What do you think?
Rate this book
Heart of the Frontier #1
Treasured Grace
On the grueling trail west, Grace Martindale loses her new husband and her last vestige of security. Upon arriving in Oregon Country, she uses her midwifery skills to help the other settlers, and—with the aid of fur trapper Alex Armistead—the Cayuse tribe. But peace between the groups is fragile, and tension soon leads to violence.
450 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 1, 2017
1754 people are currently reading
2907 people want to read
About the author
Tracie Peterson
249 books3,128 followersTracie Peterson is a bestselling author who writes in both historical and contemporary genres. Her novels reveal her love for research as well as her strong desire to develop emotionally meaningful characters and stories for her readers. Tracie and her family live in Montana.
pen name: Janelle Jamison
pen name: Janelle Jamison
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 335 reviews
November 2, 2018
I recently listened to Cherished Mercy not realising the book was part three of a trilogy but the audiobook worked absolutely fine as a standalone. The story really impressed me so I decided to read the other books in the series. I wasn't disappointed at all with the audiobook Treasured Grace it was just as as good as the first book that I listened to. It's really nice to have found another author whose stories I have really enjoyed. The narration was really good and added to the enjoyment of this audiobook. Can't wait for the next book to continue the story.
November 3, 2019
Sagaidīju vieglu kristīgo lubeni vēsturiskajos kostīmos un sagaidīju ko daudz vairāk. Romāns neizvairās no smagajiem, lielajiem jautājumiem - kā jau dzīvē nāve un slimības neiet ar līkumu arī krietniem un ticīgiem. Uzzināju arī ko jaunu vēsturē - Vitmena misijas slaktiņš izrādās ir patiess notikums, par kuru tagad tad palasījos internetos.
July 1, 2020
I have always liked Tracie Peterson's books, and this was no exception. With the wilds of remote, unsettled Oregon Territory, three sisters learn how to survive.
Grace, Hope and Mercy come west to find their uncle in Oregon City. With the death of Grace's husband, leave them in the care of Dr. and Mrs. Whitman. Local trapper Alex Armistead catches Grace's eye but she refuses to marry again without being in love, but his past keeps him from hurting her more. Grace is a healer, but Dr. Whitman does not recognize her type of medical treatment once a measles outbreak hits the fort and surrounding Cayuse tribe. With Grace gone to help a friend, and many dead from the measles, the Cayuse blame Dr. Whitman and plan an attack. Hope and Mercy are caught in the attack and nothing Grace does can ease those fears and feelings. Moving on to Oregon City brings new challenges, an old marriage prospect, but there is only one man for Grace's heart.
I enjoyed the first installment of this trilogy and look forward to reading the rest and how Mercy and Hope settle into the wild frontiers of Oregon.
Grace, Hope and Mercy come west to find their uncle in Oregon City. With the death of Grace's husband, leave them in the care of Dr. and Mrs. Whitman. Local trapper Alex Armistead catches Grace's eye but she refuses to marry again without being in love, but his past keeps him from hurting her more. Grace is a healer, but Dr. Whitman does not recognize her type of medical treatment once a measles outbreak hits the fort and surrounding Cayuse tribe. With Grace gone to help a friend, and many dead from the measles, the Cayuse blame Dr. Whitman and plan an attack. Hope and Mercy are caught in the attack and nothing Grace does can ease those fears and feelings. Moving on to Oregon City brings new challenges, an old marriage prospect, but there is only one man for Grace's heart.
I enjoyed the first installment of this trilogy and look forward to reading the rest and how Mercy and Hope settle into the wild frontiers of Oregon.
August 26, 2017
Tracie Peterson has written some of my favorite books and this one certainly did not disappoint.
This book was set in the 1800's about three sisters who head west to Oregon territory. Along the way there they end up stopping for the winter at a mission that is close to two different tribes of Native Americans, Cayuse and the Nez Perce, as tensions rise between "the Boston men" and the Natives the struggle for the sisters increases.
I thought the character development was really thought through and I loved the emotion that Tracie Peterson is able to draw out of the reader. This was such a sad time in American history, but I thought Peterson did a really good job of portraying all sides and I found it to be a very interesting read both historically and just in general.
This book was set in the 1800's about three sisters who head west to Oregon territory. Along the way there they end up stopping for the winter at a mission that is close to two different tribes of Native Americans, Cayuse and the Nez Perce, as tensions rise between "the Boston men" and the Natives the struggle for the sisters increases.
I thought the character development was really thought through and I loved the emotion that Tracie Peterson is able to draw out of the reader. This was such a sad time in American history, but I thought Peterson did a really good job of portraying all sides and I found it to be a very interesting read both historically and just in general.
July 1, 2020
History has never been my strong suit. Though I did fairly well in all of my core subjects in school--at least, when I applied myself--I just had trouble wrapping my head around American history. While I do recall some of the basic facts from our nation's past--which is more than some people of my generation can claim--if it hadn't been repeated throughout my schooling, I likely would have forgotten most of it by now.
Still, when it comes to historical fiction, I can appreciate it just as well as any other type of novel. This book does a great job of taking me back to a time long past, when there were serious tensions between Caucasians and Native Americans. Though it was heartbreaking at times, overall, it was touching.
Still, when it comes to historical fiction, I can appreciate it just as well as any other type of novel. This book does a great job of taking me back to a time long past, when there were serious tensions between Caucasians and Native Americans. Though it was heartbreaking at times, overall, it was touching.
April 6, 2017
1/5 stars.
I have to admit, I didn't enjoy this book.
The back cover of Treasured Grace by Tracie Peterson sounded interesting, which was why I picked it up. I had read a book by Peterson in the past, and though I didn't remember loving that one, I thought I'd give her another shot. I probably would have thought better of it if I had realized this book was about a massacre.
I don't have a problem with books that deal with tragedy, but I have little patience for historical fiction books that portray historical events by heaping one tragic event after another upon the characters, with no lighthearted moments to break it up. That's what this book did, and by the end I was just so tired of the book. It felt like every time something got slow she'd throw another death or other difficult situation in there to try to keep it interesting.
This book also just dragged on and on to me, and I think that is because I just don't personally like Peterson's writing style. I felt like a lot of the deaths and tragedies felt cold, because I never felt like we really got into the character's heads and emotions. The author was just telling us how the characters were feeling instead of letting us feel things with them, if that makes sense. The characters seemed one-dimensional, and any personal histories that were woven into the story seemed like an afterthought, instead of something that was incorporated from the beginning. There was nothing really driving the plot forward, it just felt like a bunch of historical events and personal tragedies were strung together, and that was it.
