What do you think?
Rate this book
Kurland St. Mary Mystery #4
Death Comes to the Fair
It's harvest time in the village of Kurland St. Mary as Lucy and Robert prepare to wed--but a murderer has taken an unseasonable vow of vengeance . . .
As Miss Lucy Harrington, daughter of the village rector, and Major Sir Robert Kurland plan their nuptials, the major is beginning to wonder if he'll ever hear wedding bells. He's seen complex military campaigns that involved less strategy, and he's finding Lucy's meddling family maddening.
When the body of Ezekiel Thurrock, the church verger, is discovered crushed by a gargoyle that has fallen from the bell tower, the wedding is delayed. But the evidence suggests this was no accident, and Lucy wonders if bad blood at the village fair had anything to do with the man's mysterious demise, since there was much bitterness over Ezekiel's prizewinning vegetables.
As Lucy and Robert uncover long-standing village feuds, the town's dark secrets begin to take their toll and the couple soon finds they too are in grave danger . . .
As Miss Lucy Harrington, daughter of the village rector, and Major Sir Robert Kurland plan their nuptials, the major is beginning to wonder if he'll ever hear wedding bells. He's seen complex military campaigns that involved less strategy, and he's finding Lucy's meddling family maddening.
When the body of Ezekiel Thurrock, the church verger, is discovered crushed by a gargoyle that has fallen from the bell tower, the wedding is delayed. But the evidence suggests this was no accident, and Lucy wonders if bad blood at the village fair had anything to do with the man's mysterious demise, since there was much bitterness over Ezekiel's prizewinning vegetables.
As Lucy and Robert uncover long-standing village feuds, the town's dark secrets begin to take their toll and the couple soon finds they too are in grave danger . . .
306 pages, Paperback
First published November 29, 2016
303 people are currently reading
957 people want to read
About the author
Catherine Lloyd
18 books527 followersCatherine Lloyd was born just outside London, England, into a large family of dreamers, artists, and history lovers. She completed her education with a master’s degree in history at the University College of Wales, Aberystwyth, and uses the skills she gained there to research and write her historical mysteries. Catherine currently lives in Hawaii with her husband and youngest daughter..
Please note only the Kurland St. Mary mysteries are written by this Catherine Lloyd, not the romances.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Please note only the Kurland St. Mary mysteries are written by this Catherine Lloyd, not the romances.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 188 reviews
March 16, 2017
Lucy and Robert can't wait to be married but Lucy's relatives insist on taking over the wedding planning to have a grand society wedding in London, something the happy couple doesn't want. Lucy is busy running the harvest fair in the village and trying to ensure no one's feelings are hurt. Robert has other ideas and insists judging based on merit. When the verger wins all the produce prizes, the villagers are upset. Robert thinks they'll get over it but when the verger ends up dead, Lucy isn't so sure. Only she believes Mr. Ezekiel Thurrock was murdered and Robert believes in Lucy. Could it be his brother Mr. Nathaniel Thurrock killed his own brother for some reason? Mr. Nathaniel is a newcomer to the village and wants to delve into the Kurland estate archives. Has he discovered a secret? When Lucy and Robert start their own investigation into the village's past, they uncover long buried secrets and simmering resentment that dates back generations. Is a generation feud enough to kill? Meanwhile, as Lucy and Robert are trying to investigate the murder at all hours and carve out some alone time, her reputation takes a nose dive. Does she care what gossipy villagers say or is this the opportunity she needs to take charge of her life once and for all?
Wow! This was the best book in the series. I never ever even suspected "whodunnit." There are so many twists in this story and not enough suspects. Lucy failed to pick up on one clue she should have paid more attention to but other than that, I was just as shocked as Lucy to discover the identity of the murderer. I loved learning the history of Kurland St. Mary from the English Civil War to the present year of 1817. I learned a bit of British history and saw the English Civil War from a different perspective. I also loved learning about so-called wise women, herbals and charms they used. My only quibble was Lucy's usage of "Romany" for the people her father would probably refer to as Gypsies. I wanted more of the Romany in the story but it's otherwise excellent.
This book also features an adorable romance. I love Lucy and Robert together. He understands she's bossy and nosy but loves her for it. Though at times he's very much a man of his time and station, he loves Lucy and wants her to be happy so he follows her lead. She accepts Robert for who is he. He can be grumpy and sometimes too authoritative, his politics are very radical but that makes him appealing. Robert's political views are very democratic. Maybe they'll end up settling in America some day. I love the way they investigate together and support each other as they go along. Their views of weddings are also similar. It says a lot about Robert that he's willing to marry her even if the situation is not ideal. Lucy supports Robert and keeps quiet about his PTSD fear of horses and his physical limitations. She helps him function normally in a society that REALLY REALLY loves horses.
The major supporting characters include the Thurrock brothers. Mr. Ezekiel is the much loved verger of the village. This seems to be some sort of clergy job but they never explain what he did exactly. He isn't in the story long enough to know if he is an appealing character. His brother, on the other hand, is supremely awful. He is a bully, demeans Lucy and women in general and is generally unpleasant. His arrival in the village sets off a wave of old memories that die hard. Robert's ex-fiance Penelope Chingford is a major supporting character. At first she seems nice but then she goes back to being nasty. I was a little surprised at her plot but not entirely. Her sister barely has anything to do but tag along as chaperone. Lucy's father mostly seems uncaring but deep down he loves Lucy. He just has antiquated ideas about women, meaning, he's a typical man of his time.
The "downstairs" characters appear more often here. Lucy is training Betty to be a ladies' maid and I really liked Betty. She's hardworking, intelligent and loyal to Lucy, unlike Maisey and Mrs. Fielding. Mrs. F is insolent and lazy. She's training Maisie to be just as lazy. I felt bad for Maisie because she doesn't seem very bright and seems afraid of everything.
