What do you think?
Rate this book
The Dog Who Was There
Revisit the story of Jesus through the eyes of man’s best friend—a special dog named Barley.
No one expected Barley to have an encounter with the Messiah. He was homeless, hungry, and struggling to survive in first century Jerusalem. Most surprisingly, he was a dog. But through Barley’s eyes, the story of a teacher from Galilee comes alive in a way we’ve never experienced before.
Barley’s story begins in the home of a compassionate woodcarving family who finds Barley as an abandoned, nearly-drowned pup. Tales of a special teacher from Galilee are reaching their tiny village, but when life suddenly changes again for Barley, he carries the lessons of forgiveness and love out of the woodcarver’s home and through the dangerous roads of Roman-occupied Judea.
On the outskirts of Jerusalem, Barley meets a homeless man and petty criminal named Samid. Together, Barley and his unlikely new master experience fresh struggles and new revelations. Soon Barley is swept up into the current of history, culminating in an unforgettable encounter with the truest master of all as he bears witness to the greatest story ever told.
“An incredibly inspiring and beautiful tale of a blessed journey of lessons learned as told through the voice of one man’s (and humanity’s) best friend, a loving dog named Barley. Ron Marasco transports both heart and mind heralding understanding and acceptance while weaving rich religious history within the pages of this unique adventure.” —Kristen Chenoweth, Tony and Emmy award–winning actress
“If you need a spirit-lift, a book of hope, a read that will urge you to believe that hope is worth the risk, you are holding the right book. Do yourself a favor—read and enjoy!” —Max Lucado, New York Times bestselling author of How Happiness Happens and Anxious for Nothing
“Some of the greatest life lessons about courage, loyalty, trust, and patience . . . I’ve learned from my dog. Read The Dog Who Was There and learn an amazing lesson about faith.” —Andy Andrews, New York Times bestselling author of The Noticer and The Traveler’s Gift
“The Dog Who Was There is a page-turning read that stops and opens the heart. Revealing profound truth with compelling grace, Ron Marasco offers a singular vision of the greatest story ever told.” —Beth Henley, Pulitzer Prize–winning playwright of Crimes of the Heart and The Jacksonian
“The Dog Who Was There is a wonderful, engaging book that adds a completely new perspective to the Passion story. Ron Marasco has created a character in Barley who will entertain and inspire readers. The retelling of Christ’s ministry through the human characters connects the reader in a unique was to the Gospel message, but it is Barley who will charm people of all ages.” —Kevin Baxter, EdD, Superintendent of Catholic Schools, Archdiocese of Los Angeles
Inspirational standalone novel with biblical elements.Book 52,000 words.Includes discussion questions for book clubs.
No one expected Barley to have an encounter with the Messiah. He was homeless, hungry, and struggling to survive in first century Jerusalem. Most surprisingly, he was a dog. But through Barley’s eyes, the story of a teacher from Galilee comes alive in a way we’ve never experienced before.
Barley’s story begins in the home of a compassionate woodcarving family who finds Barley as an abandoned, nearly-drowned pup. Tales of a special teacher from Galilee are reaching their tiny village, but when life suddenly changes again for Barley, he carries the lessons of forgiveness and love out of the woodcarver’s home and through the dangerous roads of Roman-occupied Judea.
On the outskirts of Jerusalem, Barley meets a homeless man and petty criminal named Samid. Together, Barley and his unlikely new master experience fresh struggles and new revelations. Soon Barley is swept up into the current of history, culminating in an unforgettable encounter with the truest master of all as he bears witness to the greatest story ever told.
“An incredibly inspiring and beautiful tale of a blessed journey of lessons learned as told through the voice of one man’s (and humanity’s) best friend, a loving dog named Barley. Ron Marasco transports both heart and mind heralding understanding and acceptance while weaving rich religious history within the pages of this unique adventure.” —Kristen Chenoweth, Tony and Emmy award–winning actress
“If you need a spirit-lift, a book of hope, a read that will urge you to believe that hope is worth the risk, you are holding the right book. Do yourself a favor—read and enjoy!” —Max Lucado, New York Times bestselling author of How Happiness Happens and Anxious for Nothing
“Some of the greatest life lessons about courage, loyalty, trust, and patience . . . I’ve learned from my dog. Read The Dog Who Was There and learn an amazing lesson about faith.” —Andy Andrews, New York Times bestselling author of The Noticer and The Traveler’s Gift
“The Dog Who Was There is a page-turning read that stops and opens the heart. Revealing profound truth with compelling grace, Ron Marasco offers a singular vision of the greatest story ever told.” —Beth Henley, Pulitzer Prize–winning playwright of Crimes of the Heart and The Jacksonian
“The Dog Who Was There is a wonderful, engaging book that adds a completely new perspective to the Passion story. Ron Marasco has created a character in Barley who will entertain and inspire readers. The retelling of Christ’s ministry through the human characters connects the reader in a unique was to the Gospel message, but it is Barley who will charm people of all ages.” —Kevin Baxter, EdD, Superintendent of Catholic Schools, Archdiocese of Los Angeles
Inspirational standalone novel with biblical elements.Book 52,000 words.Includes discussion questions for book clubs.
267 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 31, 2017
240 people are currently reading
890 people want to read
About the author
Ron Marasco
10 books20 followersRon Marasco is a professor in the College of Communication and Fine Arts at Loyola Marymount University in Los Angeles. His first book, Notes to an Actor, was named by the American Library Association an "Outstanding Book of 2008." For the past five years he has taught a very popular course on the subject of grief using film, theatre, literature and oral history as a way to study this often intimidating subject. He has acted extensively on TV―in everything from Lost to West Wing to Entourage -and appeared opposite screen legend Kirk Douglas in the movie Illusion, for which he also wrote the screenplay. He has a BA from Fordham at Lincoln Center and an MA and Ph. D. from UCLA. Brian Shuff is a writer from Mesa, Arizona, who now lives in Los Angeles where he is at work completing a book of short stories. His mother died when he was eight years old, giving him a life-long interest in the subject of grief. Along with Ron Marasco he has written a screenplay based on Louise Hay's groundbreaking book, You Can Heal Your Life that will premiere in 2011. He and Marasco are also working on a dramatic adaptation of John McNulty's book This Place on Third Avenue.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 230 reviews
January 31, 2021
A short, easy to read book which will appeal to many dog lovers and particularly to Christian dog lovers. I am not sure that the attitudes of the characters toward dogs accurately reflect first century attitudes in the Holy Land but that is not the point of the story anyway. A unique view of Jesus and the crucifixion as seen through the adventures and trials of a dog.