I also felt like Peterson tried to address too much in this book. This book tried to address loveless marriage, alternative medicine, hypocrisy, racism, death and grief, r.ape, abortion, adoption - all in one book, and it was too much. I couldn't pick out an overall theme or point to the story.
I also had little confidence in Peterson's portrayal of historical events. Some of the historical figures were portrayed in less than flattering ways, and she provided no historical research to back up her representation of their personalities. I'm thinking particularly of Dr. Whitman, the missionary involved in the massacre, who came off like a total jerk. When I read historical fiction, I like to know that the author tried her best to get it right, and I didn't see the effort here aside from a short note at the beginning of the book. There was no explanation of her research and why she included certain figures/events/conversations. It felt careless.
On top of that, I find the main character very unrelatable, and almost unlikeable. She acted like a know-it-all and got on my nerves. This is obviously just a personality conflict between me and the character (that does happen, and I don't blame the author for that).
Finally, and this was disturbing to me - there was also a comment on page 89-90 where a character made a very sympathetic statement about someone wanting to marry their dog...I think it might have been a joke, but the context didn't seem like that statement was a joke. No characters laughed after he said it. Some people might not take this seriously, but I do, because I know in many countries around the world people do actually marry animals. And it's animal abuse, and it's sick. That sentence came out of left field and made me very uncomfortable. We no longer live in a global culture where a sentence like that can automatically be counted as a joke, and I have no idea what she was getting at by including it.
The one thing I did think she did well was to incorporate the salvation message into her story. She did it very naturally I thought, and I like when Christian authors take that kind of effort. However, I can hardly give the author any points for that considering my other problems with the book, especially the seemingly sympathetic reference to be.asti.ality.
Overall though, this book just really wasn't for me at all. Others with different tastes may like it more. I will not be reading Peterson again.
Note: I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for a review. This is my honest opinion.
I have to admit, I didn't enjoy this book.
The back cover of Treasured Grace by Tracie Peterson sounded interesting, which was why I picked it up. I had read a book by Peterson in the past, and though I didn't remember loving that one, I thought I'd give her another shot. I probably would have thought better of it if I had realized this book was about a massacre.
I don't have a problem with books that deal with tragedy, but I have little patience for historical fiction books that portray historical events by heaping one tragic event after another upon the characters, with no lighthearted moments to break it up. That's what this book did, and by the end I was just so tired of the book. It felt like every time something got slow she'd throw another death or other difficult situation in there to try to keep it interesting.
This book also just dragged on and on to me, and I think that is because I just don't personally like Peterson's writing style. I felt like a lot of the deaths and tragedies felt cold, because I never felt like we really got into the character's heads and emotions. The author was just telling us how the characters were feeling instead of letting us feel things with them, if that makes sense. The characters seemed one-dimensional, and any personal histories that were woven into the story seemed like an afterthought, instead of something that was incorporated from the beginning. There was nothing really driving the plot forward, it just felt like a bunch of historical events and personal tragedies were strung together, and that was it.
I also felt like Peterson tried to address too much in this book. This book tried to address loveless marriage, alternative medicine, hypocrisy, racism, death and grief, r.ape, abortion, adoption - all in one book, and it was too much. I couldn't pick out an overall theme or point to the story.
I also had little confidence in Peterson's portrayal of historical events. Some of the historical figures were portrayed in less than flattering ways, and she provided no historical research to back up her representation of their personalities. I'm thinking particularly of Dr. Whitman, the missionary involved in the massacre, who came off like a total jerk. When I read historical fiction, I like to know that the author tried her best to get it right, and I didn't see the effort here aside from a short note at the beginning of the book. There was no explanation of her research and why she included certain figures/events/conversations. It felt careless.
On top of that, I find the main character very unrelatable, and almost unlikeable. She acted like a know-it-all and got on my nerves. This is obviously just a personality conflict between me and the character (that does happen, and I don't blame the author for that).
Finally, and this was disturbing to me - there was also a comment on page 89-90 where a character made a very sympathetic statement about someone wanting to marry their dog...I think it might have been a joke, but the context didn't seem like that statement was a joke. No characters laughed after he said it. Some people might not take this seriously, but I do, because I know in many countries around the world people do actually marry animals. And it's animal abuse, and it's sick. That sentence came out of left field and made me very uncomfortable. We no longer live in a global culture where a sentence like that can automatically be counted as a joke, and I have no idea what she was getting at by including it.
The one thing I did think she did well was to incorporate the salvation message into her story. She did it very naturally I thought, and I like when Christian authors take that kind of effort. However, I can hardly give the author any points for that considering my other problems with the book, especially the seemingly sympathetic reference to be.asti.ality.
Overall though, this book just really wasn't for me at all. Others with different tastes may like it more. I will not be reading Peterson again.
Note: I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for a review. This is my honest opinion.
June 1, 2020
What an incredible story. From beginning to end, I was deeply invested in this novel. As I’ve come to expect with Tracie Peterson’s books, this one delivered a faith-rich, emotion-filled journey that wrenched my heart yet filled it with hope at the same time.
What I wasn’t expecting was to learn about a heartbreaking piece of American history: the Whitman Incident. While the events of this massacre were atrocious, the author handled them with grace and kept the gory details to a minimum. It was very clear what happened, but it wasn’t written in a way that turned my stomach more than necessary at the shock of the brutal behavior of certain folks within the story. What’s even more excruciating to understand is that this incident of rape and massacre really happened in the 1840s in the country I call my earthly home. Such atrocities should never even enter the mind of man, but because sin is rampant in this world, unfortunately, they do.
What made this book a five-star read for me was the rich faith that lent hope to the affected characters even in the midst of their worst nightmare coming true. It’s that thread of God-centered hope that is woven through our lives if we trust Jesus with our lives, and I’m so grateful for authors like Tracie Peterson who have made it their life’s mission to share the Gospel of Christ through fictional stories (even ones inspired by true and heartbreaking events, such as this book).
I’m glad I read this book, and I hope many other readers will discover not only this story about Grace and Alex and their journey to conquer injustices by extending grace to their enemies, but also the deeper, richer, and more extraordinary story of Jesus’ eternal love and unrelenting grace.