The village families are important characters. There are two main families who work for Robert. The Mallards are a large village family. The men work on the estate and seem nice. Robert values them not just for their work but also for being intelligent and not bowing and scraping to him. There is also the Pethridge family. They seem a little more ignorant than the Mallards and young Martin doesn't come across as very bright. He doesn't seem to know how to think for himself or hold his tongue when necessary. Finally, there's the Turners. They are two sisters who live on land they own and make a living as "wise women" and midwives. What they do is harmless and makes ignorant people feel better about their worries. They also help safely deliver babies. I'd trust a wise woman over an "educated" doctor of this period any day! Since they're single, independent women, of course they get labeled "witches" and other insulting epithets. The upper class people are afraid of them and men are afraid of the power they have as independent women. I especially liked them since that would be me if I lived back then and lacked money and family connections! They may have been my favorite secondary characters.
This is such an amazing series! The research is top notch and the stories get better as they go along. I'd recommend this series to any Regency fanatic or light mystery fan.
Wow! This was the best book in the series. I never ever even suspected "whodunnit." There are so many twists in this story and not enough suspects. Lucy failed to pick up on one clue she should have paid more attention to but other than that, I was just as shocked as Lucy to discover the identity of the murderer. I loved learning the history of Kurland St. Mary from the English Civil War to the present year of 1817. I learned a bit of British history and saw the English Civil War from a different perspective. I also loved learning about so-called wise women, herbals and charms they used. My only quibble was Lucy's usage of "Romany" for the people her father would probably refer to as Gypsies. I wanted more of the Romany in the story but it's otherwise excellent.
This book also features an adorable romance. I love Lucy and Robert together. He understands she's bossy and nosy but loves her for it. Though at times he's very much a man of his time and station, he loves Lucy and wants her to be happy so he follows her lead. She accepts Robert for who is he. He can be grumpy and sometimes too authoritative, his politics are very radical but that makes him appealing. Robert's political views are very democratic. Maybe they'll end up settling in America some day. I love the way they investigate together and support each other as they go along. Their views of weddings are also similar. It says a lot about Robert that he's willing to marry her even if the situation is not ideal. Lucy supports Robert and keeps quiet about his PTSD fear of horses and his physical limitations. She helps him function normally in a society that REALLY REALLY loves horses.
The major supporting characters include the Thurrock brothers. Mr. Ezekiel is the much loved verger of the village. This seems to be some sort of clergy job but they never explain what he did exactly. He isn't in the story long enough to know if he is an appealing character. His brother, on the other hand, is supremely awful. He is a bully, demeans Lucy and women in general and is generally unpleasant. His arrival in the village sets off a wave of old memories that die hard. Robert's ex-fiance Penelope Chingford is a major supporting character. At first she seems nice but then she goes back to being nasty. I was a little surprised at her plot but not entirely. Her sister barely has anything to do but tag along as chaperone. Lucy's father mostly seems uncaring but deep down he loves Lucy. He just has antiquated ideas about women, meaning, he's a typical man of his time.
The "downstairs" characters appear more often here. Lucy is training Betty to be a ladies' maid and I really liked Betty. She's hardworking, intelligent and loyal to Lucy, unlike Maisey and Mrs. Fielding. Mrs. F is insolent and lazy. She's training Maisie to be just as lazy. I felt bad for Maisie because she doesn't seem very bright and seems afraid of everything.
The village families are important characters. There are two main families who work for Robert. The Mallards are a large village family. The men work on the estate and seem nice. Robert values them not just for their work but also for being intelligent and not bowing and scraping to him. There is also the Pethridge family. They seem a little more ignorant than the Mallards and young Martin doesn't come across as very bright. He doesn't seem to know how to think for himself or hold his tongue when necessary. Finally, there's the Turners. They are two sisters who live on land they own and make a living as "wise women" and midwives. What they do is harmless and makes ignorant people feel better about their worries. They also help safely deliver babies. I'd trust a wise woman over an "educated" doctor of this period any day! Since they're single, independent women, of course they get labeled "witches" and other insulting epithets. The upper class people are afraid of them and men are afraid of the power they have as independent women. I especially liked them since that would be me if I lived back then and lacked money and family connections! They may have been my favorite secondary characters.
This is such an amazing series! The research is top notch and the stories get better as they go along. I'd recommend this series to any Regency fanatic or light mystery fan.
February 9, 2017
Death Comes to the Fair
4 Stars
When the verger of St. Mary's church is found dead after winning several prizes at the local fair, Lucy Harrington and her betrothed, Major Robert Kurland, are not convinced that the death was an accident. As some strange evidence emerges, Lucy and Robert uncover a centuries old vendetta that may have devastating consequences in their own lives.
Another enchanting installment in Lloyd's cozy-historical series. As with the previous books, it is the characterization rather than the mystery that is most appealing.
Much of the charm of this series is the witty banter between Lucy and the Major. This has not changed now that the two are engaged and their repartee is as delightful as ever.
Although the investigation into the verger's death appears trivial at first, it becomes more interesting as the motives for his murder begin to emerge and there are one or two truly suspenseful moments. That said, the ultimate explanation feels somewhat contrived and the identity of the villain is a surprise mainly due to the lack of clues along the way.
All in all, this is a wonderful series overall and this book is entertaining albeit not as good as the previous three. Looking forward to more of Lucy and Robert in the future.
4 Stars
When the verger of St. Mary's church is found dead after winning several prizes at the local fair, Lucy Harrington and her betrothed, Major Robert Kurland, are not convinced that the death was an accident. As some strange evidence emerges, Lucy and Robert uncover a centuries old vendetta that may have devastating consequences in their own lives.
Another enchanting installment in Lloyd's cozy-historical series. As with the previous books, it is the characterization rather than the mystery that is most appealing.
Much of the charm of this series is the witty banter between Lucy and the Major. This has not changed now that the two are engaged and their repartee is as delightful as ever.
Although the investigation into the verger's death appears trivial at first, it becomes more interesting as the motives for his murder begin to emerge and there are one or two truly suspenseful moments. That said, the ultimate explanation feels somewhat contrived and the identity of the villain is a surprise mainly due to the lack of clues along the way.
All in all, this is a wonderful series overall and this book is entertaining albeit not as good as the previous three. Looking forward to more of Lucy and Robert in the future.
January 6, 2022
Two for one in this mystery: as well as the Regency period it is set in, there is also some references to the times of Cromwell and the Commonwealth which added interest for me. This series is really well done.
