What do you think?
Rate this book


336 pages, Hardcover
First published February 27, 2018
When Aden meets Tate, something catches her eye and something irrevocably shifts within her.![]()
Immediately I want him. Not because he has pierced ears. Not because he has unruly brown hair and gray-blue eyes. I want Tate Newman because he is wearing a two-toned blue handwoven yarmulke atop his head.Tate is unlike any other boy she's seen. He spent the summer in Israel with a group of Jewish teens on a pilgrimage and
He's the only one in the group still wearing his yamulke, and when I look at him, I see audacity and spirit, and I want those things in my life. I decide I want him in my life.But deciding she wants him and actually getting him are two wholly different things.
"I'm perfectly capable of opening a door," I say.Gah! I love a good banter between the leads.
"Prove it." He steps aside and the door slams...
"But seriously. You don't see things the way everyone else does. You don't act the way everyone else does. It's refreshing."For once, we have a real life-sized heroine with real life-sized issues. Aden finds a way to become comfortable in her skin without resorting to starving herself skinny or fad-dieting the pounds away. hallelujah!
But this? This is so far from okay. And yet it is. I have to be okay without my mom because I am without herEverything was just spot-on...except for one teeny-tiny slip-up in the dialogue:
"Great. Coke or Dr. Pepper?"No one ever chooses Dr. Pepper in real life. This is the equivalent of watching a movie and someone uses Bing as a search engine.
"A Dr Pepper would be awesome, thanks."
"Calculus," he says.
And I know exactly what he means.
"Calculus," I say.
I was really excited for this book, because even though I'm not really that great at calculus, I still like the idea of it, and I was hoping I'd be able to really relate to the main character, Aden, through her love of calculus. I imagined myself reading about how Aden was working on differentiation by substitution, or the mean value theorem for integrals, and thinking "Ooooh, I know that!" I realize that probably sounds really nerdy but oh, well. The sad part is, though, that for a book with an integral on the cover and calculus in the name, there really wasn't a whole lot of calculus involved. There was talk about calculus class a little bit, and Aden tutored Tate (the love interest) in calculus, and there were a few x's and y's in there, but that's pretty much it. I suppose maybe that was done for those people who really hate math, so they could still enjoy the story, but I think there are ways it could've been done without being boring. I think this bugged me so much partly because our English class a few months ago read and wrote essays where we took a physical thing and used it as a metaphor to help explain something intangible, e.g. calculus to explain/represent change, and carried the metaphor throughout the whole piece. So that's what I was expecting here, and in the end it didn't really seem to be much about calculus or change.
The second thing I expected this to be when I picked it up, was about Aden and Tate's relationship. While I can't say that wasn't included, because it very much was, it seemed like the story centered around it, but it felt like maybe it shouldn't have. Compared to everything else that went on, their relationship felt sort of insignificant, except the author wanted it to be significant. Those things don't really make the story terrible, it just means that the cover and the blurb on the back of the book are kind of misleading.
Meanwhile, I really liked the parts about Aden's mother, father, brother, and best friend. I don't mean I like everything that happened, but I liked the development of the characters and Aden's relationships with them as she learns she can let go (she's always been the person they all depend upon, possibly too much) and not actually leave them at the same time. The main focus of the book was really, I think, Aden's self image. She's always criticizing her looks, comparing herself to others, and throughout the story, she's working on being happy with herself, which felt like a really empowering message that the summary really should've been more about. I think I would have liked it a little more if I had known what it was actually going to be about from the start, because it really was a pretty good story.
The only other major problem was that it felt really unfinished at the end. I was actually even nearing the end and turned a page and was completely shocked to see "Acknowledgements" at the top where the next chapter title should've been. I don't mean that in a mean way, I just think the author was ready for the book to be over, but the story wasn't ready to end yet. I think it had to do with just having too many topics in one book, that not everything finished at the same time. When I'm writing this right now, I'm imagining a friendship bracelet made with multiple colors of thread, but when you finish it and look at the ends, some threads are shorter than the others, even though they were all the same length when you started. I'm thinking that might've been what happened here. But I want to be clear (because I feel bad about how much I've picked on this book) that none of this means this is a bad author, or a bad story; it's pretty good considering it's her first book. In fact, I plan to continue reading more of her books when they come out.