**SPOILER ALERT**
This is, by far, *not* Lent's finest novel. It's barely readable, in fact. I wanted to give it 2 1/2 stars, not 3; I decided to give him 3 solely b/c it's a lengthy novel and no doubt he went to some pains to figure out the various flashbacks. Still. Those flashbacks are part of the problem, but not the biggest part.
First, the author needs to learn how to use commas. He uses them rarely, and usually when they aren't needed. The novel suffers from sentences that are fragmented and long, and don't make sense, and then the reader has to backtrack and read them two or three times to make sense of them. I loved his writing in earlier books. But not here.
Second, the plot is ludicrously unrealistic. No 17 year old girl is as wise and discerning as Katy, and almost none of them - and certainly not one as sheltered as Katy - would do what she does in this novel. And none of them would undergo a rape and then, a mere 24 hours later, shake it off like it was nothing. Are you kidding me?
Furthermore, her mother Ruth's character completely changes, without explanation, 2/3 of the way into the book. There is no way she would do what she does with Brian. Nor would Brian talk the way he does, going on and on with descriptions of people and places. No man talks that way, and esp. not one who has been damaged by war. And Katy's father, who is, we're told, also incredibly damaged by the war, somehow doesn't seem all that damaged once Brian comes to visit. Was the visit like some sort of magic? Did it give Oliver some kind of catharsis? We are left to figure it out on our own.
I loved Lent's "In the Fall" and "Lost Nation" but ever since those two - and of the two, "Lost Nation" is by far the most well crafted - Lent has lost his way. At one point I looked down and saw I was only 67% of the way through the book, and I became very depressed b/c I was anxious to finish the book and be done with my misery. Lent has, in the two previous works mentioned, had a poetical way of expressing himself. I throughly enjoyed that expression. But this book seemed rote. I didn't particularly like any of the characters, but worse, I found the plot improbable and forced.
This simply is not a very good book. Mr. Lent seems as lost as his characters.