October 13, 2016
Catherine Lloyd has added yet another outstanding historical mystery novel to the Kurland St. Mary Mystery series. Miss Lucy Harrington and Major Sir Robert Kurland are now engaged and their back and forth banter and sparring have settled somewhat. It isn't that it isn't there, he's just learned to better accommodate her independent spirit and she's learned to accommodate his need to be in charge and to protect her. She's still just as determined as ever, she just now includes him in whatever plans she's concocting -- and he has learned that he might as well support her in those plans because she's going to do them anyway. They make an excellent team working together and respecting each others talents and intelligence. They are growing nicely together.
It is fall in Kurland St. Mary and it seems that everybody - except Lucy and Robert -- are planning their wedding. The family has decided that it has to be a big, splashy, society wedding in London, but Lucy wants her father to marry them in their own small church in Kurland St. Mary -- and Robert just wants to get married SOON!! He's even suggested eloping.
The mystery is an excellent one and keeps you guessing about who the villains are and how they managed to perpetrate it. It is well written, well paced and well thought out. There is even witchcraft -- woot!
During a really bad rainstorm, Lucy ducks into the church bell tower to take refuge and she trips over the lifeless body of the verger Mr. Ezekiel Thurrock. Everyone, except Lucy and Robert, assumes it is an accident. Who could want to harm a nice, sweet man like the verger who has lived quietly in Kurland St. Mary for over thirty years? Then, we get another yet another dead body -- there were LOTS of people who wanted that second one dead.
The investigation into the murders keep Lucy and Robert hopping. Then, of course, there is the tension from trying to sneak out together to investigate when they are supposed to always be chaperoned. They are, of course, caught and though their time spent together was in investigating, her father clamps down on her and makes it really hard to get out to investigate. Lets just say it actually works out better for Lucy in the long run because she ends up getting what she wants.
The last chapter is really sweet
"I requested and received this book from the publisher at no cost to me and volunteered to read it; my review is my honest opinion and given without any influence by the author or publisher."
It is fall in Kurland St. Mary and it seems that everybody - except Lucy and Robert -- are planning their wedding. The family has decided that it has to be a big, splashy, society wedding in London, but Lucy wants her father to marry them in their own small church in Kurland St. Mary -- and Robert just wants to get married SOON!! He's even suggested eloping.
The mystery is an excellent one and keeps you guessing about who the villains are and how they managed to perpetrate it. It is well written, well paced and well thought out. There is even witchcraft -- woot!
During a really bad rainstorm, Lucy ducks into the church bell tower to take refuge and she trips over the lifeless body of the verger Mr. Ezekiel Thurrock. Everyone, except Lucy and Robert, assumes it is an accident. Who could want to harm a nice, sweet man like the verger who has lived quietly in Kurland St. Mary for over thirty years? Then, we get another yet another dead body -- there were LOTS of people who wanted that second one dead.
The investigation into the murders keep Lucy and Robert hopping. Then, of course, there is the tension from trying to sneak out together to investigate when they are supposed to always be chaperoned. They are, of course, caught and though their time spent together was in investigating, her father clamps down on her and makes it really hard to get out to investigate. Lets just say it actually works out better for Lucy in the long run because she ends up getting what she wants.
The last chapter is really sweet
"I requested and received this book from the publisher at no cost to me and volunteered to read it; my review is my honest opinion and given without any influence by the author or publisher."
September 27, 2021
What the heck happened to this charming series? Robert becomes a misogynist jerk. Lucy waivers between being her bold self and a shaking, fearful coward. They continue to call each other by formal names, even after they’re engaged? What's even funnier is that the narration was informal in previous books and is formal in this one.
Right out of the gate, Robert is bashing women for planning weddings. He makes some crack about “female brains” or something. Later, he mentions his superior understanding while thinking about Lucy…who has solved all the mysteries up to this point and run her father’s house without help for something like eight years. Search for the word “female” and “women” in the ebook and see for yourself.
Lucy is tough. She has been abused and threatened, psychologically and physically, in previous books. She has only lost it when witnessing someone kill themselves. Otherwise, she’s pretty much been a rock. So why does she become a coward at one point in this book, repeatedly asking if everything will be okay when trapped in tunnel with Robert. A couple hours later, she’s in the tunnel alone and gets out all by herself. No quivering and crying.
The lack of tutoyer (using informal names) between lifelong friends who are now engaged MAKES NO SENSE. It made sense in the first couple books, but not anymore. I can’t think of ANY historical fiction in which characters maintain this level of formality. It’s ridiculous.
I started skimming because I was so irritated.
Right out of the gate, Robert is bashing women for planning weddings. He makes some crack about “female brains” or something. Later, he mentions his superior understanding while thinking about Lucy…who has solved all the mysteries up to this point and run her father’s house without help for something like eight years. Search for the word “female” and “women” in the ebook and see for yourself.
Lucy is tough. She has been abused and threatened, psychologically and physically, in previous books. She has only lost it when witnessing someone kill themselves. Otherwise, she’s pretty much been a rock. So why does she become a coward at one point in this book, repeatedly asking if everything will be okay when trapped in tunnel with Robert. A couple hours later, she’s in the tunnel alone and gets out all by herself. No quivering and crying.
The lack of tutoyer (using informal names) between lifelong friends who are now engaged MAKES NO SENSE. It made sense in the first couple books, but not anymore. I can’t think of ANY historical fiction in which characters maintain this level of formality. It’s ridiculous.
I started skimming because I was so irritated.
January 10, 2020
This has been my favorite book of the series thus far. The focus on the personal relationships was a welcomed changed. I switched from reading to audio and love the series even more now because of the narrator. Cat Gould is fabulous with all the voices/accents, and this is one I definitely recommend listening to over reading.
November 9, 2020
Setting: Kurland St. Mary, England, October, 1817. Catherine Lioyd’s Death Comes to the Fair has a great first line.
“But the thing is, Andrew, how long does it take a female to organize a simple wedding?” I think men will always be asking that question no matter what the time period may be. Major Sir Robert Kurland of Kurland Hall is engaged to Miss Lucy Harrington, and in this small village it is harvest time. With harvest time comes the Fair where the villagers exhibit their vegetables and fruits. Sir Robert must view the produce and pick five winners which he does not understanding the ‘politics’ of this small village. Sir Robert’s decision causes major rumbling among most of the villagers. Then the church verger is found dead. Did Sir Robert’s decision at the Fair bring old feuds and desire for vengeance to the forefront? Sir Robert and Lucy decide to solve this mystery which puts them in harm’s way. And will Lucy and Sir Robert ever hear wedding bells? As a military man, Sir Robert wonders as the plans for this wedding do not appear as military strategy which he understands! Enjoyed the characters, but the mystery seemed too convoluted. 3.5 stars
“But the thing is, Andrew, how long does it take a female to organize a simple wedding?” I think men will always be asking that question no matter what the time period may be. Major Sir Robert Kurland of Kurland Hall is engaged to Miss Lucy Harrington, and in this small village it is harvest time. With harvest time comes the Fair where the villagers exhibit their vegetables and fruits. Sir Robert must view the produce and pick five winners which he does not understanding the ‘politics’ of this small village. Sir Robert’s decision causes major rumbling among most of the villagers. Then the church verger is found dead. Did Sir Robert’s decision at the Fair bring old feuds and desire for vengeance to the forefront? Sir Robert and Lucy decide to solve this mystery which puts them in harm’s way. And will Lucy and Sir Robert ever hear wedding bells? As a military man, Sir Robert wonders as the plans for this wedding do not appear as military strategy which he understands! Enjoyed the characters, but the mystery seemed too convoluted. 3.5 stars
October 10, 2016
The Kurland St. Mary Mystery series is charming and traditional, and I thought the previous books were quite quaint. Death Comes to the Fair is the fourth outing in the series, and unlike the previous three titles, I thought this latest lost some magic.
At the centre of this series are Miss Lucy Harrington and Major Sir Robert Kurland, who are now engaged to be married. Part of the charm in the previous books was the sparring between these two characters. Lucy and Robert were often at loggerheads; however, after being caught in a compromising position in the previous book. the two are forced to marry. To be clear, neither Lucy or Robert are upset about being married, and perhaps this lack of tension between these two characters is what stole some of the momentum while I was reading. For me, the lack of tension meant a loss of interest on my part. Characters are what makes or breaks a book for me, and in this case, I felt disappointed with the lack of character development in our principle players.
Unfortunately, the mystery did not compensate for the lackluster showing of the main characters. The mystery was simple, quaint and a tad contrived. If you like your mysteries cozy the formulaic approach will appeal, but those looking for a meatier series should look elsewhere.
Having enjoyed the previous books in the series, I will certainly check out the next book, but I will need some change to continue to be a follower of the series. I hold on to the hope that marriage can bring some life back into these characters.
At the centre of this series are Miss Lucy Harrington and Major Sir Robert Kurland, who are now engaged to be married. Part of the charm in the previous books was the sparring between these two characters. Lucy and Robert were often at loggerheads; however, after being caught in a compromising position in the previous book. the two are forced to marry. To be clear, neither Lucy or Robert are upset about being married, and perhaps this lack of tension between these two characters is what stole some of the momentum while I was reading. For me, the lack of tension meant a loss of interest on my part. Characters are what makes or breaks a book for me, and in this case, I felt disappointed with the lack of character development in our principle players.
Unfortunately, the mystery did not compensate for the lackluster showing of the main characters. The mystery was simple, quaint and a tad contrived. If you like your mysteries cozy the formulaic approach will appeal, but those looking for a meatier series should look elsewhere.
Having enjoyed the previous books in the series, I will certainly check out the next book, but I will need some change to continue to be a follower of the series. I hold on to the hope that marriage can bring some life back into these characters.
September 19, 2016
Set in the village of Kurland St. Mary in 1817, this is the fourth book in the series finds murder hindering the upcoming nuptials of Major Kurland and Lucy Harrington. Authentic to the period, the pace is reminiscence of the slower horse and buggy days. Major Kurland thinks planning for their wedding is taking forever and wants to elope. Lucy is concerned about the ramification on her family if they did elope. The major will not let town gossip, feuds, ruined reputations, and two murders spoil their wedding plan. There are enjoyable moments such as local reactions to the winners of best harvest vegetables. It was a very pleasant read.
July 5, 2017
This is the first book in the Kurland St. Mary Mystery series I have read. I did not have a problem following the story, but I believe that the development of the characters that I missed in the prior books might have made this one more interesting to me. I did not really get to know the characters in this book, it seemed like they were supposed to be old friends that I really didn't know well. Not the author's fault, just a warning if you have not read the others in the series.
Miss Lucy Harrington is betrothed to Sir Major Robert Kurland and they are the main characters in the story. Lucy is the vicar's's daughter and has to be careful not to be seen with her betrothed without a chaperone. Unfortunately, she is also a very strong woman and puts herself into that situation often during the story, causing some gossip. When the verger (an official in a church who acts as a caretaker and attendant), Ezekeal Thurrock, of St. Mary's church is found dead after winning several prizes at the local fair, Lucy and Sir Robert become convinced that the death was not an accident. They begin to uncover evidence that the Thurrock family has some skeletons in their closet as well as many enemies. As some strange occurences come to light and more evidence emerges, Lucy and Robert uncover a centuries old vendetta that may have caused the deaths in present day.
This series is very character driven. The dialogue and the relationship between Lucy and Robert carry much of the book. The secondary characters such as Lucy's father, the staff as well as the sisters acting as chaperones also add to the story and the background. When the verger was first found dead, the story was a bit slow, but as the investigation moved forward, I found myself much more vested in what was going to happen. I did not figure out who the murderer was as was a bit perturbed at one point as there was mention of the characters but not many clues or motivation given, but as the story unfolded, it cleared up the issues, but not to my satisfaction. I am going to go back and read the previous books and see how I feel then. A good read for cozy mystery lovers with a Victorian setting. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book via Netgalley.
