The Downward Spiral

Lock and Key #2

by Ridley Pearson

James Moriarty hasn’t been the same since he enrolled at Baskerville Academy. During his first year, he was forced to room with the insufferable Sherlock Holmes, he grew distant from his younger sister, Moria, and then, horribly, his father died under mysterious circumstances.

Now with school back in session, James has become more isolated than ever. And for the first time in her life, Moria isn’t sure if her brother is on her side. The only person she can trust is Sherlock. Sherlock listens to Moria’s problems and tries to break through James’s wall. He is obsessed, maybe to an extreme, with finding the truth about their father’s death. But at least Sherlock cares, and that’s why Moria joins him on a quest that leads to a secret sect, a rare jewel, and a murder that may change everything. The search for the truth is darker than even they could have anticipated. Rick Riordan, author of the Percy Jackson series, said, “Only a mastermind like Ridley Pearson could put such a fresh spin on Sherlock Holmes.” It’s another edge-of-your-seat mystery-adventure from New York Times bestselling author Ridley Pearson.

Genres: Mystery, Middle Grade, Fiction, Fantasy, Adventure, Childrens, Action

432 pages, Hardcover

First published October 1, 2017

About the author

Ridley Pearson is the author of more than fifty novels, including the New York Times bestseller Killer Weekend; the Lou Boldt crime series; and many books for young readers, including the award-winning children's novels Peter and the Starcatchers, Peter and the Shadow Thieves, and Peter and the Secret of Rundoon, which he cowrote with Dave Barry. Pearson lives with his wife and two daughters, dividing their time between Missouri and Idaho.

Also writes Chris Klick mysteries as Wendell McCall.

Reviews

[Daniel · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars

[Ken W · Rating 5 out of 5]

Fun series! After reading the first two books, I can highly recommend this trilogy! This book started just a little bit slow but once it got going, it really got going! I can’t wait to read the third and final book of the trilogy! 4.5 stars rounded up to 5!!

[Scottsdale Public Library]

Back again at Baskerville Academy with Sherlock Holmes and James Moriarty, Moria Moriarty once again narrates this tale about the continuing change in her brother's personality as he seeks to take on their late father's role. For fans of Sherlock Holmes stories, we are expecting Moriarty to become the arch Villain and this second book moves him pretty far down that line. The title Downward Spiral perhaps gives it away, James is not returning from his dark place. The story is good and introduces readers to a number of shadowy organizations that may or may not play any leading roles in the next book. I admit to ambivalence about them. They're convenient but trope-y. As ever there were mysteries to solve and Sherlock was clever; these books are a joy to read. It is a pleasure to have them in present time and hopefully they will work their charm and cause some readers to read the originals. But gosh, these are loads of fun on their own. - Suzanne R.

[Sharon · Rating 3 out of 5]

I almost inevitably feel disappointed by the middle book of a trilogy; sometimes it feels like the sole purpose of the work is to bridge the first and third volumes.

That was definitely the case here, as Sherlock and Moria continue working on the puzzles surrounding James, as well as the death of James and Moria's father.

The Baskerville is a little more sinister, and more secrets are revealed.

I have to be honest, though; I nearly quit reading the story all together several times. Looking forward to the resolution in the next book.

[Sheila Beaumont · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is the second book in a trilogy about James Moriarty's journey to the dark side during his teens. The story is set in the present day, but has a rather old-fashioned ambience. Sherlock Holmes and James are roommates at Baskerville Academy, and James' younger sister, Moria, who also attends the boarding school, is the narrator.

I've been reading two other trilogies with a similar theme, both of them YA. They are very good too, but this middle-grade trilogy is my favorite of them all so far. Recommended for Sherlockians of all ages.

