What do you think?
Rate this book
Convicted: A Crooked Cop, an Innocent Man, and an Unlikely Journey of Forgiveness and Friendship
Speaking directly to recent headlines and cultural tensions, this is the poignant account of a crooked white cop who framed an innocent black man--and how their stories later intersected to show a divided nation a way forward to reconciliation and healing. This revealing story explores racism in small-city America and ultimately highlights the power of the gospel to heal the relationship of two of the most unlikely candidates for reconciliation.
224 pages, Hardcover
Published September 19, 2017
55 people are currently reading
1116 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 163 reviews
August 12, 2017
Thank you Waterbrook Multnomah for this book. This is a true story of Andrew and Jameel. It is a powerful story of greed , power and being wrongfully imprisoned. I did the ugly cry, got angry, and found myself in awe of both of these men. Everyone needs to read this book. Especially with the division we are currently facing. We could all learn and be inspired by their story.
September 21, 2017
This really sounded like such an odd story, especially in today's world with the current tensions, that I thought I just had to give it a look and see if it was all it seemed to be. Once I got into it, I really got involved in it thoroughly. I ended up reading it cover to cover and was very moved and inspired by this dual memoir written by two men from my home state of Michigan. Both Jameel and Andrew's stories came together so well and give such hope for the future that it is possible for us all to find ways to get along better if we make the effort that they did. I'm so glad I read it. I was given a free advance review copy by NetGalley and the publisher.
August 23, 2017
Convicted is a thoroughly enjoyable read. Written as a double autobiography it tells the dual stories of Andrew Collins and Jameel McGee. The first a police officer who is cutting corners and breaking the rules, and the second an innocent man caught up in Collins wake.
From the beginning we know Collins is crooked and McGee is innocent; it says so on the cover of the book. We are not taken on their journeys to discover this. What we learn, are the motivations and emotions behind the decisions each man makes and the fallout of those decisions. We grow to care about each of these men. They are not cardboard cutouts, they are real people. Neither of their lives fit into neat packages. We get to see the good and bad of each of them.
Structurally, I like the way that the two stories run in parallel and so we get to see what each one is doing and thinking along the way.
I was most interested to learn how there could not just be forgiveness but also a genuine friendship between these two very different men. That part of their story is only possible by genuine heart change brought about by each man's spiritual journey. It is touching without being sappy and I appreciate that.
For those who question whether or not there is hope for their own situation; and if God can bring anything good from injustice, this book is a shining example and a hope for all of us.
Highly recommended.
Note: I received an advance copy of this book for my unbiased review.
From the beginning we know Collins is crooked and McGee is innocent; it says so on the cover of the book. We are not taken on their journeys to discover this. What we learn, are the motivations and emotions behind the decisions each man makes and the fallout of those decisions. We grow to care about each of these men. They are not cardboard cutouts, they are real people. Neither of their lives fit into neat packages. We get to see the good and bad of each of them.
Structurally, I like the way that the two stories run in parallel and so we get to see what each one is doing and thinking along the way.
I was most interested to learn how there could not just be forgiveness but also a genuine friendship between these two very different men. That part of their story is only possible by genuine heart change brought about by each man's spiritual journey. It is touching without being sappy and I appreciate that.
For those who question whether or not there is hope for their own situation; and if God can bring anything good from injustice, this book is a shining example and a hope for all of us.
Highly recommended.
Note: I received an advance copy of this book for my unbiased review.
September 19, 2017
When I first picked up this book, I didn't really know what to expect. The story sounded interesting enough, but I wasn't expecting such a beautifully written and powerful book!
Wow! This redemption and forgiveness story is simply amazing!
This is the true story of Jameel McGee and Andrew Collins. These two first meet when Andrew Collins, a police officer at the time, arrests Jameel McGee for something he didn't do and lies on the police report to get a conviction.
Jameel is sent to prison, and eventually Andrew is arrested for his crimes, but it is only the beginning of their journey.
I found this book to be written in a very compelling way. Non-fiction can sometime feel a bit drab, but not Convicted. The story is told from alternating POVs, both Jameel's and Andrew's. They each get to give their side of the story.
This is a book that I will never recommend enough. Furthermore, this is a real story, which makes it that much more powerful!
Thanks to the publisher for providing me with a complimentary copy of this book.
Wow! This redemption and forgiveness story is simply amazing!
This is the true story of Jameel McGee and Andrew Collins. These two first meet when Andrew Collins, a police officer at the time, arrests Jameel McGee for something he didn't do and lies on the police report to get a conviction.
Jameel is sent to prison, and eventually Andrew is arrested for his crimes, but it is only the beginning of their journey.
I found this book to be written in a very compelling way. Non-fiction can sometime feel a bit drab, but not Convicted. The story is told from alternating POVs, both Jameel's and Andrew's. They each get to give their side of the story.
This is a book that I will never recommend enough. Furthermore, this is a real story, which makes it that much more powerful!
Thanks to the publisher for providing me with a complimentary copy of this book.
August 14, 2017
The first few chapters of this book were a difficult read, emotionally. I almost stopped, but difficult stories are the ones that need to be told the most.
Overall, this is the story of how God appeared to these two men at a time when He was most needed. The strong belief of Jameel and Andrew saved them from continuing down dark paths. He took on their pain and grief so they could learn to let go and forgive. This lesson allowed them to become positive influences in their community.