Miss Lucy Harrington is betrothed to Sir Major Robert Kurland and they are the main characters in the story. Lucy is the vicar's's daughter and has to be careful not to be seen with her betrothed without a chaperone. Unfortunately, she is also a very strong woman and puts herself into that situation often during the story, causing some gossip. When the verger (an official in a church who acts as a caretaker and attendant), Ezekeal Thurrock, of St. Mary's church is found dead after winning several prizes at the local fair, Lucy and Sir Robert become convinced that the death was not an accident. They begin to uncover evidence that the Thurrock family has some skeletons in their closet as well as many enemies. As some strange occurences come to light and more evidence emerges, Lucy and Robert uncover a centuries old vendetta that may have caused the deaths in present day.
This series is very character driven. The dialogue and the relationship between Lucy and Robert carry much of the book. The secondary characters such as Lucy's father, the staff as well as the sisters acting as chaperones also add to the story and the background. When the verger was first found dead, the story was a bit slow, but as the investigation moved forward, I found myself much more vested in what was going to happen. I did not figure out who the murderer was as was a bit perturbed at one point as there was mention of the characters but not many clues or motivation given, but as the story unfolded, it cleared up the issues, but not to my satisfaction. I am going to go back and read the previous books and see how I feel then. A good read for cozy mystery lovers with a Victorian setting. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book via Netgalley.
May 5, 2018
I was delighted to read the 4th book in Kurland St. Mary Mystery. The setting is charming and the mystery was well planned and engaging! I always enjoy reading about Jane and the other characters in this quaint English village and the discussion of her upcoming wedding to Major Kurland was exciting! There was a twist at the end that I didn't see coming and it made for a very satisfying conclusion! I am hoping to read more books in this series!
February 5, 2024
I absolutely ADORE this series! The mystery, the romance, the relationships...all pitch perfect. I especially like the delving into the familial past with this one. This one worked some potential magic into the mix which I thought was interesting. Catherine Lloyd has the tone and writing perfect for the time period and for the genre. I'm trying to space these out so I don't read them all at once.
January 15, 2017
I had wondered whether Death Comes to the Fair would hold up to my overly high expectations, following as it did on the heels of the virtually perfect Death Comes to Kurland Hall, but for the most part it succeeded in being a satisfying sequel. Robert and Lucy were delightful as always, and the mystery took an interesting turn into the dark, long-buried past of Kurland St. Mary and its oldest inhabitants.
It is ironic that Robert and Lucy should find it harder to spend time alone together after they are finally betrothed, particularly since they seemed to have no trouble doing so before. But now that they’re in love and their constant arguments are a thing of the past (at least for now), they face the obstacle of having to be quite creative in dodging Lucy’s chaperones and avoiding the wrath of the rector so that they could go sleuthing together. The result is some fairly amusing moments of frustration and exasperation from Robert, and the sweetness of their romantic interactions when they do manage to carve out some time alone made up for their infrequency.
More than ever, Robert and Lucy prove that they’re the perfect team, and I enjoyed seeing them take what they’ve learnt from each other and put it into action – Robert is increasingly learning to trust Lucy’s judgment, diplomacy and bravery implicitly, and Lucy draws strength from the Major’s clear head in times of danger and his way of standing his ground. Gone is the pessimistic and unsociable Robert, and the Lucy who was once run roughshod by her selfish father, siblings and Mrs. Fielding in the first book. Their character and relationship development has been so satisfying to watch.
Those who have found the identities of the murderers in the previous three books a little too easy to guess might be pleased by how the murder mystery plays out in this story. What begins as a seemingly simple case of a murder committed over petty village rivalries is gradually revealed to have very deep roots that stretch two centuries back into the history of Kurland St. Mary, with a touch of village superstition for good measure. Fascinating as it was, however, readers were given little chance to know or care about the people involved, and thus the resolution of the case felt rather convoluted, rushed and anti-climatic. I have little fondness for the criminal, and would have loved to have been given a chance to experience the rush of triumph that would have come from seeing them brought to justice.
I have absolutely no complaints about the note on which the book finished, however – so satisfying! I can’t wait for more of Robert and Lucy’s adventures and to see how their relationship continues to develop; hopefully the author will have a sequel soon, because my life already feels empty without Kurland St. Mary.
It is ironic that Robert and Lucy should find it harder to spend time alone together after they are finally betrothed, particularly since they seemed to have no trouble doing so before. But now that they’re in love and their constant arguments are a thing of the past (at least for now), they face the obstacle of having to be quite creative in dodging Lucy’s chaperones and avoiding the wrath of the rector so that they could go sleuthing together. The result is some fairly amusing moments of frustration and exasperation from Robert, and the sweetness of their romantic interactions when they do manage to carve out some time alone made up for their infrequency.
More than ever, Robert and Lucy prove that they’re the perfect team, and I enjoyed seeing them take what they’ve learnt from each other and put it into action – Robert is increasingly learning to trust Lucy’s judgment, diplomacy and bravery implicitly, and Lucy draws strength from the Major’s clear head in times of danger and his way of standing his ground. Gone is the pessimistic and unsociable Robert, and the Lucy who was once run roughshod by her selfish father, siblings and Mrs. Fielding in the first book. Their character and relationship development has been so satisfying to watch.
Those who have found the identities of the murderers in the previous three books a little too easy to guess might be pleased by how the murder mystery plays out in this story. What begins as a seemingly simple case of a murder committed over petty village rivalries is gradually revealed to have very deep roots that stretch two centuries back into the history of Kurland St. Mary, with a touch of village superstition for good measure. Fascinating as it was, however, readers were given little chance to know or care about the people involved, and thus the resolution of the case felt rather convoluted, rushed and anti-climatic. I have little fondness for the criminal, and would have loved to have been given a chance to experience the rush of triumph that would have come from seeing them brought to justice.
I have absolutely no complaints about the note on which the book finished, however – so satisfying! I can’t wait for more of Robert and Lucy’s adventures and to see how their relationship continues to develop; hopefully the author will have a sequel soon, because my life already feels empty without Kurland St. Mary.
November 21, 2016
See this and all of my reviews at Mystereity Reviews
I've enjoyed this historical mystery series from the start, and each book is better than the last. In Death Comes to the Fair, Robert is impatiently awaiting his wedding to Miss Lucy. Acting as a judge at the harvest fair's vegetable contest, Robert awards most of the prizes to Ezekial Thurrock, angering many villagers. When Thurrock is later found dead, Lucy begins to suspect that his death wasn't an accident. Was he killed by an angry villager? Or is his death connected to a decades old feud?