[Stephanie · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars

[Grace Carter · Rating 3 out of 5]

Again, despite the rating, I enjoyed this book - though not as much as the first one. The reason why I enjoyed the first one so much was because of the subtle romance, and in this one, it kind of tanked. There will be minor spoilers in this review, mostly surrounding that point. It will be marked as [Spoilers Incoming].
Going to preface all this by saying, though, that a lot of work going into a book, and while I do have a lot to say, I still appreciate the effort on part of the writer. This is not an easy business, lol.
As far as the entirety of the plot goes, there was a lot more going on in this one. Lots of secret society shenanigans and mystery-solving, as one would expect. Things felt higher-stakes. Still, similarly to how I felt about the previous book, there weren't any moments where I felt on the edge of my seat; emotionally, I found a balance somewhere between mild interest and mild frustration. I can't really account for why, but my guess would be that everything felt like it went just a bit too well for the characters, and all the goings-on were just a hair unrealistic. Likely, a problem that could've been solved with a bit more in-depth plotting. Instead of the plot coming to a crescendo, I feel like the book stayed mellow. The characters felt too capable, too unrattled. There was few to no moments that had the author pulling on my heartstrings.
The thing that I did really appreciate about the book, though, was the dialogue, specifically between Moria and Sherlock. While I think Moria seemed to have maturity FAR surpassing a twelve year old, it was still nice to see that their conversations were generally focused on the mystery afoot and not other extenuating circumstances. Most of their conversations were about far more important issues, and while I wouldn't expect that from kids actually their age, it was still refreshing. Not to mention that I think Moria's feelings of admiration and irritation towards Sherlock were pretty well balanced. My husband is actually of the same breed (smart, but often obnoxiously so) and I felt myself relating to Moria very much, lololol.
[Spoilers Incoming] The saving grace of the first book had been the romance. In this book, however, that was stripped away to be replaced by petty jealousy on Moria's end and poor morals on Sherlock's. Namely, involving his sudden attention to a girl named Ruby - AFTER Sherlock had gone so much to actually kiss Moria. (Don't get me started on that scene, too. Ugh. It was kind of uncomfortable. Admittedly, a lot of first kisses ARE uncomfortable, but the way it came across... I don't know. It wasn't even sweet. From what I remember, Sherlock just got excited because she said something smart and came flying towards her, all arms and legs, with wide eyes and kissed her that way. Which was like... just, unsettling lol. And James was even in the room, and said absolutely nothing about it. Like, everything just seemed all wrong. But I digress.) Anyway, even though I can't really deny that a lack of commitment and stupid hurt feelings is a realistic turn for teenage drama, I am NONETHLESS DISAPPOINTED. That probably accounts for more of a personal feeling than an objective review... but I don't care >:( Sherlock had seemed like the sort of guy who had the sort of confidence and genuine nature not to mess with another person's feelings, regardless of whatever other flaws he had, but I guess he's not. Boo-hoo for Moria and for me.
[End Spoilers]
I really don't have anything else to say about the book, I don't think :,) Big sad, ahaha. I hate to be so critical, but those were all things that jumped out at me. As a last parting thought, I will commend the author for making it a really easy read, as I flew through it in less than two days. And he DID manage to hold my attention to the end. I think I'm going to take a break from this trilogy and try reading another book, but I do plan to come back to it. It's not so horrible that I simply stopped reading, which I will do if things get too boring or too terrible. Hence why I gave it three stars; it is a likeable book! But not much more, imo.

[Sunny the Sassy · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.5 stars

[Eden Michelle · Rating 5 out of 5]

Wow. So I loved the first book in this series but dayyygg this one is so good. Definitely my favorite in the series. I’m writing this after I have finished the trilogy so I do know how the whole thing ends, but still this book was definitely my favorite! The shipper in me really came out for Moria and Sherlock lol. So good 5/5!

[Meghan · Rating 4 out of 5]

There were a few inconsistencies, such as the fact that James was not with Sherlock and Moria when they found the family Bible in the first book. I would love a map of the Moriarty house, to help visualize where each part is taking place.

[Nannette Demmler · Rating 3 out of 5]

I had some mixed feelings about the first book in this series and my issues with that book continue on into this one. Still it is a good read and an interesting retelling of the Sherlock and Moriarty story.

