More of a 4.5. Listened on audio. This book was crazy helpful and I will be buying a paper copy. The authors are Christian counselors and go through emotional, social, and spiritual milestones that kids of different age groups need to work on. There are building blocks and stumbling blocks that they address for each one. The info is also separated out by gender which helps as well. I can’t outline the book bc there were too many details. And that’s not my forte. I felt like I was already well acquainted with the emotional and spiritual skills for younger kids, especially boys. But social skills, older kids, and girl stuff are new to me!
There were a couple things that bugged me, some personal and some legit issues with the book. It was personally hard for me to learn about support I haven’t received and skills I don’t have. This isn’t the authors’ fault, of course, but it was a challenge for me. But it was also helpful because I was able to see and work through things in my own heart there.
The other issue is one I have with many books, including Christian nonfiction: the authors come from a specific mindset and act as though it’s normative, when really it’s just one way of living. Theirs is a white western upper middle class evangelical neurotypical perspective. They briefly touch on adhd and autism as potential roadblocks to learning these things, but dealing with other perspectives seemed out of the scope of this book.
I’d love an updated version with things like neurodiversity, racism, disability, poverty, and cultural differences addressed as potential roadblocks. People in different circumstances may value different spiritual, emotional, and social skills and may approach this book differently. Im not saying this because I’m trying to be an intersectional snowflake, but because I found their advice hard to follow in my very ADHD home, and extra tips would help me. Specifically in things relating to executive function like emotional control and social skills. I can also imagine someone with an eastern perspective thinking certain milestones are more or less important based on cultural values.
But I am an American, as are my kids, so it will help us trust God and worship him with all our heart, soul, mind, and strength and love our neighbor as ourselves in our current circumstances. I learned a lot and look forward to applying it!