DNF @57% = automatic 3 stars
Writing style not for me. It was written as a stream of consciousness, but the narrative would go off on a side quest, get lost there for a bit, before journeying back to the original point being made. The only problem is how the reader forgot what the original point being shown was. As for the story itself, the writing style muddied it, burying it beneath the way it was written. Storyteller narrative, all told, not shown.
But that wasn't my biggest issue. Early on in the novel, the reader meets Zeus, and his backstory is told via conversation, and this rubbed me wrong. I tried three more times after that to get into the story, trying to forget my earlier irritation, but I didn't succeed.
I'm unsure if I should post my thoughts on how the author created Zeus, afraid it will be taken the wrong way with insult being seen where none was meant, but I was personally insulted by Zeus' backstory.
I had a problem with the character of Zeus, to the point I couldn’t read the novel after I became hyper-focused. To go through the transition from female to male is admirable and brave, especially after coming out as a lesbian. What I couldn’t swallow...
As a female, she was a lesbian = / = as a male, he is gay.
That does not equate.
There was no indecision, no in the closet (actually, when female, she would have been straight if gay as a male, attracted to the male gender). No in denial. To make a conscious choice be come out as a lesbian, which by very definition means you are attracted to the female gender, not the male gender, that is not an easy choice to be made. A lot of soul-searching, self-reflection, and being attracted to the female gender. Then to struggle with your gender identity, which is both courageous and no doubt terrifying. But once the transition occurred from FtM, Zeus changed his sexual inclination as if it’s not something innate in our beings. After struggling to come out as a lesbian (wanting women), as a male, he decides he's gay (wanting men).
The gender you are attracted to does not change with your gender identity. Apples/oranges.
Bisexuality and pansexuality are more fluid, not necessarily wanting genders equally. When gay/lesbian/straight, it’s more rigid, wanting a specific gender, or you wouldn’t be gay/lesbian/straight by very definition.
Transitioning changes what you call your sexual orientation based on your gender vs the gender you are attracted toward, not the specific gender you’re attracted to. When Val, she wanted females = / = when Zeus, he wanted males- this erased all the progress we’ve made, which was ironic in a book featuring a conversion camp which also believed it was a choice. Who you are attracted to is not a choice.
Zeus' character made it seem as if it's a choice. When deciding to live as his true gender, he also decided to change which gender he is attracted to, making it seem as if the decision she was lesbian was a frivolity- a lie. A mockery. We can be in denial when saying we're straight, because of societal pressure, but to go through all the soul-searching to come out as a lesbian, as if it's easy... "My therapist made me realize I'm a gay man." There never would have been a struggle with sexual orientation (straight, not lesbian) as he struggled with his gender identity (FtM) gay male.
No matter how intrigued I was by Will’s story, not put off by his personality or how difficult it was to fall into the story itself due to the stream of consciousness writing style, when Zeus’ name was on the page, I got angry.
This visceral reaction is why I chose to not finish, instead of continuing on until the end.