I don't know who Noel Keyes is, but he did A good job picking stories for this anthology. It's too bad that this is the only anthology he edited. The very little bit I could find out about him online was from ISFDB. Noel Keyes was a pen name, his real name was David Noel Keightley.
Done in refreshing ways and with ultimate style, this collection is quite possibly the best anthology on the subject that I have ever read. verdict: Unmissable, don't!
I was in the mood for some short stories.. this collection actually maintains it stated theme throughout.. 1/2 the book is first contact stories with 'man the discoverer' and the 2nd half 'man the discovered'.
The stories are all from the the early fifties, and is quite an all-star roster. There are a few classic ones that I've read before elsewhere.
First Contact by Murray Leinster is one of my favorites... the perfectly dated cold-war era first contact story. Both the human and alien captain assume they have to kill each other to keep their planets safe until on crew member comes up with a unique plan. There's also 'What's he doing in there?' by Fritz Leiber, which is a very short cute story that makes a great point about people understanding one another. 'Knock' by Frederic Brown is another classic one that can be found here.. with the famous start. 'The last man on Earth sat alone in a room. There was a knock on the door...'
Among those I hadn't read before, Asimov's 'Gentle Vultures' was great..an alien race hangs out on the moon waiting for Earth to destroy itself.. only we don't.. yet. 'Specialist' by Robert Sheckley and 'Lost Memory' by Peter Phillips were both really unique and interesting takes on first contacts with similar aliens but very different results.
Just what I need to get over a bit of readers block!
Mostly good stories but kind of hit or miss though. I kind of like that some of these are super unknown and it is not all "classics". Really shows where the genre was in that era.
Entertaining collection of stories. Includes the story Orson Welles used for his October 1939 Mercury Theater broadcast --almost word-for-word if memory serves. "Intelligence Test" by Harry Walton is a good thought problem. I can see it as a Twilight Zone episode. "What's He Doing In There?" by Fritz Leiber is great; funny.