Trigger warning: rape, massacre
Both are handled well, focusing less on the gory details than the emotional impact of the events.
Content: rape, massacre, breastfeeding
What I wasn’t expecting was to learn about a heartbreaking piece of American history: the Whitman Incident. While the events of this massacre were atrocious, the author handled them with grace and kept the gory details to a minimum. It was very clear what happened, but it wasn’t written in a way that turned my stomach more than necessary at the shock of the brutal behavior of certain folks within the story. What’s even more excruciating to understand is that this incident of rape and massacre really happened in the 1840s in the country I call my earthly home. Such atrocities should never even enter the mind of man, but because sin is rampant in this world, unfortunately, they do.
What made this book a five-star read for me was the rich faith that lent hope to the affected characters even in the midst of their worst nightmare coming true. It’s that thread of God-centered hope that is woven through our lives if we trust Jesus with our lives, and I’m so grateful for authors like Tracie Peterson who have made it their life’s mission to share the Gospel of Christ through fictional stories (even ones inspired by true and heartbreaking events, such as this book).
I’m glad I read this book, and I hope many other readers will discover not only this story about Grace and Alex and their journey to conquer injustices by extending grace to their enemies, but also the deeper, richer, and more extraordinary story of Jesus’ eternal love and unrelenting grace.
Trigger warning: rape, massacre
Both are handled well, focusing less on the gory details than the emotional impact of the events.
Content: rape, massacre, breastfeeding
June 17, 2019
Well, after reading several of Tracie Peterson's books, I've come to the conclusion that I do not care for her writing style. She seems to be a fairly popular Christian fiction author, but the few books I have read from her have been lackluster and just "ok".
Treasured grace centers around a horrifying event, so it has a dark and depressing feel for a good section of the story. That does not help the already mediocre characters and lack of direction. However, for me Hope's story saves the day as she battles with her predicament. The way Peterson brought in biblical truths during Hope's decisions was what saved this story from a 2 star. Hope's decision really made me think and pray.
This will be my last Peterson novel, as life is too short to read 3 star books :)
Treasured grace centers around a horrifying event, so it has a dark and depressing feel for a good section of the story. That does not help the already mediocre characters and lack of direction. However, for me Hope's story saves the day as she battles with her predicament. The way Peterson brought in biblical truths during Hope's decisions was what saved this story from a 2 star. Hope's decision really made me think and pray.
This will be my last Peterson novel, as life is too short to read 3 star books :)
June 4, 2020
This first of the series is set in the 1840s at the Whitman Mission in Oregon Country.
Oldest sister Grace is a healer as passed down to her by her mother and grandmother. I loved the parts of the book that Grace was helping others and standing up for herself as a medical contributor.
The romance was lukewarm much of the time, but ended strong.
Oldest sister Grace is a healer as passed down to her by her mother and grandmother. I loved the parts of the book that Grace was helping others and standing up for herself as a medical contributor.
The romance was lukewarm much of the time, but ended strong.
June 15, 2020
A well-done fictional story about the early days in Oregon Territory and the Whitman Massacre. I really liked Grace as a character and found it easy to relate to her.
One thing that bugged me was the portrayal of Whitman as a self-focused autocrat because I've never heard his character read that way before. In the audio version, it also bugged me that the narrator kept saying "neszh purse" instead of "nay pur-say" for Nez Percé (which apparently is a common pronunciation now, but definitely wasn't in the time period of the story). Otherwise it's a really enjoyable(?) story despite the heart-wrenching issues with the massacre.
One thing that bugged me was the portrayal of Whitman as a self-focused autocrat because I've never heard his character read that way before. In the audio version, it also bugged me that the narrator kept saying "neszh purse" instead of "nay pur-say" for Nez Percé (which apparently is a common pronunciation now, but definitely wasn't in the time period of the story). Otherwise it's a really enjoyable(?) story despite the heart-wrenching issues with the massacre.
April 25, 2017
Don't let this ethereal cover art fool you. As gorgeous as it is, it doesn't begin to reflect the emotional turmoil found within the pages of this compelling book. Peterson has built a fascinating tale around an alarming piece of American history. It's a story rife with angst during a tumultuous time when settlers made their way West in hopes of a better life.
Grace only wants two things. To keep what's left of her family together and use her healing gifts to serve others. Going west seems to be the way to do that. But Grace and her sisters aren't prepared for the hardships they must endure in the untamed wilderness. Heart breaking, gut-wrenching times are ahead for these sisters and it will take every last ounce of faith they possess to make it through.
Fur trapper Alex has reasons for his mostly solitary lifestyle but they stop making sense once he meets Grace. There's lots of clashing wills and strong opinions as these two butt heads. But admiration soon grows into something deeper -- a bond that is difficult to sever no matter how hard they try!
Breathtaking historical details bring all the complexities of this time period to life. And it's interesting to read with the benefit of 21st century knowledge. Settler and Native relationships are volatile -- and with good reason. I'll admit to cringing a time or two over White arrogance and ignorance when it comes to the Natives and their way of life.
A gripping read that puts me in mind of Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman even though Grace isn't actually a physician. And bonus -- this is just the first in the Heart of the Frontier series so there's much more to look forward to.
Book providing courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications.
Grace only wants two things. To keep what's left of her family together and use her healing gifts to serve others. Going west seems to be the way to do that. But Grace and her sisters aren't prepared for the hardships they must endure in the untamed wilderness. Heart breaking, gut-wrenching times are ahead for these sisters and it will take every last ounce of faith they possess to make it through.
Fur trapper Alex has reasons for his mostly solitary lifestyle but they stop making sense once he meets Grace. There's lots of clashing wills and strong opinions as these two butt heads. But admiration soon grows into something deeper -- a bond that is difficult to sever no matter how hard they try!
Breathtaking historical details bring all the complexities of this time period to life. And it's interesting to read with the benefit of 21st century knowledge. Settler and Native relationships are volatile -- and with good reason. I'll admit to cringing a time or two over White arrogance and ignorance when it comes to the Natives and their way of life.
A gripping read that puts me in mind of Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman even though Grace isn't actually a physician. And bonus -- this is just the first in the Heart of the Frontier series so there's much more to look forward to.
Book providing courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications.
