What do you think?
Rate this book
Liar's Winter: An Appalachian Novel
Lochiel Ogle was born with a red-wine birthmark--and it put her life in jeopardy from the moment she entered the world. Mountain folks called it "the mark of the devil," and for all the evil that has plagued her nineteen-year existence, Lochiel is ready to believe that is true. And the evil surely took control of the mind of the boy who stole her as an infant, bringing her home for his mother to raise.
Abused and abandoned by the only people she knows as family, Lochiel is rescued by a peddler and given the first glimpse of love she has ever known. The truth of her past is gradually revealed as is the fact that she is still hunted by a brother driven to see her dead. Unsure if there's anyone she can truly trust, Lochiel is faced with a series of choices: Will she continue to run for escape or will she face her past and accept the heartbreaking secrets it reveals? Which will truly free her?
Set in the wild and beautiful Appalachian Mountains of nineteenth-century East Tennessee, Liar's Winter is an unflinching yet inspirational exploration of prejudice and choice.
249 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 29, 2017
105 people are currently reading
1207 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 134 reviews
December 22, 2025
Liar's Winter by Cindy K. Sproles
5 Stars
Another favorite book of 2025
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
I met Cindy at a local bookstore in Tennessee a couple of years ago and purchased most of her books that day. It's been a long time coming for me to finally read one of her books and I am SO glad I did! She was so kind and I loved Liar's Winter so much!
As a Tennessee girl, specifically growing up in East Tennessee, I heard so much about the Appalachian Mountain stories and the history of its people. Cindy has a gift for capturing the grit and grace of mountain life. It is a story of secrets, identity and the heavy burden of shame in a mark our main character Lochiel has on her face. She has the "mark of the devil" as they call it, something to be afraid of. She was raised in isolation with everyone thinking she is cursed.
Her entire life she has been hated and felt less than over this mark. Tragedy strikes and she flees for her life. She is rescued by a peddler and shown the first glimpse of love she has ever known. She starts to learn all about her past and her family, but the danger continues to come after her every turn she makes.
This book was real, raw, gritty....but also filled with the hope of the Lord. While it deals with darker themes such as superstition, family abuse, deception, death, loss of a loved one, grief, etc., it is a grace filled book that has hope within the heartbreak.
It's also deeply atmospheric in the Appalachian setting (I LOVE these settings y'all) - Cindy brings you RIGHT in.
This book made me cry but also had me filled with hope.
Another favorite book of 2025! Can't wait to read more by Cindy!
5 Stars
Another favorite book of 2025
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
I met Cindy at a local bookstore in Tennessee a couple of years ago and purchased most of her books that day. It's been a long time coming for me to finally read one of her books and I am SO glad I did! She was so kind and I loved Liar's Winter so much!
As a Tennessee girl, specifically growing up in East Tennessee, I heard so much about the Appalachian Mountain stories and the history of its people. Cindy has a gift for capturing the grit and grace of mountain life. It is a story of secrets, identity and the heavy burden of shame in a mark our main character Lochiel has on her face. She has the "mark of the devil" as they call it, something to be afraid of. She was raised in isolation with everyone thinking she is cursed.
Her entire life she has been hated and felt less than over this mark. Tragedy strikes and she flees for her life. She is rescued by a peddler and shown the first glimpse of love she has ever known. She starts to learn all about her past and her family, but the danger continues to come after her every turn she makes.
This book was real, raw, gritty....but also filled with the hope of the Lord. While it deals with darker themes such as superstition, family abuse, deception, death, loss of a loved one, grief, etc., it is a grace filled book that has hope within the heartbreak.
It's also deeply atmospheric in the Appalachian setting (I LOVE these settings y'all) - Cindy brings you RIGHT in.
This book made me cry but also had me filled with hope.
Another favorite book of 2025! Can't wait to read more by Cindy!
September 30, 2017
Reviewed at The Power of Words: http://bit.ly/2x4uYjZ
Liar’s Winter is a powerful story written by an equally powerful storyteller. Cindy K. Sproles writes with a fresh voice in Christian fiction and spins a mesmerizing, character-driven tale as hauntingly beautiful as its Smoky Mountain setting.
From the time in my youth when I read Catherine Marshall’s Christy, I’ve been drawn to Appalachian settings, and I’m not sure why. Maybe it’s a combination of elements – for instance, the raw beauty of an untamed land – isolated, an area unto itself – and the naiveté, superstition and innocence of its people. The lyrical voice of Sproles captures the essence of late nineteenth-century Appalachia and its people in this story of faith and redemption. The dialect and ungrammatical language of the mountain people is easy to follow, even bringing back memories of my own north Georgia ancestry.
If a character has ever stolen my heart, it’s Lochiel. With her horrifying background of abuse, brokenness and abandonment, concepts of love, trust, tenderness and caring are unimaginable to her. Liar’s Winter is raw and gritty, just like Lochiel’s life. But contrasted with that is Lochiel’s moving response to honesty, compassion, and grace.
I’m more of a fan of drama than suspense and adventure; but although those elements are present, they fit the storyline. Strong secondary characters like Walton, Edna and Silas also captured my heart. Liar’s Winter is a story of prejudice and choices; it’s not a light read, but a compelling and memorable one. Highly recommended.
I was provided a free copy of this book from Kregel Publications. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Liar’s Winter is a powerful story written by an equally powerful storyteller. Cindy K. Sproles writes with a fresh voice in Christian fiction and spins a mesmerizing, character-driven tale as hauntingly beautiful as its Smoky Mountain setting.
From the time in my youth when I read Catherine Marshall’s Christy, I’ve been drawn to Appalachian settings, and I’m not sure why. Maybe it’s a combination of elements – for instance, the raw beauty of an untamed land – isolated, an area unto itself – and the naiveté, superstition and innocence of its people. The lyrical voice of Sproles captures the essence of late nineteenth-century Appalachia and its people in this story of faith and redemption. The dialect and ungrammatical language of the mountain people is easy to follow, even bringing back memories of my own north Georgia ancestry.
If a character has ever stolen my heart, it’s Lochiel. With her horrifying background of abuse, brokenness and abandonment, concepts of love, trust, tenderness and caring are unimaginable to her. Liar’s Winter is raw and gritty, just like Lochiel’s life. But contrasted with that is Lochiel’s moving response to honesty, compassion, and grace.
I’m more of a fan of drama than suspense and adventure; but although those elements are present, they fit the storyline. Strong secondary characters like Walton, Edna and Silas also captured my heart. Liar’s Winter is a story of prejudice and choices; it’s not a light read, but a compelling and memorable one. Highly recommended.
I was provided a free copy of this book from Kregel Publications. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
August 29, 2017
For me, novels set in the Appalachian Mountains have this unique quality about them. And Liar’s Winter by Cindy K. Sproles was no different—it was intriguing, heart wrenching, and very much an adventure of a certain mystery, danger, and drama.
Dealing with superstition, hate, prejudice, and an abused, naïve girl named Lochiel who has the “devil’s mark”, this book snags your attention and keeps it to the end. It had me guessing and wondering. It made my heart squeeze painfully within my chest. It made me smile. It made my breath catch. It made me hope.
It was a small-ish book, but the story captured my attention and resounded in my heart. It was real, raw, and gritty. And filled with this authentic journey to faith. To healing. To new life. With suspense and heart-pounding danger … as well as surprises and tender new friendships, Liar’s Winter told a story different than other Christian historical fiction.