February 19, 2017
Quite a unique novel! The Dog Who Was There is written from the perspective of a mutt named Barley. We follow his journey from birth to two days following Christ's crucifixion. While the novel is primarily about Barley, the reader is given glimpses at what life was like during that time as well as a look at Christ's final day in human form on earth. I found it to be a sweet read.
My gratitude to publisher Thomas Nelson for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
My gratitude to publisher Thomas Nelson for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
February 6, 2017
When your favorite genre happens to be one that sees very few newcomers, you tend to get excited when a new author emerges. This was my primary impetus for reading Ron Marasco’s debut biblical fiction release, The Dog Who Was There. Marasco puts his own unique signature on this story by telling it from the point of view of a pup named Barley. Barley and his owners make their home in first century Judea where a new Teacher (Jesus) is creating quite a stir.
Much to my chagrin, the author’s execution failed to meet my expectations. Within the first 3 chapters, I began to question whether the story was written for middle grade readers or adults. I didn’t have a problem with the anthropomorphism of the dog, but rather the simple writing and dialogue. As I read on, I recognized the frequency in which the author uses Barley’s name. Once noticed, I couldn’t overlook it and it began to annoy me. The same was true with the repetition of “The Kind Man” during the crucifixion scenes. My final complaint is how little direct interaction the characters have with Jesus. Instead, the primary focus is on how people treat Barley and how his three different owners react to the words of the Teacher. Apart from the scenes at the foot of the cross, the author could have chosen any period of time and given his characters the opportunity to wrestle with Christ’s teachings. In lieu of these things I cannot recommend the book.
I received a free review copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Much to my chagrin, the author’s execution failed to meet my expectations. Within the first 3 chapters, I began to question whether the story was written for middle grade readers or adults. I didn’t have a problem with the anthropomorphism of the dog, but rather the simple writing and dialogue. As I read on, I recognized the frequency in which the author uses Barley’s name. Once noticed, I couldn’t overlook it and it began to annoy me. The same was true with the repetition of “The Kind Man” during the crucifixion scenes. My final complaint is how little direct interaction the characters have with Jesus. Instead, the primary focus is on how people treat Barley and how his three different owners react to the words of the Teacher. Apart from the scenes at the foot of the cross, the author could have chosen any period of time and given his characters the opportunity to wrestle with Christ’s teachings. In lieu of these things I cannot recommend the book.
I received a free review copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
February 12, 2017
The Dog Who Was There by Ron Marasco is a beautiful novel and one that will remain in your heart long after the last page is read.
The novel is told through the eyes of Barley, a small seven year old dog. The reader witnesses his search for a home, for love, for a place to belong. Barley is a metaphor for us - we all need a home, love and a place to belong. We find our home is not in bricks and mortar. Our home is in a person and His name is Jesus.
Barley 'sees' the final week of Jesus' life as he follows the Kind Man. The Kind Man has compassion for all, even a small dog. The Kind Man has compassion for you and for me.
The Dog Who Was There is breathtakingly beautiful. It speaks straight to your soul. It gives you a feeling of peace. It shows that the world needs kindness.
Barley was looking for a home. His home was found in people. Our home is found in Jesus.
Pure beauty in a book.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
The novel is told through the eyes of Barley, a small seven year old dog. The reader witnesses his search for a home, for love, for a place to belong. Barley is a metaphor for us - we all need a home, love and a place to belong. We find our home is not in bricks and mortar. Our home is in a person and His name is Jesus.
Barley 'sees' the final week of Jesus' life as he follows the Kind Man. The Kind Man has compassion for all, even a small dog. The Kind Man has compassion for you and for me.
The Dog Who Was There is breathtakingly beautiful. It speaks straight to your soul. It gives you a feeling of peace. It shows that the world needs kindness.
Barley was looking for a home. His home was found in people. Our home is found in Jesus.
Pure beauty in a book.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
February 14, 2017
This is the story of Barley, the dog who had an encounter with the Messiah in Jerusalem. Barley was homeless, hungry and struggling to survive in first century Jerusalem. We see the teacher from Galilee through the eyes of Barley, a dog. The story comes alive in a way you never thought possible.
Barley's story begins in the home of a compassionate woodcarver and his wife who find Barley as an abandoned, nearly drowned puppy. Tales of a special teacher from Galilee are reaching their tiny village, but when life suddenly changes for Barley, he carries the lessons of love and forgiveness out of the woodcarver's home and through the dangerous roads of Roman occupied Judea.
On the outskirts of Jerusalem, Barley meets a homeless man and petty criminal named Samid. Together, Barley and his new master experience struggles and revelations. Soon Barley is swept up into the current of history, culminating in an unforgettable encounter with the truest master of all as he bears witness to the greatest story every told.
Dog lovers will be entranced by this story. I love dogs and own one myself, who is the joy of my heart. I often find myself wondering what Sam is thinking and how he feels. I know he loves me, but I would just like to see into his mind. Ron Marasco has written a completely delightful tale that allows the reader into the mind of a dog and how he feels. I was in tears in places during the reading. One scene just did me in. This is a book you'll love if you love dogs and Jesus.
*I was provided with a copy of this book by The Fiction Guild. My review is my own and honest opinion.
Barley's story begins in the home of a compassionate woodcarver and his wife who find Barley as an abandoned, nearly drowned puppy. Tales of a special teacher from Galilee are reaching their tiny village, but when life suddenly changes for Barley, he carries the lessons of love and forgiveness out of the woodcarver's home and through the dangerous roads of Roman occupied Judea.
On the outskirts of Jerusalem, Barley meets a homeless man and petty criminal named Samid. Together, Barley and his new master experience struggles and revelations. Soon Barley is swept up into the current of history, culminating in an unforgettable encounter with the truest master of all as he bears witness to the greatest story every told.
Dog lovers will be entranced by this story. I love dogs and own one myself, who is the joy of my heart. I often find myself wondering what Sam is thinking and how he feels. I know he loves me, but I would just like to see into his mind. Ron Marasco has written a completely delightful tale that allows the reader into the mind of a dog and how he feels. I was in tears in places during the reading. One scene just did me in. This is a book you'll love if you love dogs and Jesus.
*I was provided with a copy of this book by The Fiction Guild. My review is my own and honest opinion.
February 6, 2017
As a dog lover, I was intrigued to read a story about a dog who experienced first hand the life of Jesus. I didn't really know what to expect and now having read it I have a mix of thoughts as regards reviewing it.
