What do you think?
Rate this book
The Oberon Cycle #1
Skythane
Jameson Havercamp, a psych from a conservative religious colony, has come to Oberon—unique among the Common Worlds—in search of a rare substance called pith. He’s guided through the wilds on his quest by Xander Kinnson, a handsome, cocky skythane with a troubled past.
Neither knows that Oberon is facing imminent destruction. Even as the world starts to fall apart around them, they have no idea what’s coming—or the bond that will develop between them as they race to avert a cataclysm.
Together, they will journey to uncover the secrets of this strange and singular world, even as it takes them beyond the bounds of reality itself to discover what truly binds them together.
Neither knows that Oberon is facing imminent destruction. Even as the world starts to fall apart around them, they have no idea what’s coming—or the bond that will develop between them as they race to avert a cataclysm.
Together, they will journey to uncover the secrets of this strange and singular world, even as it takes them beyond the bounds of reality itself to discover what truly binds them together.
244 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 17, 2017
43 people are currently reading
358 people want to read
About the author
J. Scott Coatsworth
90 books188 followersScott lives with his husband in a leafy Sacramento, California suburb, in a cute yellow house with a pair of pink flamingoes in the front yard.
He has always been in the place between the here and now and the what could be. He started reading science fiction and fantasy at the tender age of nine, encouraged by his mother. But as he read the golden age classics and more modern works too, he started to wonder where all the queer people were.
When Scott came out at 23, he decided he wanted to create the kinds of stories he couldn't find at the bookstore. If there weren't gay characters in his favorite genres, he would reimagine them, filling them with a diverse universe of characters. He'd remake them to his own ends, and if he was lucky enough, someone would even want to read them.
Scott's brain works a little differently from most folks - he sees connections where others don't. Born an introvert, he learned how to reach outside himself and connect with other queer folks.
Scott's fiction defies expectations, transforming traditional science fiction, fantasy, and contemporary worlds into something fresh and surprising. He also created both Queer Sci Fi and QueeRomance Ink with his husband Mark, and is an associate member of the Science Fiction Writer's Association (SFWA).
His writing, both romance and genre fiction, brings a queer energy to his work, infusing them with love, beauty and strength and making them fly. He imagines how the world could be, and maybe changes the world that is, just a little.
Scott was recognized as one of the top new gay authors in the 2017 Rainbow Awards, and his debut novel "Skythane" received two awards and an honorable mention.
He has always been in the place between the here and now and the what could be. He started reading science fiction and fantasy at the tender age of nine, encouraged by his mother. But as he read the golden age classics and more modern works too, he started to wonder where all the queer people were.
When Scott came out at 23, he decided he wanted to create the kinds of stories he couldn't find at the bookstore. If there weren't gay characters in his favorite genres, he would reimagine them, filling them with a diverse universe of characters. He'd remake them to his own ends, and if he was lucky enough, someone would even want to read them.
Scott's brain works a little differently from most folks - he sees connections where others don't. Born an introvert, he learned how to reach outside himself and connect with other queer folks.
Scott's fiction defies expectations, transforming traditional science fiction, fantasy, and contemporary worlds into something fresh and surprising. He also created both Queer Sci Fi and QueeRomance Ink with his husband Mark, and is an associate member of the Science Fiction Writer's Association (SFWA).
His writing, both romance and genre fiction, brings a queer energy to his work, infusing them with love, beauty and strength and making them fly. He imagines how the world could be, and maybe changes the world that is, just a little.
Scott was recognized as one of the top new gay authors in the 2017 Rainbow Awards, and his debut novel "Skythane" received two awards and an honorable mention.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews
February 26, 2017
Pretty dang good little sci-fi/fantasy story.
To be honest I liked this way more than I expected I would. I had just finished reading an amazing series and I couldn’t help but compare this book to it. But, once I got into the story I found myself comparing it less and less. The world building was fascinating. It was well thought out; no stone left unturned. I could tell the author spent tons of time on it, planning it out to the littlest detail.
Jameson has been asked to investigate why there has been a shortage of pith, a substance used primarily for medicinal purposes. He’s unsure as to why he was chosen for this task. He’s a nobody, just one more psych (therapist) in a sea of others of the like.
Once he arrives on Oberon he’s greeted by Xander, who will be his escort to where the pith is manufactured. Xander is a skythane, one of the winged humans from Oberon who are ostracized from the regular humans inhabiting the strange half-planet. Oberon is an enigma as it is literally half a planet and no one can figure out why it still exists and hasn’t gone spinning off into the universe or broken up into itty bitty pieces.
From the moment these two meet, the story takes off to an action packed adventure filled with high flying chases, gunfights, mystery and intrigue as they journey to the edge of the world and beyond. I was glued to my screen throughout. I just had to know what happened next and what enfolded was a fascinating tale about destiny and greatness. These two seemingly nobodies were much more than they first appeared.
The writing was creative. I loved the detailed history of the planet and its inhabitants that was told gradually as the story progressed. The character development was well above par and all of the characters, even the secondary ones, were fully fleshed. What I loved most was the delicate balance between sci-fi and fantasy that was woven into the book. Most of the time when I read sci-fi, it is all logical and straightforward without any fantasy to it so it was great to see a bit of magic thrown in.
I recommend Skythane to sci-fi lovers who like a little fantasy and romance mixed in to sweeten the pot. The romance does take a backseat but I didn’t mind at all, I was busy being distracted by the fabulous world building and enthralling storyline. They do get their HFN though, don’t worry about that. And the ending was left open for a sequel which I’m thankful for as I want to know more about this world. I can’t wait for the next book!
To be honest I liked this way more than I expected I would. I had just finished reading an amazing series and I couldn’t help but compare this book to it. But, once I got into the story I found myself comparing it less and less. The world building was fascinating. It was well thought out; no stone left unturned. I could tell the author spent tons of time on it, planning it out to the littlest detail.
Jameson has been asked to investigate why there has been a shortage of pith, a substance used primarily for medicinal purposes. He’s unsure as to why he was chosen for this task. He’s a nobody, just one more psych (therapist) in a sea of others of the like.
He was nothing special, a cog in the machine. A low-level psych who was never meant for anything greater than midlevel success.
Once he arrives on Oberon he’s greeted by Xander, who will be his escort to where the pith is manufactured. Xander is a skythane, one of the winged humans from Oberon who are ostracized from the regular humans inhabiting the strange half-planet. Oberon is an enigma as it is literally half a planet and no one can figure out why it still exists and hasn’t gone spinning off into the universe or broken up into itty bitty pieces.
From the moment these two meet, the story takes off to an action packed adventure filled with high flying chases, gunfights, mystery and intrigue as they journey to the edge of the world and beyond. I was glued to my screen throughout. I just had to know what happened next and what enfolded was a fascinating tale about destiny and greatness. These two seemingly nobodies were much more than they first appeared.