Lochiel Ogle was different than your average POV character. Her story is horrifying … but ultimately beautiful, as God can bring healing and beauty where there was once only destruction and brokenness. Her emotional fight was real. Wow. It was rough. Still thinking about some of things that happened.
I quite loved this book. Highly recommend to historical fiction lovers, especially those who enjoys stories set in the nineteenth century Appalachian Mountains! Liar’s Winter is definitely worth your time, and I’m greatly looking forward to reading more by this author!
I received a copy of Liar’s Winter from Kregel Publications in exchange for my honest review.
Dealing with superstition, hate, prejudice, and an abused, naïve girl named Lochiel who has the “devil’s mark”, this book snags your attention and keeps it to the end. It had me guessing and wondering. It made my heart squeeze painfully within my chest. It made me smile. It made my breath catch. It made me hope.
It was a small-ish book, but the story captured my attention and resounded in my heart. It was real, raw, and gritty. And filled with this authentic journey to faith. To healing. To new life. With suspense and heart-pounding danger … as well as surprises and tender new friendships, Liar’s Winter told a story different than other Christian historical fiction.
Lochiel Ogle was different than your average POV character. Her story is horrifying … but ultimately beautiful, as God can bring healing and beauty where there was once only destruction and brokenness. Her emotional fight was real. Wow. It was rough. Still thinking about some of things that happened.
I quite loved this book. Highly recommend to historical fiction lovers, especially those who enjoys stories set in the nineteenth century Appalachian Mountains! Liar’s Winter is definitely worth your time, and I’m greatly looking forward to reading more by this author!
I received a copy of Liar’s Winter from Kregel Publications in exchange for my honest review.
February 16, 2025
I can't get enough of Cindy K. Sproles! Her books are always fanatically written, with characters that stick with you long after the first page.
July 27, 2017
Liar’s Winter is a book that will warm your heart and bring tears to your eyes. A baby snatched from those who loved her and taken to be raised as more or less a slave with no comfort from other humans, ah but that is just the beginning.
The author makes you think about the injustice of all that happens to Lochiel, and we wonder with all that transpires to her if she will survive until the end of the story. A powerful read if there ever was one, and you will not want to put it down, and then you will want it to continue once you get to the end.
Superstition plays a part in a lot of cultures, and these mountain folks are ripe for it, when it is spread that this innocent young woman has the “mark of the devil”, but you can see the hand of the Lord in her rescue and surprises abound as you peruse the pages of this novel. We find friends and family, but also those who believe the lies and take it out on a defenseless girl, and yet she has the power of God on her side, will it be enough, or will those who believe in evil prevail?
Don’t miss this one; it will linger with you for a long time.
I received this book through Kregel Blogging Program, and was not required to give a positive review.
The author makes you think about the injustice of all that happens to Lochiel, and we wonder with all that transpires to her if she will survive until the end of the story. A powerful read if there ever was one, and you will not want to put it down, and then you will want it to continue once you get to the end.
Superstition plays a part in a lot of cultures, and these mountain folks are ripe for it, when it is spread that this innocent young woman has the “mark of the devil”, but you can see the hand of the Lord in her rescue and surprises abound as you peruse the pages of this novel. We find friends and family, but also those who believe the lies and take it out on a defenseless girl, and yet she has the power of God on her side, will it be enough, or will those who believe in evil prevail?
Don’t miss this one; it will linger with you for a long time.
I received this book through Kregel Blogging Program, and was not required to give a positive review.
April 19, 2023
You know who I never hear about on bookstagram, facebook, or anywhere else? Cindy K. Sproles. And I don't know why. Her books aren't feel-good, quick read books, but they're full of emotion and heart, and everyone should read at least one of them. But I don't recommend stopping at just one. Read them all, and tell me they don't touch your soul.
December 1, 2020
This is an incredible and emotionally packed book. Holy buckets, Sproles writes good characters.
September 29, 2017
Liar’s Winter is a story that took me by surprise. From the prologue to the epilogue this story drew me in and had me reading in a rapid pace. Set in the Appalachian’s in the early 1900’s we are given a glimpse of a young woman’s life, one that has been abused and lied to for almost 19 years. One where superstitions and hate run deep, deeper than the birthmark that has marked Lochiel (Low kill) believing that she is worthless and the devil’s daughter.
Lochiel was rescued by a kind man who begins to reveal the truth of whom she is and where she is from. This man and his mother treat her as though she matters, with kindness and love and show her about a God who loves her even more. I felt her impatience as the truth was slowly revealed to her and she had to weigh that with the lies she always believed. I wanted these kind folks to tell Lochiel her entire story in one sitting, but as the story unfolded I saw as the author did that that would not be best for Lochiel. Receiving the truth had Lochiel hanging on to the lies she believed her whole life for a little bit longer as the ramifications of the truth swirled inside of her head.
I saw so many life lessons in this story and marveled with Lochiel as she finally saw who she really was. This was my first read by author Sproles and I found it unique in its setting and authenticity in the characters.
I received a copy of this book for free from Kregel Publications. I was not required to post a positive review and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
Lochiel was rescued by a kind man who begins to reveal the truth of whom she is and where she is from. This man and his mother treat her as though she matters, with kindness and love and show her about a God who loves her even more. I felt her impatience as the truth was slowly revealed to her and she had to weigh that with the lies she always believed. I wanted these kind folks to tell Lochiel her entire story in one sitting, but as the story unfolded I saw as the author did that that would not be best for Lochiel. Receiving the truth had Lochiel hanging on to the lies she believed her whole life for a little bit longer as the ramifications of the truth swirled inside of her head.
I saw so many life lessons in this story and marveled with Lochiel as she finally saw who she really was. This was my first read by author Sproles and I found it unique in its setting and authenticity in the characters.
I received a copy of this book for free from Kregel Publications. I was not required to post a positive review and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
July 15, 2018
It is a pleasure to read a historical fiction novel where the characters act appropriately for their time and place. Lochiel Ogle is also a kidnap victim growing up in a family that she tries to love and depends on but continually abuse her. She also has a birthmark and has been told her entire life that it is a "mark of the devil". Beaten and left for dead by her "brother," she is rescued by a peddler who may know more about her past than he's telling.
This is just the first couple of chapters. One of the stories main points is that poor Lochiel needs to choose whether to forgive or seek vengiance. No matter what she decides, she is fighting terrible prejudice and superstition and is frequently running for her life.
This is just the first couple of chapters. One of the stories main points is that poor Lochiel needs to choose whether to forgive or seek vengiance. No matter what she decides, she is fighting terrible prejudice and superstition and is frequently running for her life.
August 28, 2025
EXCELLENT! Loved it !
onward to book #3
I will be passing this one on to others.
well done !!
onward to book #3
I will be passing this one on to others.
well done !!
February 8, 2024
3.5 rounded up
September 26, 2017
I am just sitting here trying to think of a way to review this powerful novel. It has moved me greatly and taught me something wonderful. It deserves more than the 5 stars allowed. Truly, it does.
Lochiel Ogle was born with a red birthmark on her face, the Devil's mark, folks called it. Stolen away from her parents, hidden away and abused, she has never known the love of anyone, never known what a hug feels like, never felt as if she mattered to anyone. Lochiel is 19 years old now and abandoned by the people she has known as her family all her life. Beaten and bruised, she is rescued by a mountain peddler and shown such care and love that she is wary of it. Will Lochiel trust this peddler and allow some measure of peace in her life? Or will she, as she begins to piece together her past and what it means to her, reject the only love she's ever known?
