October 1944- Will this dreadful war ever be over? Miss Dimple laments the loss of her best and brightest former pupils. So many of them are now gone, just like the fiance she loved and lost many decades ago. She's feeling a bit blue, especially since Odessa has gone to care for an ill relative and the boarders have to cook for themselves. Her mystery-loving self is awakened when a mysterious woman known as Dora shows up at the library. When Dimple brings the woman home and arranges for lodging, Dora simply disappears! When Dora is discovered dead the next morning, Dimple feels guilty. Jo and Lou are determined to get the bottom of the mystery along with Phoebe and the other boarders. Only Dimple is not as interested as she usually is. Their new cook, a slightly mysterious woman named Augusta Goodnight, urges Dimple to confront her emotions head on and become involved in the mystery. In this battle of wills, will Dimple rally to the cause or has the long war finally worn her down?
This is the best book of the series. The addition of Augusta Goodnight, from the author's other series, shakes up the pattern a bit and makes the story more enjoyable. I mainly liked that she pushed Dimple to open up and share her feelings. Finally, we get Dimple's backstory and find out why she is the way she is. Her unemotional, matter-of-fact nature is what I didn't care for in a heroine so I was happy to get more inside her head and her heart. Her past is very interesting. I liked the romance a lot. It was partly shown and partly described- a nice balance for a secondary plot line. I didn't realize Miss Dimple was so old. She's older than my 2xs great-grandfather who lied about his age to fight in the Spanish-American war. (My grandparents are around Delia's age).
The mystery is very engaging. I never guessed who did it at all. It wasn't as obvious this time. I was left a bit confused as to why the murderer tried to frame Jesse Dean and what the connection was. Also, why was Dora so nervous? That wasn't fully explained either.
The historical details are excellent. Rationing is starting to become wearisome and there's more mention of ration points and foods being unavailable. I liked all the cooking bits and learning what could be made with so little. This book REALLY made me crave waffles! I also liked the inclusion of book titles, none of which I've read but some of which I have heard of.
Most of the characters are the usual cast with a few new additions. Augusta Goodnight is a delight. She's slightly vague but so charming and lovely. How can you not love someone who smells like strawberries and whose food tastes like, well, heaven?! The reader is clued in to the fact Augusta and her friends are guardian angels but the characters never discover this. I thought the plot might require suspension of disbelief but it never reaches that point. If you don't read the title or the summary or know who Augusta is, it's slightly ambiguous. Mysterious things happen but the characters rationalize them. I liked how she cheered everyone up and lightened the mood. Reading about her in the summaries of her books shows she died during World War II, so I'm a little confused about her timeline of events and how being an angel works exactly but it doesn't really matter.
Other residents of Elderberry include Lily, who I had forgotten existed before the previous book. She's a demure spinster type but finally comes into her own in this book. There's also Rose McGinnis, an unfortunate young woman who is in need of a guardian angel herself. Her aunt Gertrude also plays a small role in the story but frankly I forgot they both existed for much of the story. The rest of the cast of characters centers around Dora, including her husband and mother-in-law. There's one surprise character who pops up in the story. In the flashback sequences, we met Ned, Dimple's young fiance who tragically died of Yellow Fever during the Spanish American War. He sounds like a wonderful boyfriend. He loved to read, like Dimple, but wasn't as serious or practical as she is. He brought out the best in her and they obviously loved each other very much. Charlie and Annie's fiances are not as cute. They're still away at war and we're left wondering what happens to them.
This is a great book to read this time of year. It has a Halloween element and the angel aspect make it a little Christmasy.
I hope there's at least one more book to take us to the end of the war so we can find out what happens to everyone.