Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Pulpit and Nation: Clergymen and the Politics of Revolutionary America

Rate this book
In Pulpit and Nation, Spencer McBride highlights the importance of Protestant clergymen in early American political culture, elucidating the actual role of religion in the founding era. Beginning with colonial precedents for clerical involvement in politics and concluding with false rumors of Thomas Jefferson’s conversion to Christianity in 1817, this book reveals the ways in which the clergy’s political activism―and early Americans’ general use of religious language and symbols in their political discourse―expanded and evolved to become an integral piece in the invention of an American national identity. Offering a fresh examination of some of the key junctures in the development of the American political system―the Revolution, the ratification debates of 1787–88, and the formation of political parties in the 1790s―McBride shows how religious arguments, sentiments, and motivations were subtly interwoven with political ones in the creation of the early American republic. Ultimately, Pulpit and Nation reveals that while religious expression was common in the political culture of the Revolutionary era, it was as much the calculated design of ambitious men seeking power as it was the natural outgrowth of a devoutly religious people.

272 pages, Hardcover

Published January 12, 2017

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Spencer W. McBride

9 books8 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
8 (42%)
4 stars
8 (42%)
3 stars
2 (10%)
2 stars
1 (5%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews
Profile Image for Chris.
336 reviews
October 2, 2019
I've always enjoyed learning and history but I've also always had a hard time reading history books. I'm not quite sure why. The reading for my history classes in school was always a struggle. Over the years I've read a handful of historical books and, while I enjoyed them, found that they took a while to read.

I found the same thing to be true as I read Pulpit and Nation. I was intrigued by the topic and I won a copy of the book from the author so I was interested in reading this. Sadly it took me far longer to read than a standard novel as I had to re-read sections and take more breaks between reading to keep things clear. Still, I found it very interesting and enlightening especially with relation to our current social and political climate.

The book explores the relationship between Religion and Politics in the decades leading up to and immediately following the formation of the United States of America. When thinking about the role of religion with regards to the American Constitution and Independence, most people just think of the "separation of Church and State." Even that simply stated notion is laced with all sorts of intricacies that go beyond the face value.

In the book, McBride spends some time exploring the concept of 'separation of Church and State.' Even more than that he dives deeply into the nature of Religion and Politics and the way the two interact during that era. He shows many, many ways in which "Church and State" were heavily entangled during the birth of our Nation. From prayers offered during political meetings to preachers on the battlefield to studying the sermons given around the countryside, the book shows that religion played a very important part in the way America traveled the path to Independence and how our political landscape developed in subsequent years.

I found it very interesting to see the way that political leaders manipulated religious agendas to further their own aspirations. It was enlightening to read about the way religious leaders advocated for political change through sermons, essays and other means. In present day, some people try very hard to push for an ultra clear delineation of a "separation of Church and State." What people don't realize (and what this book helped to illustrate) is that there never has been a full separation of Church and State and it's difficult to accurately deduce exactly what our founders meant when they discussed this policy.

This book takes a well balanced view of the part religion in general (and Christianity in specific) played in the establishment of the United States. In spite of the "separation of Church and State" policy that we can all rattle off, the reality of America's birth is far more nuanced and is worth pondering. By exploring that historical interaction, it sheds some light on original intent but also shows that we should be wary of the ways that platforms (such as religion) can be manipulated for political means. This is a very well researched and well-presented exploration into a sticky subject that continues to spread tendrils of influence in our modern political arena.

****
3.5 out of 5 stars


Profile Image for Brad Hart.
197 reviews17 followers
February 2, 2018
The history of early American religion is one of my favorite things to study. I have read several books on the topic over the years, some well done, others not so much. "Pulpit and Nation" by Spencer McBride is one that I would call exceptional.

The question, "Was the United States established as a Christian Nation?" is one that has infected political discourse for over two centuries. Pundits on both sides seem to believe that winning this tug-o-war will somehow add credence to their respective cause. This question, however interesting it may be, is completely misleading and actually distorts the true historical character of America's founding generation. The truth of the matter is religion and government, though separate, have always leaned on one another and taken advantage of one another in too many ways to mention. Instead of visualizing a wall separating church and state, I prefer to think of a cell membrane. Though the membrane does keep a clear barrier protecting interior cell functions, it does occasionally allow for different things to pass through its semi-permeable membrane. Such has been the case with religion and government.

McBride mentions how religious leaders regularly made use of political institutions and political allies to help bolster their agendas. On the flip side, political leaders did the same with religious institutions/leaders. For example, those who both supported and opposed ratification of the Constitution relied heavily on their respective political and religious supporters to add credence to their claims.

History is rarely if ever clear-cut. It is complex, fluid and nuanced. McBride's work does an exemplary job of illustrating just how complex the question of religion in early American society really was. Even though the Founding Fathers created a secular government, we should not be so naive as to believe religion didn't have an influential seat at the table.

I highly recommend this book to anyone who is interested in this era of history!
Profile Image for Vern Wolfley.
101 reviews18 followers
August 9, 2025
I love history, especially about the founding and the men and women who shaped this country. This book was a fascinating perspective and analysis that I had not considered before, exploring the role of religion in Revolutionary-era politics. It was great to explore the religious part of politics, how faith influenced—and was influenced by—the political landscape.
Profile Image for Maddie Peters.
15 reviews
April 20, 2018
Absolutely fascinating. I swear I learned more about the process of founding the United States from reading this than I did in my myriad of history courses. A wonderful addition to my American history collection
Profile Image for Michael.
7 reviews1 follower
May 15, 2017
An interesting exploration of the impact and influence of religion and the clergy in early US History. It was interesting to see how the clergy impacted the setup of a secular society.
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews