflict and the Burke family’s role in that history. Much of the dialogue includes Gaelic, helping to make the story authentic and placing it in the times it occurred.
The story showcases Emery’s meticulous attention to the historic record as she describes the tensions and conflicts that have simmered between the Irish and the English for years, trying to keep a neutral tone, advocating for neither side. Despite her efforts, it is clear the Protestant case receives less attention given the fact many in Northern Ireland viewed the Catholics as their oppressors rather than the British. That history has been long and violent, filled with incidents of torture, outright murder, bomb blasts and destruction. Women and children, often turned out of their homes, were often caught in the crossfire. At times the dark history threatens to overwhelm the story rather than being the backdrop to the history of the Burke family and the mystery Molly, Brennan and Terry are trying to solve.
Emery creates a novel with a mystery set against a violent history that includes a touch of romance, all the while asking readers to consider thought provoking questions about what constitutes a “just war”. What justifies killing? Who makes the decisions about what is to be done during a conflict and who is held accountable for the results? The complex question of what is right and what is wrong in war, the moral implications of not going to war and surrendering a population to continued oppression all arise in the dialogue between the family members as they try to solve the mystery of who carried out the crimes Conn is accused of.
This is another good addition to the series, a little heavy on the history side, but still a good tale with lots of twists and turns.