Set in the beautiful and wild Appalachian mountains of the late nineteenth century, this book is breathtaking in its telling. This is a book that is very, very hard to read at times. Often I was in tears during the reading. How could one person endure such pain, abuse and shame? But God has a purpose for all things. And one old granny woman teaches Lochiel some very valuable lessons. Choice. That's what this book is about. Our life is about choices. All our life. I thank God for the lesson I myself learned here.
This is a powerful book and one I highly recommend. It will stay with me a long time. Boy, what a tale! Don't miss this one.
Lochiel Ogle was born with a red birthmark on her face, the Devil's mark, folks called it. Stolen away from her parents, hidden away and abused, she has never known the love of anyone, never known what a hug feels like, never felt as if she mattered to anyone. Lochiel is 19 years old now and abandoned by the people she has known as her family all her life. Beaten and bruised, she is rescued by a mountain peddler and shown such care and love that she is wary of it. Will Lochiel trust this peddler and allow some measure of peace in her life? Or will she, as she begins to piece together her past and what it means to her, reject the only love she's ever known?
Set in the beautiful and wild Appalachian mountains of the late nineteenth century, this book is breathtaking in its telling. This is a book that is very, very hard to read at times. Often I was in tears during the reading. How could one person endure such pain, abuse and shame? But God has a purpose for all things. And one old granny woman teaches Lochiel some very valuable lessons. Choice. That's what this book is about. Our life is about choices. All our life. I thank God for the lesson I myself learned here.
This is a powerful book and one I highly recommend. It will stay with me a long time. Boy, what a tale! Don't miss this one.
March 23, 2019
"Start here and go there, but my best guess is, you'll know home when you see it. "
"Whole mountain knows the legend. A family raisin' the Devil's daughter. Keepin her hid away. Course that's just legend. Never knew it was true." But it was true, not the "devil's daughter" part, but the part about being hidden away all of her life. Lochiel Ogle had been snatched from the arms of the one person who should have been able to love her the most, and handed to one who grew to hate her with a vengeance, . . . . . all because of the "mark".
Now running for her life, and having to trust total strangers, Lochiel must make a choice, " Angry? Bitter? Or will (she) be better than that?" Temporarily sheltered from her brother, who wants nothing more than to have Lochiel's blood on his hands, Lochiel struggles to accept the truth of her circumstances; while cautiously accepting the kindness of an old woman and placing her trust in a man who seems determined to lead her heart towards home.
"And now abideth faith, hope and charity, these three; but the greatest of these is charity. . . . . . . I choose love."
This is an absolutely amazing story, written by quite a talented story teller.
"Whole mountain knows the legend. A family raisin' the Devil's daughter. Keepin her hid away. Course that's just legend. Never knew it was true." But it was true, not the "devil's daughter" part, but the part about being hidden away all of her life. Lochiel Ogle had been snatched from the arms of the one person who should have been able to love her the most, and handed to one who grew to hate her with a vengeance, . . . . . all because of the "mark".
Now running for her life, and having to trust total strangers, Lochiel must make a choice, " Angry? Bitter? Or will (she) be better than that?" Temporarily sheltered from her brother, who wants nothing more than to have Lochiel's blood on his hands, Lochiel struggles to accept the truth of her circumstances; while cautiously accepting the kindness of an old woman and placing her trust in a man who seems determined to lead her heart towards home.
"And now abideth faith, hope and charity, these three; but the greatest of these is charity. . . . . . . I choose love."
This is an absolutely amazing story, written by quite a talented story teller.
August 13, 2017
About the Book:
The choices you make determine who you are. No no mark." Lochiel Ogle was born with a red-wine birthmark--and it put her life in jeopardy from the moment she entered the world. Mountain folks called it "the mark of the devil," and for all the evil that has plagued her nineteen-year existence, Lochiel is ready to believe that is true. And the evil surely took control of the mind of the boy who stole her as an infant, bringing her home for his mother to raise.
Abused and abandoned by the only people she knows as family, Lochiel is rescued by a peddler and given the first glimpse of love she has ever known. The truth of her past is gradually revealed as is the fact that she is still hunted by a brother driven to see her dead. Unsure if there's anyone she can truly trust, Lochiel is faced with a series of choices: Will she continue to run for escape or will she face her past and accept the heartbreaking secrets it reveals? Which will truly free her?
Set in the wild and beautiful Appalachian Mountains of nineteenth-century East Tennessee, Liar's Winter is an unflinching yet inspirational exploration of prejudice and choice.
My Review:
Reading about the Appalachian Mountains was truly remarkable and breath taking at the same time. I have always wanted to visit this part of the country so I try when I review a book based on this location, I try to live vicariously through the characters. Even at the turn of the century I am almost sure that it was simply a marvelous place to visit much less live.
In Liar's Winter, we are taken on a journey of self hope and self reliance. Following the story of Lochiel Ogle you learn rather quickly that she only had herself to rely on. Which is tough enough for a child trying to grow up but now as she becomes a young adult she has to keep looking over her shoulder to see if her brother is on the verge on pouncing on her because he wants to see her dead.
I immediately feel sorry for this girl because she has been abused her whole life only to be stalked by a crazy loon of a sibling. WOW! This book is packed to the hilt with action. A lot of action for such a tiny book.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the author. All opinions are my own.
The choices you make determine who you are. No no mark." Lochiel Ogle was born with a red-wine birthmark--and it put her life in jeopardy from the moment she entered the world. Mountain folks called it "the mark of the devil," and for all the evil that has plagued her nineteen-year existence, Lochiel is ready to believe that is true. And the evil surely took control of the mind of the boy who stole her as an infant, bringing her home for his mother to raise.
Abused and abandoned by the only people she knows as family, Lochiel is rescued by a peddler and given the first glimpse of love she has ever known. The truth of her past is gradually revealed as is the fact that she is still hunted by a brother driven to see her dead. Unsure if there's anyone she can truly trust, Lochiel is faced with a series of choices: Will she continue to run for escape or will she face her past and accept the heartbreaking secrets it reveals? Which will truly free her?
Set in the wild and beautiful Appalachian Mountains of nineteenth-century East Tennessee, Liar's Winter is an unflinching yet inspirational exploration of prejudice and choice.
My Review:
Reading about the Appalachian Mountains was truly remarkable and breath taking at the same time. I have always wanted to visit this part of the country so I try when I review a book based on this location, I try to live vicariously through the characters. Even at the turn of the century I am almost sure that it was simply a marvelous place to visit much less live.
In Liar's Winter, we are taken on a journey of self hope and self reliance. Following the story of Lochiel Ogle you learn rather quickly that she only had herself to rely on. Which is tough enough for a child trying to grow up but now as she becomes a young adult she has to keep looking over her shoulder to see if her brother is on the verge on pouncing on her because he wants to see her dead.
I immediately feel sorry for this girl because she has been abused her whole life only to be stalked by a crazy loon of a sibling. WOW! This book is packed to the hilt with action. A lot of action for such a tiny book.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the author. All opinions are my own.
September 25, 2017
Like MERCY’s RAIN, LIAR’S WINTER chronicles a difficult time in history and in the life of a little girl.
