I saw an advertisement for "Outsystem" on Goodreads. It sounded like the type of novel I would really enjoy, so I was eager to dig into it.
SUMMARY
In the year 4123, humanity is still constrained by the speed of light. The solar system has been thoroughly colonized, as have planets at nearby stars by means of slower-than-light colony ships.
The Intrepid is a massive colony ship bound for an ideal world, if it can be completed and launched before corporate and political enemies destroy it. Major Tanis Richards, an experienced combat soldier and intelligence operative, is charged with maintaining security for the Intrepid, and is also slated to escape her violent life by becoming a colonist.
It won't be an easy job though. Those who would like to see the Intrepid destroyed or delayed are numerous, and they have the funds to do nearly anything. Major Richards finds herself surrounded by hosts of enemies and few friends as she tries to determine who is masterminding the attacks.
OVERALL: 2.6 out of 5
I actually liked this book quite a bit; I think the problem was that I went in expecting something else.
"Outsystem (Aeon 14)" is really a 1930s style cliffhanger, told in episodes, filled with action, and solid science fiction. What it lacks, in my opinion, is a stronger human element in the characters and an appropriate threat. There are no Nazis here, no doomsday cults, no big villain that feels insurmountable.
I like a book that tells me a complete story. There are a ton of threads here that I think must be meant for the sequel; the entire ending, a dodgy officer nobody likes (but who isn’t mentioned until the end, and never does anything to earn the reader's distrust), there is an unnamed colonel in suspended animation who has implied importance, and a mysterious package that is never explained. In fact, the presence of several important-but-background characters aboard the colony mission isn't explained either.
If there had just been one string or two for the next novel, I would have been happy. The ending, which basically is real cliffhanger in a novel of cliffhangers, just made me disappointed rather than excited. I would have rather had a neat, well-written finish, and then the excitement could start back up in the next novel.
Overall, I will check out the sequel and definitely keep my eye on M.D. Cooper. I don't mean to savage his work by any means, and I think that we probably have a lot in common in terms of what we like and look for.
RATINGS BY CATEGORY
CHARACTERS: 3 out of 5
Tanis is the primary viewpoint character. I don't hate her, but I didn't like her. She is always in control, always smooth, always knows what she is doing (except in a few brief romantic parts), and never has that "Oh, I'm screwed now" expression that I like in my heroes. She is a perfect example of the modern, Angelina Jolie-inspired "I always knows what I'm doing" type.
Most of the other characters play their roles, but no one really shined for me. Major Evans is a hot shot space fighter pilot, but he never really gets to show off. A girl named Trist is basically a punk cyber-thief who is introduced halfway through the novel, and the primary antagonist, a terrorist named Trent, is appropriately evil (like all the villains; and willing to do ANYTHING to achieve his goal). Staff Sergeant Williams, a tough marine, is interesting, but his dialogue is predictable.
My Cast
Tanis Richards: Mira Sorvino
Joseph Evans: Josh Dallas
Captain Andrews: Anderson Cooper
Admiral Sanderson: Billy Dee Williams
Trent: Adrien Brody
PACE: 3 out of 5
I thought the pace of this book was fast and it has a traditional layout of chapters, but it is episodic in nature. Tanis confronts one challenge after another, each not necessarily related to the previous one. Normally I like episodic fiction, but presented in this book format and unaware of what I was getting into, the story felt slow at times.
STORY: 2 out of 5
I was expecting something different. The advertisement led me to believe that without a solution to the speed of light problem, human society in the solar system had overpopulated the entire solar system, and thus decayed. A colony ship was a "last ditch effort" to rebuild civilization; maybe I was expecting something closer to the "Blade Runner" vibe. However, the human society in this book is generally an extension of modern day Western civilization if nothing much changes except technology.
That isn't unwelcome though. I love "optimistic sci-fi". My problem with the story lies mostly in wasted potential. While I admire the simplicity of what the author was trying to do, the colonists aboard the Intrepid are leaving behind everything- family, friends, the cradle of life; and the human element is only existent in short bits and pieces between the immediate characters. As a result, some of the majesty of the colonization project is lost.
I also thought the threat was not well defined earlier in the book, and then felt let down when I realized how predictable (to the characters) and mundane the final threat was. It's possible the author means to offer more explanation in the sequel, but I like concise, self-contained books, even when they're in a series.
Another problem I have are the laughable extents the villains go to. Tanis is surrounded by enemies and unhelpful parties (the reader definitely questions why the Intrepid is being built at Mars in the first place, where the authorities are so corrupt or inept that they all but roll out a welcome mat to terrorists). The villains seem to have no other existence except to derail this project, and they put themselves into extreme legal danger and mortal death, all while using massive amounts of money to defeat one person.
DIALOGUE: 2 out of 5
Judging the dialogue is among the hardest things to do in this book. Most of the conversations aren't difficult to understand, and the author doesn't try to impress me with fancy accents or "tricks" to account for the science fiction setting (tons of new words, mingling dialogue with other languages to create a population mixing effect, etc.)
However, there is a TON of jargon that I didn't understand (reading the Kindle edition, I wasn't aware there was a glossary of terms at the back), and I am a military science fiction reader. There is also a lot of cliché dialogue, particularly of the military nature. Officers give orders, sergeants bark, villains all but squeal with glee when they think they have the hero where they want them, and regular soldiers load up on "sir, yes, sir" at the military dialogue salad bar.
STYLE/TECHNICAL: 3 out of 5
The book is generally well written; most of the problems I had were typos and missing words that weren't caught in editing. Most of the action is clear, and I like the episodic nature of events (although it isn't what I was expecting).
The author does spend too much time casually referring to different parts of massive space stations (and defining what is "up" and what is "down"), but that may be a danger of writing something like this; when you're looking at a story that is two thousand years in the future, I am sure many structures humanity has built (assuming we're still around) will be quite daunting.
There are some disjointed areas too. The villain Trent is the viewpoint character in one or two parts, as are other people, but besides Tanis (the primary viewpoint character), the others are semi-regulars. Making only one appearance, offering his side of the story, didn't shed any light on his character or motivations.
Excerpts that Jumped Out at Me:
"Mmmm?" Tanis said around a mouthful of sticky goo.
-Quite possibly the worst line I've ever read in a book.
"Conversation was getting redundant," Tanis muttered and killed the connection;
-In the next paragraph, Tanis says, "Cause they're melting through the hatch and we'll be having tea with them in no time." Han Solo, anyone?
The train's closest stop to the SouRing commons was the sort of place that made people with death wishes deploy protective nano; Sue let out a veritable cloud.
-So she has a death wish? Maybe this was a typo, but also, the last sentence is a real gasser.