The writing was creative. I loved the detailed history of the planet and its inhabitants that was told gradually as the story progressed. The character development was well above par and all of the characters, even the secondary ones, were fully fleshed. What I loved most was the delicate balance between sci-fi and fantasy that was woven into the book. Most of the time when I read sci-fi, it is all logical and straightforward without any fantasy to it so it was great to see a bit of magic thrown in.
I recommend Skythane to sci-fi lovers who like a little fantasy and romance mixed in to sweeten the pot. The romance does take a backseat but I didn’t mind at all, I was busy being distracted by the fabulous world building and enthralling storyline. They do get their HFN though, don’t worry about that. And the ending was left open for a sequel which I’m thankful for as I want to know more about this world. I can’t wait for the next book!
October 13, 2020
‘Skythane’ is the exciting opening novel to what looks to be a fascinating series set in the future around the year 3000 or so, as far as I can determine. Oberon is a pretty unique world – it is split into two halves, with its other side hidden in some mysterious parallel universe. This has all sorts of consequences for the planetary ecology, and it was fascinating to find out more details about this well-developed world as the story developed. But solar flares signal a potential catastrophe, one that occurs every 750 years or so, and this time the event might just mean the end of this planet. As if that were not enough, there is an addictive substance called pith, drug smugglers and corporate interests battling for supremacy, and a cultural war between the skythane and the landers. Skythane are descendants of the first wave of human colonization, who genetically engineered themselves to have wings and can fly. The second wave of human settlers are called landers and they despise the skythane. No, that doesn’t really make sense, but racism never does, no matter what millennium it happens in.
Please find my full review of the second edition on Rainbow Book Reviews.
Please find my full review of the second edition on Rainbow Book Reviews.
January 7, 2018
Большую часть книги думала, что поставлю "пятерку". Но в последней трети (или четверти) динамика и атмосфера изменились. Сюжет развязали как будто второпях, и удовлетворительной концовки не получилось.
Я разочарована, так как первые две трети я читала взахлеб, не имея сил оторваться от интересного мира и захватывающего сюжета. Но автор заготовил трилогию, и я почитаю продолжение обязательно, интерес к этому миру не угас.
Я разочарована, так как первые две трети я читала взахлеб, не имея сил оторваться от интересного мира и захватывающего сюжета. Но автор заготовил трилогию, и я почитаю продолжение обязательно, интерес к этому миру не угас.
March 24, 2018
I thought I would like this book but never thought that I would love it! Terrific world building and character development from beginning to end. All of the sex was off page which kept me glued to the story itself. The memory flash backs were well done and made the awful info dump unnecessary. I'm diving right into Lander. Bravo!
March 22, 2017
4.5 Stars.
March 1, 2017
Is there anything more attractive than the idea of people having wings? For me, at least, there isn’t. Since I was younger, I’ve always relished the idea of having actual wings attached to my back, and whenever I see those “Would you rather?” questions about super powers, I always gravitate towards the wings. I want the power of flight, but I better have some big, beautiful wings to do it. I don’t care how much they get in the way. Bring it on!
With that said, Skythane appealed to me. The cover is gorgeous, and I liked the idea of people who at one point were genetically engineered to have wings. That, coupled with a world that is literally split in half, and I was hooked. It sounded like such a fascinating premise. Mixing science fiction and fantasy is not always a good move, and there are many authors who have attempted to do so and failed, but Coatsworth pulled it off nicely. While the first half of the book was more focused on the science fiction, the latter half was dedicated to the fantasy, and the divide was done neatly.
Xander is a skythane man living in Oberon, a planet that has literally been split in two by some cataclysmic event in the ancient past. How it happened and how the planet doesn’t collapse, no one knows. He is given a job to collect a psych who is coming to work for OberCorp to discover the pith shortage.
Jameson is the psych, a lander from the religious world of Beta Tau. He’s a bit stuffy, does his job well, and is more or less resigned to the fact that he is going to marry a woman. It’s what his parents want, after all.
When the two men meet, they are immediately attacked by enforcers from OberCorp, and soon their entire lives are flipped upside down. Nothing is safe and they no longer know who they even are. When Xander’s friend Quince arrives to help them, it becomes clear she has a lot of secrets she’s been keeping, and she is planning something big. But what?
Xander and Jameson were interesting characters. I enjoyed seeing Xander grow as a character and become more serious and focused on his forced task. Jameson grew even more. Not only did he discover his true past, but he became a strong individual determined to do what needs to be done in order to save the world.
Quince was a bit hit or miss for me. While I did like her character, she made some choices that I had serious problems with.
While it bothered me just a little bit at first, the more I thought about it, the angrier I got. I don’t know whether to believe the characters truly care about each other, or if their feelings are because of the drug. And that is disappointing.
Morgan was an interesting character, but I wanted to know more about him. He’s introduced randomly, and he becomes integral to the plot, driving it along at the perfect times (and conveniently so) in order to get to the end goal…and then nothing. What is he? Why was he at the abandoned farm? Was he placed there for Xander? How long was he waiting?
Two other things bothered me, not enough to not enjoy the book but enough that I noticed it and was bothered by it. First, the use of flashbacks. They’re used often. A little too often, to be honest, and while they reveal interesting things, I wish it had been done a little less or in different ways. Finally, the lack of sex scenes. Now, I don’t need sex scenes in a book to enjoy it; however, the author hinted at them throughout the book and I was getting excited to see the tension between Jameson and Xander finally break (plus, hey, hot wing sex), but when the moment comes, it fades to black very quickly. This lack also helped in my wondering how much the characters truly cared about each other because I couldn’t feel it.
Overall, I did enjoy the story. I really did. I liked the characters and the world building was fascinating. The explanation for how the worlds were able stay without crumbling and collapsing under the force of gravity was explained in a very unique way. The book is also left WIDE OPEN for a sequel ,and I’m curious as to what will happen because I was unsettled by the ending. So, will I read the next book? Yes, I will.
Fans of sci-fi fantasy blends should enjoy this book. If you’re a fan of men with the power of flight due to gorgeous wings, then this will also appeal to you as it appealed to me.
Reviewed by Jennifer for The Novel Approach Reviews
With that said, Skythane appealed to me. The cover is gorgeous, and I liked the idea of people who at one point were genetically engineered to have wings. That, coupled with a world that is literally split in half, and I was hooked. It sounded like such a fascinating premise. Mixing science fiction and fantasy is not always a good move, and there are many authors who have attempted to do so and failed, but Coatsworth pulled it off nicely. While the first half of the book was more focused on the science fiction, the latter half was dedicated to the fantasy, and the divide was done neatly.
Xander is a skythane man living in Oberon, a planet that has literally been split in two by some cataclysmic event in the ancient past. How it happened and how the planet doesn’t collapse, no one knows. He is given a job to collect a psych who is coming to work for OberCorp to discover the pith shortage.
Jameson is the psych, a lander from the religious world of Beta Tau. He’s a bit stuffy, does his job well, and is more or less resigned to the fact that he is going to marry a woman. It’s what his parents want, after all.