February 26, 2024
An a child I was fascinated with a TV show called “Wagon Train” It featured settlers from the east traveling out west to begin a new life. The travelers journey’s were continuous fraught with illness, conflicts and often with Indian attacks.
I still hold an interested in that part of American history. I decided to read Treasured Grace. It is a historical fiction story and it features three sisters as main characters. In the story there is a measles epidemic and of course a horrific Indian attack. This book is listed as historical fiction but it should also be categorized as a Christian romance story. That being said, I did enjoy the story.
I still hold an interested in that part of American history. I decided to read Treasured Grace. It is a historical fiction story and it features three sisters as main characters. In the story there is a measles epidemic and of course a horrific Indian attack. This book is listed as historical fiction but it should also be categorized as a Christian romance story. That being said, I did enjoy the story.
March 30, 2024
Native American Heritage Month: book number 13.
WHY I read this book:
I found this book while browsing Goodreads for books to read for NAHM (Native American Heritage Month). It was available on Libby so I listened to the audiobook without knowing much about it. The cover drew me in.
I am very interested in knowing what any Native American thinks about this book. I cringed a few times. I wondered what Natives would think about the portrayal of the conflict between Natives and Whites. Also what they may think about the strong Christian theme with no mention of Native beliefs.
It turns out that THERE ARE MULTIPLE THEMES in the book: (some spoilers)
•White settlers headed for Oregon in 1847.
•Prejudices and mistrust of Whites towards Natives.
•Prejudices and mistrust of Natives towards Whites.
•Characters who overcame their prejudices and befriended each other.
•Christian Missions/Missionaries/Bible quotes and Christian doctrine.
•Disease: Predominately a Measles epidemic with the loss being greater for the Natives.
•Medicine/Limited knowledge/Physician vs. Healer.
•Loss/Grieving.
•Friendship.
•Sibling love and sacrifice.
•Two love stories.
•Communication problems.
•The historic Whitman Mission Massacre, including the murder and mutilation of Dr. and Mrs. Whitman and the murder of eleven men staying at the mission. A hostage situation for the women and children. Rape of women and teen-aged girls.
•The aftermath: PTSD (some of these terms didn’t exist at the time)/Depression/Suicidal Ideation/Thoughts of how to obtain an abortion.
•Revenge/justice/making plans to bring the perpetrators to future trial.
•Voluntary relocation plans of innocent Native tribes due to fear of retaliation against any or all Natives.
•Overcoming trauma or loss in the past.
•Marriage for practical reasons/Marriage for desperate reasons.
•Infertility/Adoption.
•Can some find a Happily-ever-after???
WHY I read this book:
I found this book while browsing Goodreads for books to read for NAHM (Native American Heritage Month). It was available on Libby so I listened to the audiobook without knowing much about it. The cover drew me in.
I am very interested in knowing what any Native American thinks about this book. I cringed a few times. I wondered what Natives would think about the portrayal of the conflict between Natives and Whites. Also what they may think about the strong Christian theme with no mention of Native beliefs.
It turns out that THERE ARE MULTIPLE THEMES in the book: (some spoilers)
•White settlers headed for Oregon in 1847.
•Prejudices and mistrust of Whites towards Natives.
•Prejudices and mistrust of Natives towards Whites.
•Characters who overcame their prejudices and befriended each other.
•Christian Missions/Missionaries/Bible quotes and Christian doctrine.
•Disease: Predominately a Measles epidemic with the loss being greater for the Natives.
•Medicine/Limited knowledge/Physician vs. Healer.
•Loss/Grieving.
•Friendship.
•Sibling love and sacrifice.
•Two love stories.
•Communication problems.
•The historic Whitman Mission Massacre, including the murder and mutilation of Dr. and Mrs. Whitman and the murder of eleven men staying at the mission. A hostage situation for the women and children. Rape of women and teen-aged girls.
•The aftermath: PTSD (some of these terms didn’t exist at the time)/Depression/Suicidal Ideation/Thoughts of how to obtain an abortion.
•Revenge/justice/making plans to bring the perpetrators to future trial.
•Voluntary relocation plans of innocent Native tribes due to fear of retaliation against any or all Natives.
•Overcoming trauma or loss in the past.
•Marriage for practical reasons/Marriage for desperate reasons.
•Infertility/Adoption.
•Can some find a Happily-ever-after???
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 20, 2017
Strong pro life message! Thank you Tracie Peterson!
March 20, 2017
Grace Martindale has known more than her share of hardship. After her parents died, raising her two younger sisters became her responsibility. A hasty marriage to a minister who is heading to the untamed West seemed like an opportunity for a fresh start, but a cholera outbreak along the wagon trail has left Grace a widow in a very precarious position.
Having learned natural remedies and midwifery from her mother, Grace seeks an opportunity to use her skills for the benefit of others. So when she and her sisters arrive at the Whitman mission in “Oregon Country,” she decides to stay rather than push on.
With the help of Alex Armistead, a French-American fur trapper, Grace begins to provide care for her neighbors, including some of the native populace. But not everyone welcomes her skills–or her presence–and soon Grace finds herself and those she loves in more danger than she imagined possible.
First, I have to say that I rarely read Christian Fiction, as I have yet to find any authors that I really like and this is the first book by Tracie Peterson that I have read. This book sounded interesting to me because I really enjoy historical fiction and I thought the inclusion of midwifery also sounded interesting. For Christian Fiction, I have to admit that some of the elements of the plot very fairly violent and traumatic, which I was not expecting. And there were many other topics, that I don’t want to mention because I don’t want to give away any spoilers, but they didn’t really set up the story to be a great romance. I have read other romance books where the main characters have traumatic pasts, but most of the time the traumatic events weren’t happening right in the middle of the love story. That aspect just wasn’t what I was expecting in a Christian romance novel, but like I said, I have not really read anything from this genre. I did like the setting of historical Oregon, but I never really found myself connecting with the main character, Grace. The books has fairly high ratings and I imagine that fans of the author will very much enjoy this book. I personally just didn’t really connect to the characters or the story, although I did enjoy the historical setting. The writing itself is fine and I do really enjoy historical fiction, I think I might have just been surprised by the violence and traumatic events focused on in this book.
Thank you to the publisher, Bethany House, for sending me a review copy of this book.
Having learned natural remedies and midwifery from her mother, Grace seeks an opportunity to use her skills for the benefit of others. So when she and her sisters arrive at the Whitman mission in “Oregon Country,” she decides to stay rather than push on.
