Crossbones feels like the most fun party ever I haven't been invited to.
I have read the first part of it last year, considering it some sort of a teaser and I saw a lot of potential in it. The author provided me with a copy of the book in exchange for a honest review and I was excited to discover how the magic-fae-pirate idea evolved.
I will start with the things that I liked. The beginning of the book starts in the middle of the action, with the so called opening incident. This thing told me the book has a plan behind, it follows some kind of book architecture. The chapters have a very cinematic feeling, the whole story is structured like a film script and I think it would make a rather interesting action packed film. The fighting scenes are dynamic and engaging. Considering the fact that half of the book consists of such scenes, there is no time to get bored. But...
...there are some things I didn't liked. The main downer of this book is being too short. The structure and planned events are made for a full length novel, but the actual length of it is of a novella. This is caused by the fact that each of the chapters are 1-2-3 pages long. Because of it every event feels rushed, it all ends before the reader had any chance to take a peek at characters and surroundings. There is no build up, therefore the immersion into the story is minimal. The characters are interesting, their personalities trying to burst out in the short one-page chapters, but because they are cut out so quickly they appear to be manic and lacking solid reason. Also because of being too short, the events are condensed, every piece of the puzzle falls in place too soon, everything is so obvious (making me say "oh, come on!" every 5 minutes) resulting in unbalance in favor of the "good" party, their invulnerability making it one sided.
I did enjoyed the diversity of the elements the writer used in the story, but I did not liked all the clichés of the YA genre like the mocking between main characters in the middle of some serious events, the need to introduce a romantic relation when it does not benefit to the story at all.
The editing work of the book could be better too.
In the end I do believe the idea and the author skill is up to make a great fantasy novel, it just lack the effort of planning and about 70 thousands words.
It's an "OK" type of novel, nothing more.