I appreciated the grittiness of the story. We see the times of Jesus from the ground level so we get a taste of the dirt and squalor of certain areas of Jerusalem and other nearby locales. We get a view of the violence of the period, in particular, the ruthless and callous disregard the Romans had for life, both human and canine. For some readers this may be a bit confronting.
Barley is a rescue dog in the true sense of the description (we have 2 at home) and has a delightful spirit even though for much of his life he is poorly treated. But we do get to see him being loved by a married couple and later by a petty criminal, Samid, which Barley responds well too.
Jesus, or the Kind Man as Barley describes Him, doesn't really enter the story until about halfway and then it's not until the last 30% of the book when Barley gets up close to Him in His last days. And the crucifixion scene is tremendously portrayed from the eyes of Barley.
What I found challenging about the novel is that not a lot happens in the first half and I struggled to get through to it. I kept wondering when Jesus was going to become more prominent as that's what the title alluded to. I was confused by the POV quite a lot. The author jumped between Barley and 3rd person narrator frequently to the extent they almost meshed. I felt Barley often saw things through a human and not, a dog perspective.
The last third of the novel was very good to read with a couple of very clever twists which amped up the emotional connection I had to the story. However, there is so much quality reading material available I'm not sure I'm able to recommend this one.
I received a complimentary Netgalley advanced readers' copy of "The Dog who was There" via Litfuse. This is an independent and honest review of the book.
I appreciated the grittiness of the story. We see the times of Jesus from the ground level so we get a taste of the dirt and squalor of certain areas of Jerusalem and other nearby locales. We get a view of the violence of the period, in particular, the ruthless and callous disregard the Romans had for life, both human and canine. For some readers this may be a bit confronting.
Barley is a rescue dog in the true sense of the description (we have 2 at home) and has a delightful spirit even though for much of his life he is poorly treated. But we do get to see him being loved by a married couple and later by a petty criminal, Samid, which Barley responds well too.
Jesus, or the Kind Man as Barley describes Him, doesn't really enter the story until about halfway and then it's not until the last 30% of the book when Barley gets up close to Him in His last days. And the crucifixion scene is tremendously portrayed from the eyes of Barley.
What I found challenging about the novel is that not a lot happens in the first half and I struggled to get through to it. I kept wondering when Jesus was going to become more prominent as that's what the title alluded to. I was confused by the POV quite a lot. The author jumped between Barley and 3rd person narrator frequently to the extent they almost meshed. I felt Barley often saw things through a human and not, a dog perspective.
The last third of the novel was very good to read with a couple of very clever twists which amped up the emotional connection I had to the story. However, there is so much quality reading material available I'm not sure I'm able to recommend this one.
I received a complimentary Netgalley advanced readers' copy of "The Dog who was There" via Litfuse. This is an independent and honest review of the book.
April 4, 2023
After seeing this book repeatedly recommended as a CF read for Holy Week, I decided to give it a go. I'm glad I did. If I'm being honest, I wasn't sure I would enjoy a book written from a dogs point of view. But this was well done. And is probably one of the most unique books I've read.
The story is told from Barley, the little dogs, point of view. It's the story of his life, and during his life, he briefly meets Jesus, and ends up witnessing the crucifixion. I enjoy descriptive books that make me feel like I'm actually inside the story and seeing and experiencing it for myself, and Ron Marascos writing style definitely did that.
The story doesn't tell much about Jesus life on earth, and it's well past the half way mark when Barley witnesses the crucifixion. (Prior to that he does also witness Palm Sunday.) So there's a good bit of the book that focuses on Barleys story, but it is actually really good! It felt a bit suspenseful because there was danger at every turn for this little dog. I found myself rooting for him and loved the emotions that the writing style stirs up for Barley!
The actual crucifixion scene is brutal. The author doesn't hold back in providing historical details of how awful it was and what Jesus endured. It doesn't end with the Resurrection, but the ending was very sweet.
The story is told from Barley, the little dogs, point of view. It's the story of his life, and during his life, he briefly meets Jesus, and ends up witnessing the crucifixion. I enjoy descriptive books that make me feel like I'm actually inside the story and seeing and experiencing it for myself, and Ron Marascos writing style definitely did that.
The story doesn't tell much about Jesus life on earth, and it's well past the half way mark when Barley witnesses the crucifixion. (Prior to that he does also witness Palm Sunday.) So there's a good bit of the book that focuses on Barleys story, but it is actually really good! It felt a bit suspenseful because there was danger at every turn for this little dog. I found myself rooting for him and loved the emotions that the writing style stirs up for Barley!
The actual crucifixion scene is brutal. The author doesn't hold back in providing historical details of how awful it was and what Jesus endured. It doesn't end with the Resurrection, but the ending was very sweet.
February 14, 2025
I love this story so much and wasn't sure if I'd like the dogs perspective but I think that made the story for me. I won't lie, it made me cry, but obviously it's a sad story, a sad story that ends with a true happily ever after ❤️🙌
April 23, 2025
One of my 2025 favorites.
I have never read anything like this and it warmed my heart so many times.
I teared up more than once!
It's a beautiful book!!
I have never read anything like this and it warmed my heart so many times.
I teared up more than once!
It's a beautiful book!!
February 13, 2017
The Dog Who Was There is quite unlike any other title I have read for some time. Setting a book in Jerusalem during the life of Christ is nothing new - but telling that story from the primary point of view of a stray dog is quite another. It granted a unique and different perspective and afforded a chance to observe events through literally completely innocent eyes.
We are first introduced to Barley (so named for the barley growing around where he was found) as a pup abandoned and abused. Cruelly separated from his mother and siblings and tossed out into a harsh and unforgiving world, quickly Barley learns to fend for himself. But fortunately for him - a kind hearted merchant couple take a shine to him and he quickly becomes a treasured member of their family.
But tragic events seem to mire Barley’s life - and this becomes the pattern for the book. Barleys search for a true master and the ones who fill that position down through the years.
The book culminates at the crucification - and the prose penned here are simply stunning. Viewing such cataclysmic events through little Barley’s eyes is both harrowing and heartening.
The ending was a complete surprise for me - and a perfect reward for little Barley and us as the readers. While a smaller novel than many I would normally read - it was engaging and entertaining and moving at the same time. Definitely a keeper.
