I have appreciated Hank Smith's presentations on multiple occasions. Some of his ideas and thoughts have helped my children understand the gospel more deeply and his presentations, particularly in audio, resonate will with just about anybody, not just youth. He is mighty in speaking!
Even in this book, there were some great concepts to consider and apply in my life. However, I felt this book misrepresented happiness, and at times misrepresented attributes or doctrines that lead to happiness. Often, what is shared in this book is consistent with the words of prophets, but sometimes the interpretations of the prophets gave me pause. At other times it seemed to relegate happiness to a feeling that manifests itself in smiles, laughter, and general niceties. As just one example, I have met many contemplative, sober-minded people who don't always show the outward signs of happiness this book seems to advocate, but still find themselves enjoying the peace and tranquility that the gospel brings. While happiness sometimes manifests itself in the outgoing and extroverted ways, it can manifest itself in other ways too.
I also think that God must be happy, and yet he shows traits and does things that this book recommends avoiding. Granted, most of the ideas I struggled with stemmed from not completing or giving the whole view of a particular attribute or doctrine, so it is possible that the author didn't have time in this book to dive a little deeper into some of the premises.
I think this book would have benefited from broadening the discussion on some of the topics by clarifying what a particular attribute isn't. As just one example from this book, (There were quite a few) we got to see from the author's perspective what patience is and looks like, but not exploring what patience isn't left us with a hole that needed to be filled so that patience isn't misrepresented. A one sided view of an attribute may cause some readers to believe that patience is found only in those brave souls who never get snippy. It doesn't wrestle with the reality of godly acts in the scriptures that were actually quite snippy indeed. There are many instances in the scriptures when God, Christ, prophets, captains, and generally good and happy people needed to get snippy to further the Lord's work. Clearly, some "triggers" were meant by God to send us over the edge so that we can defend truth and righteousness. Captain Moroni, Nephi, Jospeh Smith (I really could make quite the list here) all demonstrate what appears to be righteous irritation and annoyance. Captain Moroni with the King-men, Nephi with his brothers and generally his people, Joseph Smith when demanding that the jail keeps stop their filthy talk, etc. Patience is exhibited in each of those stories, and yet those actions are hard to explain as patience if we went solely off the recommendations of this book.
By not talking about the other side of patience, it seems it could lead everyone to believe that happiness is elusive unless we never let triggers get to us or quickly repent when they do. This book also encouraged us to avoid contention at all costs, but not defining that contention is a very specific type of conflict with specific motives. Conflict is unavoidable once you unleash agency into the world. Encouraging people to be peace keepers instead of peace makers can lead to a whole lot of "good people doing nothing" syndrome!
Christ was perfectly happy, even when telling off the pharisees and the Sadducees and letting them really have it. I also don't think he ever apologized for it. And if he someone thinks he did or should, that would mean he shouldn't have done it ... I don't feel comfortable with that line of thinking. Somehow off of Christ's teachings need to fit into our definition of patience and contention. If our definitions don't make room for His behavior, then we don't have a complete understanding of those ideas. It is interesting how often Christ is portrayed as a fairly stoic figure, not nearly the outwardly "happy" guy that seems to be advocated for in this book. Some of that is we only get snippets of his life, but it also shows that a happy life isn't lollipops and cotton candy all the time either! In trying to emulate Him, I think we can add to what has been taught and include aspects to happiness that might not always end in smiles.
By the way, I have nothing against smiles, laughter, or any of those things. There is divinity there too. I just think happiness also encompasses sadness and other godly characteristics. I believe in the God who weeps ... but remains perfectly happy!
I had similar feelings about some of the other chapters in the book, but again, there are some good ideas, they just aren't as well rounded as I would hope. I gave this 3 stars because it was slightly better than okay. I would have liked this book much better with a little balance to its arguments. Happiness to me is the culmination of all godly attributes and traits, even the less warm fuzzy ones ...