I am so happy for these two men and their families. They not only survived years of torment and heartache, they seem to be even stronger for it. The tests and trials they all experienced had to be overwhelming. I wish them all the best.
I enjoyed reading this story. I learned the importance of finding acceptance and loving unconditionally. These virtues may not come easily or naturally, but once found, the heart becomes lighter and happier.
This review is based on the ARC version provided by Blogging for Books. Full review can be found on my blog.
Overall, this is the story of how God appeared to these two men at a time when He was most needed. The strong belief of Jameel and Andrew saved them from continuing down dark paths. He took on their pain and grief so they could learn to let go and forgive. This lesson allowed them to become positive influences in their community.
I am so happy for these two men and their families. They not only survived years of torment and heartache, they seem to be even stronger for it. The tests and trials they all experienced had to be overwhelming. I wish them all the best.
I enjoyed reading this story. I learned the importance of finding acceptance and loving unconditionally. These virtues may not come easily or naturally, but once found, the heart becomes lighter and happier.
This review is based on the ARC version provided by Blogging for Books. Full review can be found on my blog.
August 16, 2017
When I was a freshman in small Michigan liberal arts college I asked a man where he was from. He said from outside of Benton Harbor. Where was that, I asked? He described the town in most negative terms and said, “if a bird flew from here directly west to Lake Michigan, and dropped a bomb just before the lake, that’s Benton Harbor.” Over the years I learned more about Benton Harbor and its affluent sister city across the bridge, St. Joseph.
I was moved to read Convicted: A Crooked Cop, an Innocent Man, and an Unlikely Journey of Forgiveness and Friendship by Jameel McGee and Andrew Collins with Mark Tabb because it was about Benton Harbor and a Michigan story.
Benton Harbor was once was a booming port town until the 1960s when manufacturing jobs disappeared and the white population moved across the river to St. Joseph. It has suffered forty years of racial tension, high unemployment, and the decay of city services and infrastructure. The murder rate per capita is one of the highest in the United States and drugs are rampant.
As in African American communities across the nation, the push to be tough on crime resulted in aggressive police tactics. Officer Andrew Collins yearned for recognition and success and became legendary for his narcotics related arrest rates and conviction. When he took short cuts and illegally manipulated evidence he justified it as part of putting away the bad guys. When he skimmed money off confiscated drug money, it was his just due for working for so little money.
Jameel McGee tried to keep away from drugs and criminal activities but was convicted for a crime he did not commit as a teenager. And then one day he asked a stranger to give him a ride to the store and his life changed forever. The police found drugs in the car and the stranger set Jameel up for the crime. The policeman who arrested him was Andrew, who manipulated evidence to ensure a conviction.
Convicted is the story of how these two men came to this fatal meeting, how it changed their lives, and how they each turned to faith and God. It is a story of how forgiveness is the first step in reconciliation and new life.
“Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.”
The book is presented with first-hand stories by both Andrew and Jameel, which gives an immediacy and authenticity to the story. Jameel insists on his innocence, and Andrew professes that his using ‘short cuts’ was part of his wanting to do good by ensuring bad people were off the street. They both had to come to terms with their personal responsibility for their fate and to stop blaming others.
Jameel turns to God to help him let go of his murderous anger. Andrew turns to faith to find forgiveness.
Ten years after Andrew arrested Jameel they meet again. They must decide between vengeance and hate, or forgiveness and healing.
Convicted is an inspirational biography about Christian redemption. But the basic lessons shared are important and universal, applicable even for those outside of a faith community. Don’t travel the easy path, Don't justify your errors and choices. Anger corrupts. Admit your failings and ask for forgiveness from those you have harmed. Put aside hate and vengeance in order to grow into health.
He has told you, O man, what is good;
And what does the Lord require of you
But to do justice, to love kindness,
And to walk humbly with your God? (Micah 6:8)
America has created a police culture that corrupted Andrew, as I read about in I Can’t Breathe by Matt Taibbi and Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson, and the poverty that causes crime as I read about in Michelle Kuo’s Reading with Patrick. For people of faith, it is clear that we are called to do justice and to forgive and to be kind.
There are many ways of telling the stories that we need to hear. Perhaps Convicted will reach people who would not otherwise read about the issues of institutional racism, the failure of the police and justice system, and the poverty that fuels crime.
I received a free book from Blogging for Books in exchange for a fair and unbiased review.
I was moved to read Convicted: A Crooked Cop, an Innocent Man, and an Unlikely Journey of Forgiveness and Friendship by Jameel McGee and Andrew Collins with Mark Tabb because it was about Benton Harbor and a Michigan story.
Benton Harbor was once was a booming port town until the 1960s when manufacturing jobs disappeared and the white population moved across the river to St. Joseph. It has suffered forty years of racial tension, high unemployment, and the decay of city services and infrastructure. The murder rate per capita is one of the highest in the United States and drugs are rampant.
As in African American communities across the nation, the push to be tough on crime resulted in aggressive police tactics. Officer Andrew Collins yearned for recognition and success and became legendary for his narcotics related arrest rates and conviction. When he took short cuts and illegally manipulated evidence he justified it as part of putting away the bad guys. When he skimmed money off confiscated drug money, it was his just due for working for so little money.
Jameel McGee tried to keep away from drugs and criminal activities but was convicted for a crime he did not commit as a teenager. And then one day he asked a stranger to give him a ride to the store and his life changed forever. The police found drugs in the car and the stranger set Jameel up for the crime. The policeman who arrested him was Andrew, who manipulated evidence to ensure a conviction.