Set in the Appalachian Mountains in the 1800s—a time when people grappled to survive—Lochiel Ogle is raised in a dark world of hatred and fear. Literally marked since birth, Lochiel is stolen away from her mother and raised by a family that treats her like she is the plague incarnate. Called the Devil’s child because of the red-wine birthmark on her face, Lochiel is abused physically, emotionally, and psychologically. She is brainwashed into believing she is evil and constantly told she is worthless and has the ability to hex others. When her brother beats her, and leaves her to die, a stranger rescues her. Instantly Lochiel’s world changes. She is treated with kindness and compassion for the first time in her life. Suspicious why strangers would treat her so well, she soon finds out Walton and Edna aren’t strangers at all. What follows is a story of discovery and hope. Lochiel learns of her past and looks forward to a new future. Unfortunately, even with people who love her and want to protect Lochiel, the world might never be a safe place for her. When her life is threatened once again, she must be spirited away to safety.
There are both pros and cons to Ms. Sproles artistic style. Though the writing vernacular is authentic to the time period, it takes some getting used to, and the darkness of the subject matter can weigh heavy on the reader. However, if you can get past those snags, and allow yourself to attach to the characters, the story moves quicker. This isn’t a series I would necessarily recommend to the typical fiction reader. Someone with an interest in the historical value would appreciate the authenticity, but for the average reader, it might be a stumbling block.
Book provided for review purposes.
Set in the Appalachian Mountains in the 1800s—a time when people grappled to survive—Lochiel Ogle is raised in a dark world of hatred and fear. Literally marked since birth, Lochiel is stolen away from her mother and raised by a family that treats her like she is the plague incarnate. Called the Devil’s child because of the red-wine birthmark on her face, Lochiel is abused physically, emotionally, and psychologically. She is brainwashed into believing she is evil and constantly told she is worthless and has the ability to hex others. When her brother beats her, and leaves her to die, a stranger rescues her. Instantly Lochiel’s world changes. She is treated with kindness and compassion for the first time in her life. Suspicious why strangers would treat her so well, she soon finds out Walton and Edna aren’t strangers at all. What follows is a story of discovery and hope. Lochiel learns of her past and looks forward to a new future. Unfortunately, even with people who love her and want to protect Lochiel, the world might never be a safe place for her. When her life is threatened once again, she must be spirited away to safety.
There are both pros and cons to Ms. Sproles artistic style. Though the writing vernacular is authentic to the time period, it takes some getting used to, and the darkness of the subject matter can weigh heavy on the reader. However, if you can get past those snags, and allow yourself to attach to the characters, the story moves quicker. This isn’t a series I would necessarily recommend to the typical fiction reader. Someone with an interest in the historical value would appreciate the authenticity, but for the average reader, it might be a stumbling block.
Book provided for review purposes.
September 25, 2017
Sproles takes readers to the Appalachian Mountains over a hundred years ago when myth and superstition held more sway than logic objective knowledge. Into this culture a girl was born with a wine-red birthmark on her cheek and neck. Many thought her a daughter of the devil and fearfully treated her as an outcast. How she survived is a brutal story framed by parental love.
I live far away from the Appalachian Mountains and this novel was a very interesting journey to another time and another place. Sproles has done a good job giving the flavor of religious belief and the condition of society of the day. I was appalled at how people were treated. But this was a time and place of small communities being cut off from each other. Mistrust and fear were common. Violence was a way of life.
We experience the struggle of a girl told all her life she was evil and dangerous and must remain hidden. But we also see the steady love of a parent break through toward rescue. The clash of violence and love does not make for a pretty story. It was hard for me to read of the continued mistreatment of the girl, even though love and forgiveness won out in the end.
I recommend this novel to those who would enjoy a journey into the Appalachian past. You'll be immersed in the culture of the time, be confronted with violence and anger, and be amazed at the saving grace of God.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
I live far away from the Appalachian Mountains and this novel was a very interesting journey to another time and another place. Sproles has done a good job giving the flavor of religious belief and the condition of society of the day. I was appalled at how people were treated. But this was a time and place of small communities being cut off from each other. Mistrust and fear were common. Violence was a way of life.
We experience the struggle of a girl told all her life she was evil and dangerous and must remain hidden. But we also see the steady love of a parent break through toward rescue. The clash of violence and love does not make for a pretty story. It was hard for me to read of the continued mistreatment of the girl, even though love and forgiveness won out in the end.
I recommend this novel to those who would enjoy a journey into the Appalachian past. You'll be immersed in the culture of the time, be confronted with violence and anger, and be amazed at the saving grace of God.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
November 21, 2019
I just finished Liar's Winter, and it was absolutely outstanding. I found myself intentionally stalling at the end because I truly didn't want it to end, and yet I couldn't put it down because I was emotionally invested in every single one of the characters. I cried when I got to the last page!! Cindy Sproles is one of my very favorite authors now, and I'm so eager to read everything she'll ever write from here on out. Also, having lived for about eight years in the Appalachians, she captured the voice and the feel of the mountains in a way that is holy, authentic, moving and beautiful. I LOVED. THIS. BOOK! It's a must-read.
October 10, 2017
This book was great! It was my first Appalachian Novel and I really enjoyed it. This writer was able to portray the story as if you were taken back in time and you were really there watching the events unfold.
September 4, 2024
Very very good book. You will squeal and laugh also oh and aww. And you will cry too
Read
July 28, 2017LJ
May 14, 2018
Liar's Winter, by Cindy Sproles, is one of the most exceptional novels in the Christian Fiction genre that I've read in a long time. It's a story about prejudice: the ignorance behind it, the personal pain resulting from it, and the horrifying way it has of making otherwise good people become filled with hate and fear.
Cindy tells the story from the deep first person POV of Lochiel Ogle, who was stolen from her mother in infancy. She was raised by a man and woman who were of terrified her, and had a "brother" who brutally harassed her. She has a mark on the side of her face which, according to Appalachian lore, is the mark of the devil. All sorts of insane superstitions are associated with that mark.
She spent her life under the assumption that the way she was treated is normal. That it's "love." Only when her real father finds her does she learn what love is. He and his mother, her grandmother, have their work cut out for them. They have to undo the damage her "parents" did by showing her what true love is, while fighting against the image she has of herself which was thrust upon her by others.
Cindy doesn't go easy on Lochiel. From beginning to end, what the girl endures is difficult, often physically dangerous and terrifying. Even the chapters dedicated to her "reprogramming" are hard to read because of how realistic the struggle is. When a person is ingrained with a low self-worth, it's nigh unto impossible to see herself in a different, more favorable light. It's hard enough accepting love from people who are there with you, but accepting love from a God you can't see? That takes faith. Until Lochiel can accept love from her real family, she can't conceive of love from an invisible God.
Amazing 5-star book. Totally worth the read. Highly recommended. Highest accolades. Don't know what else I can say to convince you to put it on your TBR list.
Cindy tells the story from the deep first person POV of Lochiel Ogle, who was stolen from her mother in infancy. She was raised by a man and woman who were of terrified her, and had a "brother" who brutally harassed her. She has a mark on the side of her face which, according to Appalachian lore, is the mark of the devil. All sorts of insane superstitions are associated with that mark.
She spent her life under the assumption that the way she was treated is normal. That it's "love." Only when her real father finds her does she learn what love is. He and his mother, her grandmother, have their work cut out for them. They have to undo the damage her "parents" did by showing her what true love is, while fighting against the image she has of herself which was thrust upon her by others.
