Mostly solid advice -- some of it is weird, though... so I took it down to 3 stars. Here's the weird bits:
1 - starting the intro with victim Olympics that personal finance isn't taught in schools (what a WEIRD stretch of the concept of "oppression" -- can only be done by people so far removed from actual trials - made me look up the authors immediately) ...when Financial Literacy is literally a state requirement to graduate from high school in most states -- and was a required class in junior high too. Blaming teachers and schools is such a tired trope and these authors in well of their creativity dove right into that sad puddle. Obnoxious, but not worth taking a star.
2 - Not citing who came up with the 50-30-20 rule. The author's made it sound like some ubiquitous rule when really, it was created by a well-known senator: Warren.
3 - I'm reading it in 2025 -- it was written in 2017 -- and that 8 year gap MAKES A DIFFERENCE. We are upper-working class (not quite middle class) and yet according to this book, our net worth is better than the average of any country cited.
4 - It covered CDs but not HYSA...but the latter do better than CDs and aren't tied up like CDs.
5-It simultaneously encourages marriage (joining resources) but getting away from family (to "reduce your expenses")...so a hard lean to the nuclear family and ignoring that the extended family/village is a major way to pool resources. I mean, while we are floating in the best case scenario mode (because getting married is a "good" financial decision for everyone...)
6 - it switches tone from "best case scenario" to "worst case scenario"...it needs to pick a perspective, because otherwise it creates obvious bias towards certain strategies over others
7 - It suggests getting rid of cereal on one page but continuing cable TV on another. What the random. The only pattern I can see is some 1990s home where they have cable, but homemade meals (that was emphasized a lot), nuclear family, no extended family nearby, and 5 credit cards, with lots of debt. Also, use a broker (...but then admit on the next page that index funds do better than brokers -- so a lot of people like them). Also -- stock market is encouraged as an alternative way to gamble.
Ok - this review is too long. There were also some good points I want to look into (apparently, a lot of credit cards have lots of hidden rewards...I'll check --- and "check your credit" is different than "read your statements" -- which is a bit alarming and I'll look into it too).