With the help of Alex Armistead, a French-American fur trapper, Grace begins to provide care for her neighbors, including some of the native populace. But not everyone welcomes her skills–or her presence–and soon Grace finds herself and those she loves in more danger than she imagined possible.
First, I have to say that I rarely read Christian Fiction, as I have yet to find any authors that I really like and this is the first book by Tracie Peterson that I have read. This book sounded interesting to me because I really enjoy historical fiction and I thought the inclusion of midwifery also sounded interesting. For Christian Fiction, I have to admit that some of the elements of the plot very fairly violent and traumatic, which I was not expecting. And there were many other topics, that I don’t want to mention because I don’t want to give away any spoilers, but they didn’t really set up the story to be a great romance. I have read other romance books where the main characters have traumatic pasts, but most of the time the traumatic events weren’t happening right in the middle of the love story. That aspect just wasn’t what I was expecting in a Christian romance novel, but like I said, I have not really read anything from this genre. I did like the setting of historical Oregon, but I never really found myself connecting with the main character, Grace. The books has fairly high ratings and I imagine that fans of the author will very much enjoy this book. I personally just didn’t really connect to the characters or the story, although I did enjoy the historical setting. The writing itself is fine and I do really enjoy historical fiction, I think I might have just been surprised by the violence and traumatic events focused on in this book.
Thank you to the publisher, Bethany House, for sending me a review copy of this book.
January 15, 2019
5 stars
Grace Flannagen Martindale is headed west with her siblings the story starts with her burying her husband. It was a loveless match only put together so all parties could travel to Oregon. Grace decides to stay the winter at the Whitman Mission well she awaits word from her uncle. This is a decision that will end up haunting all.
Alex Armistead is a fur trapper who lives among the Native american’s he has ran from his home in New Orleans ten years before and his past still haunts him. He meets grace and her sisters at the Mission but can’t bring himself to love her as his past holds him back. When the mission is attacked he has to try and help the Native American’s figure out what the future holds well at the same time trying to rescue the women and Children from the mission. Can he let go of his past during all this and let love in.
This is a fictionalized account of a real life massacre and of course it’s set in the west during the late 1840’s so there is lots of death and illness. Add on to that trigger warnings for talk of rape, abortion and thoughts of suicide. Well this story does have a HEA and I put this book high up on my fav’s list I know it’s not for everyone so I caution anyone who goes into it that you need a strong stomach or a box of Kleenex.
Now that I have read book one it’s time for me to reread books 2 and three with fresh eyes.
Grace Flannagen Martindale is headed west with her siblings the story starts with her burying her husband. It was a loveless match only put together so all parties could travel to Oregon. Grace decides to stay the winter at the Whitman Mission well she awaits word from her uncle. This is a decision that will end up haunting all.
Alex Armistead is a fur trapper who lives among the Native american’s he has ran from his home in New Orleans ten years before and his past still haunts him. He meets grace and her sisters at the Mission but can’t bring himself to love her as his past holds him back. When the mission is attacked he has to try and help the Native American’s figure out what the future holds well at the same time trying to rescue the women and Children from the mission. Can he let go of his past during all this and let love in.
This is a fictionalized account of a real life massacre and of course it’s set in the west during the late 1840’s so there is lots of death and illness. Add on to that trigger warnings for talk of rape, abortion and thoughts of suicide. Well this story does have a HEA and I put this book high up on my fav’s list I know it’s not for everyone so I caution anyone who goes into it that you need a strong stomach or a box of Kleenex.
Now that I have read book one it’s time for me to reread books 2 and three with fresh eyes.
March 23, 2017
Series "Heart of the frontier" book #1, Treasured Grace by Tracie Peterson
I like reading this author and the story of Grace is one you don't want to miss.
Three young women Grace-Hope and Mercy head west on the Oregon trail, Grace marries The Rev Martindale to be a marriage in name only as he needs a wife only to go to the mission field.
He was a man that seemed to be full of himself and was always "Right", the sisters did not seem to miss him much when he died early on and was buried along the way, Now the sisters hope to stay at the Whitman mission over the winter as many have been ill and died when Measles affected the train.
Grace is a healer and works helping many but while at the mission the good doctor does not want her helping him. His ways are different from hers. At the mission they also meet a tribe of indians called Cayuse , many were not happy with the good doctor and thought he was killing their people with poison. There is tension between the mission and the indians.
This is a complex story and you will enjoy reading how the girls live and work at the mission. Grace meets a man named Alex that becomes a great friend over time.
I like reading this author and the story of Grace is one you don't want to miss.
Three young women Grace-Hope and Mercy head west on the Oregon trail, Grace marries The Rev Martindale to be a marriage in name only as he needs a wife only to go to the mission field.
He was a man that seemed to be full of himself and was always "Right", the sisters did not seem to miss him much when he died early on and was buried along the way, Now the sisters hope to stay at the Whitman mission over the winter as many have been ill and died when Measles affected the train.
Grace is a healer and works helping many but while at the mission the good doctor does not want her helping him. His ways are different from hers. At the mission they also meet a tribe of indians called Cayuse , many were not happy with the good doctor and thought he was killing their people with poison. There is tension between the mission and the indians.
This is a complex story and you will enjoy reading how the girls live and work at the mission. Grace meets a man named Alex that becomes a great friend over time.
April 27, 2017
I loved the characters very much and also the subject matter of the story. I felt for those that suffered and for all those who were not directly affected but had loved ones who were. I look forward to the next book!
February 16, 2020
I really enjoyed this exciting story of the frontier by Tracie Peterson. ~ Lizzie :)
September 6, 2019
I really enjoyed this book. It's been awhile since I've read a "old west" type book. I thought the characters and story were well developed and thought out.
The author did a great job in handling the "abuse" that happened within the story and was not too descriptive about it.
Rating: PG-13 (physical violence, abuse)
Language: no use of deity, no profanity (clean language throughout)
Recommend: yes
The author did a great job in handling the "abuse" that happened within the story and was not too descriptive about it.
Rating: PG-13 (physical violence, abuse)
Language: no use of deity, no profanity (clean language throughout)
Recommend: yes
January 3, 2024
So cute! I liked the frontier stuff, but the colonization stuff feels a bit questionable?