Cindy doesn't go easy on Lochiel. From beginning to end, what the girl endures is difficult, often physically dangerous and terrifying. Even the chapters dedicated to her "reprogramming" are hard to read because of how realistic the struggle is. When a person is ingrained with a low self-worth, it's nigh unto impossible to see herself in a different, more favorable light. It's hard enough accepting love from people who are there with you, but accepting love from a God you can't see? That takes faith. Until Lochiel can accept love from her real family, she can't conceive of love from an invisible God.
Amazing 5-star book. Totally worth the read. Highly recommended. Highest accolades. Don't know what else I can say to convince you to put it on your TBR list.
June 10, 2018
Liar's Winter is far outside my normal fare. If given the choice, I'm never going to gravitate towards Appalachian-set novels, and frankly I loathe reading dialect. However, I'm so glad I ventured outside my preferred comfort zone in this instance to read Lochiel's story. This is an extraordinarily difficult read -- rife with scenes of stark, horrific emotional and physical violence -- not for the faint of heart. But that said, this is an extraordinarily hopeful, redemptive book. For anyone who thinks "Christian" fiction is light on the issues, I challenge them to read Sproles' starkly poetic work.
September 19, 2017
"Kindness if from the soul. It's gived 'cause it can't help but be gived."
That about sums up Liar's Winter by Cindy K. Sproles who has given us the first novel in her Appalachian series. It is about judging people simply based on their looks without looking at their heart. For poor Lochiel Ogle, she has had to endure the cruelest kind of abuse at the hands of those who raised her. Being found by Gerald, her 'brother' and given to his Momma in hopes it might help with the loss and grief she had been experiencing but all the babies she had only to lose them moments after being born. However that was not the case, because Lochiel was different. She had a mark that covered her check down to her neck and the entire family made sure to tell Lochiel that it was the mark of the devil. It was the reason why bad things were blamed on her that happened to the family. Even losing more babies after Lochiel came to live with them.
They kept her locked away whenever the family had to go to town. Her only boundaries were those self imposed on her by the rope that her Poppy tied to her waist to keep her from wandering off. If you think that was cruel, you might just want to see how Gerald treated her when others weren't looking and of course hiding the blame. Gerald wanted Lochiel dead and he would try numerous times to get rid of her, until one day she ran. She ran with the help of a strange man named Walton, who was a half-breed white man whose father was an Indian. He would help Lochiel hide from Gerald even if it meant constantly being on the run and never far enough ahead for Gerald to find her.
At this time of the year she wasn't sure if the weather would turn to more snow or spring was just around the corner, thus the name Liar's Winter. Now living with Walton and his mother Edna, she found what kindness, faith and love were really. Those terms she had been led to believe were a far cry from how she had been raised, like an outcast, someone different that had to be hidden from the world and no matter how she tried to believe she was good inside, she couldn't help understanding that she was forever marked by the devil and his imprint remained on her face where it would always be seen and thus judged in an instant as being worse than she was on the inside. It would take more love than she had ever known to change her life, if she could stay one step ahead of Gerald, who wanted her dead.
I received Liar's Winter by Cindy K. Sproles compliments of Kregel Publications. There are so many good words of wisdom the reader will come across and like me, highlight or mark those places so when I need a kind or wise word in my own life I can find it. One of my favorites is, "You never know the hardships others carry. Looks is deceivin so you love and respect everybody. Even the ones who do you wrong." I reckon I couldn't have learned a stouter lesson, since I had walked in the shoes of one judged." Even Lochiel (pronounced Lo-Kill) learns something by the end of the novel about God is, "He give me eyes to see the best in folks, even when it looks bad. He give me love and I know now that love changes everything." Perhaps that is why the Bible reminds us that love is the greatest gift! It even outlasts time! I give this novel a 4 out of 5 stars in my opinion.
That about sums up Liar's Winter by Cindy K. Sproles who has given us the first novel in her Appalachian series. It is about judging people simply based on their looks without looking at their heart. For poor Lochiel Ogle, she has had to endure the cruelest kind of abuse at the hands of those who raised her. Being found by Gerald, her 'brother' and given to his Momma in hopes it might help with the loss and grief she had been experiencing but all the babies she had only to lose them moments after being born. However that was not the case, because Lochiel was different. She had a mark that covered her check down to her neck and the entire family made sure to tell Lochiel that it was the mark of the devil. It was the reason why bad things were blamed on her that happened to the family. Even losing more babies after Lochiel came to live with them.
They kept her locked away whenever the family had to go to town. Her only boundaries were those self imposed on her by the rope that her Poppy tied to her waist to keep her from wandering off. If you think that was cruel, you might just want to see how Gerald treated her when others weren't looking and of course hiding the blame. Gerald wanted Lochiel dead and he would try numerous times to get rid of her, until one day she ran. She ran with the help of a strange man named Walton, who was a half-breed white man whose father was an Indian. He would help Lochiel hide from Gerald even if it meant constantly being on the run and never far enough ahead for Gerald to find her.
At this time of the year she wasn't sure if the weather would turn to more snow or spring was just around the corner, thus the name Liar's Winter. Now living with Walton and his mother Edna, she found what kindness, faith and love were really. Those terms she had been led to believe were a far cry from how she had been raised, like an outcast, someone different that had to be hidden from the world and no matter how she tried to believe she was good inside, she couldn't help understanding that she was forever marked by the devil and his imprint remained on her face where it would always be seen and thus judged in an instant as being worse than she was on the inside. It would take more love than she had ever known to change her life, if she could stay one step ahead of Gerald, who wanted her dead.
I received Liar's Winter by Cindy K. Sproles compliments of Kregel Publications. There are so many good words of wisdom the reader will come across and like me, highlight or mark those places so when I need a kind or wise word in my own life I can find it. One of my favorites is, "You never know the hardships others carry. Looks is deceivin so you love and respect everybody. Even the ones who do you wrong." I reckon I couldn't have learned a stouter lesson, since I had walked in the shoes of one judged." Even Lochiel (pronounced Lo-Kill) learns something by the end of the novel about God is, "He give me eyes to see the best in folks, even when it looks bad. He give me love and I know now that love changes everything." Perhaps that is why the Bible reminds us that love is the greatest gift! It even outlasts time! I give this novel a 4 out of 5 stars in my opinion.
September 24, 2017
MY THOUGHTS
What would an innocent child, a baby do, when born with a birthmark that changes her life forever? Born in the Appalachian Mountains of Tennessee, Lochiel is considered evil, all because of the birthmark. The mountain people called it "the mark of the devil." But superstitions were very often believed and still are. Now being nineteen years old and having lived those nineteen years being constantly in battle with the evil believed has been bestowed upon her by her people, she is beginning to believe it. She wasn't raised by family, which only added to the problem. She had been taken w hen an infant and raised by another. Then being abandoned by what she believes is her family, a poor peddler saves her and she now believes she is loved. But she knows she still is being haunted by a brother who wants her dead because of the so called evil she carries.