Convicted is the story of how these two men came to this fatal meeting, how it changed their lives, and how they each turned to faith and God. It is a story of how forgiveness is the first step in reconciliation and new life.
“Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.”
The book is presented with first-hand stories by both Andrew and Jameel, which gives an immediacy and authenticity to the story. Jameel insists on his innocence, and Andrew professes that his using ‘short cuts’ was part of his wanting to do good by ensuring bad people were off the street. They both had to come to terms with their personal responsibility for their fate and to stop blaming others.
Jameel turns to God to help him let go of his murderous anger. Andrew turns to faith to find forgiveness.
Ten years after Andrew arrested Jameel they meet again. They must decide between vengeance and hate, or forgiveness and healing.
Convicted is an inspirational biography about Christian redemption. But the basic lessons shared are important and universal, applicable even for those outside of a faith community. Don’t travel the easy path, Don't justify your errors and choices. Anger corrupts. Admit your failings and ask for forgiveness from those you have harmed. Put aside hate and vengeance in order to grow into health.
He has told you, O man, what is good;
And what does the Lord require of you
But to do justice, to love kindness,
And to walk humbly with your God? (Micah 6:8)
America has created a police culture that corrupted Andrew, as I read about in I Can’t Breathe by Matt Taibbi and Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson, and the poverty that causes crime as I read about in Michelle Kuo’s Reading with Patrick. For people of faith, it is clear that we are called to do justice and to forgive and to be kind.
There are many ways of telling the stories that we need to hear. Perhaps Convicted will reach people who would not otherwise read about the issues of institutional racism, the failure of the police and justice system, and the poverty that fuels crime.
I received a free book from Blogging for Books in exchange for a fair and unbiased review.
August 8, 2017
What an amazing book! Convicted is a true story of forgiveness and grace and what I like to call a "Look what God can do" story. I wasn't sure how I would like this book because I don't read books in this genre very often, but I was so touched and inspired by this book.
Convicted begins by describing its setting of Benton Harbor, MI. Benton Harbor is a poverty-stricken town where drug deals and racism are everyday issues. Andrew Collins is a police officer in Benton Harbor who has lost himself and has become a "bad cop." Collins wrongfully arrests an innocent man named Jameel McGee and this book is their surprising story of forgiveness and friendship.
The book alternates between Collins' and McGee's viewpoints and I loved that style in this book. Once I started reading, I did not want to put it down.
The circumstances in the lives of these men could only be explained as "God things." God brought these men together and allowed them to be a blessing to each other and allowed such a powerful example of forgiveness to be expressed through them. We could all learn so much about forgiveness and God's grace by hearing Andrew and Jameel's story. I could only hope to be able to forgive this way if I were in Jameel's shoes.
I am blessed to be chosen to be on the launch team for this book and this book changed me for the better. I would highly recommend this book to everyone. It is a book that everyone can relate to, especially with the things that are going on in our world today. Thank you WaterBrook for the opportunity to read an Advanced Copy of Convicted.
Convicted begins by describing its setting of Benton Harbor, MI. Benton Harbor is a poverty-stricken town where drug deals and racism are everyday issues. Andrew Collins is a police officer in Benton Harbor who has lost himself and has become a "bad cop." Collins wrongfully arrests an innocent man named Jameel McGee and this book is their surprising story of forgiveness and friendship.
The book alternates between Collins' and McGee's viewpoints and I loved that style in this book. Once I started reading, I did not want to put it down.
The circumstances in the lives of these men could only be explained as "God things." God brought these men together and allowed them to be a blessing to each other and allowed such a powerful example of forgiveness to be expressed through them. We could all learn so much about forgiveness and God's grace by hearing Andrew and Jameel's story. I could only hope to be able to forgive this way if I were in Jameel's shoes.
I am blessed to be chosen to be on the launch team for this book and this book changed me for the better. I would highly recommend this book to everyone. It is a book that everyone can relate to, especially with the things that are going on in our world today. Thank you WaterBrook for the opportunity to read an Advanced Copy of Convicted.
August 13, 2017
Wow! I just read this book in two hours flat. I thought I would just read some before bed but I couldn't put it down. It is a gripping true story of two men whose lives were forever changed by bad decisions and forgiveness. It is such a powerful testimony of Gods grace, mercy and forgiveness. Honestly, nonfiction books are not my usual read but this book flowed like a fiction story. It is a great book that points to an even better Savior and the power of forgiveness. Read it as soon as you can. You will not be sorry that you did.
I received an advance copy of this book but my review is definitely my own.
I received an advance copy of this book but my review is definitely my own.
August 18, 2017
I read Convicted quickly - in just a few sittings. Not because it's an easy read; it's not. No, the story gripped me like few have. Jameel's and Andrew's stories really happened, and the book reads like any news headline you've seen for the last however many years.
My jaw dropped repeatedly, my heart ached, at every turn. "Surely that didn't just happen," I thought. And yet, it did. Both the good and the bad ... really happened. We can't set aside this book when we're done and say, "That was a nice book on paper." Or, "The theory is great, but the reality is that this could never happen." It. Did. Happen. Horrible things, bad choices, innocents convicted, happened. And so did forgiveness and reconciliation.
My heart breaks for what Jameel went through - and I know that many others have experienced similar. But what we don't hear about too often is a response like his: forgiveness. Truly allowing God to get ahold of him and change him. Let. It. Go. ... an oft-repeated phrase, and thankfully not because of Frozen.
