Received as a gift from the author with no promise of a review, favorable or otherwise.
4.5 rounded to 5 stars
You should take the warning in this title seriously, but it is far from being pornography. The graphic bits are, admittedly, very graphic, but they are integral to the plot development in this deeply moving and well-written tale.
At the opening of the story, our heroine is the widow of Mr. Collins and now Mistress of Longbourn. This came about because Mr. Collins had been at Longbourn, clumsily trying to charm Elizabeth. On the morning after the Netherfield ball, he had every intention of proposing and she had every intention of refusing him if he did.
Unfortunately for her, before that happened, Mr. Bennet suddenly developed chest pain, fell over and died. This shocking event didn't change Mr. Collins' plans in the slightest, and he proceeded with his proposal in the midst of the family's initial shock. It certainly changed Elizabeth's answer, as she had no choice but to accept in order to save her family.
All too quickly (at her betrothed's insistence), she found herself trapped in a horrific, although mercifully short-lived, marriage. During that time, Mr. Collins devalued, disrespected and demeaned her. In particular, he gave her such a revulsion of the marriage bed that she has developed PTSD symptoms whenever she even contemplates repeating the experience.
This is the crux of the obstacle that she must be willing to face and overcome if she is ever to marry again. As the book begins, she has no intention of giving a man such power over her again.
Meanwhile, we have a Mr. Bingley with a very strong backbone. Love this guy! When he learned Jane's father had died, not only did he refuse to stay in London, but he gave Darcy a major smack down for being such a snob and severed their friendship. Mr. Bingley did not get an opportunity to propose until after Elizabeth and Mr. Collins had already wed. He and Jane have been living at Netherfield, which was Elizabeth's only place of escape while under the thumb of her dictatorial husband until an accident killed him.
When Darcy and Bingley see each other in London some years after their break, they reconcile. The timing is perfect, as Bingley invites his old friend to a house party at Netherfield. Darcy, aware that Mrs. Collins is now a widow, plans to make the best of his second chance to win Elizabeth.
Mrs. Collins and her mother are in conflict more than ever, since Mrs. Bennet resents not being able to resume her former position as Mistress and instead must defer to her more practical-minded daughter. Lydia is already married (although not to Wickham), mostly because she was desperate to get out of Longbourn, away from Mr. Collins. Mary and Kitty still live at home, but they are different after observing Elizabeth's emotionally abusive marriage. Mary's attitude is less severe, and Kitty isn't certain that she ever wants to marry.
Elizabeth enjoys having the responsibility of managing the estate and proves to be quite good at it. She is just coming out of mourning at the Bingley's house party, though, and men are sniffing around from all over the area, eager to woo her in order to gain Longbourn (which is now more profitable than either Mr. Bennet or Mr. Collins was able to manage).
Such is the starting point for this unusual and richly-developed premise. Darcy and Elizabeth renew their acquaintance with pleasant banter. He doesn't present himself as a suitor but as a resource she comes to esteem and rely upon for advice about estate management. Most importantly, he demonstrates his respect for her intellect and abilities.
Over time, they move from acquaintance to friendship to romance. Darcy is at his most tender, patient and swoon-worthy. Even after Darcy wins Elizabeth's heart (Oh, c'mon! Not much of a spoiler! This IS a P&P variation!), her past with Mr. Collins hangs like a cloud over their relationship.
Although many may find the subject matter uncomfortable, it is handled with sensitivity and restraint. Details of Mr. Collins' behavior are omitted, as descriptions are of only a more general nature. Elizabeth's experience would not be atypical of marriage for many Regency women... and, sadly, there are many women in our modern world suffering in similarly abusive marriages. Appropriately, the focus here is on how Elizabeth overcomes the emotional barriers that such an experience would create. It's also pretty down-to-earth about how difficult this is for Darcy. (Talk about performance anxiety!!) There's enough humor and romance to keep it from getting too heavy, and it certainly kept my interest throughout.