After using Saxon Math for 9 grades of homeschooling, my son just wasn't enjoying math at all. He began to fall behind once we got to algebra. While Saxon Math is a thorough math program with plenty of review, I can't really say it inspires anyone to love math. So after reading a lot of positive reviews about the Life of Fred series, we decided to give it a try, mainly out of desperation.
First off, these books are FUN! There is a narrative that runs through the series about a 5 1/2 year boy named Fred who is a math genius who teaches at Kittens University. He has many little adventures that any kid would care about. The narrative is funny and very kid-friendly-- imagine someone like Douglas Adams writing math books, and you'll have an idea what these books are like. Fred's adventures always tie in with some practical math application in each chapter, making the math problem-solving accessible to anyone's everyday life, too.
There are only 32 chapters in this book, and each chapter tends to have fewer than 10 math problems to solve. The exercises aren't labelled as "exercises"-- they are called, "Your Turn to Play." The tests aren't called tests, but "Bridges" to the next lesson (these Bridges come every 5 lessons). The student must get at least 9 out of 10 problems correct on the Bridges before being able to go on to the next lesson (if he doesn't pass, there are five Bridges offered, each with 10 problems, if the student needs more practice). The book includes an answer key and every problem is worked out (unlike Saxon which only gives the final answer in their answer keys... you have to buy the CD-ROM to see the problems worked out in full). I really appreciate this! Another plus is that these books are highly affordable.
As an example of one of the problems (from ch. 20): When Joe went out fishing with Darlene, she packed two baskets. One of them was their lunch-- five baloney sandwiches. The other basket had the bait in it-- zillions of little meal worms. Joe accidentally ate 6/17 of the basket with the bait. What fraction of the bait basket did he leave uneaten? Just the kind of math problem kids love!
The author is very anti-"drill & kill" and believes in only supplying enough math problems to get the job done. I honestly don't know if it is enough (I'm the type that had to work both the even and odd problems in school, even if the teacher only assigned the odd problems, just to get it to stick in my craw-- and even then, it didn't always stick for long). I guess we'll see once we reach the algebra book in the series, when concepts become more abstract. I'm working through these books with my son. We were able to fly through this first book in 3-4 weeks time, typically doing 3 lessons per day since the first book was largely review for us. Though this is called a fractions book, I was surprised how few of the lessons actually dealt with actual fractions... the author sort of likes to circle around and sidle up to the concept, then circle around again, to deflect intimidation. He also likes the student to use his brain and figure some concepts out by himself, rather than being told what to do all the time. He also loves his footnotes, which are often funny and include quirky tidbits, such as what an onomatopoeia is (he's well-rounded in his approach to education and does not teach math in isolation). Overall, I recommend the book, especially to those who are more word-oriented than numbers-oriented. My son often asks to do math first now, which never happened with Saxon. But it remains to be seen if this will be enough... we plan to use Saxon as a back-up, in case we need extra practice (and I pray we won't ever need it).