Posted on Les Romantiques - Le forum du site
Reviewed by Agnes
Review Copy from the Publisher
The depth of beauty is part of the Sinner’s grove series, about a retreat for artists founded at the beginning of the 20th century. The first book is The art of love, it’s the story of the founders of the retreat, Gus and Lia Wolff, and one can feel there will be another book, probably with Kat Firestone, the sister of the hero in The depth of beauty. There is also a contemporary series, the first book is called Sinner’s grove and the action takes place in the same place.
I haven’t read the first book, and although I could sense that it existed, and that things had taken place before, it wasn’t a problem at all to read The depth of beauty. The book is a mixed bag: half historical fiction, with an original setting on which the author gives a lot of information (San Francisco at the beginning of the 20th century, specifically Chinatown, and the tense relations between Chinese immigrants and the rest of the population), half romance with a love story that begins immediately between the rich Will Firestone and the poor orphan Amanda Culpepper.
Let’s say that the author should perhaps have chosen one or the other, because this book is a pleasant enough read, but neither a riveting historical rendition, nor a captivating romance.
Concerning the historical part, one can feel the author has done research, she knows things but uses them rather clumsily. I never felt transported to San Francisco in the year 1903. There is a rather ridiculous scene, where a Chinese thug, who sells opium and forces innocent young girls into prostitution, abducts the heroin. He is rapidly brought to reason with a strong sermon by the inevitable missionary… well… was I suppose to tremble in my shoes? This villain looks more like one of those Hollywood actors, who inexplicably play characters from a racial minority that is not their own. It all feels rather fake. Not to mention the earthquake, followed by a terrible fire that destroyed 80% of San Francisco, that the author makes us feel with the intensity of a wastebasket fire.
The tensions between the Chinese community and the rest of the San Francisco population are explored, but with a rather anachronistic point of view: on page 2 the super rich hero becomes inexplicably conscious that the Chinese are not that bad and filthy, and could even make him some money if he manages well! Then he falls in love with a Chinese woman because she is beauuuutiful (even though she has lotus feet, and that’s really wrong). At that moment I thought: wow, the author takes a completely unexpected turn, a multiracial romance? But don’t fret, this crush is rapidly dealt with and dear Will can go back to the poor and so beauuuutiful orphan who was meant for him in the first place.
This brings me to the romance, also rather superficial, between Will and Mandy. She loves him as soon as she sees him, because he is soooo good looking! Note: she just lost her beloved father, crushed by a tree, and is now an orphan. Don’t you think that under such circumstances, even Chris Pratt should struggle to make her heart beat faster? And yet Mandy is the character that I liked the most. Sure, she seems to come directly from a children’s fairytale: beautiful, intelligent, altruistic, she loves babies, and so on. But we can feel her pain when Will acts like an ass, for no real good reason.
As for him, well I had difficulties caring for his rich boy’s moods. At one point he wants to prove to himself that he could be successful without his family’s money, and enrolls on a boat as a simple deck hand to go on an adventure around the world for two years! Wow! What an intrepid guy. Well, considering that, if anything had happened to you, you would just have had to call mommy and daddy to the rescue, it’s not exactly the same thing as being a real adventurer, without a safety net, see? And during these two years, he sleeps with six women, states the author, but fortunately doesn’t catch any venereal disease, so everything is okay. As far as I’m concerned, he could as well have gone to hell… lol
In conclusion, I’d say that this book is rather interesting, mainly because of the historical background. It’s easy to read, but really not unforgettable.