When the two men meet, they are immediately attacked by enforcers from OberCorp, and soon their entire lives are flipped upside down. Nothing is safe and they no longer know who they even are. When Xander’s friend Quince arrives to help them, it becomes clear she has a lot of secrets she’s been keeping, and she is planning something big. But what?
Xander and Jameson were interesting characters. I enjoyed seeing Xander grow as a character and become more serious and focused on his forced task. Jameson grew even more. Not only did he discover his true past, but he became a strong individual determined to do what needs to be done in order to save the world.
Quince was a bit hit or miss for me. While I did like her character, she made some choices that I had serious problems with.
While it bothered me just a little bit at first, the more I thought about it, the angrier I got. I don’t know whether to believe the characters truly care about each other, or if their feelings are because of the drug. And that is disappointing.
Morgan was an interesting character, but I wanted to know more about him. He’s introduced randomly, and he becomes integral to the plot, driving it along at the perfect times (and conveniently so) in order to get to the end goal…and then nothing. What is he? Why was he at the abandoned farm? Was he placed there for Xander? How long was he waiting?
Two other things bothered me, not enough to not enjoy the book but enough that I noticed it and was bothered by it. First, the use of flashbacks. They’re used often. A little too often, to be honest, and while they reveal interesting things, I wish it had been done a little less or in different ways. Finally, the lack of sex scenes. Now, I don’t need sex scenes in a book to enjoy it; however, the author hinted at them throughout the book and I was getting excited to see the tension between Jameson and Xander finally break (plus, hey, hot wing sex), but when the moment comes, it fades to black very quickly. This lack also helped in my wondering how much the characters truly cared about each other because I couldn’t feel it.
Overall, I did enjoy the story. I really did. I liked the characters and the world building was fascinating. The explanation for how the worlds were able stay without crumbling and collapsing under the force of gravity was explained in a very unique way. The book is also left WIDE OPEN for a sequel ,and I’m curious as to what will happen because I was unsettled by the ending. So, will I read the next book? Yes, I will.
Fans of sci-fi fantasy blends should enjoy this book. If you’re a fan of men with the power of flight due to gorgeous wings, then this will also appeal to you as it appealed to me.
Reviewed by Jennifer for The Novel Approach Reviews
April 23, 2018
3.8 Stars
So I was super excited about this one; I love books that start during NaNoWriMo...and the author's note at the beginning cranked up my anticipation even more.
For the first half of the book this eagerness held. The world-building was great, the characters interesting, the plot engaging. But...then it dragged on in the middle as the MCs struggled to get to their destination. (Seriously, too much camping detailed.) And that bit in the AN about how the book originally started on a sex scene? Well it got moved in a bit...and honestly? That exchange with a whore? Was more explicit than the ones to follow with the MCs - all of them were basically fade-to-black.
Which is okay in principle (I don't mind non-explicit stories), but if the most detailed sex scene is with someone of absolutely no importance? I think that short-changes the growing intimacy with the characters. And given one of them thought himself to be straight? Yeah, an afterthought about how he had to re-think his orientation and the way he was raised (in a "Christianist" world)...well, I wanted more of that at the time of discovery.
But still, I was engaged with the plot. It's definitely more Fantasy-based than Scifi. Sure it takes place on another planet and one part of that world has a dystopian feel...but there are shared memories with ancestors, the interference of "gods" and a sketchy plan to save the planet (that was decidedly paranormal in theory as well as practice) plus some magical creatures with unexplained abilities...which tilted it to the Fantasy genre. I'm not mad at that; the story was that interesting
The last part was frenetic and intense. The author did a good job with conveying the urgency necessary to protect the more technologically advanced world on the other side of this planet, somehow split in two with each existing in a different dimension (or maybe an alternate universe?)...ESPECIALLY with that epilogue.
And the epilogue? Yeah, that introduced a cliff-hanger of some epic proportions when I was all set to see how the worlds dealt with being reunited and calling it a day. So I'm probably gonna read that one as well...because DAMN! Can't wait to see how that turns out. (I do have a theory about Alix: .)
So I was super excited about this one; I love books that start during NaNoWriMo...and the author's note at the beginning cranked up my anticipation even more.
For the first half of the book this eagerness held. The world-building was great, the characters interesting, the plot engaging. But...then it dragged on in the middle as the MCs struggled to get to their destination. (Seriously, too much camping detailed.) And that bit in the AN about how the book originally started on a sex scene? Well it got moved in a bit...and honestly? That exchange with a whore? Was more explicit than the ones to follow with the MCs - all of them were basically fade-to-black.
Which is okay in principle (I don't mind non-explicit stories), but if the most detailed sex scene is with someone of absolutely no importance? I think that short-changes the growing intimacy with the characters. And given one of them thought himself to be straight? Yeah, an afterthought about how he had to re-think his orientation and the way he was raised (in a "Christianist" world)...well, I wanted more of that at the time of discovery.
But still, I was engaged with the plot. It's definitely more Fantasy-based than Scifi. Sure it takes place on another planet and one part of that world has a dystopian feel...but there are shared memories with ancestors, the interference of "gods" and a sketchy plan to save the planet (that was decidedly paranormal in theory as well as practice) plus some magical creatures with unexplained abilities...which tilted it to the Fantasy genre. I'm not mad at that; the story was that interesting
The last part was frenetic and intense. The author did a good job with conveying the urgency necessary to protect the more technologically advanced world on the other side of this planet, somehow split in two with each existing in a different dimension (or maybe an alternate universe?)...ESPECIALLY with that epilogue.
And the epilogue? Yeah, that introduced a cliff-hanger of some epic proportions when I was all set to see how the worlds dealt with being reunited and calling it a day. So I'm probably gonna read that one as well...because DAMN! Can't wait to see how that turns out. (I do have a theory about Alix: .)
March 12, 2017
Loved this! Great characters, worldbuilding & storyline. Seriously, if you like sci-fi, alt-world, fantasy check this out.
The only reason I didn't give this a full five stars is because as much as I did enjoy the read I didn't shed any tears. There has to be a real tear for me to award five stars.
The only reason I didn't give this a full five stars is because as much as I did enjoy the read I didn't shed any tears. There has to be a real tear for me to award five stars.
Read
November 24, 2020DNF at 72%.
Meh. Felt this went gently downhill as the book progressed. I began to discover plot niggles, and then found myself trying to remember them for this review. That's not a good sign of the level of my investment in the story.
I found myself comparing it, probably unfairly since it's a first novel, unfavourably with An Uncommon Whore by Belinda McBride, Turbulence by Lyn Gala and for some reason with (some of my favourite ever books) the Liaden series by Sharon Lee and Steve Miller.
So, niggles:
*
* if you're on watch, you need to be on watch
* What's the point of Morgan? Will there be any character development of his own?
*
* the physical limits of the Skythane (e.g. their ability to carry someone else while flying) seemed inconsistent from one scene to another
* if you (and others) have had twenty five years to plan something along these lines you should endeavour not to leave everything to the last minute,
*
Meh. Felt this went gently downhill as the book progressed. I began to discover plot niggles, and then found myself trying to remember them for this review. That's not a good sign of the level of my investment in the story.