If these two men could go through what they did, the horrible and the incredible, who's to say that their own situation is hopeless? God is bigger than every situation we experience.
I strongly encourage each and every person reading this review to read Convicted cover to cover. It's a needed story for our time and the days we are walking through. You won't walk away unchanged.
I received a free ARC of Convicted; all opinions are my own.
My jaw dropped repeatedly, my heart ached, at every turn. "Surely that didn't just happen," I thought. And yet, it did. Both the good and the bad ... really happened. We can't set aside this book when we're done and say, "That was a nice book on paper." Or, "The theory is great, but the reality is that this could never happen." It. Did. Happen. Horrible things, bad choices, innocents convicted, happened. And so did forgiveness and reconciliation.
My heart breaks for what Jameel went through - and I know that many others have experienced similar. But what we don't hear about too often is a response like his: forgiveness. Truly allowing God to get ahold of him and change him. Let. It. Go. ... an oft-repeated phrase, and thankfully not because of Frozen.
If these two men could go through what they did, the horrible and the incredible, who's to say that their own situation is hopeless? God is bigger than every situation we experience.
I strongly encourage each and every person reading this review to read Convicted cover to cover. It's a needed story for our time and the days we are walking through. You won't walk away unchanged.
I received a free ARC of Convicted; all opinions are my own.
August 20, 2017
"Convicted" is a compelling and gripping novel that will have you turning the pages as you read the story of Jameel and Andrew. Jameel was convicted of a crime and Andrew was the police officer who arrested him. However, the story doesn't end there, but starts there. This is the story of how two men had an experience where their lives would forever be changes when they each surrendered their lives and turned to God. It is a powerful story of forgiveness, redemption, reconciliation and the gift of new life. I love how the story is told is present tense as we hear the first accounts by both Andrew and Jameel. This book is perfect because it relates to how the world and Christian culture are handling things today. We need to be more willing to forgive and move on, instead of being angry and holding on to hate. This book would be perfect for a church who has a prison ministry as it offers hope to those who are convicted of crimes they did not commit. It is also encouraging as it shows that people are failed, broken and need a savior even if they are in high positions in the world, such a police officers. It shows that no one is better than another. We are all equally loved by our creator. Thank you to Waterbook Multnomah for providing a complimentary copy for review. A favorable review was not required. I give this book 5/5 stars.
August 22, 2017
Thank you, Blogging for Books for allowing me to read this amazing story.
I believe there are more stories like this across the country, but what you hear most often are the racially charged stories that end badly. Especially at this tough time our nation faces, this is a must read for everyone. It's a quick read, told from the perspectives of both people involved.
The story draws you in. It reads like a typical movie we've all watched about crooked cops except that this is a true story. It is truly shocking what Andrew admits to doing over the course of his career. It really opened my eyes to the racial divide that I have no personal experience with.
I am a Christian, and a religious person, but I don't appreciate religious views from others being shoved down my throat. There is none of that in this story. It definitely touches on their journeys of finding Christ and on forgiveness but is not overwhelming or uncomfortable if you're not religious.
I believe there are more stories like this across the country, but what you hear most often are the racially charged stories that end badly. Especially at this tough time our nation faces, this is a must read for everyone. It's a quick read, told from the perspectives of both people involved.
The story draws you in. It reads like a typical movie we've all watched about crooked cops except that this is a true story. It is truly shocking what Andrew admits to doing over the course of his career. It really opened my eyes to the racial divide that I have no personal experience with.
I am a Christian, and a religious person, but I don't appreciate religious views from others being shoved down my throat. There is none of that in this story. It definitely touches on their journeys of finding Christ and on forgiveness but is not overwhelming or uncomfortable if you're not religious.
August 5, 2017
This book is amazing! I received an advance copy of the book, and went into it thinking this would be an interesting story. This story is so beautifully written and gripping at the same time. It took me one day to read, I couldn't put it down. If you want to read about real life forgiveness in action than get this book. It's amazing and thought proving. I recommend to everyone!!!
August 11, 2017
This book is amazing. One of the best love and forgiveness stories I have ever heard. I am so glad Jameel and Andrew have been able to share their story!
September 7, 2017
Wow, with all the negative lately in the news regarding crooked cops etc this book is really a breath of fresh air. Worth Reading!!
July 31, 2019
An amazing story because it reveals God's sovereignty, mercy, grace, and love. This is the true story of a crooked police officer and an innocent man he falsely arrested and helped convict. It follows their lives from the time of the arrest forward. God, in His sovereignty, reunites them and provides a powerful illustration of the forgiveness only available because of Jesus Christ. Incredible story! Sort of a Joseph story where "ye meant it for evil but God meant it for good."
February 17, 2022
With all the tensions in our world right now, this is a BEAUTIFUL book to read. I think it shows that while we are broken people, we can still show love, kindness and forgiveness. That’s what this world needs so much of right now. By far my favorite book I’ve read and helps me to remember to forgive when it can feel impossible.
September 20, 2017
Convicted (2017) by Jameel McGee and Andrew Collins is a true story about a crooked cop and an innocent man. This non-fiction text will be released on September 19, 2017. This book will come in all forms including eBook, and is 213 pages in length. With a full-time job and a five-year old at home, this book took me three days to read. I received a copy of this book from WaterBrook Press; all opinions expressed in this review are my own. I give this book 5 STARS. This text is a Non-Fiction Christian biography.
