The Unlikely Story of a Pig in the City is honestly one of my favorite middle-grade books! It's such a sweet, wholesome story about family that I would recommend to readers of all ages!
I first read the book in elementary school, and I raved about it so much that my brother bought me a physical copy of it for my birthday. I reread it sooo many times since then, and I decided to reread it now in light of the holiday season.
11-year-old Josie Shilling feels like she's invisible, like she doesn't fit into her big, loud family. Until she meets Hamlet, an adorable little piglet stolen from a farm by her older brother. It's up to Josie to find a perfect home for Hamlet - but do pigs belong in the city?
The family dynamics between the Shillings are realistic: even though they sometimes fight with each other, the family is still built on love.
Josie is a lovely main character who's just trying her best to be seen among her sisters. She often feels as if she's the invisible one, overshadowed by her loud siblings. Throughout the novel, Josie experiences anxiety and insecurity over how tall she is, and later she gains confidence as she realizes she has more talents than just gymnastics.
The Shilling sisters (and brother) can be annoying at times, but they're all still sweet and lovable. I really liked Ellen in particular, because she was smart, loved to read, and wanted to be a book editor when she was older. (so basically me lol)
And the romance!!! This story has the perfect amount of romance to satisfy a middle-grade story: just enough to be cute, but not so much that it takes over the novel. And it's fairly realistic for a sixth-grader, too.
And I love the fact that it takes place around Christmas too! On Goodreads it isn't marked as "Christmas" or "Holiday" but Christmas (and Thanksgiving) is actually a major plot point!
The ending: It's actually so good! Not super predictable, not unrealistic.
My only complaint is about the gymnastics people. All of her gymnastics "friends" (except maybe Lucy) were super unsupportive and kind of annoying. The older girls called her "Josie Long Legs." None of the other gymnasts took the time to encourage her or make her feel better. Her Coach wasn't super helpful, either. The place seemed like a rather toxic environment to be in. No wonder she was so stressed out about it!
Overall, this is a cute, wholesome middle-grade read that I will continue rereading for a long time. I would totally recommend it! 5 stars!