I found myself comparing it, probably unfairly since it's a first novel, unfavourably with An Uncommon Whore by Belinda McBride, Turbulence by Lyn Gala and for some reason with (some of my favourite ever books) the Liaden series by Sharon Lee and Steve Miller.
So, niggles:
*
* if you're on watch, you need to be on watch
* What's the point of Morgan? Will there be any character development of his own?
*
* the physical limits of the Skythane (e.g. their ability to carry someone else while flying) seemed inconsistent from one scene to another
* if you (and others) have had twenty five years to plan something along these lines you should endeavour not to leave everything to the last minute,
*
February 28, 2017
Independent reviewer for Divine Magazine, I was gifted my copy of this book.
Jameson is sent to Oberon to see why the supply of pith has all but dried up. Xander is his guide into the Split, the *quite literally* underbelly of Oberon following a catastrophic event nearly a millennia ago. It was supposed to be routine, in and out, job done. But Jameson's arrival on Oberon is all but routine, and a chain of events is set off that will either destroy all life on Oberon, or reunite it with it's other half, Titania.
Sci-fi is, for me at least, very hit and miss. Sometimes the technology goes way over my head, and sometimes the words used means I don't fully understand what I'm reading about and I'm not ashamed to say that!
But here?? None of that! I loved this book!
The story flows like a river, from its source, getting faster and faster, deeper and wider until.... well, until it reaches the sea! There is no massive info dump that you sometimes get in this sort of story, it comes in drips, so you can process each drip before you get the next one. Or in my case, many times through this book, you can pull a face at the kindle and " say what now???" when you get a particularly fat drip!
The relationship between Jameson and Xander grows at a steady and even pace, even with the assistance of Quince and the pith. I was ...surprised by the route these guys took. Our introduction to Xander led me to think this book might be more explicit, which, you know me, I'd be happy with that but Jameson and Xander shut you down just as they get to the good stuff!! Very much fades to black but I LOVED that, I really did.
I love books that make me think, make me plan ahead as to where I think the story is gonna go, and how it's gonna get there, watching it either pan out the way I thought, or unravel before my eyes in a totally different way. And this book made me question every little fat drip and drop and I loved it!!
But what made this book were two things, for me, anyway.
One: there is a bit at the front of the book, telling the story of this story, as it were. How long its been sitting, waiting to be fully told. I don't usually read the bits at the front, but I'm glad I did.
And the other bit was the epilogue. Because up to that point, the story was told, finished, done and dusted all wrapped up in a big fat bow, sporting 4 stars. THEN, Coatsworth throws it all for a loop with that epilogue! And I WANT book two! Because I'm told there will be a book two. I wonder how THAT character is gonna affect Jameson and Xander's bond, and how Quince will react to the other character.
Basically, I'm left hanging. And sometimes that's good, sometimes not but here its bloody brilliant and I LOVED this book. *did I say that yet, don't think I did, did I??*
A stunning 5 star read
**same worded review will appear elsewhere**
Jameson is sent to Oberon to see why the supply of pith has all but dried up. Xander is his guide into the Split, the *quite literally* underbelly of Oberon following a catastrophic event nearly a millennia ago. It was supposed to be routine, in and out, job done. But Jameson's arrival on Oberon is all but routine, and a chain of events is set off that will either destroy all life on Oberon, or reunite it with it's other half, Titania.
Sci-fi is, for me at least, very hit and miss. Sometimes the technology goes way over my head, and sometimes the words used means I don't fully understand what I'm reading about and I'm not ashamed to say that!
But here?? None of that! I loved this book!
The story flows like a river, from its source, getting faster and faster, deeper and wider until.... well, until it reaches the sea! There is no massive info dump that you sometimes get in this sort of story, it comes in drips, so you can process each drip before you get the next one. Or in my case, many times through this book, you can pull a face at the kindle and " say what now???" when you get a particularly fat drip!
The relationship between Jameson and Xander grows at a steady and even pace, even with the assistance of Quince and the pith. I was ...surprised by the route these guys took. Our introduction to Xander led me to think this book might be more explicit, which, you know me, I'd be happy with that but Jameson and Xander shut you down just as they get to the good stuff!! Very much fades to black but I LOVED that, I really did.
I love books that make me think, make me plan ahead as to where I think the story is gonna go, and how it's gonna get there, watching it either pan out the way I thought, or unravel before my eyes in a totally different way. And this book made me question every little fat drip and drop and I loved it!!
But what made this book were two things, for me, anyway.
One: there is a bit at the front of the book, telling the story of this story, as it were. How long its been sitting, waiting to be fully told. I don't usually read the bits at the front, but I'm glad I did.
And the other bit was the epilogue. Because up to that point, the story was told, finished, done and dusted all wrapped up in a big fat bow, sporting 4 stars. THEN, Coatsworth throws it all for a loop with that epilogue! And I WANT book two! Because I'm told there will be a book two. I wonder how THAT character is gonna affect Jameson and Xander's bond, and how Quince will react to the other character.
Basically, I'm left hanging. And sometimes that's good, sometimes not but here its bloody brilliant and I LOVED this book. *did I say that yet, don't think I did, did I??*
A stunning 5 star read
**same worded review will appear elsewhere**
Read
November 2, 2020This was a pleasant short-ish science-fantasy romance. I thought the first half, with the characters meeting and the what-is-happening? suspense was the strongest.
Notes on genre, for potential readers:
-Despite the soft-focus nude on the cover this is not graphic at all. There is growing attraction between two men, one a virgin from a religious background, but there's no on-page sex, just a couple kisses.
-This is sci-fi set on another planet, but after the first couple chapters it is very low-tech and there are no long explanations of science or tech. Many elements seem closer to magic.
Notes on genre, for potential readers:
-Despite the soft-focus nude on the cover this is not graphic at all. There is growing attraction between two men, one a virgin from a religious background, but there's no on-page sex, just a couple kisses.
-This is sci-fi set on another planet, but after the first couple chapters it is very low-tech and there are no long explanations of science or tech. Many elements seem closer to magic.
May 11, 2017
Really good! I would love to read more in this world.
February 24, 2017
WOW! This is epic sci-fi at it's absolute best. The world building, character development was incredible. I was completely floored reading this.
You can tell J.Scott Coatsworth is an epic sci-fi reader by this book. Having been a science fiction reader for most of my life, I feel like I just finished reading my first book by one of the greats, THAT is how amazing this book is. How original his world split was. How original his Skythane and Landers were. How original that there are gay MC's that don't get lost in all the sex. (don't get me wrong, sex is VERY nice), but this story was more about the world, characters, their pursuits and the story more than sex. I really hope there is going to be more of this world, as it truly is amazing!!
You can tell J.Scott Coatsworth is an epic sci-fi reader by this book. Having been a science fiction reader for most of my life, I feel like I just finished reading my first book by one of the greats, THAT is how amazing this book is. How original his world split was. How original his Skythane and Landers were. How original that there are gay MC's that don't get lost in all the sex. (don't get me wrong, sex is VERY nice), but this story was more about the world, characters, their pursuits and the story more than sex. I really hope there is going to be more of this world, as it truly is amazing!!