We are first introduced to Barley (so named for the barley growing around where he was found) as a pup abandoned and abused. Cruelly separated from his mother and siblings and tossed out into a harsh and unforgiving world, quickly Barley learns to fend for himself. But fortunately for him - a kind hearted merchant couple take a shine to him and he quickly becomes a treasured member of their family.
But tragic events seem to mire Barley’s life - and this becomes the pattern for the book. Barleys search for a true master and the ones who fill that position down through the years.
The book culminates at the crucification - and the prose penned here are simply stunning. Viewing such cataclysmic events through little Barley’s eyes is both harrowing and heartening.
The ending was a complete surprise for me - and a perfect reward for little Barley and us as the readers. While a smaller novel than many I would normally read - it was engaging and entertaining and moving at the same time. Definitely a keeper.
February 8, 2017
Barley has it rough at first, then he finds a good home with a couple who follow the man from Galilee. Thru an unexpected turn of events Barely finds himself alone on the outskirts of Jerusalem. There he sees “Jesus” up-close and personal. Barley calls him “The kind man.”
He notices how people treat “the teacher from Galilee” (that’s what his master called him). Some people loved him and tried to apply his teachings to their lives. Others wanted to harm him. Barely watched this man share a love he hadn’t witness before.
A woman explains how Barley’s not desperate like some people she knew. “Prisca laughs and says, “this little one doesn’t despair.” She rubs Barley’s belly. “He’s always looking for the next good thing. A hand to lick, some food to chomp, a stuck to fetch, a sight to see, a friend to curl up next to.”
The retelling of the greatest story ever told will have you see familiar events with fresh eyes. It’s an endearing and inspirational tale dealing with themes of forgiveness, struggles to survive, ordinary people facing hard situations with a new-found courage and experience an unforgettable love. I liked how this author put in a few surprises for readers along this dog’s journey thru Jerusalem. Barley is a charmer, he grows on you. You’ll be moved by what he sees and how he interprets it. I liked how this novel was written through Barely the dog’s eyes.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the BookLook site. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins! www.bookfun.org
The Book Club Network blog www.psalm516.blogspot.com
Book Fun Magazine
He notices how people treat “the teacher from Galilee” (that’s what his master called him). Some people loved him and tried to apply his teachings to their lives. Others wanted to harm him. Barely watched this man share a love he hadn’t witness before.
A woman explains how Barley’s not desperate like some people she knew. “Prisca laughs and says, “this little one doesn’t despair.” She rubs Barley’s belly. “He’s always looking for the next good thing. A hand to lick, some food to chomp, a stuck to fetch, a sight to see, a friend to curl up next to.”
The retelling of the greatest story ever told will have you see familiar events with fresh eyes. It’s an endearing and inspirational tale dealing with themes of forgiveness, struggles to survive, ordinary people facing hard situations with a new-found courage and experience an unforgettable love. I liked how this author put in a few surprises for readers along this dog’s journey thru Jerusalem. Barley is a charmer, he grows on you. You’ll be moved by what he sees and how he interprets it. I liked how this novel was written through Barely the dog’s eyes.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the BookLook site. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins! www.bookfun.org
The Book Club Network blog www.psalm516.blogspot.com
Book Fun Magazine
February 15, 2017
" . . despair is so difficult to let go of because if helps us justify the worst things inside of us."
Barley, the little dog, has seen, heard and experienced human despair in a canine sort of way. Being separated from his mother at an early age, losing masters who were thoughtful and kind, living among those who fought, stole, and begged for their daily sustenance, Barley fights to survive on the streets of ancient Jerusalem. How ironic that he becomes an eyewitness to what many refer to as "the greatest story ever told"; coming to a full understanding of "the lesson of lessons - the way to overcome evil", through a Kind Man who suffered much in order to love many.
I can honestly say that I have never read anything quite like, "The Dog Who Was There".
I was provided a copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
Barley, the little dog, has seen, heard and experienced human despair in a canine sort of way. Being separated from his mother at an early age, losing masters who were thoughtful and kind, living among those who fought, stole, and begged for their daily sustenance, Barley fights to survive on the streets of ancient Jerusalem. How ironic that he becomes an eyewitness to what many refer to as "the greatest story ever told"; coming to a full understanding of "the lesson of lessons - the way to overcome evil", through a Kind Man who suffered much in order to love many.
I can honestly say that I have never read anything quite like, "The Dog Who Was There".
I was provided a copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
February 15, 2017
For anyone who love pets, we know that these creatures can be the most innocent of all. They love unconditionally and trust without measure. Pets can be like little children.
In this book it begins with Barley, the little pup that was ripped from his mother but saved by a loving couple. Through heartache and despair, Barley is thrust onto an ever moving path.
Told in the fashion of Milo & Otis and The Jungle Book, the reader is both the dog and the people around him. We can see in detail and feel with such passion the loneliness, fear, hope, and love.
The story is written in a simple way, and yet it speaks volumes. Such simplicity brought about the strongest of emotions, especially as we witness the last days of Christ before His crucifixion.
The Dog Who Was There could become a timelessly story that would span the ages of all readers. From young to old, this book has a lesson for all and shows the wonderful and awesome power of love.
Definitely a keeper and one that I think most everyone would enjoy.
In this book it begins with Barley, the little pup that was ripped from his mother but saved by a loving couple. Through heartache and despair, Barley is thrust onto an ever moving path.
Told in the fashion of Milo & Otis and The Jungle Book, the reader is both the dog and the people around him. We can see in detail and feel with such passion the loneliness, fear, hope, and love.
The story is written in a simple way, and yet it speaks volumes. Such simplicity brought about the strongest of emotions, especially as we witness the last days of Christ before His crucifixion.
The Dog Who Was There could become a timelessly story that would span the ages of all readers. From young to old, this book has a lesson for all and shows the wonderful and awesome power of love.
Definitely a keeper and one that I think most everyone would enjoy.
dnf
April 2, 2023Read 45% of book and so far, nothing but abuse and tragedy every time there’s a glimmer of good in Barley’s life. Almost halfway through and no encounters with Jesus yet, so the interaction I had hoped for isn’t as central to the plot as I expected. As someone who reads as an escape from the atrocities of the world and who is horrified by the commission of abuse of those who can’t defend themselves (whether human or canine), I don’t feel the need to continue this one.
March 4, 2017
The Dog Who Was There is the story of a dog and his experiences of first century Judea and as a witness to the final days of Jesus. After finishing this book earlier this week, I posted a review and then quickly took it back down. The review focused on the book's shortcomings, and as soon as it was posted it occurred to me that I hadn't addressed the primary issue - my approach to the book.