The suspenseful plot was enjoyable and tricky; there's a whole village of suspects, including the victim's brother, whose claims against the Kurland land and the story behind it were a great subplot. The plot unwound steadily up to an action packed ending, where Lucy proves herself a resourceful and stubborn woman, and I look forward to watching how Robert and Lucy spar once married - and their future investigations!
This book can be read as a standalone, or as an entry into the series, but I definitely recommend starting from the beginning, as there are some plot threads that run through the books.
Overall, Death Comes to the Fair is an excellent historical mystery that will appeal to fans of regency era stories.
Thank you to Kensington Books and Netgalley for providing an advance copy of the book in return for my honest review
I've enjoyed this historical mystery series from the start, and each book is better than the last. In Death Comes to the Fair, Robert is impatiently awaiting his wedding to Miss Lucy. Acting as a judge at the harvest fair's vegetable contest, Robert awards most of the prizes to Ezekial Thurrock, angering many villagers. When Thurrock is later found dead, Lucy begins to suspect that his death wasn't an accident. Was he killed by an angry villager? Or is his death connected to a decades old feud?
The suspenseful plot was enjoyable and tricky; there's a whole village of suspects, including the victim's brother, whose claims against the Kurland land and the story behind it were a great subplot. The plot unwound steadily up to an action packed ending, where Lucy proves herself a resourceful and stubborn woman, and I look forward to watching how Robert and Lucy spar once married - and their future investigations!
This book can be read as a standalone, or as an entry into the series, but I definitely recommend starting from the beginning, as there are some plot threads that run through the books.
Overall, Death Comes to the Fair is an excellent historical mystery that will appeal to fans of regency era stories.
Thank you to Kensington Books and Netgalley for providing an advance copy of the book in return for my honest review
March 7, 2017
The heroic Major Sir Robert Kurland and the indefatigable Lucy Harrington are readying for their long awaited nuptials when the deacon is murdered. A link to the Kurland estate prompts Robert and Lucy to start investigating. And when another murder follows the first, the pressure is on for the pair to find the killer.
Lloyd has created a regency mystery series whose characters are delightful and the mysteries gentle. Robert and Lucy will entice readers to look for every installment.
Lloyd has created a regency mystery series whose characters are delightful and the mysteries gentle. Robert and Lucy will entice readers to look for every installment.
December 22, 2016
DNF, two stars as in "ok" on my personal scale. The digital loan on this book expired before I had a chance to finish it and I may try to check it out again, but had honestly lost interest at the halfway point and hadn't had time to read it for a few days - and didn't really care! Not a good sign. The first two books in this series were fun but the last two have been much slower-going for me.
January 31, 2020
Death Comes to the Fair by Catherine Lloyd is the fourth book in the Kurland St. Mary series and was an engaging afternoon read. The smoothly paced plot that centered around the history of both Kurland St. Mary and Kurland St. Anne. The characters are now well developed and I do enjoy Sir Robert and Lucy's verbal sparring as they try to resolve the mysteries.
January 22, 2019
I'm lucky enough to have won a copy on Facebook. This is the best one so far - more meat to the story.
June 9, 2017
Mystery, romance and 18th Century England. What more could we want? This fourth addition to the Kurland St. Mary Mystery series is another delightful charmer and well worth waiting for.
This book could be a stand-alone, but trust me, you will want to read the earlier three offerings. We’ve followed the romance and adventures of Miss Lucy Harrington and Major Sir Robert Kurland with baited breaths. Recently engaged, will they ever marry? Social conventions keep intervening, and of course, there’s those murders. The church berger has been killed and Lucy and Sir Robert team up to again unravel the mystery.
The story is rich in historical details and atmosphere. The startling division of classes beggars our American sense of equality and fairness and is fascinating. The limits imposed on women of all ranks is distressing, not that Lucy lets them get in the way of what she actually wants. The mystery is complex and satisfying. You might think you have it figured out, but probably not. Which makes it all the more fun to read to my mind.
This series, set in the early 1800s is perfect for we smart readers: there is more than a mystery to be solved. Rather this is a complex blend of excellent writing, engaging characters and a terrific setting. Love this series!
This book could be a stand-alone, but trust me, you will want to read the earlier three offerings. We’ve followed the romance and adventures of Miss Lucy Harrington and Major Sir Robert Kurland with baited breaths. Recently engaged, will they ever marry? Social conventions keep intervening, and of course, there’s those murders. The church berger has been killed and Lucy and Sir Robert team up to again unravel the mystery.
The story is rich in historical details and atmosphere. The startling division of classes beggars our American sense of equality and fairness and is fascinating. The limits imposed on women of all ranks is distressing, not that Lucy lets them get in the way of what she actually wants. The mystery is complex and satisfying. You might think you have it figured out, but probably not. Which makes it all the more fun to read to my mind.
This series, set in the early 1800s is perfect for we smart readers: there is more than a mystery to be solved. Rather this is a complex blend of excellent writing, engaging characters and a terrific setting. Love this series!
March 19, 2024
Lucy Harrington once again proves to be an exceptional sleuth in the early 1800s. Lucy is awaiting her wedding day to Sir Robert Kurland when trouble comes to town. It seems that the church vergers' brother has come to stir the pot regarding the possibility that some of the Kurland land is actually owned by his family, the Thurrocks. It just so happens that the piece of land in question may also be a hiding spot of a great treasure from the 1600s.
Trouble begins when the church verger, Ezekial Thurrock is found dead. Who would want him dead and what will someone do to right a wrong from a few hundred years ago.
Lucy must navigate around the strict rules for ladies of that time period, and along with her betrothed, unearth what is really going on in Kurland St. Mary.
I always enjoy the stories in this series and was not disappointed with this latest read. I am looking forward to the next book in this series.
Trouble begins when the church verger, Ezekial Thurrock is found dead. Who would want him dead and what will someone do to right a wrong from a few hundred years ago.
Lucy must navigate around the strict rules for ladies of that time period, and along with her betrothed, unearth what is really going on in Kurland St. Mary.