Moira, James’s sister is still mostly telling the story, although there are times when James and occasionally Sherlock takes up the narrative. I like Moira, but I don’t always trust that she is telling the whole story. She also has a somewhat weird relationship with Sherlock that I can’t decide if I like or not. She also doesn’t appear to have any other friends that she can trust. Her relationship with James is definitely changing in this book and not for the better.

James takes center stage in this book, more so than the last. We see more of what he is thinking and what he is doing when he is not with Moira and Sherlock. It is interesting to see the development of his character. His thoughts fight against doing the wrong thing, but he still goes through with what the Scowerers (the bad secret society he was initiated into in the first book) tell him to do. I enjoyed watching him become friends with Alexandria Carlisle, a girl at their school. There is a great scene where the two of them go out sailing on a small boat, which was very well done. You don’t often see sailing is kid’s books, so it was nice to have that added. There is some attraction between them as they get closer, but it is not overly done.

Sherlock continues to be a conundrum for me in this series. We rarely ever see what he is doing when not with the others, nor do we get his perspective very often (ever?) Although he is very much like the original, smart and pays attention to everything, he isn’t as likable. He tends to irritate me. Although I do like how he looks out for both James and Moira and is always there to help them out.

I still have issues with the plot, it just doesn’t flow smoothly. At times I kept thinking that I missed something, so I would go back a page or two, but couldn’t find anything. The dialog also is a little stilted and the kids at times sound older than they are (especially Sherlock). But the overall plot is good, lots of twists and unexpected things happening that keep you moving along. It does drag at times, and they still don’t seem any closer to solving the death of their father than they were in the first book. I don’t know for sure how many books are planned, I think three, but I hope that this plot point at least is resolved in the next book.

Definitely a book for older Tweens and Teens who are interested in a different take on the Sherlock and Moriarty story.

If you liked my review check out my blog at https://elnadesbookchat.com/

[Suzanne · Rating 5 out of 5]

Back again at Baskerville Academy with Sherlock Holmes and James Moriarty, Moria Moriarty once again narrates this tale about the continuing change in her brother's personality as he seeks to take on their late father's role. For fans of Sherlock Holmes stories, we are expecting Moriarty to become the arch Villain and this second book moves him pretty far down that line. The title Downward Spiral perhaps gives it away, James is not returning from his dark place. The story is good and introduces readers to a number of shadowy organizations that may or may not play any leading roles in the next book. I admit to ambivalence about them. They're convenient but trope-y. As ever there were mysteries to solve and Sherlock was clever; these books are a joy to read. It is a pleasure to have them in present time and hopefully they will work their charm and cause some readers to read the originals. But honestly, these are loads of fun. I received my copy from the publisher through edelweiss.

[BLuciano Leoni · Rating 4 out of 5]

"Lock and Key: The Downward Spiral" by Ridley Pearson is the thrilling follow-up to the first book in the series. It takes us back into the world of The Alliance, where danger and mystery await.

In this sequel, our group of young heroes faces new challenges and dangers. As they try to uncover the secrets of The Alliance, they find themselves in even more trouble than before.

Pearson's storytelling keeps us hooked with lots of excitement and surprises. The characters grow and change, facing tough decisions and learning who they can trust.

One thing I liked about "The Downward Spiral" is how it makes us think about important stuff like trust and doing the right thing. As the story unfolds, we see the characters facing tough choices that could change everything.

Overall, "Lock and Key: The Downward Spiral" is an exciting sequel that keeps the adventure going strong. With its cool plot, interesting characters, and deep themes, it's a book you won't want to put down. Whether you loved the first book or are new to the series, this one is definitely worth reading.

[Brooke Pisarsky · Rating 1 out of 5]

This will be quick: despite really enjoying the first book, my son & I found this one to be more confusing, less exciting (what really happened?) & the writing to be rather awful. I believe in the first book there was a note about the story being told from Moira's point of view. However, the second book offered no such explanation. Even had there been an explanation, the writing contradicted that theory, with the viewpoint switching from third to first in a matter of paragraphs. Surprisingly poorly done.