My mistake was that I had approached this as a book written for adults, to be read by adults. Upon reflection, I realized that this is a family book. Read more… Much as family movies seem to be aimed at younger viewers, at times with elements woven in to appeal more to the adults, this is a book meant to be read by a wide range of ages. This is a book to be shared and enjoyed together.
It opens with a warm, cozy feel and the story is told in third person from the point of view of Barley, a young dog. Barley, as the lead character, will definitely engage the younger members of the family. Written at what feels to be a middle grade level, this book would lend itself to shared reading or read-aloud, perhaps after being previewed for the level of violence in certain scenes.
The writing is competent and approachable though quite repetitive, particularly in the over-use of character names. Over the span of two pages, for example, where the main character Barley and his new master Samid are in a scene, barely a sentence seems to go by without one or both of them being named. And while I thought that having the back story of how he came to be separated from his mother being told through a puppy dream was a cute device, it felt a bit clumsy to immediately follow this with a flash-back to explain how he came to live with the elderly couple we first meet as his masters.
The main attraction of this novel is that it is the story of the crucifixion as witnessed by a dog who was, as the title states, there. While this is indeed the case, it is not in the crucifixion of Jesus, or the "Kind Man" as he is called (repeatedly), but in the death of Samid on one of the three crosses that is most touching and most impactful. The actual witnessing of Jesus' journey to Golgotha and death on the cross receives a surface portrayal and is very much just something seen in passing.
Barley's story has a happy ending and while there multiple scenes with violence and other potentially upsetting events, it is a sweet and poignant story that does include his witnessing of the greatest story ever told. However, more informed readers are likely to find fault with the historical and cultural inaccuracies as well as the cameo appearances of Jesus, who is mainly referred to as the Teacher and then as the Kind Man.
While Barley's point of view is definitely a new approach to a well-known story, this is a book I suggest be read either by a younger reader or as a family but I can not recommend it for adult readers. However, if you absolutely adore stories told from an anthropomorphized dog's point of view and the premise interests you, don't let this stop you. After all, this is just one reader's opinion and your experience of the story might be quite different.
This review refers to a free copy received from Thomas Nelson and Zondervan's Fiction Guild, in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. This review was originally posted on bookworlder.wordpress.com
My mistake was that I had approached this as a book written for adults, to be read by adults. Upon reflection, I realized that this is a family book. Read more… Much as family movies seem to be aimed at younger viewers, at times with elements woven in to appeal more to the adults, this is a book meant to be read by a wide range of ages. This is a book to be shared and enjoyed together.
It opens with a warm, cozy feel and the story is told in third person from the point of view of Barley, a young dog. Barley, as the lead character, will definitely engage the younger members of the family. Written at what feels to be a middle grade level, this book would lend itself to shared reading or read-aloud, perhaps after being previewed for the level of violence in certain scenes.
The writing is competent and approachable though quite repetitive, particularly in the over-use of character names. Over the span of two pages, for example, where the main character Barley and his new master Samid are in a scene, barely a sentence seems to go by without one or both of them being named. And while I thought that having the back story of how he came to be separated from his mother being told through a puppy dream was a cute device, it felt a bit clumsy to immediately follow this with a flash-back to explain how he came to live with the elderly couple we first meet as his masters.
The main attraction of this novel is that it is the story of the crucifixion as witnessed by a dog who was, as the title states, there. While this is indeed the case, it is not in the crucifixion of Jesus, or the "Kind Man" as he is called (repeatedly), but in the death of Samid on one of the three crosses that is most touching and most impactful. The actual witnessing of Jesus' journey to Golgotha and death on the cross receives a surface portrayal and is very much just something seen in passing.
Barley's story has a happy ending and while there multiple scenes with violence and other potentially upsetting events, it is a sweet and poignant story that does include his witnessing of the greatest story ever told. However, more informed readers are likely to find fault with the historical and cultural inaccuracies as well as the cameo appearances of Jesus, who is mainly referred to as the Teacher and then as the Kind Man.
While Barley's point of view is definitely a new approach to a well-known story, this is a book I suggest be read either by a younger reader or as a family but I can not recommend it for adult readers. However, if you absolutely adore stories told from an anthropomorphized dog's point of view and the premise interests you, don't let this stop you. After all, this is just one reader's opinion and your experience of the story might be quite different.
This review refers to a free copy received from Thomas Nelson and Zondervan's Fiction Guild, in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. This review was originally posted on bookworlder.wordpress.com
February 15, 2017
A Dog Witnesses the Last Days of the Messiah
Barley lived with a woodcarver and his wife. He dearly loved the old couple who had rescued him as a pup, but he could also remember a young boy who played with him before he was rescued. When Duv and Adah, his owners, are murdered, Barley finds himself on the streets again. Ultimately he arrives in Jerusalem during the last days of Jesus.
The story is told through Barley’s eyes. He’s a wonderful character, loving, wanting to have a family and help his people. The first chapters are slow. We meet Adah and Duv. Barley dreams of his young boy and the tenor of the book is comfortable. However, when Barley gets to Jerusalem, the tenor changes. Some of the scenes he witnesses are quite violent.
The setting is well done and believable as are the characters Barley interacts with. Although the pace is slow in the first half of the book, it picks up at the end as Barley witnesses the violent end of the Messiah.
I enjoyed the book and recommend it. Although it’s an adult book, the writing is clear and simple as befits the story told by the dog. Unless there is an objection to the violent scenes, this book could also be enjoyed by young adult readers.
I received this book from the Lifuse Publicity Group for this review.
Barley lived with a woodcarver and his wife. He dearly loved the old couple who had rescued him as a pup, but he could also remember a young boy who played with him before he was rescued. When Duv and Adah, his owners, are murdered, Barley finds himself on the streets again. Ultimately he arrives in Jerusalem during the last days of Jesus.
The story is told through Barley’s eyes. He’s a wonderful character, loving, wanting to have a family and help his people. The first chapters are slow. We meet Adah and Duv. Barley dreams of his young boy and the tenor of the book is comfortable. However, when Barley gets to Jerusalem, the tenor changes. Some of the scenes he witnesses are quite violent.
The setting is well done and believable as are the characters Barley interacts with. Although the pace is slow in the first half of the book, it picks up at the end as Barley witnesses the violent end of the Messiah.
I enjoyed the book and recommend it. Although it’s an adult book, the writing is clear and simple as befits the story told by the dog. Unless there is an objection to the violent scenes, this book could also be enjoyed by young adult readers.