February 20, 2018
A novel of parallel Science and Fantasy worlds, existing on two halves of a planet that physically spans dimensions. It was a good story, in the 'misplaced prince' trope. As the story progressed, however, there was an increasing level of unexplained magical elements that pushed the plot along, with references to the gods or other unnamed forces taking an interest. The story felt incomplete for that reason. Hopefully, more of the back/sidestory will be explored in subsequent books in the series.
August 26, 2018
A very elegant read.
Well developed characters, a lush world, and plenty of action earned this book a place on my keeper shelf.
Well developed characters, a lush world, and plenty of action earned this book a place on my keeper shelf.
December 24, 2019
Great sci-fi/fantasy world building with interesting MCs and lots of action. Definitely going onto remaining books of the series.
May 28, 2018
4.0 of 5 stars - “I always wanted to [fly and] save the world."
I love good gay sci-fi, and this had me smiling and engaged the whole way. It’s an intriguing other-world story with good action and a slow-building romance, a strong first novel and start of the series.
J. Scott Coatsworth wrote an intelligent space opera with creative, richly-textured world building and likable, realistic characters. He painted the scenes, action, and people so that I could easily visualize them. The maps were helpful in that as well (although I did think a couple things were off). I didn’t need the glossary this time around (Scott did a good job of introducing and explaining terms within the story), but it will be of more use in book 2 to remember things later.
The story is told effectively from three povs - Jameson, Xander and Quince. I identified most with Jameson, the human, because I identify with stories of the everyman (like Cary Grant in North by Northwest, or Luke in Star Wars) - the everyday guy who stumbles upon a mystery, a grand adventure or a save-the-world crisis, pursued by villains, and has to learn fast and deal with it. I felt like that could be me instead of Jameson.
One feature I loved was the details of the flying. Jameson dreamt about flying, and I did too. As a therapist, he figured them to be a “classic subconscious symbol of seeking freedom or release from an underlying problem” (which they did symbolize in this story). But I fondly remember being just thrilled with the sensation, and enjoyed how Scott captured the details of those moments.
The storyline was fairly well-built as well with good pace. I was pulled in by the developing relationship, the action and some of the mystery and clandestiny. A few niggles - I actually would have liked more romance and not just hugs and kisses (the one sex scene went off page). Yet it was after all just starting, with I’m sure more twists to come. The villain was pretty nondescript at this point, and things sometimes worked out a little too conveniently, especially when unknown powers just happen to appear when needed. And the one big battle scene was disappointing in its brevity and credibility.
This all led to a satisfactory conclusion of the arc in book 1; and then in the epilogue, teasing me into book 2, I thought, “Scott, now look what you’ve gone and done!” But by then, I already knew I was going to continue with this adventure.
I love good gay sci-fi, and this had me smiling and engaged the whole way. It’s an intriguing other-world story with good action and a slow-building romance, a strong first novel and start of the series.
J. Scott Coatsworth wrote an intelligent space opera with creative, richly-textured world building and likable, realistic characters. He painted the scenes, action, and people so that I could easily visualize them. The maps were helpful in that as well (although I did think a couple things were off). I didn’t need the glossary this time around (Scott did a good job of introducing and explaining terms within the story), but it will be of more use in book 2 to remember things later.
The story is told effectively from three povs - Jameson, Xander and Quince. I identified most with Jameson, the human, because I identify with stories of the everyman (like Cary Grant in North by Northwest, or Luke in Star Wars) - the everyday guy who stumbles upon a mystery, a grand adventure or a save-the-world crisis, pursued by villains, and has to learn fast and deal with it. I felt like that could be me instead of Jameson.
One feature I loved was the details of the flying. Jameson dreamt about flying, and I did too. As a therapist, he figured them to be a “classic subconscious symbol of seeking freedom or release from an underlying problem” (which they did symbolize in this story). But I fondly remember being just thrilled with the sensation, and enjoyed how Scott captured the details of those moments.
The storyline was fairly well-built as well with good pace. I was pulled in by the developing relationship, the action and some of the mystery and clandestiny. A few niggles - I actually would have liked more romance and not just hugs and kisses (the one sex scene went off page). Yet it was after all just starting, with I’m sure more twists to come. The villain was pretty nondescript at this point, and things sometimes worked out a little too conveniently, especially when unknown powers just happen to appear when needed. And the one big battle scene was disappointing in its brevity and credibility.
This all led to a satisfactory conclusion of the arc in book 1; and then in the epilogue, teasing me into book 2, I thought, “Scott, now look what you’ve gone and done!” But by then, I already knew I was going to continue with this adventure.
May 14, 2017
Three POVs, Shakespearian references, and a rich tapestry of a plot that’ll leave you asking for more. Skythane, by J Scott Coatsworth, proved to be a delightful Sci-Fantasy read. The story, albeit a bit short for a novel in the genre, flows naturally, and the main characters, Jameson, Xander, and Quince bring their own backstories into the mix, weaving a rich tale where Jameson and Xander seem as opposite as their worlds of origin. When sparks inevitably fly between them, the tension rises, more so when one of their home worlds is threatened.
Reviewer opinions naturally vary too greatly for any work to ever be considered perfect, but this reviewer did find one potential flaw in Coatsworth’s tale. Quince, in hindsight, seems an almost unnecessary character. She drives the plot, provides story-cohesion, and helps bring Jameson and Xander together, but the story might have been better without her. This is not to say that Quince, a mature woman and, perhaps, the wise sage every epic tale needs, isn’t a terrific character, but this reviewer wonders what Skythane would have been like without her presence.
But then, there’s the epilogue— so maybe Quince is more needed than it seems., which, of course, means there will be a second novel in the series!
Nicely done, J Scott Coatsworth. Can’t wait for the next installment.
Reviewer opinions naturally vary too greatly for any work to ever be considered perfect, but this reviewer did find one potential flaw in Coatsworth’s tale. Quince, in hindsight, seems an almost unnecessary character. She drives the plot, provides story-cohesion, and helps bring Jameson and Xander together, but the story might have been better without her. This is not to say that Quince, a mature woman and, perhaps, the wise sage every epic tale needs, isn’t a terrific character, but this reviewer wonders what Skythane would have been like without her presence.
But then, there’s the epilogue— so maybe Quince is more needed than it seems., which, of course, means there will be a second novel in the series!
Nicely done, J Scott Coatsworth. Can’t wait for the next installment.
October 13, 2020
‘Skythane’ is the exciting opening novel to what looks to be a fascinating series set in the future around the year 3000 or so, as far as I can determine. Oberon is a pretty unique world – it is split into two halves, with its other side hidden in some mysterious parallel universe. This has all sorts of consequences for the planetary ecology, and it was fascinating to find out more details about this well-developed world as the story developed. But solar flares signal a potential catastrophe, one that occurs every 750 years or so, and this time the event might just mean the end of this planet. As if that were not enough, there is an addictive substance called pith, drug smugglers and corporate interests battling for supremacy, and a cultural war between the skythane and the landers. Skythane are descendants of the first wave of human colonization, who genetically engineered themselves to have wings and can fly. The second wave of human settlers are called landers and they despise the skythane. No, that doesn’t really make sense, but racism never does, no matter what millennium it happens in.