The author gives the reader a heart breaking story of a baby raised to believe she is nothing but evil, pure evil, because of a birth mark. Nothing she did, but what she was born with. The setting in a way, counter acts the heart break since it is so breath taking and yet wild. The people of these mountains were extremely prejudice in their thinking. Not only that, but they were willing to kill to get rid of this superstitious belief that this child was evil. But what is really behind this prejudice, this so called belief of being born filled with evil? Will Lochiel be able to bring out her strength to face her past, to face the hidden secrets that could possibly free her? Or will she continue to run away thinking everyone is right. She is evil? The writer of this book did a wonderful job of writing of what happened back in the deep mountains of Tennessee. The back hills were and are still, filled with these superstitions. People were and still are prejudiced about certain things and probably always will be. But will Lochiel bring all of her nineteen years plus out in the open, even if, it may mean, facing things she didn't know and may not want to know? The author gives inspiration to those who have been and are plagued by similar situations. Don't kid yourself. IT happens, even in today's society. True this is fiction but sometimes fiction is just a fine line before you enter reality and the author puts this forth magnificently. You won't have a chance to pause because you must turn the pages to follow Lochiel and what is happening to her. This all started because of being born, being born with a birthmark, considered a "mark of the devil." We all have choices, it's what we do with those choices that matters.
I received a copy of this book from the author and Kregel Publications and voluntarily decided to review it. I was not required to post a review and I was not influenced in any way.
What would an innocent child, a baby do, when born with a birthmark that changes her life forever? Born in the Appalachian Mountains of Tennessee, Lochiel is considered evil, all because of the birthmark. The mountain people called it "the mark of the devil." But superstitions were very often believed and still are. Now being nineteen years old and having lived those nineteen years being constantly in battle with the evil believed has been bestowed upon her by her people, she is beginning to believe it. She wasn't raised by family, which only added to the problem. She had been taken w hen an infant and raised by another. Then being abandoned by what she believes is her family, a poor peddler saves her and she now believes she is loved. But she knows she still is being haunted by a brother who wants her dead because of the so called evil she carries.
The author gives the reader a heart breaking story of a baby raised to believe she is nothing but evil, pure evil, because of a birth mark. Nothing she did, but what she was born with. The setting in a way, counter acts the heart break since it is so breath taking and yet wild. The people of these mountains were extremely prejudice in their thinking. Not only that, but they were willing to kill to get rid of this superstitious belief that this child was evil. But what is really behind this prejudice, this so called belief of being born filled with evil? Will Lochiel be able to bring out her strength to face her past, to face the hidden secrets that could possibly free her? Or will she continue to run away thinking everyone is right. She is evil? The writer of this book did a wonderful job of writing of what happened back in the deep mountains of Tennessee. The back hills were and are still, filled with these superstitions. People were and still are prejudiced about certain things and probably always will be. But will Lochiel bring all of her nineteen years plus out in the open, even if, it may mean, facing things she didn't know and may not want to know? The author gives inspiration to those who have been and are plagued by similar situations. Don't kid yourself. IT happens, even in today's society. True this is fiction but sometimes fiction is just a fine line before you enter reality and the author puts this forth magnificently. You won't have a chance to pause because you must turn the pages to follow Lochiel and what is happening to her. This all started because of being born, being born with a birthmark, considered a "mark of the devil." We all have choices, it's what we do with those choices that matters.
I received a copy of this book from the author and Kregel Publications and voluntarily decided to review it. I was not required to post a review and I was not influenced in any way.
September 28, 2017
It never ceases to surprise me how beauty and tragedy can not only dwell side by side, but can be so intertwined that the full beauty could not exist without the tragedy. Today I get to review a book that powerfully depicts such an intertwining.
Liar’s Winter by Cindy K. Sproles is the story of a young woman who has known nothing but shame her entire life. For the superstition-ridden mountain folk among whom she lives, any little anomaly is the sign of evil, and Lochiel Ogle is living proof of that harsh reality. Born with a red-wine birthmark on one side of her face and neck, Lochiel has been raised with the understanding that the mark brands her as the Devil’s own daughter. Time and again she is reminded that her birth mother discarded her in fear and she would not be alive at all were it not for the kindness of the Ogles who have hidden her away and protected her from the prying eyes of the mountain folk.
But when Lochiel’s brother attacks her and leaves her for dead, the hands of a stranger bring rescue and an introduction to the world beyond the Ogle’s yard. Even more than that, her rescuer possesses a kindness - a real love - that plants seeds of doubt in her mind. Did the man she called Poppy and the woman she called Momma ever truly love her? Or had their raising been something else entirely?
I honestly did not know what to expect when I picked up this novel. The description intrigued me, but I anticipated that I would read it, review it, then stick it on my shelf and forget about it. The opposite occurred. Liar’s Winter captivated me from page one. I felt drawn into Lochiel’s very soul as I watched events unfold from her perspective. Superstition, abuse, fear, and stubbornness collided with love and faith as Lochiel slowly discovered the truth about her nineteen years of life and the people she called family. Each page made me want to turn another, and even in the memory I’m drawn back into the powerful story Cindy K. Sproles weaves through every scene. This is a book I want to read and reread, share with friends and my children, discuss, and explore.
Liar’s Winter is not an easy book to read, by any means, especially knowing that these mentalities and this sort of abuse ran rampant throughout history and continue even into our day and age. This is the real reason I want my children to read it, as they reach an appropriate age. They need to know what this world hands out, and they need to see how they can either be rescuers or bring additional harm. Most of all, though, the can see that the powerful love of God shines beautifully even through the darkest of circumstances.
This is my first experience with Cindy K. Sproles, but it will not be my last, and I will definitely not hesitate to recommend Liar’s Winter.
I received this book from Kregel Publications in exchange for my honest review.
Liar’s Winter by Cindy K. Sproles is the story of a young woman who has known nothing but shame her entire life. For the superstition-ridden mountain folk among whom she lives, any little anomaly is the sign of evil, and Lochiel Ogle is living proof of that harsh reality. Born with a red-wine birthmark on one side of her face and neck, Lochiel has been raised with the understanding that the mark brands her as the Devil’s own daughter. Time and again she is reminded that her birth mother discarded her in fear and she would not be alive at all were it not for the kindness of the Ogles who have hidden her away and protected her from the prying eyes of the mountain folk.
But when Lochiel’s brother attacks her and leaves her for dead, the hands of a stranger bring rescue and an introduction to the world beyond the Ogle’s yard. Even more than that, her rescuer possesses a kindness - a real love - that plants seeds of doubt in her mind. Did the man she called Poppy and the woman she called Momma ever truly love her? Or had their raising been something else entirely?
I honestly did not know what to expect when I picked up this novel. The description intrigued me, but I anticipated that I would read it, review it, then stick it on my shelf and forget about it. The opposite occurred. Liar’s Winter captivated me from page one. I felt drawn into Lochiel’s very soul as I watched events unfold from her perspective. Superstition, abuse, fear, and stubbornness collided with love and faith as Lochiel slowly discovered the truth about her nineteen years of life and the people she called family. Each page made me want to turn another, and even in the memory I’m drawn back into the powerful story Cindy K. Sproles weaves through every scene. This is a book I want to read and reread, share with friends and my children, discuss, and explore.
Liar’s Winter is not an easy book to read, by any means, especially knowing that these mentalities and this sort of abuse ran rampant throughout history and continue even into our day and age. This is the real reason I want my children to read it, as they reach an appropriate age. They need to know what this world hands out, and they need to see how they can either be rescuers or bring additional harm. Most of all, though, the can see that the powerful love of God shines beautifully even through the darkest of circumstances.