I received this book from the Lifuse Publicity Group for this review.
May 2, 2019
I won a copy of this book during a Goodreads giveaway. I am under no obligation to leave a review or rating and do so voluntarily. So that others may also enjoy this book, I am paying it forward by donating it to my local library.
March 6, 2021
I wasn't sure I wanted to continue the story after some rather brutal treatment of dogs, but realized that it was essential to the story as well as being the type of behavior some folks show towards them. I liked the wording, the pictures painted with the verbiage. The use of the crucifixion from a dog's perspective is just part of it - like how it went into the spiritual teachings as understood by folks who wanted to understand, or who defied the ideas, or held different believes. It made for a rather simplistic understanding of love and forgiveness - which is what is needed, rather than taking it to depths and wordiness where folks just don't get it. Well done!
July 26, 2021
The author chose a unique perspective by telling a familiar story through the eyes of a dog.
October 24, 2023
A simple story of a dog who lives during the time of Christ and witnesses the Passion of Christ. Filled with religious references and lessons, it is more of a self help book than a novel.
January 26, 2024
This is such a beautiful story and so original! I can't tell you how many times I cried. Cried for Barley the dog. Cried for Jesus. Cried for the saved. I would love to read this again with fresh eyes as if I've never read it before. This may become my annual new year book bc it's that beautiful and hopeful!
April 3, 2021
So, I read "The Dog Who Was There" by Ron Marasco in three days. There were times I had trouble putting it down, sometimes in tears. I immediately fell in love with Barley, the dog; who never gave up on humans. The start of his life was not easy as he saw his mother and siblings killed by unkind men. He was tossed in a tied bag and flung into the river. He was found and rescued by a couple that gave him love and security for seven years; only to lose their lives to thiefs at the market.
He was now on his own and experiencing both love and cruelty. Through his travels Barley met Samid and "The Kind Man", Jesus. He is there when Jesus is beaten for falling while carrying his cross and when he was crucified. His friend Samid was also crucified with Jesus.
Forgiveness, kindness, and love propels the story to it's conclusion; a conclusion that leaves the reader satisfied and transformed. This was a great story for young and old especially with Easter coming in a few days.
He was now on his own and experiencing both love and cruelty. Through his travels Barley met Samid and "The Kind Man", Jesus. He is there when Jesus is beaten for falling while carrying his cross and when he was crucified. His friend Samid was also crucified with Jesus.
Forgiveness, kindness, and love propels the story to it's conclusion; a conclusion that leaves the reader satisfied and transformed. This was a great story for young and old especially with Easter coming in a few days.
February 4, 2017
What a story this was to read and share. I couldn’t imagine a more interesting view point to have read through. Barley touched my heart in so many ways, and I was drawn to his views of Christ. Life wasn’t easy for Barley but he sure kept a pretty optimistic outlook on life. I wish to strive more for that. This a book for readers of faith filled stories, animal lovers and those needing a warming to their souls.
Full Review on 2/4/17: https://bibliophile.reviews/book-revi...
Full Review on 2/4/17: https://bibliophile.reviews/book-revi...
December 22, 2024
A precious book about Jesus’s death and resurrection through the eyes of a dog 🤗 very quick and easy read!
April 21, 2017
In 1st century Jerusalem, a pregnant stray dog gives birth to a litter of pups in a wooded area near the river. The runt of the litter is spotted by Micah, the young son of a wealthy landowner. Micah sneaks away from chores each day to play with the pup, until the day he is found out by his father. The father tries to have the whole litter killed but thanks to the efforts of Duv, a woodcarver, and his wife, Adah, the young pup is saved and named Barley.
It is in the home of the woodcarver that Barley first starts to hear stories of an already near-mythic man from the land of Galilee. That's right, none other than than big man himself, Jesus! For seven years, Barley has a cozy home life full of love and treats. But one regular work day in town leads to tragedy for the woodcarver and his wife, a turn of events that once again puts Barley out on the streets. The scared canine is soon spotted by Samid, a homeless man / petty criminal, and his lady friend Prisca. Though the accomodations are significantly more humble than his previous pad, Barley takes what he can get and soon settles into a moderately comfortable routine with new pal Samid. Barley's life with Samid puts him in close proximity to Jesus, now in Jerusalem, so Barley is there to witness the final days leading up to the Passion of Christ.
Well, right off, I will say that this is a unique way to breathe fresh new perspective into a tale that's been told a million times over! The writing sometimes struck me as somewhat simplistic but that could just be a natural by-product of the author choosing to tell the story from the inner thoughts of a dog. Perhaps the simplicity is intentional? Regardless, the benefit of a simple voice is that it makes this story perfect for sharing with readers within a wide age range.
Note that I was careful not to say "of all ages", because there is material within this novel that may be a little traumatic for the littlest ones in your life, whether they read independently or have you read to them. Barley witnesses (and describes) seeing the bodies of people executed by hanging, there are moments of extreme violence within Barley's own life, moments where he is injured, not to mention Barley relaying the sights of the Crucifixion itself near the end of the novel. The fate of Duv & Adah (the woodcarver and his wife) show just how rough and sometimes lawless this time period could be. So when it comes to the smallest of your story lovers, I'd recommend maybe first doing a read-through to see what you need to gloss over for them.
Much of the story, as far as plot, while solidly enjoyable, lacked that little something extra for me. For the majority of the book, I kept waiting for that extra oomph to kick in. That said, I did enjoy the "voice" of our dog narrator and one of my favorite bits of the whole story was Samid and his friendship / something more? with Prisca. There was a good dose of humor and lively banter between them. I agree with Prisca, Samid outwardly appears rough around the edges, but you get the sense there's a good guy there deep down.
What ended up bumping this up to a four star read for me was simply Barley's observations during the Crucifixion. The way author Ron Marasco painted these scenes gave me a whole new visual of this event I've heard told in stories SO many times over. Yet something in the way Marasco illustrates it (in words) made it more real for me than nearly any other piece on the Crucifixion I've ever read. Ever. I physically flinched at what Barley describes himself seeing as the walk up to the cross is taking place. The attention to detail Marasco provides when describing the whippings Jesus is taking from soldiers, the way Barley winces and whimpers and thinks of him (Jesus) as Kind Man. It all just knocks you right in the heart! Beyond the Crucifixion scene, there is a further twist to the ending that I did not entirely see coming!
