'Hospital Hill' is a novel that takes so many of my favorite things and combines them into a gripping mystery story that I was reluctant to put down: a headstrong female protagonist, an abandoned asylum, my favorite place in the world (Western Massachusetts), a killer plot twist, and accurate depictions of mental health care at the middle of the twentieth century that don't smack of stigma or stereotyping, which is rare to find in any fictional work that involves mental health treatment. I'm someone who cares very much about facts and historical accuracy; historical fiction is often a gamble for me as a reader, because if an author can't get his or her facts straight, it completely ruins both the integrity of their work and my ability to enjoy it. However, through her writing, it is apparent that Ms. Anderson thoroughly conducted her research before putting pen to paper.
Perhaps my favorite thing about this book is that, while the story is engrossing and the characters are accessible, Ms. Anderson has truly brought to life the legacy and memory of Northampton State Hospital. Although I never had the chance to go inside Old Main before it was torn down, I did have the opportunity to thoroughly explore the Memorial Complex portion of the hospital, and I have spent countless hours on Hospital Hill (including a brief stint of sleeping in my car, parked behind the Haskell Building, because I was temporarily out a place to live -- proving that, even after its closure, NSH acted as a refuge of sorts to those in need). Though I've walked the hallways of many abandoned asylums, Northampton State Hospital and its grounds have always conveyed a particular air of security and safety to me. Even though the institutional buildings are gone, and prefab houses now stand in their place, that feeling still hangs in the air surrounding the old hospital property on Prince Street. Valerie Martin felt it, and it's part of what called her back to the hospital. And through this story, and Ms. Anderson's writing, I think all readers -- even those who've never stepped foot on the actual Hospital Hill -- will be able to feel it too.