Reading this book is like going on a roller coaster. I went through every type of emotion possible from shock to anger to disbelief to resignation to defeat to hope. This text is a must read for everyone! It will challenge you, it will hold a mirror up to you and force you to confront some ugly truths that may be lurking deep inside. This book will help you draw closer to God.
When I signed up to be part of the book launch team for this book, I didn’t really have any expectations. The description of the book caught my attention, and it really caught my husband’s attention, but I didn’t really know what to expect. I actually thought it would be a bit stereotypical: a wicked white cop with an ego the size of Antartica, and a poor black man. I didn’t want that story. That story is always being told on TV, in movies, and in the news. Now, Andrew Collins does eventually describe himself as a bad cop with an ego and pride problem, and Jameel Collins does become a poor black man because of depression and bad life choices, BUT this book is not a stereotype. What I really like about the book is that it is told through both men’s points of view. One chapter is Jameel’s, the next is Andrew’s, and it continues to switch back and forth as the events take place. The reader gets to see the same event in history through two eyes. I loved this so much. It was fascinating to see an event unfold through two vastly different people’s experiences.
Forgiveness is hard. Forgiveness is really hard. Whether you have to give it or accept it, it’s one of the hardest things to experience. If you have to give it, you have to overcome your pride, arrogance, fear, failings, etc., which is a really hard thing to do. Many times, our egos and selves get in the way, and we don’t even realize it. If you have to receive forgiveness, you have to overcome your anger and distrust with the person who hurt you. For me, anger is my Achilles heal. I relate so much to Jameel McGee’s struggle with anger and forgiveness in this book that many times it felt like I was looking into a mirror while I was reading. This book is a Godsend. There are so many good reminders in this book, but for me, the best reminder is Proverbs 15:1, “A soft answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger” (ESV).
I cannot express how important this book is. I highly, highly recommend it. This is a story that needs to be read by everyone, especially with all that is going on in our nation today. This book has left a lasting impression in me. It has shown me some things I need to change NOW. And, it has again shown me just how important and necessary it is to draw close to God every day. I hope that when this book is released, you purchase a copy immediately.
Reading this book is like going on a roller coaster. I went through every type of emotion possible from shock to anger to disbelief to resignation to defeat to hope. This text is a must read for everyone! It will challenge you, it will hold a mirror up to you and force you to confront some ugly truths that may be lurking deep inside. This book will help you draw closer to God.
When I signed up to be part of the book launch team for this book, I didn’t really have any expectations. The description of the book caught my attention, and it really caught my husband’s attention, but I didn’t really know what to expect. I actually thought it would be a bit stereotypical: a wicked white cop with an ego the size of Antartica, and a poor black man. I didn’t want that story. That story is always being told on TV, in movies, and in the news. Now, Andrew Collins does eventually describe himself as a bad cop with an ego and pride problem, and Jameel Collins does become a poor black man because of depression and bad life choices, BUT this book is not a stereotype. What I really like about the book is that it is told through both men’s points of view. One chapter is Jameel’s, the next is Andrew’s, and it continues to switch back and forth as the events take place. The reader gets to see the same event in history through two eyes. I loved this so much. It was fascinating to see an event unfold through two vastly different people’s experiences.
Forgiveness is hard. Forgiveness is really hard. Whether you have to give it or accept it, it’s one of the hardest things to experience. If you have to give it, you have to overcome your pride, arrogance, fear, failings, etc., which is a really hard thing to do. Many times, our egos and selves get in the way, and we don’t even realize it. If you have to receive forgiveness, you have to overcome your anger and distrust with the person who hurt you. For me, anger is my Achilles heal. I relate so much to Jameel McGee’s struggle with anger and forgiveness in this book that many times it felt like I was looking into a mirror while I was reading. This book is a Godsend. There are so many good reminders in this book, but for me, the best reminder is Proverbs 15:1, “A soft answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger” (ESV).
I cannot express how important this book is. I highly, highly recommend it. This is a story that needs to be read by everyone, especially with all that is going on in our nation today. This book has left a lasting impression in me. It has shown me some things I need to change NOW. And, it has again shown me just how important and necessary it is to draw close to God every day. I hope that when this book is released, you purchase a copy immediately.
July 12, 2021
Very timely book and my book club had some interesting discussions.
August 23, 2017
“Voiceless...I took his voice away...How many more voices have I stolen? Whose am I stifling now? I pray this book gives [Jameel] back his voice.”
Convicted is a true story of Jameel and Andrew as well as the events leading up to, surrounding, and following February 8, 2006. Both men have made decisions that led to their lives intersecting in many ways. As the title infers, this story accounts a cop determined to convict, no matter the cost, and an innocent man who was at the wrong place at the wrong time. Jameel and Andrew learn about forgiveness and letting go in different ways.
Jameel is from Benton Harbor, MI, where the population is predominately black, drugs rule the streets, and there is little trust between the people and their police department. On February 8, 2006, Andrew arrested Jameel for possession of drugs with intent to distribute. Andrew was absolutely sure he caught a notorious local drug dealer and he was sure the conviction would hold up. Andrew had a history of pushing the limits of the law, falsifying police reports, and being a dirty cop. But that didn’t matter because he was “cleaning up the streets.”