FTC Disclaimer: TNZ Fiction Guild kindly provided me with a complimentary copy of this book & requested that I check it out and share my thoughts. The opinions above are entirely my own.
It is in the home of the woodcarver that Barley first starts to hear stories of an already near-mythic man from the land of Galilee. That's right, none other than than big man himself, Jesus! For seven years, Barley has a cozy home life full of love and treats. But one regular work day in town leads to tragedy for the woodcarver and his wife, a turn of events that once again puts Barley out on the streets. The scared canine is soon spotted by Samid, a homeless man / petty criminal, and his lady friend Prisca. Though the accomodations are significantly more humble than his previous pad, Barley takes what he can get and soon settles into a moderately comfortable routine with new pal Samid. Barley's life with Samid puts him in close proximity to Jesus, now in Jerusalem, so Barley is there to witness the final days leading up to the Passion of Christ.
Well, right off, I will say that this is a unique way to breathe fresh new perspective into a tale that's been told a million times over! The writing sometimes struck me as somewhat simplistic but that could just be a natural by-product of the author choosing to tell the story from the inner thoughts of a dog. Perhaps the simplicity is intentional? Regardless, the benefit of a simple voice is that it makes this story perfect for sharing with readers within a wide age range.
Note that I was careful not to say "of all ages", because there is material within this novel that may be a little traumatic for the littlest ones in your life, whether they read independently or have you read to them. Barley witnesses (and describes) seeing the bodies of people executed by hanging, there are moments of extreme violence within Barley's own life, moments where he is injured, not to mention Barley relaying the sights of the Crucifixion itself near the end of the novel. The fate of Duv & Adah (the woodcarver and his wife) show just how rough and sometimes lawless this time period could be. So when it comes to the smallest of your story lovers, I'd recommend maybe first doing a read-through to see what you need to gloss over for them.
Much of the story, as far as plot, while solidly enjoyable, lacked that little something extra for me. For the majority of the book, I kept waiting for that extra oomph to kick in. That said, I did enjoy the "voice" of our dog narrator and one of my favorite bits of the whole story was Samid and his friendship / something more? with Prisca. There was a good dose of humor and lively banter between them. I agree with Prisca, Samid outwardly appears rough around the edges, but you get the sense there's a good guy there deep down.
What ended up bumping this up to a four star read for me was simply Barley's observations during the Crucifixion. The way author Ron Marasco painted these scenes gave me a whole new visual of this event I've heard told in stories SO many times over. Yet something in the way Marasco illustrates it (in words) made it more real for me than nearly any other piece on the Crucifixion I've ever read. Ever. I physically flinched at what Barley describes himself seeing as the walk up to the cross is taking place. The attention to detail Marasco provides when describing the whippings Jesus is taking from soldiers, the way Barley winces and whimpers and thinks of him (Jesus) as Kind Man. It all just knocks you right in the heart! Beyond the Crucifixion scene, there is a further twist to the ending that I did not entirely see coming!
FTC Disclaimer: TNZ Fiction Guild kindly provided me with a complimentary copy of this book & requested that I check it out and share my thoughts. The opinions above are entirely my own.
February 14, 2017
When I first heard about this adult novel, I loved the unique premise that the story would be told through the perspective of a dog wandering about first century Judea.
The first several chapters move very slowly with quite a few flashbacks, dreams, and "had been" moments rather than immediately drawing the reader in to current action. Much of the writing could be tightened and more active phrasing employed. (Perhaps this was a voice choice, though.) I also noticed several inconsistencies within the first half of the book (ie: a character calling the time "first century AD" when I'm not sure someone living during the time of Christ would have called it that). Also, at times Barley is portrayed as only understanding certain words, yet at other times, he is shown as understanding full conversations.
The book also is a bit of an Americanized version. For example: one of the characters in the first chapter has a more culturally appropriate name of "Duv," but his wife says it rhymes with "love," which is an English word, of course, and wouldn't have been used in ancient Judea. Though the book is pitched as told in Barley the dog's point of view, readers are tossed between Barley's perspective and several other characters' perspectives throughout the book, which breaks the flow of reading.
Barley himself is a wonderful character. The author does a lovely job of showing the dog's instincts and natural desire to be in a 'family' group and love and protect. Those traits are (in my animal-adoring experience) God-given, which plays well into the themes and plot of this novel. The last third of this book picks up in action, making it a quicker read. Many of the violence scenes are graphic, just as a note to readers who prefer not to read such. Barley (and the readers) only see Jesus in his last few days as he reaches Jerusalem, so you can imagine the intensity of those chapters. The ending, though, is satisfying and offers redemption to the many, many trials Barley endures throughout the book. It winds together Barley's experiences in a way that offers an example of how God works in our lives.
A couple of favorite quotes:
"It was rather that the Teacher had put into beautiful and memorable words what this couple already knew to be true about how to live." - p. 48
"I think despair is so difficult to let go of because it helps us to justify the worst things inside of us." - p. 152
Disclosure: I received a free copy of this book via Litfuse. This is an honest review, and all opinions expressed are my own.
The first several chapters move very slowly with quite a few flashbacks, dreams, and "had been" moments rather than immediately drawing the reader in to current action. Much of the writing could be tightened and more active phrasing employed. (Perhaps this was a voice choice, though.) I also noticed several inconsistencies within the first half of the book (ie: a character calling the time "first century AD" when I'm not sure someone living during the time of Christ would have called it that). Also, at times Barley is portrayed as only understanding certain words, yet at other times, he is shown as understanding full conversations.
The book also is a bit of an Americanized version. For example: one of the characters in the first chapter has a more culturally appropriate name of "Duv," but his wife says it rhymes with "love," which is an English word, of course, and wouldn't have been used in ancient Judea. Though the book is pitched as told in Barley the dog's point of view, readers are tossed between Barley's perspective and several other characters' perspectives throughout the book, which breaks the flow of reading.
Barley himself is a wonderful character. The author does a lovely job of showing the dog's instincts and natural desire to be in a 'family' group and love and protect. Those traits are (in my animal-adoring experience) God-given, which plays well into the themes and plot of this novel. The last third of this book picks up in action, making it a quicker read. Many of the violence scenes are graphic, just as a note to readers who prefer not to read such. Barley (and the readers) only see Jesus in his last few days as he reaches Jerusalem, so you can imagine the intensity of those chapters. The ending, though, is satisfying and offers redemption to the many, many trials Barley endures throughout the book. It winds together Barley's experiences in a way that offers an example of how God works in our lives.
