Smugglers & Scones, the first novel in a new mystery series set in a quirky and quaint Oregon Coast town, opens with our protagonist Pippa, who owns a bed and breakfast open only for mystery writers. The reason for this unique stipulation is Moorehaven was once owned by a World famous mystery writer, A. Raymond Moore, and now Pippa owns and runs the B&B, with her great-uncle, Hilt, helping her day to day.
The excitement kicks off instantly with a boat wreck, an injured newbie to the town, a death of a long-time townie, and lots of unanswered questions. Add in numerous excited mystery writer guests, some gossipy girlfriends, and long held family secrets, and the majority of the town doesn't know who to trust or what they know.
Right away I loved Talbot's writing style and the voice and character of Pippa. I could feel her passion for Moorehaven and Moore himself. She was brave, independent, determined, and a girl I could see as my friend. Additionally, Moore felt like a very present character despite having passed away many years ago. The writing has a sensuous quality to it that I loved - I could smell and taste the food Talbot described, I could picture Moorehaven' exterior and interior, and Skylar, Paul, and Al appeared in my imagination and drawn out clearly.
There were just a few things that prevented me from loving this as much as I hoped. Firstly, I think the main reason this started going downhill for me is that the setup of characters and plot points began to feel very crowded. The book started strong, but the further in I read, the more frustrated I became with trying to keep track of characters and plot points I wasn't sure were important to this first book. I imagine that many of the guests, friends, and family members will play a significant part in future books, but for this first one, none really stood out as more important than the others, so I found it difficult to know who to remember more clearly than others. It just felt as if a couple of the secondary characters could have been left off for the story to flow better. Secondly, I have mixed feelings about the romance subplots. I can see many people liking the addition, finding parts of it amusing, adorable, and feeling the confusion and what its that Pippa is feeling, but for me, it distracted from the mystery and the background storylines. In future books, if the romance continues, I can see myself growing more attached to the idea of the couple(s) and how they might work together to solve different mysteries, as the characters were all likable.
The plot is strong, if you are into this specific kind of mystery. Smugglers, treasure, real life crimes happening to author(s) being the basis for crime novels, family secrets, etc. There is also a scene involving water that felt extremely real and frightening. It's not often that I feel myself tensing up while reading thrillers/mysteries, but in this case, I felt just as terrified as the characters. There just felt something missing for me in the overall conclusion. Something about the killer felt not fleshed out, and also, not quiet surprising enough for my tastes.
However, this is a strong start to what seems will be a very fun series. If you are interested in a wide variety of characters, some interesting history, and a dash of romance and friendly gossip, Moorehaven Mysteries is one I'd check out.
*Copy provided from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*