Most of the book focuses on the events taking place after Jameel’s arrest. We follow Jameel’s trial and time in prison. In prison, Jameel is forced with a tough decision—should be carry on the way he always has? Or should he let people in and share his story? On the other hand, we follow Andrew’s climb to being the top narcotics detective in the city, the choices Andrew made, and his inevitable downfall. However, we also get to see each man make the best of the hand they were dealt and how they overcame the men they were in the past.
Andrew and Jameel’s lives intersect in Benton Harbor in multiple ways. Both men have to decide whether revenge or a clear conscious is the better option. The growth of both men is evident over the course of the several years this novel spans. In finding and listening to God, each man learns that forgiveness is the best course of action and that both men have something to offer Benton Harbor.
In this story, we learn of forgiveness and how far love and understanding can take us. I highly recommend this book. It is both eye opening and heart-warming to know that two men who were on the opposite sides of the law, one guilty of committing crimes and the other innocent, have woven two separate stories that come together in an unexpected way. I am impressed with the writing style and the set up of this book. I love seeing both Andrew’s and Jameel’s perspective of the same pivotal event and how each man deals with the fallout from the choices he made.
I received this book from Blogging for Books in exchange for this review.
Convicted is a true story of Jameel and Andrew as well as the events leading up to, surrounding, and following February 8, 2006. Both men have made decisions that led to their lives intersecting in many ways. As the title infers, this story accounts a cop determined to convict, no matter the cost, and an innocent man who was at the wrong place at the wrong time. Jameel and Andrew learn about forgiveness and letting go in different ways.
Jameel is from Benton Harbor, MI, where the population is predominately black, drugs rule the streets, and there is little trust between the people and their police department. On February 8, 2006, Andrew arrested Jameel for possession of drugs with intent to distribute. Andrew was absolutely sure he caught a notorious local drug dealer and he was sure the conviction would hold up. Andrew had a history of pushing the limits of the law, falsifying police reports, and being a dirty cop. But that didn’t matter because he was “cleaning up the streets.”
Most of the book focuses on the events taking place after Jameel’s arrest. We follow Jameel’s trial and time in prison. In prison, Jameel is forced with a tough decision—should be carry on the way he always has? Or should he let people in and share his story? On the other hand, we follow Andrew’s climb to being the top narcotics detective in the city, the choices Andrew made, and his inevitable downfall. However, we also get to see each man make the best of the hand they were dealt and how they overcame the men they were in the past.
Andrew and Jameel’s lives intersect in Benton Harbor in multiple ways. Both men have to decide whether revenge or a clear conscious is the better option. The growth of both men is evident over the course of the several years this novel spans. In finding and listening to God, each man learns that forgiveness is the best course of action and that both men have something to offer Benton Harbor.
In this story, we learn of forgiveness and how far love and understanding can take us. I highly recommend this book. It is both eye opening and heart-warming to know that two men who were on the opposite sides of the law, one guilty of committing crimes and the other innocent, have woven two separate stories that come together in an unexpected way. I am impressed with the writing style and the set up of this book. I love seeing both Andrew’s and Jameel’s perspective of the same pivotal event and how each man deals with the fallout from the choices he made.
I received this book from Blogging for Books in exchange for this review.
August 9, 2017
Wow, just wow! What a moving, convicting story. I'm not one to read non-fiction stories but this one was so amazing and was so well written that it read like a fiction story. Two men tell their stories and their amazing transformations. God was in this from the beginning. You can see his "fingerprints" on it all.
Jameel was a young black man and seemed to be in the wrong place at the wrong time more than once. Each time mistaken identity or mistaken circumstances landed him in jail and or prison.
Andrew was a hard-nosed "dirty" cop. He worked to put drug dealers and sellers behind bars no matter how he had to do it. Each arrest got easier and easier and he bent the rules and laws more than not to get the job done. Lying, planting evidence, forging signatures, whatever it took!
One of those times what he did put an innocent Jameel in prison for a minimum of ten years.
This is a story of forgiveness, love, and God's amazing grace. A story like I've never read before. I'm convinced if everyone were required to read this story, so many of our problems with each other would be reconciled.
I received an uncorrected proof of Convicted and was not required to write a review, positive or otherwise. All opinions are strictly my own.
Jameel was a young black man and seemed to be in the wrong place at the wrong time more than once. Each time mistaken identity or mistaken circumstances landed him in jail and or prison.
Andrew was a hard-nosed "dirty" cop. He worked to put drug dealers and sellers behind bars no matter how he had to do it. Each arrest got easier and easier and he bent the rules and laws more than not to get the job done. Lying, planting evidence, forging signatures, whatever it took!
One of those times what he did put an innocent Jameel in prison for a minimum of ten years.
This is a story of forgiveness, love, and God's amazing grace. A story like I've never read before. I'm convinced if everyone were required to read this story, so many of our problems with each other would be reconciled.
I received an uncorrected proof of Convicted and was not required to write a review, positive or otherwise. All opinions are strictly my own.
August 25, 2017
Inspiring story of forgiveness.
Convicted is a true story of two men who were caught in the snare of ego, greed, and corruption, one inadvertently, the other intentionally. Jameel McGee is an innocent man who was convicted because of a corrupt and arrogant cop, Andrew Collins. Convicted is a story of God's grace and redemptive power in a frustrating situation of injustice that could have led to murder and revenge. Racial unrest, poverty, and drugs all played a part in creating a scenario where this true life tragedy occurred. A young man making a wrong choice and a cop who had no qualms about shaping the truth to ensure indictments...you say what you need to say to get a conviction and who cares whose life is shattered. The journey to freedom from fear and anger and to friendship and fellowship from this appalling beginning is an amazing testament to a God of second chances. Written from both men's viewpoints, readers are given an eye witness account of the background, arrest, conviction, and imprisonment--gritty and divisive. The story moves quickly and kept my interest as I wondered how things would be turned around...how God would work in each of their lives to bring about reconciliation. Convicted sends a powerful message that God is alive and at work in our lives as we let go and let Him do His redemptive, restorative work.
I received a complimentary advance reader copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a review and the opinions are my own.
Convicted is a true story of two men who were caught in the snare of ego, greed, and corruption, one inadvertently, the other intentionally. Jameel McGee is an innocent man who was convicted because of a corrupt and arrogant cop, Andrew Collins. Convicted is a story of God's grace and redemptive power in a frustrating situation of injustice that could have led to murder and revenge. Racial unrest, poverty, and drugs all played a part in creating a scenario where this true life tragedy occurred. A young man making a wrong choice and a cop who had no qualms about shaping the truth to ensure indictments...you say what you need to say to get a conviction and who cares whose life is shattered. The journey to freedom from fear and anger and to friendship and fellowship from this appalling beginning is an amazing testament to a God of second chances. Written from both men's viewpoints, readers are given an eye witness account of the background, arrest, conviction, and imprisonment--gritty and divisive. The story moves quickly and kept my interest as I wondered how things would be turned around...how God would work in each of their lives to bring about reconciliation. Convicted sends a powerful message that God is alive and at work in our lives as we let go and let Him do His redemptive, restorative work.
I received a complimentary advance reader copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a review and the opinions are my own.
August 26, 2017
“Convicted” is written by Jameel McGee (the prisoner) and Andrew Collins (the policeman).
“Convicted” is a true story that is shocking!
First there is the outrage over the treatment Jameel gets from the police, and when he gets sent to prison even though he is innocent! Yes, I felt outrage!
Secondly there is the astonishment that Andrew, a former policeman, would so honestly expose the illegal activities that are practiced by many of the police he worked with, and by Andrew himself! Truly amazing that he has admitted to everything dishonest that he did.
BUT then Jesus! Jesus enters the picture and changes everything!
I was cheering on both of these men – Jameel and Andrew. What they did is truly awesome! They went beyond what anyone would expect of them. You don’t want to miss reading this book! It could become a movie one day, but don’t wait for that! READ this book!
“Convicted” is a true story that is shocking!
First there is the outrage over the treatment Jameel gets from the police, and when he gets sent to prison even though he is innocent! Yes, I felt outrage!
Secondly there is the astonishment that Andrew, a former policeman, would so honestly expose the illegal activities that are practiced by many of the police he worked with, and by Andrew himself! Truly amazing that he has admitted to everything dishonest that he did.
BUT then Jesus! Jesus enters the picture and changes everything!
I was cheering on both of these men – Jameel and Andrew. What they did is truly awesome! They went beyond what anyone would expect of them. You don’t want to miss reading this book! It could become a movie one day, but don’t wait for that! READ this book!
January 1, 2018
A timely read, given the state of our nation today; this book was compelling. It made me angry and frustrated. It also gave me hope as I saw God turn around the lives of the authors.
I am sure that it wasn’t the intent, but I am going to say I felt this book made all cops look bad. We know they’re not. I personally know some great cops. However, given the area of Michigan in which this took place and knowing the racial issues that have happened, I can understand why. I say I understand; I understand as much as possible. I haven’t lived the way people have lived in Benton Harbor although I have found it appalling over the years.
As the author’s pointed out, you cannot heal without complete forgiveness. We see that it is possible to forgive those who have wronged us. And it is possible to receive forgiveness when you’ve done terrible things. Christ is always there and ready to forgive. What an awesome testimony of this! I have had my eyes opened to some of the issues faced by both authors. Both were wounded deep in their souls, causing the problems that arose. I highly recommend this book to people who want to make a difference in this world.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review.
I am sure that it wasn’t the intent, but I am going to say I felt this book made all cops look bad. We know they’re not. I personally know some great cops. However, given the area of Michigan in which this took place and knowing the racial issues that have happened, I can understand why. I say I understand; I understand as much as possible. I haven’t lived the way people have lived in Benton Harbor although I have found it appalling over the years.
As the author’s pointed out, you cannot heal without complete forgiveness. We see that it is possible to forgive those who have wronged us. And it is possible to receive forgiveness when you’ve done terrible things. Christ is always there and ready to forgive. What an awesome testimony of this! I have had my eyes opened to some of the issues faced by both authors. Both were wounded deep in their souls, causing the problems that arose. I highly recommend this book to people who want to make a difference in this world.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review.
August 21, 2017
Powerful! Amazing! Absolutely Incredible!
Convicted is a book that is definitely a "must-read". I was hooked from the beginning!
Convicted is a true story. It's constant action, exciting, moving, and very well- written. The primary characters of the story are also the book's main authors. Jameel McGee and Andrew Collins couldn't have been more different. Together, they wrote their true story, each from their own unique perspective.
Convicted is so relevant to today's world, and a first-hand account similar to current headlines. Anyone who reads Convicted will come away with hope, and be greatly inspired by the power of forgiveness.
I want to tell you all the details, but I would love for you to read Convicted for yourself. It's a story that will amaze you, but it will touch your heart. You will be filled with hope. It's a book you'll love reading, but one that you will want to share.
I very highly recommend Convicted.