March 11, 2017
Sad time in history was the era when this took place. Interesting perspective through eyes of witnesses. How in hindsight looking back how the matter was dealt with. Plus their are victims today. Tough subject to write about. Interested in the setting of how Tracie will write the next books.
January 10, 2018
Having read books 2 and 3 of Tracie Peterson's Heart of the Frontier series, I knew a bit more going into this book than I normally would have. Nevertheless, seeing the story play out was very enjoyable and I again appreciated the way in which true historical events were used and people portrayed.
Having Grace (Flanagan) Martindale's first marriage only be shown in retrospect was a choice I appreciated, as the Right Reverend Martindale would have been an insufferable character. Alex Armistead, on the other hand, was an interesting choice as a protagonist and I enjoyed his interactions with Grace as they discuss attitudes and she quickly adapts her pre-conceived notions. Having attitudes of the day shown in this way was another choice that enhanced my enjoyment of the story.
Whether or not the reader is familiar with the Whitman Massacre and the tensions surrounding it, this is a novel and a series that weaves them into enjoyable, though sometimes necessarily unpleasant, fictional storylines. What may feel like misery heaped on top of misery felt like a reflection of the place and time, so the moments of faith, love, and hope shone through.
Now, all this is not to say that I found no fault. In particular, the story did seem to get bogged down from time to time and Grace's propensity for announcing "I am a healer" still has me wanting to roll my eyes.
If you enjoy Historical Christian Romance, or Historical Fiction with romance, set in 1800's Oregon Territory, then give this trilogy a try. This is not one for the faint of heart, however, as this is the book in which the actual historical event known as the Whitman Massacre is portrayed. I do recommend reading them in order for maximum enjoyment.
This review refers to a paperback copy purchased through Amazon. All opinions expressed are my own. This review was previously published, unedited, on bookworlder.wordpress.com
Having Grace (Flanagan) Martindale's first marriage only be shown in retrospect was a choice I appreciated, as the Right Reverend Martindale would have been an insufferable character. Alex Armistead, on the other hand, was an interesting choice as a protagonist and I enjoyed his interactions with Grace as they discuss attitudes and she quickly adapts her pre-conceived notions. Having attitudes of the day shown in this way was another choice that enhanced my enjoyment of the story.
Whether or not the reader is familiar with the Whitman Massacre and the tensions surrounding it, this is a novel and a series that weaves them into enjoyable, though sometimes necessarily unpleasant, fictional storylines. What may feel like misery heaped on top of misery felt like a reflection of the place and time, so the moments of faith, love, and hope shone through.
Now, all this is not to say that I found no fault. In particular, the story did seem to get bogged down from time to time and Grace's propensity for announcing "I am a healer" still has me wanting to roll my eyes.
If you enjoy Historical Christian Romance, or Historical Fiction with romance, set in 1800's Oregon Territory, then give this trilogy a try. This is not one for the faint of heart, however, as this is the book in which the actual historical event known as the Whitman Massacre is portrayed. I do recommend reading them in order for maximum enjoyment.
This review refers to a paperback copy purchased through Amazon. All opinions expressed are my own. This review was previously published, unedited, on bookworlder.wordpress.com
July 24, 2018
The trials of the settlers of the Western Frontier were not easy. This book takes a look at a time in history when the "whites" and the "Indians" were in conflict. It follows a young woman, Grace Martidale, and her sisters as they follow the Oregon Trail.
I appreciated that this book did not gloss over details of life for the people. Part of this book focuses on the Whitman Mansion Massacre. The book looks at the tensions that led up to it, the plight of the victims, and the aftermath. It isn't pretty. Tracie Peterson stays true to the history and covers the treatment of the hostages (including rape, without details). It was a violent action and that is described as well. If anything, it gave me an appreciation for history and for the people who were brave enough to leave their homes and security to settle the frontier.
Grace is a healer. She and her sisters stay at the mansion due to an outbreak of the measles on the trail. She is compassionate and brave. The romance between her and a trapper, Alex, is sweet. It doesn't come close to being rushed. In some ways it was a little slow for me.
I think that Tracie Peterson did a great job at describing the position of both sides of the conflict. There was so much misinformation and hurt egos. This book touched me and reminds me that sometimes we need to learn of the unpleasant points in history so that it doesn't happen again. I can relate this to so many social and political point in our wold today and see that we still have a long way to go.
I appreciated that this book did not gloss over details of life for the people. Part of this book focuses on the Whitman Mansion Massacre. The book looks at the tensions that led up to it, the plight of the victims, and the aftermath. It isn't pretty. Tracie Peterson stays true to the history and covers the treatment of the hostages (including rape, without details). It was a violent action and that is described as well. If anything, it gave me an appreciation for history and for the people who were brave enough to leave their homes and security to settle the frontier.
Grace is a healer. She and her sisters stay at the mansion due to an outbreak of the measles on the trail. She is compassionate and brave. The romance between her and a trapper, Alex, is sweet. It doesn't come close to being rushed. In some ways it was a little slow for me.
I think that Tracie Peterson did a great job at describing the position of both sides of the conflict. There was so much misinformation and hurt egos. This book touched me and reminds me that sometimes we need to learn of the unpleasant points in history so that it doesn't happen again. I can relate this to so many social and political point in our wold today and see that we still have a long way to go.
January 11, 2018
This was a great start to a new series. Grace was the embodiment of her name. She was a very Christian and hospitable woman. Her attitudes towards the Native Americans started out severely prejudiced but overtime she modified her thinking. Despite all the tragedy struck the family, they kept their faith in God for the most part although they did ask questions. Anyone who had been through what they had to go through word. I think Alex was just a little too stubborn not to have come to his senses sooner but I suppose if it was a whole lot sooner in the book would not have been as good. I appreciated hearing the stories of the different tribes of Native Americans involved. It’s so sad to hear about all of misunderstandings and issues that they had back then. The faith of the family in Jesus carried through the whole novel and I felt that it was very well written as are all of Tracy Peterson’s works. I’m looking forward to reading the next in the series which I’m sure will be story of Hope... Who really had some trails and issues to deal with through this book and I’m praying that she finds her solution in the next one. I’m sure she well :-).
October 24, 2024
The story follows Grace Martindale, a recently widowed healer traversing the Oregon Trail with her two younger sisters in tow.
