I have mixed feelings about this book. On the one hand, I'd give it five stars for the purpose I read it for (research). I definitely had some five-star moments while reading this book, mostly when history I'd read about in another book coincided with Alice Roosevelt's recollections. I found her recollections of TR fascinating, as well as her trip to Asia with Taft. It was fun seeing through the eyes of a presidential daughter: the people she met, the things she witnessed, etc, and it gave me insight into the rift that formed between Taft/Roosevelt after Taft's election. (which I read about in the Bully Pulpit by D.K. Goodwin) (I'd lost respect for Roosevelt and his family based on the way they treated Taft later in Roosevelt's life, but seeing this period through Alice's eyes softened me and helped me understand/sympathize with the Roosevelts even if I don't entirely agree with how they handled themselves)
The down side to this book is that there are some sections that are impossibly dry if one isn't familiar with the people Alice is talking about. For example, she details dinners and social gatherings without elaborating much, which can feel a bit like a travelogue at times, and, without context, can be confusing/boring.