I always enjoy the stories in this series and was not disappointed with this latest read. I am looking forward to the next book in this series.
November 24, 2020
There was a weird drunk guy working at the fair who called the heroine Little One. It was creepy!
September 24, 2024
Really good cozy mystery with delightful characters.
November 13, 2021
Nice light mystery, read very competently and with some touches of humor.
November 19, 2016
Death Comes to the Fair is the fourth book in the Kurland St. Mary Mystery series. The story is set in the small village of Kurland St. Mary in England, 1817. Major Sir Robert Kurland is engaged to Miss Lucy Harrington, the daughter of the local Rector. After the judging at the local fair awards most of the prizes to Ezekiel Thurrock's vegetables, he is found dead in the local church where he is the verger (an official in a church who acts as a caretaker and attendant). A stone gargoyle has fallen on his head, and although first declared an accident, it soon becomes clear that he was murdered.
Lucy and Sir Robert become involved in solving the mystery. Things become complicated when Ezekiel's brother, Nathaniel begins investigating old records, trying to determine land ownership in the area. His delving into old events causes problems with the other land owners in the area. There are concerns about witchcraft and rumors of buried treasure.
The story moves along at a pretty slow pace. I don't know if this is common for other Regency books, because this is not a genre I usually read. The action doesn't really pick up until the last 1/4 of the book. At that point, it becomes pretty exciting. There are a lot of characters to keep track of, and a lot of interbreeding between the local families. It felt like everyone was related to everyone else.
I didn't feel like I was missing much by not reading the first three books. I think they would be important for the back story between Robert and Lucy, to see how they progressed from friends to fiances, but as far as the central mystery goes, not necessary.
This book was ok, but didn't really resonate with me. The pacing was too slow for my liking. I give this 3 out of 5 stars.
I received a ARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Lucy and Sir Robert become involved in solving the mystery. Things become complicated when Ezekiel's brother, Nathaniel begins investigating old records, trying to determine land ownership in the area. His delving into old events causes problems with the other land owners in the area. There are concerns about witchcraft and rumors of buried treasure.
The story moves along at a pretty slow pace. I don't know if this is common for other Regency books, because this is not a genre I usually read. The action doesn't really pick up until the last 1/4 of the book. At that point, it becomes pretty exciting. There are a lot of characters to keep track of, and a lot of interbreeding between the local families. It felt like everyone was related to everyone else.
I didn't feel like I was missing much by not reading the first three books. I think they would be important for the back story between Robert and Lucy, to see how they progressed from friends to fiances, but as far as the central mystery goes, not necessary.
This book was ok, but didn't really resonate with me. The pacing was too slow for my liking. I give this 3 out of 5 stars.
I received a ARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
July 31, 2017
Murder Comes to the Fair is the fourth book in the Kurland St. Mary Mystery Series by Catherine Lloyd. The story revolves around Lucy Harrington, the daughter of the rector, and her betrothed, the newly made baronet, Sir Robert Kurland. The trouble starts when Sir Robert is asked to judge the vegetables entered into the county fair. Against Lucy’s advice, he gives the majority of the prizes to Ezekiel Thurrock after insisting they are the best. Shortly after, Lucy finds Ezekiel dead. It appears that a gargoyle has fallen from the bell towel during a storm and struck Ezekiel. On the surface it appears to be a case of in the wrong place at the wrong time. Yet, something is not right and Lucy and Sir Robert suspect the cause of death is more than a falling gargoyle.
Part of Sir Robert’s duty as the baronet was to act as the constable. With Lucy’s help they set out to discover what really happened. At first, they contemplate that the killer was jealous over Ezekiel’s’ prize vegetables. As they slowly unravel the mystery, they discover that jealously is only the tip of the iceberg in a feud that has been going on long before their births. The secrets they uncover put their very lives in danger.
The story moves along rather nicely and has lots of twists. The characters are very likable and I loved that Lucy has such a strong personality. I suspect that Sir Robert will have his hands full upon their marriage. All in all, it was very entertaining and I look forward to reading the other books in the series.
I received a copy of this book, via NetGalley, for my honest review.
Part of Sir Robert’s duty as the baronet was to act as the constable. With Lucy’s help they set out to discover what really happened. At first, they contemplate that the killer was jealous over Ezekiel’s’ prize vegetables. As they slowly unravel the mystery, they discover that jealously is only the tip of the iceberg in a feud that has been going on long before their births. The secrets they uncover put their very lives in danger.
The story moves along rather nicely and has lots of twists. The characters are very likable and I loved that Lucy has such a strong personality. I suspect that Sir Robert will have his hands full upon their marriage. All in all, it was very entertaining and I look forward to reading the other books in the series.
I received a copy of this book, via NetGalley, for my honest review.
November 27, 2016
It is autumn in Kurland St. Mary and the plans for the nuptials of Miss Lucy Harrington, the vicar's daughter, and Major Robert Kurland are proceeding, but not nearly quickly enough for the Major. As Lucy is the niece of an Earl, her highly born London family wants everything to be just so. Both Robert and Lucy want a quiet village wedding but Lucy doesn't want to offend the family. The trouble in the village starts when Robert is called upon to judge the vegetable competition. Lucy warns him that it is a highly political competition, one in which each contestant should be rewarded in some way or peace in the village will be destroyed. Stubbornly, Robert insists on judging solely on merit. The result is that the church verger, Ezekial Thurrock, wins the bulk of the prizes. Sentiment turns ugly quickly but no one knows how ugly until Lucy finds Thurrock dead in the church, his head crushed by a stone gargoyle. His death is ruled an accident, but Lucy is not so sure. As she and Robert investigate, they turn up dark secrets that Lucy is unaware of even though she has lived in Kurland St. Mary all her life. More murder and suggestions of witchcraft place Lucy and Robert in real danger.
Death Comes to the Fair is the fourth book in this highly enjoyable cozy mystery series. I recommend it for its excellent plotting and period setting. The characters have been well developed throughout. I particularly enjoy the fact that Robert is finally learning to listen to Lucy and granting her freedom that the average man of the period would not. Thanks to Kensington Books and NetGalley for an advance digital copy in return for an honest review.