Please find my full review on Rainbow Book Reviews.
Please find my full review on Rainbow Book Reviews.
February 3, 2019
I've been under the rock because I've only read this book today. How did I manage to miss such a wonderful fantasy/SciFi saga?
On the positive side, I won't have to wait long for Ithani to get my dose of happy.
I love Scott's writing, it's very gentle, engaging and gripping at the same time.
I could not put this book down until I've finished it and started Lander right away. Most wonderful world building, very engaging protagonists and such a magical touch of humanity.
This book was pure joy to read, highly recommended to anyone who appreciates complex, multi-layered plot and a beautifully woven fantasy.
On the positive side, I won't have to wait long for Ithani to get my dose of happy.
I love Scott's writing, it's very gentle, engaging and gripping at the same time.
I could not put this book down until I've finished it and started Lander right away. Most wonderful world building, very engaging protagonists and such a magical touch of humanity.
This book was pure joy to read, highly recommended to anyone who appreciates complex, multi-layered plot and a beautifully woven fantasy.
August 20, 2019
My first venture into J Scott Coatsworth books. and am I glad I took the plunge. love the premise of the story, post apocalyptic worlds meet other worlds. Xander and Jameson two men destined and prophesied to be together don't necessarily hit it off initially, though the attraction is there. Jameson discovery of his past, sexuality, ability and destiny well crafted as with Xander. the only complaint is how quickly and easily both men especially Xander took it, especially after what he has experienced in his short life. I do look forward to reading how the saga continues.
February 24, 2018
A breathtaking adventure with a race against all odds to save the world. I couldn’t put this book down! I had to know what was going to happen. It was thrilling and fast-paced.
I enjoyed the origins and the story behind this new sci-if world.
The characters were lifelike and I thoroughly enjoyed their tension and chemistry.
I can’t wait to discover what happens next!
I enjoyed the origins and the story behind this new sci-if world.
The characters were lifelike and I thoroughly enjoyed their tension and chemistry.
I can’t wait to discover what happens next!
February 6, 2018
this is my first time reading this author, and i was not disappointed. i loved the world he created on Oberon and the future. i felt like i was there, loved Xander and Jameson. would def recommend this book/author! can't wait to read the next one.
April 6, 2019
Skythane
This is a great story loved it, it was beautifully written and I loved the scenery and the love that was part of the story. Thanks Scott for this great effort. Well worth the read.
This is a great story loved it, it was beautifully written and I loved the scenery and the love that was part of the story. Thanks Scott for this great effort. Well worth the read.
November 21, 2025
The Oberon Cycle (complete box set)
By J. Scott Coatsworth
Published by Other Worlds Ink, 2020
I read the first book in this trilogy, “Skythane,” back in 2017. I loved it and posted my five-star review for the Paranormal Romance Guild (sadly, now defunct). I finally got to sit down and read the full trilogy, and I was overwhelmed. The Oberon Cycle is 950 pages of remarkable sci-fi fantasy, replete with vivid characters I cared about, and a plot that grows increasingly complex and compelling through each successive volume: Skythane, Lander, and Ithani. Scott Coatsworth’s imagination is impressive, and his world(s) building and skill with prose and dialogue are up to the task of such a monumental work.
Skythane are just people with wings. They’re not angels, nor magical. They just have wings. On the split planet Oberon/Titania, they were the first colonizers, but have become both less commonplace and marginalized since the second wave of colonizers—ordinary humans referred to by the Skythane as “landers.” Even the Skythane don’t fully understand their own history.
As you can imagine, there’s a story there, and this first book in Scott Coatsworth’s Oberon Cycle only begins to reveal it. It is always hard, when reviewing a hugely imaginative work like this, how to talk about it without spoiling surprises. Coatsworth has taken us to a distant planet hundreds of years in the future, where, unsurprisingly, the economic culture is largely controlled by a capitalist enterprise known as OberCorp. Not only has corporate greed survived, but so has judgmental conformity, as espoused by the Christianists. I guess some things are just hardwired into humanity.
Our central protagonist is Xander Kinnson, a twenty-something Skythane with iridescent black wings like a raven’s. Xander has spent his whole life on Oberon, and it has for the most part not been an easy life.
Xander’s counterpoint (antagonist?) is Jameson Havercamp, a meek conformist from the Christianist planet Beta Tau. Jameson has been assigned by his employer, the Psych Guild, to visit Oberon to look into a recent supply reduction of a drug known as pith—both very addictive and highly useful in psychological medication. Pith can only be harvested from Oberon’s split twin, Titania, which exists simultaneously in a parallel universe. (Gulp.)
By happy coincidence, Xander has been assigned to escort Jameson on his visit. The odd thing is, Xander and Jameson have entirely different ideas of where they’re supposed to be going. The catalyst, it seems, is Quince, a middle-aged Skythane woman with the great white wings of an angel. She knows something. She knows a lot in fact, but exactly who she is and what she knows is only hinted at in the book’s prologue.
Faint echoes of “Dune” flutter in your mind as you read this story; but Coatsworth’s narrative is more straightforward and its characters are not melodramatic, in spite of the wings. Jameson, Xander, and Quince form an unlikely trio for a road trip, especially once events begin to spin out of control and the tension ratchets up. They are the central characters throughout the trilogy—but by no means the only characters. Each successive volume adds more important players in this epic drama, and by the third book, “Ithani,” it’s a challenge to keep everyone in mind (I managed it).
The vividly depicted reality of Oberon is that of a high-tech world so corrupt and jaded after centuries of development that inconvenient scientific truths have been relegated to the realm of superstition. Only our mismatched trio—and the mysterious orphan child called Morgan they pick up on the way—have any idea what’s really going on and what they have to do to stop it.
I loved the characters, and the tantalizing mix of sci-fi and fantasy in the plot. Coatsworth builds up a lot of excitement, leaving his readers hungry for more. Reading the full work is a compelling and moving experience.
By J. Scott Coatsworth
Published by Other Worlds Ink, 2020
I read the first book in this trilogy, “Skythane,” back in 2017. I loved it and posted my five-star review for the Paranormal Romance Guild (sadly, now defunct). I finally got to sit down and read the full trilogy, and I was overwhelmed. The Oberon Cycle is 950 pages of remarkable sci-fi fantasy, replete with vivid characters I cared about, and a plot that grows increasingly complex and compelling through each successive volume: Skythane, Lander, and Ithani. Scott Coatsworth’s imagination is impressive, and his world(s) building and skill with prose and dialogue are up to the task of such a monumental work.
Skythane are just people with wings. They’re not angels, nor magical. They just have wings. On the split planet Oberon/Titania, they were the first colonizers, but have become both less commonplace and marginalized since the second wave of colonizers—ordinary humans referred to by the Skythane as “landers.” Even the Skythane don’t fully understand their own history.
