This is a fantastic book, over which I have few issues (though they’re enough to make me drop a rating).
I had no clue what to expect when going into this. I’m the kind of person who adds anything that says “Laura Ingalls Wilder” and/or “Little House,” and then think about any possible consequences later. So I was surprised to see that this is a series of biology lessons steeped in Laura’s journey. Botany, phenology, and geology play key roles in McDowell’s book on common features of Laura’s life. Too, geography is present both due to provided maps as well as history lessons.
I am not a fan of biologically-based sciences, and I don’t tend to enjoy social studies, but McDowell pares things down that work well for me and keep me interested. It’s just cool to learn that Mason jars were first patented in the 1850s, y’know?!
The pictures, maps, illustrations, and other visuals provide a homely feel, a different format to a “Little House” book, and a deeper glimpse into Laura’s life.
The book as a whole guarantee a different perspective that links Little House (+) to reality, particularly beyond that of other books (like Prairie Fires) that solely look at the content in a historical context.
The book is broken into two parts: Life on the Land (a chronological look at Laura’s life) and Wilder Gardens. The latter is a mini [botanical] tour of where both Almanzo and Laura lived. The former includes:
~ Interjections by McDowell on her own experiences that mirror Laura’s, which make the book more meaningful.
~ Sad reminders as to how much was lost due to logging and farming
~ The fact that Malone, NY in 1890 looks very progressive for its time.
~ Great reminders as to how much was done without modern technology
~ The fact that the “Great Plains” was once a shallow sea. For the first time in my life, I want to look into how such arid nature translates to other similar areas in the world. Not that I will, but I’m actually curious; and I’m never curious about geological eras.
~ The amount of gardening Rose did (which I didn’t realize before now).
My Issues with the Book:
- None of the information is formally cited, so although all the sources of the outside information are provided at the end, it is difficult to link a lot of the info to the proper source.
- There are random grammatical errors, including missing words (namely ‘the,’ ‘a,’ and ‘and’). There was also a time when one paragraph ended with the word “Unless.” IMO, there should be three dots at the end. So, while it’s evident McDowell’s strengths lie in nonfiction [biological?] writing, her editor should have cleaned things up a bit better.