A couple of favorite quotes:
"It was rather that the Teacher had put into beautiful and memorable words what this couple already knew to be true about how to live." - p. 48
"I think despair is so difficult to let go of because it helps us to justify the worst things inside of us." - p. 152
Disclosure: I received a free copy of this book via Litfuse. This is an honest review, and all opinions expressed are my own.
February 6, 2017
MY THOUGHTS
A different look on the well known story of the crucifixion of Jesus. Telling the story is a dog named Barley, just struggling to survive being hungry and without a home. Barley lives around Jerusalem. He lives with a woodcarver and his wife who found Barley wandering the streets and took him in. Barley ends up going his own way even though there are many people who love him. But when a terrible thing happens, he decides to go it alone. On his travels, Barley meets up with a thief and the thief's friends, Samid. They are just trying to make it, to survive, just like Barley. So the group joins together to face what the world gives them. They are also trying hard to understand the teacher that is from Galilee. Meeting the Messiah certainly wasn't what anyone thought would happen. This book puts the well known story in an easy and interesting way to understand, even for children. You not only get a story of love, forgiveness but you see the greatest story ever told in a different way. You get a different outlook on what happens during the journey to Golgotha and what happens along the way. Your heart will at times be very sad and there may be a tear trickle down your cheek. This isn't just a book for people who are religious, it's for anyone who likes a different look at well known stories.It's for people who like stories of forgiveness and love, of struggling to survive and yet facing it with courage and strength, just as the Messiah did.
I received this book from Litfuse Publicity Group and voluntarily decided to review it.
A different look on the well known story of the crucifixion of Jesus. Telling the story is a dog named Barley, just struggling to survive being hungry and without a home. Barley lives around Jerusalem. He lives with a woodcarver and his wife who found Barley wandering the streets and took him in. Barley ends up going his own way even though there are many people who love him. But when a terrible thing happens, he decides to go it alone. On his travels, Barley meets up with a thief and the thief's friends, Samid. They are just trying to make it, to survive, just like Barley. So the group joins together to face what the world gives them. They are also trying hard to understand the teacher that is from Galilee. Meeting the Messiah certainly wasn't what anyone thought would happen. This book puts the well known story in an easy and interesting way to understand, even for children. You not only get a story of love, forgiveness but you see the greatest story ever told in a different way. You get a different outlook on what happens during the journey to Golgotha and what happens along the way. Your heart will at times be very sad and there may be a tear trickle down your cheek. This isn't just a book for people who are religious, it's for anyone who likes a different look at well known stories.It's for people who like stories of forgiveness and love, of struggling to survive and yet facing it with courage and strength, just as the Messiah did.
I received this book from Litfuse Publicity Group and voluntarily decided to review it.
February 7, 2017
This book got off to a bit of a slow start for me but by the time I reached the end, it was very good.
The main character is Barley, a dog trying to survive near Jerusalem at the time of Jesus. He's mistreated and nearly drowned but finds a home with a woodcarver. When Barley loses that master, he travels dangerous roads until he meets a robber. The two have exciting experiences in Jerusalem. Barley's life takes another twist as he sees the greatest event in all of history.
This novel is one about the time of Christ from a very different viewpoint. A very familiar story was portrayed in a way that is new and interesting. Readers are given a view of the society of the day, including how many felt toward stray dogs. It was a violent time and people mistreated animals and humans, so be prepared.
For this reader, the violence was a little hard to take. Some of the actions toward Barley brought up memories from my childhood and the various techniques used on the farm to be rid of unwanted puppies. For most readers, this may not be an issue.
I recommend this novel to those who would like to read of the time of Jesus from a new viewpoint. Be prepared for the portrayal of the violence of that time. Also be prepared for a very touching conclusion to the novel. You just may have to have some tissues nearby.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book through Litfuse. My comments are an independent and honest review.
The main character is Barley, a dog trying to survive near Jerusalem at the time of Jesus. He's mistreated and nearly drowned but finds a home with a woodcarver. When Barley loses that master, he travels dangerous roads until he meets a robber. The two have exciting experiences in Jerusalem. Barley's life takes another twist as he sees the greatest event in all of history.
This novel is one about the time of Christ from a very different viewpoint. A very familiar story was portrayed in a way that is new and interesting. Readers are given a view of the society of the day, including how many felt toward stray dogs. It was a violent time and people mistreated animals and humans, so be prepared.
For this reader, the violence was a little hard to take. Some of the actions toward Barley brought up memories from my childhood and the various techniques used on the farm to be rid of unwanted puppies. For most readers, this may not be an issue.
I recommend this novel to those who would like to read of the time of Jesus from a new viewpoint. Be prepared for the portrayal of the violence of that time. Also be prepared for a very touching conclusion to the novel. You just may have to have some tissues nearby.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book through Litfuse. My comments are an independent and honest review.
February 12, 2017
This book proves who man's best friend is and how animals can do God's work. I loved the ending and it made me cry. In a good way. The beginning however made me cry in a very very sad way. If the beginning was different then this book would have a higher rating from me. I liked that Barley gets to meet Jesus and how the author mentioned the women at his tomb. A great read overall. I am giving this book a 3/5. I was given a copy from Litfuse, all opinions are my own,
March 30, 2018
The only part of this book I can truly say I liked was the end. The little pup coming full circle back to his little boy was a nice touch. (sorry for the spoiler) I almost put this book down after five chapters of very sad canine experiences. This pitiful pup with extremely bad luck is hard to follow as the abuses keep piling up. After 10 chapters I am wondering if the author is attempting to document all the ways to be mean to a dog. Two thirds in to the story we finally see a glimpse of what the title implies by being 'There', meanwhile the little doggie struggles on.
Many will enjoy the novelty of telling a tale from the perspective of the mutt as the author attempts to portray a concept of forgiveness, however that theme is by far overshadowed with heart wrenching animal abuse. If you make it to the end of the book you'll find Discussion Questions, (seriously?) that call for conjecture and speculation without any direct scripture reference - best to just skip this and find another book to read.
If you like the animal POV, this concept was done much better by author Dan Walsh in his Forever Home series.
Many will enjoy the novelty of telling a tale from the perspective of the mutt as the author attempts to portray a concept of forgiveness, however that theme is by far overshadowed with heart wrenching animal abuse. If you make it to the end of the book you'll find Discussion Questions, (seriously?) that call for conjecture and speculation without any direct scripture reference - best to just skip this and find another book to read.
If you like the animal POV, this concept was done much better by author Dan Walsh in his Forever Home series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 230 reviews