As you can imagine, there’s a story there, and this first book in Scott Coatsworth’s Oberon Cycle only begins to reveal it. It is always hard, when reviewing a hugely imaginative work like this, how to talk about it without spoiling surprises. Coatsworth has taken us to a distant planet hundreds of years in the future, where, unsurprisingly, the economic culture is largely controlled by a capitalist enterprise known as OberCorp. Not only has corporate greed survived, but so has judgmental conformity, as espoused by the Christianists. I guess some things are just hardwired into humanity.
Our central protagonist is Xander Kinnson, a twenty-something Skythane with iridescent black wings like a raven’s. Xander has spent his whole life on Oberon, and it has for the most part not been an easy life.
Xander’s counterpoint (antagonist?) is Jameson Havercamp, a meek conformist from the Christianist planet Beta Tau. Jameson has been assigned by his employer, the Psych Guild, to visit Oberon to look into a recent supply reduction of a drug known as pith—both very addictive and highly useful in psychological medication. Pith can only be harvested from Oberon’s split twin, Titania, which exists simultaneously in a parallel universe. (Gulp.)
By happy coincidence, Xander has been assigned to escort Jameson on his visit. The odd thing is, Xander and Jameson have entirely different ideas of where they’re supposed to be going. The catalyst, it seems, is Quince, a middle-aged Skythane woman with the great white wings of an angel. She knows something. She knows a lot in fact, but exactly who she is and what she knows is only hinted at in the book’s prologue.
Faint echoes of “Dune” flutter in your mind as you read this story; but Coatsworth’s narrative is more straightforward and its characters are not melodramatic, in spite of the wings. Jameson, Xander, and Quince form an unlikely trio for a road trip, especially once events begin to spin out of control and the tension ratchets up. They are the central characters throughout the trilogy—but by no means the only characters. Each successive volume adds more important players in this epic drama, and by the third book, “Ithani,” it’s a challenge to keep everyone in mind (I managed it).
The vividly depicted reality of Oberon is that of a high-tech world so corrupt and jaded after centuries of development that inconvenient scientific truths have been relegated to the realm of superstition. Only our mismatched trio—and the mysterious orphan child called Morgan they pick up on the way—have any idea what’s really going on and what they have to do to stop it.
I loved the characters, and the tantalizing mix of sci-fi and fantasy in the plot. Coatsworth builds up a lot of excitement, leaving his readers hungry for more. Reading the full work is a compelling and moving experience.
July 3, 2024
This is the first book by this author that I'm reading, and I believed this to be Sci Fi from the reviews and all. But having read it, I would categorise it more as Science Fantasy since the nimfeach are spirits and the waygates have no scientific explanation.
Oberon is half a world. The other half of the planet is missing and there is only the split, the part where the other half seems to have sheared off where electronics don't work. Oberon is also a technologically advanced world with a well defined division between haves and have nots. The planet is being run by OberCorp who cares only for making profits.
The story opens with Quince, a Skythane female, who recalls a mission entrusted to her by the nimfeach who appear to be a higher being with prophetic powers. Though we aren't told what the mission is, the reader gets to know it has something to do with Xander, a Skythane male and Jameson, who is coming to Oberon on an inspection to Obercorp. Skythanes are the first wave of settlers in Oberon who have wings. While we are told they adapted to the conditions here and developed wings, it doesn't really sound like evolution to me. However, I digress.
Jameson is met by Xander who has been hired by Obercorp to take Jameson to the Outlands for his inspection. Jameson who has been expecting to go to the Obercorp HQ is naturally suspicious, but has no way to get away from Xander once he has climbed on to his hoverbike. They are attacked by a group that appears to be from Obercorp and are rescued by Quince who helps get them to the Outlands where she tells them about their origins and the truth behind Oberon's history.
The story was extremely engaging and I loved how the relationship between Xander and Jameson develops. Jameson is my favourite character because I found him the most relatable. He has to face facts which makes his whole life a lie and to adjust his entire world view within a few short days and he does it with commendable grace and poise. Though he does freak out initially--who wouldn't?--he is still remarkably composed about the whole.
Morgan, the strange boy that Xander finds, with even stranger powers, is also an interesting character. I hope to see more of him and an explanation in the coming books. The book does end in what can be considered a romantic cliffhanger, which makes me want to pick up the next book, if only to know what's going to happen between Xander and Jameson now.
The book has darker themes of abuse, sexual assault of children and adults, homophobia, both internalised and otherwise, and forced mutilation.
I loved the book, the world, the characters and the writing. If you love science fantasy, science fiction, queer characters, well developed worlds and memorable characters, you will love this book.
Oberon is half a world. The other half of the planet is missing and there is only the split, the part where the other half seems to have sheared off where electronics don't work. Oberon is also a technologically advanced world with a well defined division between haves and have nots. The planet is being run by OberCorp who cares only for making profits.
The story opens with Quince, a Skythane female, who recalls a mission entrusted to her by the nimfeach who appear to be a higher being with prophetic powers. Though we aren't told what the mission is, the reader gets to know it has something to do with Xander, a Skythane male and Jameson, who is coming to Oberon on an inspection to Obercorp. Skythanes are the first wave of settlers in Oberon who have wings. While we are told they adapted to the conditions here and developed wings, it doesn't really sound like evolution to me. However, I digress.
Jameson is met by Xander who has been hired by Obercorp to take Jameson to the Outlands for his inspection. Jameson who has been expecting to go to the Obercorp HQ is naturally suspicious, but has no way to get away from Xander once he has climbed on to his hoverbike. They are attacked by a group that appears to be from Obercorp and are rescued by Quince who helps get them to the Outlands where she tells them about their origins and the truth behind Oberon's history.
The story was extremely engaging and I loved how the relationship between Xander and Jameson develops. Jameson is my favourite character because I found him the most relatable. He has to face facts which makes his whole life a lie and to adjust his entire world view within a few short days and he does it with commendable grace and poise. Though he does freak out initially--who wouldn't?--he is still remarkably composed about the whole.
Morgan, the strange boy that Xander finds, with even stranger powers, is also an interesting character. I hope to see more of him and an explanation in the coming books. The book does end in what can be considered a romantic cliffhanger, which makes me want to pick up the next book, if only to know what's going to happen between Xander and Jameson now.
The book has darker themes of abuse, sexual assault of children and adults, homophobia, both internalised and otherwise, and forced mutilation.
I loved the book, the world, the characters and the writing. If you love science fantasy, science fiction, queer characters, well developed worlds and memorable characters, you will love this book.
March 2, 2023
Audiobook Review:
Overall – 5
Performance – 4
Story – 5
Grabbed me and didn’t let go.
Skythane is not my normal type of book to read but a couple of things made me want to listen to and review it. First off, I’ve owned a copy of this book since 2018 when the author gave me a copy to review when I have time (oops). Second, I’ve enjoyed other audiobooks performed by Kevin Earlywine.
