I really wanted to love Love That Lasts.
Granted I'm not that familiar with Jeff and Alyssa Bethke. They are a young couple who have become increasingly well-known and popular in Christian circles in the last five years since Jeff's spoken word poem "Why I Hate Religion, But Love Jesus" went viral; they now live in Maui with their two young children, and create YouTube videos, host a podcast about relationships and faith, and have individually written several books. But, while I have not read their previous books or watched many of their YouTube videos, my initial impression (based on their videos) is that the Bethkes are a winsome couple who are not only lighthearted, joyful, and fun-loving but also thoughtful and intentional (like "throwing a party" to celebrate Sabbath as a way to instruct their children and to rest and re-fill as a family every week). They are genuinely likable, the kind of people who I feel like I'm on a first-name basis with even though I've never met them, and they discuss important topics with candor and maturity; plus, their media overall is top notch.
When I heard Jeff and Alyssa were publishing a book about love, relationships, and marriage, I was eager to read what they had to write. They mention in an interview that they feel there's a gap in marriage books written by older couples that don't necessarily speak to the issues in culture and society that young people are facing today, which I thought was a valid point (though I tend to think problems within marriage and relationships are ultimately deeper than surface-level cultural trends, yet I also recognize this world is more perverted than ever before); and furthermore, while I recognize the value of learning from the wisdom of older men and women specifically (Titus 2), it is similarly Biblical to exhort and learn from each other regardless of age ("Iron sharpens iron"!). And so I hoped Love That Lasts would be Jeff and Alyssa sharing truths and insights that are both Biblically based and culturally relevant, from a "young married" Millennial perspective.
Love That Lasts was, overall, what I anticipated. It is timely and real, discussing the challenges and evils in our world, from social media and a perverted definition of "love" to the pervasiveness and devastating effects of of p*rn, objectification, abuse, and divorce. In the midst of this, Jeff and Alyssa grew up with polar-opposite personal backgrounds and life experiences, as they write in the Introduction: "Alyssa had never even held a guy’s hand until she held mine when we dated in our twenties. I, on the other hand, lived with the “if it felt good, then do it” motto from the time I entered high school." Their story is the backbone of the book as they each share their unique experiences, personal struggles, and how they met, started dating and fell in love, broke up, got back together, and (finally) married. Jeff and Alyssa are characteristically authentic and vulnerable, and they share many nuggets of truth and wisdom throughout the pages, including what "Real Love" is, the importance of mentors, accountability, being complete in Christ, identity, intentionality, being friends first in a dating relationship, commitment, the purpose of marriage to make us holy (not happy), and much more.
Yet, while Jeff and Alyssa do well to acknowledge the issues and to address many from a Biblical perspective, Love That Lasts fell short for me. First, it lacks a clear, solid Biblical foundation. It is written from a Biblical perspective, yes, but it doesn't seem to start with Scripture as definitive, objective Truth about love, relationships, and marriage, and instead often mingles blanket statements about God with personal interpretations and experiences that can be a bit muddy, misleading, and a few times contrary to the Bible from my understanding. (For example, there are pragmatic, "you were made for more" rationales for not sleeping around, rather than explaining the Bible's clear position on it, i.e., Heb. 13:4, etc.) Second, Love That Lasts lacks a clear premise. While I agree with Jeff and Alyssa that "religious purity culture" has sometimes been legalistically upheld and skewed (as they posit throughout the book, and with the "religious" label), nevertheless purity and abstinence are Biblical, and in my opinion to suggest there's "a third and better way" unfairly casts the purity culture and purity by association in a negative light, as if having a warped perception from being told "sex is bad" all your life is wrong in the same sense as, in "the world's way", having sex before marriage. (I found myself getting defensive on this point while reading, mainly because I grew up in the "purity culture" to some extent, am grateful I did, - rather than dating casually, etc., etc. - and as a result in large part have a beautiful love story. 💕) Finally, and honestly the most disappointing personally, Love That Lasts lacks practical depth. Jeff and Alyssa seem so intentional, so I was hopeful they would delve into living out the "better way" and share real-life examples and suggestions, but though they touch on many wise insights in principle, most beg the question what or how (for example, what did you do differently, actually? what was some advice your mentors gave? what was your vision while dating, and now in marriage? how did you navigate social media, etc.?).
I have no doubt that Jeff and Alyssa Bethke are sincere, passionate followers of Christ who want to speak truth and light into a dark and hurting world, and in some senses the Church as well, and in so many good ways they do exactly that in Love That Lasts. Even though I have several overarching criticisms of the book (there is simultaneously too much and not enough storytelling, in a loose sense of the word) and therefore can't say I love Love That Lasts, there are still many valid and valuable truths and insights from a Biblical perspective that "expose the distorted views of love that permeate our culture" (Summary) and also help to redefine a right view of love, sexuality, dating, and marriage. I am encouraged and challenged by Jeff and Alyssa's honesty, grace, intentionality, and love for each other, Christ, the Church, and the world. They are a refreshingly mature, thoughtful young couple with an influential platform, and I pray they will continue to use it wisely. And, with them, that each of us as believers will "live in a way that when the end comes [...] we can say we lived well, loved well, and pointed to a bigger picture. [...] That when people saw us, they in some small way got a glimpse of the greatest love—Jesus." (Introduction)
Note I purchased this book and chose to write a review; it was not a complimentary copy sent to me in exchange for my review.