The heart of the story lies in Grace's relationship with Alex Armistead, a rugged fur trapper who crosses her path. Their initial interactions spark with tension, and while there are moments of genuine chemistry, their romance feels somewhat rushed, particularly as the story progresses. It's like watching a carefully tended fire suddenly flare up without enough kindling - the warmth is there, but the build-up isn't quite convincing.
Speaking of pacing, that's where I struggled most. The first portion of the book meanders along, detailing daily life at the Whitman Mission. While these details help build the world, they don't all serve the story. Then suddenly, everything kicks into high gear during the historical events, leaving me feeling slightly whiplashed by the change of pace.
What truly shines through is the portrayal of sisterly relationships. The dynamics between Grace and her sisters feel refreshingly real - complete with eye-rolling moments, fierce protectiveness, and that unique bond that only sisters share.
However, I did find the portrayal of Native American characters rather shallow, which is particularly problematic given their significant role in the historical events. They often feel more like plot devices than fully realised characters, which doesn't do justice to the complexity of this period in American history.
Religious elements are woven throughout the narrative - they're integral to the characters' worldview and decision-making, though occasionally the messaging feels a bit heavy-handed. Grace often reflects that "God has a purpose in all things, even if we cannot see it," and while this provides comfort during dark moments, sometimes these passages interrupt the natural flow of the story.
"Treasured Grace" reminds me of those vintage frontier photographs - parts are crystal clear and compelling, while others have faded into vagueness. While it may not be a perfect read, it offers an interesting window into a pivotal moment in American history, complete with themes of healing, hope, and the enduring bonds of family.
The heart of the story lies in Grace's relationship with Alex Armistead, a rugged fur trapper who crosses her path. Their initial interactions spark with tension, and while there are moments of genuine chemistry, their romance feels somewhat rushed, particularly as the story progresses. It's like watching a carefully tended fire suddenly flare up without enough kindling - the warmth is there, but the build-up isn't quite convincing.
Speaking of pacing, that's where I struggled most. The first portion of the book meanders along, detailing daily life at the Whitman Mission. While these details help build the world, they don't all serve the story. Then suddenly, everything kicks into high gear during the historical events, leaving me feeling slightly whiplashed by the change of pace.
What truly shines through is the portrayal of sisterly relationships. The dynamics between Grace and her sisters feel refreshingly real - complete with eye-rolling moments, fierce protectiveness, and that unique bond that only sisters share.
However, I did find the portrayal of Native American characters rather shallow, which is particularly problematic given their significant role in the historical events. They often feel more like plot devices than fully realised characters, which doesn't do justice to the complexity of this period in American history.
Religious elements are woven throughout the narrative - they're integral to the characters' worldview and decision-making, though occasionally the messaging feels a bit heavy-handed. Grace often reflects that "God has a purpose in all things, even if we cannot see it," and while this provides comfort during dark moments, sometimes these passages interrupt the natural flow of the story.
"Treasured Grace" reminds me of those vintage frontier photographs - parts are crystal clear and compelling, while others have faded into vagueness. While it may not be a perfect read, it offers an interesting window into a pivotal moment in American history, complete with themes of healing, hope, and the enduring bonds of family.
April 18, 2017
Treasured Grace by Tracie Peterson was an interesting historical novel set during the 1800's. The author has done her research well and really showed the hearts of the native Americans who were feeling anger and frustration of being forced off of their land by white people who gave no thought to ask first about how they could live together and instead just swooped in and took. This all comes to a head of course in a most horrifying account of an attack on the mission in which our main character resides with her two sisters Hope and Mercy.
While the story had its moments I found that I simply could not relate to the main characters of Grace and Alex. It might have been the fact that my kindle copy was poorly formatted. One page would have a conversation on it and then the next page would jump to the middle of a scene about something else, so that I had no idea what was going on. I was constantly flipping back pages to find the correct passage I was reading. Not an easy thing to do on a Kindle since the pages aren't numbered. That said, I think even if the formatting had not been off I would have still found these characters hard to relate to. They simply had no depth or personality. For example, the romance between Grace and the trapper Alex made no sense. It was instant attraction without any real explanation. And the long drawn-out reason why Alex could not commit to Grace made it even harder for me to care for them at all. This romance just fell flat.
The only characters that had any depth were Nigel and Hope. Nigel I hated because he was a pest, but at least I felt something. And Hope - well - what she went through would break anyone's heart. I liked the transformation that occurred in her and think the story would have been much better served with her as the main character. The emphasis on faith was done very well and the transition in Hope in particular was interesting to see.
Altogether this was not a bad book because it was true to the times and well-researched, but when it ended I should have felt something and I didn't. If not for the excellent research and well written scenes regarding the mission attack, I would have given this three stars.
This book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.
While the story had its moments I found that I simply could not relate to the main characters of Grace and Alex. It might have been the fact that my kindle copy was poorly formatted. One page would have a conversation on it and then the next page would jump to the middle of a scene about something else, so that I had no idea what was going on. I was constantly flipping back pages to find the correct passage I was reading. Not an easy thing to do on a Kindle since the pages aren't numbered. That said, I think even if the formatting had not been off I would have still found these characters hard to relate to. They simply had no depth or personality. For example, the romance between Grace and the trapper Alex made no sense. It was instant attraction without any real explanation. And the long drawn-out reason why Alex could not commit to Grace made it even harder for me to care for them at all. This romance just fell flat.
The only characters that had any depth were Nigel and Hope. Nigel I hated because he was a pest, but at least I felt something. And Hope - well - what she went through would break anyone's heart. I liked the transformation that occurred in her and think the story would have been much better served with her as the main character. The emphasis on faith was done very well and the transition in Hope in particular was interesting to see.
Altogether this was not a bad book because it was true to the times and well-researched, but when it ended I should have felt something and I didn't. If not for the excellent research and well written scenes regarding the mission attack, I would have given this three stars.
This book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.
July 31, 2017
First sentence: "So what do you plan to do now that he's dead?"
Premise/plot: Treasured Grace is the first in a new series, Heart of the Frontier, by Tracie Peterson. It is a three book series starring three sisters: Grace, Hope, and Mercy. The first book features Grace as its heroine. Grace and her sisters have reached the end of the Oregon Trail, but, things have ended unexpectantly. Her husband has died; she's now in charge of her two sisters and a flock of sheep. It's near winter. She does not want to take the easy solution and marry the first man who asks her. She doesn't want another marriage of convenience. She wants time to think, and time to heal. Speaking of healing, she's a healer. She would like to dedicate her time to helping others, tending the sick and dying. And she's NEEDED more than ever when measles break out just days away from reaching the Whitman mission. Measles wreaks havoc on the tense relations between the mission and the Native Americans. A few from one tribe are ANGRY, and their wrath is focused on one man: Marcus Whitman. Our heroine, Grace Martindale, is no friend of Whitman herself. The two clash in many, many ways.