This is my first experience with Cindy K. Sproles, but it will not be my last, and I will definitely not hesitate to recommend Liar’s Winter.
I received this book from Kregel Publications in exchange for my honest review.
September 26, 2017
Liar's Winter
By Cindy K. Sproles
I read the author’s first book Mercy’s Rain and could not wait to read this one! She is an incredibly talented writer that not only entertains but rivets your heart and mind to the story, bringing home incredible biblical truths.
The Appalachians and the unique people that live there have long fascinated me. Ms. Sproles was raised in the Appalachian mountains so her stories have a realism inherent from understanding the people, their ways, and their traditions.
Lochiel Ogle was born in the Tennessee mountains during the late 1800’s. Through no fault of her own, she had a large red birth mark on her face and neck. The superstition of the hills deemed it a “mark of the devil.” Due to the fear associated with this belief she suffered isolation and abuse by her adopted family.
As a young boy, her brother Gerald came upon the cabin where her mother had just given birth to her. The mother, in deep sleep was assumed dead by the boy. He was hoping a baby would ease his mother’s grief from the babies she had lost. Of course because of the mark, the infant was rejected and became a young woman filled with anger, hurt and confusion. She truly believed the curse and that the devil controlled her.
When she was 19 years old her brother tried to kill her and left her for dead. A compassionate Christian man named Walton found her and took her to his elderly mother, Edna. There for the first time in her life Lochiel, experienced love, kindness, acceptance and nurturing. While these were all very important needs, the greatest gift Edna gave her was to introduce her to God and His Word. Gently and lovingly she began to teach Lochiel that there was no curse and that she was not evil. Slowly Edna’s Christ like ways and teachings began to change Lochiel. It brought home that what we see has a horrible situation is God working to bless us.
This is an incredible story of forgiveness and love beyond what most of us cannot even begin to grasp. I saw God’s power working in Lochiel’s life in unimaginable ways. Suspense and surprise do not even begin to describe this novel. You will not be able to put it down! If you only read one fiction book this year, this is the one!
I received this book from Kregel Publishing. This is an honest review and the opinions stated are my own.
By Cindy K. Sproles
I read the author’s first book Mercy’s Rain and could not wait to read this one! She is an incredibly talented writer that not only entertains but rivets your heart and mind to the story, bringing home incredible biblical truths.
The Appalachians and the unique people that live there have long fascinated me. Ms. Sproles was raised in the Appalachian mountains so her stories have a realism inherent from understanding the people, their ways, and their traditions.
Lochiel Ogle was born in the Tennessee mountains during the late 1800’s. Through no fault of her own, she had a large red birth mark on her face and neck. The superstition of the hills deemed it a “mark of the devil.” Due to the fear associated with this belief she suffered isolation and abuse by her adopted family.
As a young boy, her brother Gerald came upon the cabin where her mother had just given birth to her. The mother, in deep sleep was assumed dead by the boy. He was hoping a baby would ease his mother’s grief from the babies she had lost. Of course because of the mark, the infant was rejected and became a young woman filled with anger, hurt and confusion. She truly believed the curse and that the devil controlled her.
When she was 19 years old her brother tried to kill her and left her for dead. A compassionate Christian man named Walton found her and took her to his elderly mother, Edna. There for the first time in her life Lochiel, experienced love, kindness, acceptance and nurturing. While these were all very important needs, the greatest gift Edna gave her was to introduce her to God and His Word. Gently and lovingly she began to teach Lochiel that there was no curse and that she was not evil. Slowly Edna’s Christ like ways and teachings began to change Lochiel. It brought home that what we see has a horrible situation is God working to bless us.
This is an incredible story of forgiveness and love beyond what most of us cannot even begin to grasp. I saw God’s power working in Lochiel’s life in unimaginable ways. Suspense and surprise do not even begin to describe this novel. You will not be able to put it down! If you only read one fiction book this year, this is the one!
I received this book from Kregel Publishing. This is an honest review and the opinions stated are my own.
September 25, 2017
What would it be like to have a birthmark on your face that makes people think you are a devil's child? How would it feel to never be loved and hidden from everybody? Lochiel knows what it feels like since birth to have everyone hate you and abuse you. The story is very emotional and I cried the entire time. Lochiel has been treated so badly all her life and for some reason her brother wants to kill her. The author grabs your heart with intense words and peels away each layer as the story digs deeper into your soul with emotions that leaves you gasping for air.
My heart went out to Lochiel immediately. It is hard when you feel different and everyone turns their back on you. All her life she wanted to feel loved and wanted. What she got was pain, rejection and a feeling of hopelessness. Someone comes into her life at a time where she is desperate for help. This person will change her life and show her the true meaning of unconditional love. The author vividly describes the vicious attacks Lochiel has endured during her young life. There are a couple of characters in the book that have a great impact on Lochiel. She will find safety and feel the presence of God when she needs Him the most.
I will mention one very special character that captured my heart with her kindness. Miss Edna is a woman that looks past Lochiel's birthmark and sees a person that God loves. She doesn't judge her, is not afraid of her , but takes her under her wings and shares wisdom and compassion with her. Her gentle touch makes Lochiel feel important and wanted. This book is one you can't put down and will stay with you forever. It is a book that shows what forgives feels like and how unconditional love covers a multitude of sin.
"Folks like me and you, we look past what's on the outside and dig into the soul."
I received a copy of this book from Kregel Publications. The review is my own opinion.
My heart went out to Lochiel immediately. It is hard when you feel different and everyone turns their back on you. All her life she wanted to feel loved and wanted. What she got was pain, rejection and a feeling of hopelessness. Someone comes into her life at a time where she is desperate for help. This person will change her life and show her the true meaning of unconditional love. The author vividly describes the vicious attacks Lochiel has endured during her young life. There are a couple of characters in the book that have a great impact on Lochiel. She will find safety and feel the presence of God when she needs Him the most.
I will mention one very special character that captured my heart with her kindness. Miss Edna is a woman that looks past Lochiel's birthmark and sees a person that God loves. She doesn't judge her, is not afraid of her , but takes her under her wings and shares wisdom and compassion with her. Her gentle touch makes Lochiel feel important and wanted. This book is one you can't put down and will stay with you forever. It is a book that shows what forgives feels like and how unconditional love covers a multitude of sin.
"Folks like me and you, we look past what's on the outside and dig into the soul."
I received a copy of this book from Kregel Publications. The review is my own opinion.
October 17, 2018
Wow. What a story. This is frankly one of the best stories I’ve read in recent times. Certainly in 2018. It is simply breathtaking as another reviewer mentions.
Lochiel (‘low-kill’) Ogle was born with a birthmark that disfigured one side of her face all the way down her neck and shoulder. In the late nineteenth century such disfigurement was considered the work of the Devil. Lochiel, as a baby, is taken from her sleeping mother’s arms and ‘adopted’ by another family. Besides having this birthmark she is also part Cherokee Indian that adds to the complexity of her background.
We meet Lochiel at 19 with frequent backstory inserts by her brother, Gerald, plus her own reflections. When we meet her she has been left for dead having been bashed by Gerald. He dumps her in the forest only for her to be found by a wandering trader who goes by the name of Walt. Walt rescues her but we’re soon involved in a chase when Gerald finds out she is still alive. Driven by hatred, Gerard wants her dead.