I’m kind of kicking myself for waiting so long to enjoy this story. It grabbed me from the beginning and held my attention throughout. I don’t think I can do a better job of describing the it than the blurb does. Reading science fiction isn’t something I do often so trying to write a review is hard for me. The characters were interesting and the plot well developed. The story doesn’t exactly end on a cliffhanger as many things were resolved but it definitely left me wanting to read or listen to the next book.
I already have a copy of book two, Lander, in my Kindle library but I’m holding out in the hopes that it will come out in audio. As further evidence of how much I enjoyed Skythane, when I realized I didn’t own book three, Ithani, I bought a copy.
Regarding the audiobook: Kevin Earlywine did a good job and I know I’ll be listening to more of his work.
A copy of this audiobook was provided to me at my request; my review was voluntary and not influenced by the author or narrator.
***Reviewed for Xtreme-Delusions dot com***
Overall – 5
Performance – 4
Story – 5
Grabbed me and didn’t let go.
Skythane is not my normal type of book to read but a couple of things made me want to listen to and review it. First off, I’ve owned a copy of this book since 2018 when the author gave me a copy to review when I have time (oops). Second, I’ve enjoyed other audiobooks performed by Kevin Earlywine.
I’m kind of kicking myself for waiting so long to enjoy this story. It grabbed me from the beginning and held my attention throughout. I don’t think I can do a better job of describing the it than the blurb does. Reading science fiction isn’t something I do often so trying to write a review is hard for me. The characters were interesting and the plot well developed. The story doesn’t exactly end on a cliffhanger as many things were resolved but it definitely left me wanting to read or listen to the next book.
I already have a copy of book two, Lander, in my Kindle library but I’m holding out in the hopes that it will come out in audio. As further evidence of how much I enjoyed Skythane, when I realized I didn’t own book three, Ithani, I bought a copy.
Regarding the audiobook: Kevin Earlywine did a good job and I know I’ll be listening to more of his work.
A copy of this audiobook was provided to me at my request; my review was voluntary and not influenced by the author or narrator.
***Reviewed for Xtreme-Delusions dot com***
February 18, 2023
The Review
I was immediately struck by the sheer volume of world-building and mythology the author was able to cement into this narrative. The in-depth history and futuristic cultures that develop in this universe of the author’s creation not only impacted the story but the character development as well. The rich setting and action-packed scenes helped elevate the tension and intrigue that settled over the cast of characters as this world came to a boiling point just ready to blow up in their faces.
What really sold this story though was the rich character development that the author was able to find with these characters. The way these two protagonists are thrust into the heat of battle and adrenaline-fueled action sets the tone for their journey, and the way in which their bond develops and grows as they start on their path of destiny made the story just sing volumes of the author’s creativity.
The Verdict
Captivating, exhilarating, and thrilling, author J. Scott Coatsworth’s “Skythane: Liminal Sky” is a great first book in the Oberon Cycle series and a rich novel to dive headfirst into. The way the author was able to find the perfect harmonious flow between both sci-fi and fantasy tropes and make the world feel both magical and otherworldly all at once was a great backdrop to the emotional bond these two characters brought together.
I was immediately struck by the sheer volume of world-building and mythology the author was able to cement into this narrative. The in-depth history and futuristic cultures that develop in this universe of the author’s creation not only impacted the story but the character development as well. The rich setting and action-packed scenes helped elevate the tension and intrigue that settled over the cast of characters as this world came to a boiling point just ready to blow up in their faces.
What really sold this story though was the rich character development that the author was able to find with these characters. The way these two protagonists are thrust into the heat of battle and adrenaline-fueled action sets the tone for their journey, and the way in which their bond develops and grows as they start on their path of destiny made the story just sing volumes of the author’s creativity.
The Verdict
Captivating, exhilarating, and thrilling, author J. Scott Coatsworth’s “Skythane: Liminal Sky” is a great first book in the Oberon Cycle series and a rich novel to dive headfirst into. The way the author was able to find the perfect harmonious flow between both sci-fi and fantasy tropes and make the world feel both magical and otherworldly all at once was a great backdrop to the emotional bond these two characters brought together.
February 19, 2023
This is a good sci fi story. I don’t read a lot of Sci fi fantasy but occasionally like stepping out of the box.
This had a long prologue but was be easy for set up.
Once the story got going and action rolling it was hard to put down.
There are lots of twists and turns.
Intriguing characters but a very good plot and storyline. The romance is slow burn and off page.
At first I wasn’t sure j was going to like the narration as I prefer voice acting to being read to. But this worked with the story as you got the world building and settings plus there was a little music and other things to break up the story and make it more interesting.
This had a long prologue but was be easy for set up.
Once the story got going and action rolling it was hard to put down.
There are lots of twists and turns.
Intriguing characters but a very good plot and storyline. The romance is slow burn and off page.
At first I wasn’t sure j was going to like the narration as I prefer voice acting to being read to. But this worked with the story as you got the world building and settings plus there was a little music and other things to break up the story and make it more interesting.
May 23, 2023
I confess. I read all three books in the Oberon Cycle back-to-back. Normally I only do that with books I love, but I guess I didn't have anything else pressing, so I just continued. Worse, I have nothing in my Kindle notes for this book. Let's see... what happened?
Oh yeah, now I remember. A very exciting beginning, a not-so-exciting middle, and a kind of forgettable end. Wait! How can be forgettable? Well, it's not, actually. I just kept reading the series, and the end of the first book kind of got lost in all the shenanigans that followed.
I will say this: Quince's actions were very questionable. Not only did she roofie Xander and Jameson (which becomes a Big Issue in book #2>, but she also doped Jameson into a delayed puberty without his consent., which he just accepted. He really should have had the choice, prophecy or no prophecy.
Still, it gets 4 stars. It's an interesting story and well-written. And the author actually took control of his books and republished them with sci-fi stuff on the covers (as best I can tell, living quarters on Oberson [Skythane] and Titiana [Lander]), and not hot, shirtless men with wings. I applaud you, J. Scott Coatsworth, although I'm not sure what's on the cover of Ithani. A temple? The Heart? A greenhouse??
Oh yeah, now I remember. A very exciting beginning, a not-so-exciting middle, and a kind of forgettable end. Wait! How can be forgettable? Well, it's not, actually. I just kept reading the series, and the end of the first book kind of got lost in all the shenanigans that followed.
I will say this: Quince's actions were very questionable. Not only did she roofie Xander and Jameson (which becomes a Big Issue in book #2>, but she also doped Jameson into a delayed puberty without his consent., which he just accepted. He really should have had the choice, prophecy or no prophecy.
Still, it gets 4 stars. It's an interesting story and well-written. And the author actually took control of his books and republished them with sci-fi stuff on the covers (as best I can tell, living quarters on Oberson [Skythane] and Titiana [Lander]), and not hot, shirtless men with wings. I applaud you, J. Scott Coatsworth, although I'm not sure what's on the cover of Ithani. A temple? The Heart? A greenhouse??
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews