Mackenzie White is a detective in a small town in Nebraska. A young and inexperienced officer, her older, male colleagues treat her with disrespect and undermine her authority. That is, until a serial killer starts targeting women in and around their town. When Mackenzie is the first to uncover a valuable lead, she is promoted to head the investigation. Local opinion quickly changes as she narrows down the killer.
Obviously the 1 star rating means that I did not like the book. However, let me preface by saying that this book was a free download. If you are stuck in an airport, out of books to read, or just want a quick and mindless page turner, this isn't the worst option - if it is still free.
Here are my top 4 issues with Before He Kills.
1. A realistic mystery/thriller needs to be REALISTIC. Mackenzie is the most stereotypical female character I have ever read about. She is pretty, extremely fit, can eat anything and stay thin, successful, the object of every man's eye, stuck with a dead beat boyfriend and underestimated because of her gender. Of course she pushes for equality and immediately gets it after uncovering one basic lead. A character must have flaws for the reader to relate to him/her. Blake Pierce over characterized Mackenzie to the point of being almost laughable. Furthermore, when a character is facing a challenge, it is important that he or she realistically resolves it and suffers from it to be a sympathetic problem.
2. A good mystery/thriller presents the predator discreetly to cause suspense and anticipation. Pierce almost immediately wrote from the serial killer's perspective and the took away the "whodunnit." From the beginning the reader knew who the serial killer was and why he was killing the women. Then it was just waiting for Detective Mackenzie White to catch up and figure it out. Very boring.
3. Good writing shows the reader, it doesn't tell the reader. Analogies and similes are to creatively describe what is happening; entertain and engross the reader. Explaining each simile and analogy defeats the purpose. If a writer needs to explain an analogy and why it relates to the story, he/she probably selected the wrong one.
4. Blake Pierce needs a new editor. This may have help with number 3 as well. However, the sheer number of grammatical errors was incredibly distracting. Pierce even got situational facts mixed up.
Overall, Before He Kills was a large disappointment.