RATING- 3.5 Stars rounded up to 4
Death Comes to the Fair is the fourth book in this highly enjoyable cozy mystery series. I recommend it for its excellent plotting and period setting. The characters have been well developed throughout. I particularly enjoy the fact that Robert is finally learning to listen to Lucy and granting her freedom that the average man of the period would not. Thanks to Kensington Books and NetGalley for an advance digital copy in return for an honest review.
RATING- 3.5 Stars rounded up to 4
August 24, 2016
* I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review *
It is Autumn and harvest has begun in Kurland St. Mary. Miss Lucy Harrington has been trying to finalize her marriage to Major Sir Kurland, but her relatives are making every detail a strenuous affair. When a bad storm churns up, Lucy takes refuge in the church bell tower, only to discover the dead body of the verger Mr. Ezekiel Thurrock. While others assume it was an accident, Lucy and Sir Robert both sense something wicked has come calling.
This is the 4th book in the Kurland St. Mary Mystery Series and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Lucy is such a likable character. She is constantly getting in trouble for not behaving as an unmarried woman should, but she really doesn't care. Sir Robert, her betrothed is with her 100% of the time, not giving a fig about propriety. He even hopes that their unchaperoned outings might bring their wedding date closer.
The mystery is very good, with a lot of twists and turns. It is amazing though how little Lucy knew about some of her neighbors. It was expected of Sir Robert, but Lucy, being the rector's daughter and an active member in the community, should have known a little more about family connections and past histories. In small towns nothing stays secret and yet she knew nothing, although some of it was common knowledge. Putting that aside, I enjoyed the conclusion of the book, although I wish to know what happened to the evil doers. The last chapter is a happy one and makes me ready to read the next installment.
It is Autumn and harvest has begun in Kurland St. Mary. Miss Lucy Harrington has been trying to finalize her marriage to Major Sir Kurland, but her relatives are making every detail a strenuous affair. When a bad storm churns up, Lucy takes refuge in the church bell tower, only to discover the dead body of the verger Mr. Ezekiel Thurrock. While others assume it was an accident, Lucy and Sir Robert both sense something wicked has come calling.
This is the 4th book in the Kurland St. Mary Mystery Series and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Lucy is such a likable character. She is constantly getting in trouble for not behaving as an unmarried woman should, but she really doesn't care. Sir Robert, her betrothed is with her 100% of the time, not giving a fig about propriety. He even hopes that their unchaperoned outings might bring their wedding date closer.
The mystery is very good, with a lot of twists and turns. It is amazing though how little Lucy knew about some of her neighbors. It was expected of Sir Robert, but Lucy, being the rector's daughter and an active member in the community, should have known a little more about family connections and past histories. In small towns nothing stays secret and yet she knew nothing, although some of it was common knowledge. Putting that aside, I enjoyed the conclusion of the book, although I wish to know what happened to the evil doers. The last chapter is a happy one and makes me ready to read the next installment.
December 19, 2016
I'm not sure if this book is the same length as the others, but it looked shorter and felt longer. Kurland is an ass to Lucy at the beginning, brushing off her concerns and her insights. One would think after solving three murders with her help he would put more stock in her opinions. If I remember correctly, she's been right about things before. How I'm supposed to buy these two as married is beyond me. They have history, and I guess they like each other just fine, but they don't really feel like they'll have a successful marriage. Beyond the occasional lustful comment from Kurland, and the fact that we really don't see them spend any time together beyond investigating, they don't seem to have much of a rapport.
The mystery this time is convoluted and messy and honestly not that interesting. We have a two hundred year old feud being the cause for modern day murders, and we don't have enough information until the end. Neither do Kurland and Lucy, making it an infodump reveal at the end that does nothing to improve my opinion of this mess. The mystery really doesn't grow. The first two thirds are boring then things speed up but not enough to make this interesting.
I'll give the next one a chance, but I've already rated this one and the last one two stars, so if the fifth one's a mess too, I'm giving up.
The mystery this time is convoluted and messy and honestly not that interesting. We have a two hundred year old feud being the cause for modern day murders, and we don't have enough information until the end. Neither do Kurland and Lucy, making it an infodump reveal at the end that does nothing to improve my opinion of this mess. The mystery really doesn't grow. The first two thirds are boring then things speed up but not enough to make this interesting.
I'll give the next one a chance, but I've already rated this one and the last one two stars, so if the fifth one's a mess too, I'm giving up.
October 13, 2016
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for my review.
Historical novels are not my usual choice of reading material, but I found this book quite entertaining. It seemed that it took a little while to really get going, but once things started happening, the action was nonstop.
I have not read the earlier books in the series, and thus did not know the characters and their relationships and backstory as well as one might who has read the earlier books. But overall I would say that it is not necessary to have read the previous books to understand what is happening in this one.
The revelation of the killer and the motive came as surprises to me, which I am sure was the author's intention. However, I am never very good at guessing who the killer is. Others' mileage may vary, of course.
Historical novels are not my usual choice of reading material, but I found this book quite entertaining. It seemed that it took a little while to really get going, but once things started happening, the action was nonstop.
I have not read the earlier books in the series, and thus did not know the characters and their relationships and backstory as well as one might who has read the earlier books. But overall I would say that it is not necessary to have read the previous books to understand what is happening in this one.
The revelation of the killer and the motive came as surprises to me, which I am sure was the author's intention. However, I am never very good at guessing who the killer is. Others' mileage may vary, of course.
November 21, 2016
A relaxing read that will take you on a historical journey back to an English village. Lucy Harrington and Sir Robert Midland are attending the annual fair. as they wait for their society wedding in London. Lucy points out to that Robert needs to judge the exhibits. Against his better judgement he does causing an uproar in the village. Ezekiel Thurrock, the village verger won most the prizes. When his body is found Lucy and Robert explore and find hatred, greed, missing historical records, family loyalty, and gypsies. As they search gossip begins about them. Lucy's father hears the tittle-rattle and demands Sir Robert marry Lucy as soon as the band are read. I recommend this book and series
Disclosure: I received a free copy from Kensington Books for an honest review. I would
Disclosure: I received a free copy from Kensington Books for an honest review. I would
Displaying 1 - 30 of 188 reviews