Spoilers
Pretty good for a New Adult book. It was well written despite the clichés, and the characters for the most part were interesting and entertaining, and the romance between Pearl/Boyce was easy to invest into and root for. I had some minor issues with their relationship and there were a number of other things that bugged about me the story, but on the whole it was an enjoyable and distracting read.
-Even though I liked Pearl more than Boyce, I much preferred his POV over hers. He was the more engrossing character, his past/present situation (with his dad/brother/mum/business) was far more interesting to read about than anything going on in Pearl's life.
-For the majority of the book, I really liked Pearl's character, she was smart and focused on her school work and ambitions. However, there were times where I absolutely hated her, mostly when she was slagging off other girls. I couldn't stand her bitchy thoughts about Brittney, they were out of order. Brittney had been nothing but nice to her, but all Pearl did was look down at her and think she was better than her. Unlike most heroines though, Pearl did eventually realise that she was being unfair too her.
-I had mixed feelings for Boyce, even though he was sweet and supportive of Pearl, there were some things he did/said that irritated me. Like when he was a teen, he treated Pearl awfully, what with him being all over another girl a few hours after sleeping with her. Ugh, if he had truly loved and wanted her (like he insisted he did) he wouldn't have done that (no matter how high he claimed to be), he knew she was his first time yet he threw that back in her face by slobbering over some other girl less than a day after they got it on.
Also, Boyce's decades long devotion/love of Pearl was hard to believe, what with him indiscriminately shagging around. I can't quite believe he loved her that much when he happily sexed it up to such an extreme level.
-I don't know why Boyce kept bitching about Pearl keeping him a secret when he wasn't exactly shouting about their friendship/relationship to his friends or anyone for that matter. He acted like she owed him something. Why would he think that when for years he'd been happily sleeping around with all the girls in their town? She probably didn't tell anyone because she had no idea how he felt about her, it was impossible to tell that he truly wanted her when he shagged around that much.
-Boyce's comment about Brittney's sex life pissed me off, he was such a misogynistic hypocrite, he had no right to judge and snarkily comment on someone else's sex life when he himself slept around so much. Even when Pearl called him out on his double standards, he just brushed it off as a harmless joke instead of properly apologising for his misogyny. What was even more annoying was Brittany clearly respected and cared for Boyce, but he had zero respect for her. Apparently, the only girls he respected were ones who didn't have too much of an active sex life.
-I LOATHED Boyce's mum, she was absolute trash. I wanted her to suffer for what she did to Boyce and his brother, but nothing happened to the silly cow. Her greedily taking Boyce's home and business when she'd abandoned him and fucked off for 15 years was such a scummy move. I really wanted Boyce to tell her exactly what he thought of her, he was way too civil and nice to her.
-Not sure whether I liked Melody, she was a pretty rubbish friend to Pearl and was quite awful to Boyce, not that he was much nicer to her. I think she could be a decent heroine though, the fact that she went back to her rich-golden-boy-high-school-boyfriend-who-she-hated after he publicly cheated on her just showed how much pressure and guilt her stuck up family put on her. I'm not surprised Melody turned out how she did with such a controlling and manipulative family, no wonder she wanted to move hundreds of miles away from them. It was ridiculous how they expected her to get engaged straight out of college, she was only 22 and she didn't want to settle down, they shouldn't have put those kinds of expectations on her. And then there was her brother selfishly using the ring her grandma left to her so he could propose to his girlfriend. What a dick. I wouldn't mind reading a book from her POV just so she can tell her vile family to piss off.
-Mitchell showing up at the end and turning into a full on psycho ex kind of seemed out of place and unrealistic. But after thinking about it, I guess it made sense since Mitchell's action were quite crazy to begin with, and after seeing so many news stories about crazy ex boyfriends/girlfriends it ended up seeming realistic.
-Arianna and Ray? Really?! What a mismatched couple, since when was Ray seeing anyone? And them being pregnant and married on top of that?? Ugh, no. Firstly, the age gap between them was seriously off putting. And their personalities didn't fit together at all. Also, Ray getting married and having a baby with a younger woman felt like he was pissing all over the memory of his murdered wife. It seemed like he had no respect or loyalty towards Lucas's mum. Why couldn't he have just dated someone and been happy that way?! I HATE that he gets to have a brand new family/life when Lucas and his mum got nothing but utter crap. He doesn't deserve a second chance like that, he should have been working on repairing his relationship with Lucas, not shacking up and starting a new family with someone that wasn't all that older than Lucas. Ugh, hated Ray ending up with Arianna.
-Why did Boyce tell Dr Frank that he hadn't seen any of evidence of his mother's boyfriend beating her? He had. He knew that her boyfriend slapped her and was threatening her, he knew he was violent. Yet he was sincere when he told Dr Frank that his mum wasn't being abused. Why was Boyce ignoring what he witnessed? I didn't get what was going on there.
-Didn't like how fast Boyce/Pearl got married, even though they'd known each other for years they'd only been dating for less than a year, plus Pearl was still in college. I would have preferred if the epilogue had taken place a few years down the line instead of nine months.
-Loved the gulf/small town setting, especially Boyce's home/garage and how he'd build it up and made it his.
-Loved Samantha, Pearl's stepdad, Randy, and Brittney. They were such great characters.