We also found the story line to be discombobulated with no big reveal at the end. It doesn't feel like any mystery was really solved, just more leads to what MIGHT happen in the next installment. I've gotta tell you, at this point, I don't even really care.

[Sharon Craft Viall · Rating 5 out of 5]

I'm hoping there is a 3rd book. The three kids want to find out about The Moriarty Father's death and all the secrets that he has been keeping all these years. They don't even trust there two loyal servants,because things are not right at the house. Sherlock is Moria's only friend that she trusts to help her. James wants nothing to do with her most of the time. James know things that he doesn't want Moria to know. They are trying to find out what happened to there Mother. Moriarty women always seems to disappear. The go on many quest's that keeps you wondering who is the goods guys and who is the bad.

[Jeff Miller · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this book! I found it very difficult to put down. The story was much more enthralling than the first. Reading this also shed more light on Book 0.5, or at least created more questions about the events in that book.

A modern-day Sherlock Holmes works with Moria and James Moriarty to solve the mystery of the death of the Moriarty's father. In this book, James Moriarty develops more into the person who will become the arch-nemesis of Sherlock. This is a fun re-invention of classic characters.

[Jessica]

This book is also really great. It gets darker, James gets turned into even more of a monster, and there is some drama between Sherlock and Moria. Thankfully they are still friends. Still, I was in tears by the ending, which I will not give away, just please read this book along with the first one.

[Barb · Rating 4 out of 5]

A solid second book that solved some mysteries and then created more intrigue and questions -- ideal for going into book three. This series most definitely is upper middle grade due to more mature subject matter (political intrigue, international business, and some violence). However, for those MG readers who are ready for a longer, more challenging mystery/intrigue book, this is a good choice.

[Cecilia Rodriguez · Rating 1 out of 5]

Twelve year old Moria Moriarty narrates the new adventure.
There is no originality and the mystery is poorly done.
I highly recommend skipping this and reading Sir Arthur Conan
Doyle's original work instead.

[Sean Cocchia · Rating 1 out of 5]

So i gave book 2 in this Youth series a shot and I did not connect to it any more than book 1. I like the concept of Sherlock and Moriarty meeting as teens, but the execution feels so unlikely even though it is grounded in the real world. Not sure if I will give book 3 a shot.

[Nadine · Rating 4 out of 5]

Well not a favorite but keeps you interested. For me it was a little hard to follow at times....different people and cults. Who’s with who....and who’s the friend or foe??? I do look forward to the next book...just hope it’s more exciting than this one. Happy Reading :)

[Kristian · Rating 4 out of 5]

A lot of fun. I stayed up way too late reading. I hadn't meant to finish it. I just couldn't put it down. I look forward to the third book. it is neat to see how Ridley is putting it all together.

[Luke Oberholtzer · Rating 4 out of 5]

A solid second entry in the series. I don’t think I liked it as much as the first but I also had my mind on other books I wanted to read or was finishing up. Still, it was a fun read throughout setting up the final (I think) third entry. I’m excited to see how it ends.

[Lily · Rating 4 out of 5]

I didn’t like this as much because I read the first one a while ago and now have a slightly different taste in books also I have watched Sherlock and now want and expected a more maniac Sherlock so three and a half stars instead of four and a half

[Nancy · Rating 4 out of 5]

Really enjoyed this book! Lots of plot twists, a ton of mysteries, and characters that hold your interest! I chose this for my 6th-8th grade Book Discussion Group. I did have to laugh when I asked them if any of them had ever heard of Sherlock Holmes before and they all said, “no.”

[Maribeth Bousum · Rating 5 out of 5]

Better than the first and left me definitely hoping there will be more books in the series.

[Cherie Bush · Rating 3 out of 5]

Fun and entertaining series for youth and adults alike.

[Rena · Rating 5 out of 5]

My son loved this.

[Mahala · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved this second book. Can't wait for the 3rd!

[Diana Gagliardi · Rating 4 out of 5]

So clever, so fun!

Demmit! Now I need #3!!!