Sorry, I may be in the minoroty , and maybe there was something wrong with the way I interpreted the novel, but I am lost with all the 5 and 4 star ratings, there is so much wrong with this novel and the characters! There are people saying that they want a man like Manning, and that the books are heartbreaking and about true love? Really? Seriously? I am worried about people's sanity, because I saw no true love, just a lot of unnecessary angst, obsession and selfishness! No offence but this booked dragged, the first part focused on a week, where Manning and Lake were together! Then, obviously for more angst and to fill the book, a massive, predicable obstacle occurs (Tiffany's pregnancy), separating these 'soulmates' (ha ha as if). This story did not need to be 3 books, because the reason they were separated was flimsy! First it was Lake's age which I get, but Manning if he was a better person would have waited, not settled for Tiffany, and been with Lake. But no, that apparently was impossible so he pushes Lake away, hurts her, then thinks it's ok to be obsessed with her, while growling at anyone who looks at her, as he marries her fucking sister? And that's ok, that's the kind of guy girls dream about? Get a grip! He stated he wanted Lake to soar and be happy, but he would not be the one to do that? He was an asshole! He wouldn't be with her, but tried to ruin her prom with Corbin! Selfish! He wanted her to be free, but only if that was at a college in California, where he could be near her and have some control while rubbing it in he was with Tiffany? I know Lake was a doormat, but at least I got her, she was young, naive and immature! But she was loyal, she made herself available to Manning, she waited! She even kept her freaking Virginity for him! What did he do? Married her sister, left her alone for 4 years to get on with things, while half her family did not speak to her! He helped cause a rift with them all, then left her alone! Even when he finally came to be with Lake, he still kept his options open by not dumping Tiffany, he still had a safe life to go back to if he did not get what he wanted! Lake did push him away when it was revealed Tiffany was pregnant, but that was the right thing to do, how could they be truly together when he would have a child with her sister? Manning went back, Tiffany had a miscarriage and they got divorced, and again he did not come back and fight for Lake! No he got on with his life! He hardly stayed true! I know we let guys off all the time because men need sex! But for goodness sake Lake gave her virginity to him! Yes later on she has sex with other people, but only after he broke her heart once again! Did Manning wait? Even try to be a better person? Nope, he was fucking some woman he knew in the dream house he supposedly built for Lake, well that would have well and truely tainted it! Even in the end when he says he loves her etc, it's all too little too late! She was back in town for a year and he still didn't go and get her, he bumped into her by chance? He was waiting till he could come to her, for what? It's been 4 years man up!
Tiffany was just a witch! All she did was spew viciousness! She got away with so much! In reality, Corbin would have been a better match for Lake, but in the end he deserved better than Lake as she was pathetic. The only decent, strong woman was Val! She was badass in this book, she was loyal, but told it straight and her speeches to Lake and to Manning were spot on! Sorry to all who loved it but this was not true love, Manning never redeemed himself, he married her sister for goodness sake! He had no real reason! He left Lake alone for years, he wouldn't touch her, but wanted no one else to! They were better off apart! Such a dragged out series, where the man basically was an ass and all was forgiven! Woo hoo for women's empowerment and self respect!