No spoilers:
Fun note: I read every Susan Trott book I can find, and Sightings was my first novel of hers I discovered (probably two decades ago)! I mention this detail because early on in The Exception, names start to sound very familiar. Of course -- she revisits a few of the characters from Sightings -- and this novel is truly about history repeating itself, death, and sacrifices we make to keep people in our lives.
The Exception is one of Trott's darkest and saddest. We meet Boy and Sister Freeling , orphaned and searching for their places in the world. Sister, depressed and tied to her childhood home, who soon takes on her birth name Amy, meets and falls in love with M. In Trott's style though, loving M. is nothing but complicated and unpredictable. He is a nomad, who does not live up to other's expectations of him, much to his high powered father's dismay. Then, there is Laurie, M's true love, who bullies her way into Amy's life, but at the same time, protects Amy and M whenever she must.
We also get to know Boy, Amy's beloved brother. Determined to become the fastest runner (surprise there?), every decision and sacrifice he makes in his life leads him to the podium wear he wears crowns of laurel and his sister cheers him on. After winning the Boston Marathon, he falls in love with Cecile, but of course, their love story is complicated,too. A single mother -- Cecile moves into Amy's and Boy's parents' house, and chaos, deception, and manipulation follow her.
By now, Shakespeare is probably applauding Trott for taking on his genre -- the tragedy and doing it right! As in other Trott novels: Someone has to die (or go) to make everything right, or as close to right, as possible. References to death are littered though out the novel -- even at its onset when Boy is reading the morning paper. So we should be prepared for the climax.
No spoilers: Toward the end of the novel, we begin to see how driven Boy is to be the best runner in the world. Our hearts break when Amy and Laurie both sacrifices what and who they love to hold on to M and to let go of him, too. Then we have the two male protagonists: M, the "irresponsible one", who must sacrifice more than his lifestyle to protect the one person he loves most in the world. Then there is Boy -- who is nothing but a boy focused on running, eschewing his own responsibility to others, especially his sister, is left standing alone with his laurel wreaths.
I love Trott's books -- absurd and quirky and unrealistic at times -- she is like a modern day Shakespeare.