*I am blessed to have been able to read Convicted. I received an Advanced Reader's Copy in exchange for my honest review. The opinion stated is my own. I have not been compensated in any way.*
Convicted is a book that is definitely a "must-read". I was hooked from the beginning!
Convicted is a true story. It's constant action, exciting, moving, and very well- written. The primary characters of the story are also the book's main authors. Jameel McGee and Andrew Collins couldn't have been more different. Together, they wrote their true story, each from their own unique perspective.
Convicted is so relevant to today's world, and a first-hand account similar to current headlines. Anyone who reads Convicted will come away with hope, and be greatly inspired by the power of forgiveness.
I want to tell you all the details, but I would love for you to read Convicted for yourself. It's a story that will amaze you, but it will touch your heart. You will be filled with hope. It's a book you'll love reading, but one that you will want to share.
I very highly recommend Convicted.
*I am blessed to have been able to read Convicted. I received an Advanced Reader's Copy in exchange for my honest review. The opinion stated is my own. I have not been compensated in any way.*
September 19, 2017
We read the headlines in the local paper as Andrew Collins,a Benton Harbor detective, was indicted for lying on police reports, possessing drugs with intent to sell, and generally being a dishonest cop. I remember the sinking feeling,as a nearby community member, knowing that many drug users and abusers would now be released because of this dishonest cop.
What we didn't know, as Paul Harvey used to say, was the rest of the story. Now, almost 11 years later, Andrew Collins has teamed up with one of those people he helped wrongfully convict, Jameel McGee, to write the book, Convicted.
It is a story of two men, one black and one white, in a racially divided town(still very racially segregated, in thinking and living quarters). One man, who had power, used it wrongly against the innocent powerless and ruined his life. Yet the powerful is cast down, as well.
What God brings out of the ashes is truly unimaginable,again to me as someone who lives nearby. Only God could bring about such change in not one, but two hearts! This is an incredible story of forgiveness that only God can write.
I wish everyone in our county, and in any racially charged area could read this story, be drawn to Christ, then ask if he/she is forgiving as Christ commands. These men are leading the way by their example!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, which in no way influenced my opinions,which are solely my own.
What we didn't know, as Paul Harvey used to say, was the rest of the story. Now, almost 11 years later, Andrew Collins has teamed up with one of those people he helped wrongfully convict, Jameel McGee, to write the book, Convicted.
It is a story of two men, one black and one white, in a racially divided town(still very racially segregated, in thinking and living quarters). One man, who had power, used it wrongly against the innocent powerless and ruined his life. Yet the powerful is cast down, as well.
What God brings out of the ashes is truly unimaginable,again to me as someone who lives nearby. Only God could bring about such change in not one, but two hearts! This is an incredible story of forgiveness that only God can write.
I wish everyone in our county, and in any racially charged area could read this story, be drawn to Christ, then ask if he/she is forgiving as Christ commands. These men are leading the way by their example!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, which in no way influenced my opinions,which are solely my own.
August 18, 2017
This is an excellent book and I love that it is a first hand account written back and forth. between Jameel and Andrew. They each got to tell their stories. Jameel had a hard life, and it's a very clear picture of what is meant by the term "privelege". But what amazed me was his humility and taking responsibility for the parts of his story that were a result of his actions instead of staying angry about everything that had happened to him. The story also gives us a look into the culture of the police force, at least in that area, and how someone could justify their wrong actions. The book doesn't directly address these themes, but we also get a look at the relationship between crime and poverty, racial tension, prejudices, issues with the prison system and the difficulty convicted criminals have afterwards, and the difficulty of overcoming homelessness. This is an amazing story of reconciliation and, most of all, of the transforming power of the love of God. Thank you, Waterbrook Multnomah for the opportunity to read and review this book.
August 22, 2017
This book!! This is not a book I would normally read and I am SO pleased that I read it! The amazing hardships, injustice and general brutally honest look at the libes of these men...is amazing, humbling. It is a book that should be read and shared, especially the way the world is. We need to expose ourselves to these stories. It is a powerful tale and leaves the reader with new perspective on life, hope for humanity, and understanding for how powerful grace in Christ is. Beautiful. Read it.
August 11, 2017
What an amazing book! Convicted was about two men from two different walks of life, Andrew Collins, a cop who let his ego get to him and operates like the law does not pertain to him and Jameel McGee, an innocent man who is in the wrong place at the wrong time. They both land up in prison and start on a journey together neither envisioned when they started their day. One that saw suffering first hand, but yet the first one to forgive the police officer. A true story of hope, forgiveness, redemption, love, truth. Both land up in prison, once released they are faced with accepting responsibility for their actions and from that they rediscover what forgiveness really is in a racially divided city. God uses situation we are all in to get our attention and protect us.
August 18, 2017
This book will draw you in and keep your interest. This true story reads like a dramatic crime novel. It is a picture of what God does in a life that is open to Him.
August 11, 2017
Jameel, an innocent man, is caught in the wrong circumstance, in the wrong place at the wrong time. Andrew is the crooked cop who arrests Jameel with no evidence, yet Jameel is convicted anyway. This is the powerful story of the changes God works in the hearts and lives of these men through these circumstances, and the lives that are changed because of them. I don't read a lot of non-fiction, but was invited to be part of the launch team of this book, and received a copy from the publisher. I am privileged to have this chance to spread the word about the power and grace of God working in the lives of the men and women involved in this story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 163 reviews