My thoughts: I found this a compelling, fascinating historical novel. I enjoyed getting to know all three sisters. I felt the book was equal parts history and romance. I liked the balance. It wasn't just a story of how a woman, Grace, is given a second chance to find love and a happily ever after. It wasn't a case of instant love either. There are obstacles in their way, but, the obstacles aren't your typical over-done "obstacles" found in 98% of Christian romances. The history in the novel is that of the Whitman mission and the tragic massacre.
Essentially, I found this to be better than your average historical romance.
Premise/plot: Treasured Grace is the first in a new series, Heart of the Frontier, by Tracie Peterson. It is a three book series starring three sisters: Grace, Hope, and Mercy. The first book features Grace as its heroine. Grace and her sisters have reached the end of the Oregon Trail, but, things have ended unexpectantly. Her husband has died; she's now in charge of her two sisters and a flock of sheep. It's near winter. She does not want to take the easy solution and marry the first man who asks her. She doesn't want another marriage of convenience. She wants time to think, and time to heal. Speaking of healing, she's a healer. She would like to dedicate her time to helping others, tending the sick and dying. And she's NEEDED more than ever when measles break out just days away from reaching the Whitman mission. Measles wreaks havoc on the tense relations between the mission and the Native Americans. A few from one tribe are ANGRY, and their wrath is focused on one man: Marcus Whitman. Our heroine, Grace Martindale, is no friend of Whitman herself. The two clash in many, many ways.
My thoughts: I found this a compelling, fascinating historical novel. I enjoyed getting to know all three sisters. I felt the book was equal parts history and romance. I liked the balance. It wasn't just a story of how a woman, Grace, is given a second chance to find love and a happily ever after. It wasn't a case of instant love either. There are obstacles in their way, but, the obstacles aren't your typical over-done "obstacles" found in 98% of Christian romances. The history in the novel is that of the Whitman mission and the tragic massacre.
Essentially, I found this to be better than your average historical romance.
April 18, 2017
2.5 Stars
I was looking forward to reading this book, but it wasn’t exactly what I was expecting, actually. On the review-email it gave the description that the main characters were a midwife and a trapper – and to me, that sounds very good, so I requested it. And while Alex was indeed a trapper, Grace wasn’t a midwife – she was a healer, which maybe they would’ve been called midwives back then, but there was nothing that even mentioned her being called a midwife or any midwifery duties…
But anyway, after I figured that out, I tried to get into the book, and it was a fine read. For me it was just that – a good read, not terrible, but not fantastic either. Pretty light.
Personally, I didn’t feel I could really connect with any of the characters much, and there wasn’t huge depth to the story. It was also a case of instant affection between characters, but not fully carried out till the end.
There was the incident in the middle that was fairly intense and a tiny bit gruesome, and while it was awful, it did help you connect a little bit with two of the side characters.
This book, I felt, was more of ‘tell rather than show’ – you didn’t get to really be involved in the characters or relate to them. You just read what happened to them.
Now, as I say this, I also want to repeat that it wasn’t an awful book – it was clean, and there was a slight sharing of the message of Salvation, albeit not a strong one. For me personally, I wouldn’t mark it as a favourite, but many may love it.
I received a copy from Bethany House. All thoughts are my own.
I was looking forward to reading this book, but it wasn’t exactly what I was expecting, actually. On the review-email it gave the description that the main characters were a midwife and a trapper – and to me, that sounds very good, so I requested it. And while Alex was indeed a trapper, Grace wasn’t a midwife – she was a healer, which maybe they would’ve been called midwives back then, but there was nothing that even mentioned her being called a midwife or any midwifery duties…
But anyway, after I figured that out, I tried to get into the book, and it was a fine read. For me it was just that – a good read, not terrible, but not fantastic either. Pretty light.
Personally, I didn’t feel I could really connect with any of the characters much, and there wasn’t huge depth to the story. It was also a case of instant affection between characters, but not fully carried out till the end.
There was the incident in the middle that was fairly intense and a tiny bit gruesome, and while it was awful, it did help you connect a little bit with two of the side characters.
This book, I felt, was more of ‘tell rather than show’ – you didn’t get to really be involved in the characters or relate to them. You just read what happened to them.
Now, as I say this, I also want to repeat that it wasn’t an awful book – it was clean, and there was a slight sharing of the message of Salvation, albeit not a strong one. For me personally, I wouldn’t mark it as a favourite, but many may love it.
I received a copy from Bethany House. All thoughts are my own.
May 23, 2017
Grace Martindale is left by alone with her sisters on the journey west when her husband dies. She isn't devastated, as it was a marriage for convenience only, but it is hard to be a single women on the wild frontier. Luckily she is smart and she has skills as a healer. When she gets to the Whitman mission she hopes to use those skills, especially as there is a devastating bout of cholera going around. She is shocked to find that the doctor there won't accept her help. On top of that, the relationship between the Indians and the whites is very tense, and the Indian chief thinks that Dr. Whitman is purposely letting the Indians die of cholera. Grace knows this is more likely because Whitman is bleeding his patients, but nevertheless tension keeps growing.
One day she meets Alex, a white man who is like a brother to the Indians. Under his guidance she begins healing them, and in doing so she gets closer to Alex.
Then one day tragedy strikes. Grace is away for the day when she gets word that the Indians massacred everyone in sight at the village and are holding all the women and children hostage. What the damage ever be repaired?
I liked this book because of how it showed that there are good and bad people in every group. It was also written very smoothly and flowed.
I recommend this book to middle school and up who like historical fiction.
One day she meets Alex, a white man who is like a brother to the Indians. Under his guidance she begins healing them, and in doing so she gets closer to Alex.
Then one day tragedy strikes. Grace is away for the day when she gets word that the Indians massacred everyone in sight at the village and are holding all the women and children hostage. What the damage ever be repaired?
I liked this book because of how it showed that there are good and bad people in every group. It was also written very smoothly and flowed.
I recommend this book to middle school and up who like historical fiction.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 335 reviews