So lately I haven't been reading as much because I've been overhauling my diet and exercising as well (I feel great but I also miss my books). When I read a quick blurb about this book, I thought, Oh good, I can still research food but in a more enjoyable book format. I don't know much about Judy Collins, but I discovered she's a lovely writer. If anything, I want more from her. So often, the chapters focused on her would give an autobiographical snapshot of what was going on career-wise, some of her personal life too, she would constantly mention her food and alcohol addictions, then she would end the chapter with something like, "But I still hadn't conquered my addiction." Then we'd jump into a chapter about the history of dieting (from Lord Byron, who is fascinating and I've recently read more about in another book I'll have to review, to Atkins to the creator of Weight Watchers to the amazing Linus Pauling, etc.), which I found interesting and broke up Collins's story nicely. Then boom-bam at the very end of the book, she conquered her alcohol addiction and in the next chapter, conquered her food addictions. This isn't to say Collins didn't struggle or work hard, but she just didn't really go into it to the detail that I would have liked.
I do agree with Collins that you can be addicted to food. I hadn't really thought about it seriously; I used to joke that I was addicted to chocolate, but I think I really was :/ Once you take that out from your life, refrigerator, and pantry, your cravings, body, and health change. I will say, though, that reading what she does eat, yikes, I can't do it. I considered it, and even felt a bit bad about myself that I couldn't restrict myself as much as she does, then I remembered we all have to do what's right for us. Bravo to Collins for doing what works for her, though, and realizing what she has to do in order to control her addictions.
In case you're wondering: Collins has taken out from her diet: corn, wheat, grains, sugar, and processed food, which I'm fine with, though I cheat on the sugar with honey. But she only eats three meals a day, brings digital scales with her everywhere, and her meals sound repetitive and boring to me. You can eat a "clean" diet without having it be boring :)