The themes of racism, superstitions, sibling rivalry, not fitting in, abandonment, familial love are powerfully woven through this story. Love, forgiveness, and God’s truth are contrasted against the hatred and bitterness born out differences between cultures and race.
We see the transformation of a young girl from being fearful, untrusting non-believing to a loving, secure in God’s love young woman.
The descriptions of the Appalachian mountains is spectacular as we follow Lochiel and Walt in a journey that transcends the beauty of nature but also the wonder of familial love and faith.
It is edge-of-the-seats suspenseful and spoken in the first person mostly by Lochiel we get to experience her native tongue (which I love) and all the variety of emotions she experiences on this journey of discovery and redemption.
Perhaps it wrapped up a little too well but that would be my only slight criticism.
Lochiel (‘low-kill’) Ogle was born with a birthmark that disfigured one side of her face all the way down her neck and shoulder. In the late nineteenth century such disfigurement was considered the work of the Devil. Lochiel, as a baby, is taken from her sleeping mother’s arms and ‘adopted’ by another family. Besides having this birthmark she is also part Cherokee Indian that adds to the complexity of her background.
We meet Lochiel at 19 with frequent backstory inserts by her brother, Gerald, plus her own reflections. When we meet her she has been left for dead having been bashed by Gerald. He dumps her in the forest only for her to be found by a wandering trader who goes by the name of Walt. Walt rescues her but we’re soon involved in a chase when Gerald finds out she is still alive. Driven by hatred, Gerard wants her dead.
The themes of racism, superstitions, sibling rivalry, not fitting in, abandonment, familial love are powerfully woven through this story. Love, forgiveness, and God’s truth are contrasted against the hatred and bitterness born out differences between cultures and race.
We see the transformation of a young girl from being fearful, untrusting non-believing to a loving, secure in God’s love young woman.
The descriptions of the Appalachian mountains is spectacular as we follow Lochiel and Walt in a journey that transcends the beauty of nature but also the wonder of familial love and faith.
It is edge-of-the-seats suspenseful and spoken in the first person mostly by Lochiel we get to experience her native tongue (which I love) and all the variety of emotions she experiences on this journey of discovery and redemption.
Perhaps it wrapped up a little too well but that would be my only slight criticism.
January 6, 2026
OVERALL STAR RATING: 5/5
CLEAN RATING: 5/5
A STUNNING work of Christian fiction! I read Mercy’s Rain last year, which was my very first experience with Cindy’s writing and I knew then that I had to dive into more of her work. Liar’s Winter did NOT disappoint. Equally as captivating. 100% unputdownable – a story that will break your heart but change you from the inside out and give you an open window view into the way God can heal even the biggest of hurts and weave tragic stories into ones filled with beauty and hope.
Cindy’s stories are raw and authentic Appalachian Mountain tales. They’re gritty, shocking and written in such an authentic way that’ll have you feeling the danger, pain and heartache of her characters within your very soul. Ultimately, they will renew your faith and trust in God and make you see so many things of this world from a different perspective. Though more historical in nature, the lessons found within the pages of Cindy’s books can absolutely be applied to modern day.
This here is the story of Lochiel Ogle, born with a red birthmark which consumed a large portion of her face. The Mountain people labeled her as having received “the mark of the Devil”. She has spent her entire 19 years of existence dodging both verbal and physical abuse as an outcast. Her very own brother wants to see her dead. The amount of hate Lochiel has withstood her entire life has just about brought her to a breaking point when a stranger finds her in the woods and guides her towards rescue and recovery. The details that unfold from this run-in with a caring stranger would contain too many spoilers to dive into here but trust me that you’re going to want to pick this one up and read what happens.
Reading through more of Cindy’s work is high on my list of goals for 2026!
*For more reviews and bookish content, be sure to follow me on Instagram @aliciasbooksanctuary
CLEAN RATING: 5/5
A STUNNING work of Christian fiction! I read Mercy’s Rain last year, which was my very first experience with Cindy’s writing and I knew then that I had to dive into more of her work. Liar’s Winter did NOT disappoint. Equally as captivating. 100% unputdownable – a story that will break your heart but change you from the inside out and give you an open window view into the way God can heal even the biggest of hurts and weave tragic stories into ones filled with beauty and hope.
Cindy’s stories are raw and authentic Appalachian Mountain tales. They’re gritty, shocking and written in such an authentic way that’ll have you feeling the danger, pain and heartache of her characters within your very soul. Ultimately, they will renew your faith and trust in God and make you see so many things of this world from a different perspective. Though more historical in nature, the lessons found within the pages of Cindy’s books can absolutely be applied to modern day.
This here is the story of Lochiel Ogle, born with a red birthmark which consumed a large portion of her face. The Mountain people labeled her as having received “the mark of the Devil”. She has spent her entire 19 years of existence dodging both verbal and physical abuse as an outcast. Her very own brother wants to see her dead. The amount of hate Lochiel has withstood her entire life has just about brought her to a breaking point when a stranger finds her in the woods and guides her towards rescue and recovery. The details that unfold from this run-in with a caring stranger would contain too many spoilers to dive into here but trust me that you’re going to want to pick this one up and read what happens.
Reading through more of Cindy’s work is high on my list of goals for 2026!
*For more reviews and bookish content, be sure to follow me on Instagram @aliciasbooksanctuary
September 26, 2017
Monday, September 25, 2017
Liar's Winter: An Appalachian Novel by Cindy K. Sproles, © 2017
An incredibly beautiful story woven in the truth of revealed overcoming love.
1893 East Tennessee ~
Lochiel Ogle has been hidden away from Love, unaware of the touch of life that will enfold her and expose beauty.
Climb the mountains of Appalachia and view the sunrises and sunsets high above the valley glens beneath. The movement in this story will bring you along, sad to leave them behind at the end. The author brought me to tears with her touching words of vision and hope displayed, lovingly given and honored bringing joy to the bearers.
I would love to read a sequel to this story!
The secondary characters have been robbed as well. Gerald Ogle hoped to revive his mother by his gift, but her life dwindles and so does his dream of restoring what has been lost. A disparity of hearts torn with anger brings this family to ruin.
Choice. Bitterness or forgiveness shaping a life affects those distant or near. Lives interwoven bring release or bondage by their presence. Walton Grubbs has never given up hope of restoring what is his. As he travels the hillsides, he becomes beloved by those he meets and is trusted. This has a lot of bearing on the story as being associated with him brings you into places that would not be opened to you without his proven character.
Step out on the porch early in the foggy morning. So vividly written, I enjoyed the characters who displayed remarkable insight into receiving another. The assurance of God's presence in their midst enables them to move ahead to remarkable outcomes of mercy and grace.
***Thank you, Kregel Publications, for inviting me on this book tour for Cindy K. Sproles' novel, Liar's Winter, and sending me a copy. This review was written in my own words. No other compensation was received.***
Liar's Winter: An Appalachian Novel by Cindy K. Sproles, © 2017
An incredibly beautiful story woven in the truth of revealed overcoming love.
1893 East Tennessee ~
Lochiel Ogle has been hidden away from Love, unaware of the touch of life that will enfold her and expose beauty.
Climb the mountains of Appalachia and view the sunrises and sunsets high above the valley glens beneath. The movement in this story will bring you along, sad to leave them behind at the end. The author brought me to tears with her touching words of vision and hope displayed, lovingly given and honored bringing joy to the bearers.
I would love to read a sequel to this story!
The secondary characters have been robbed as well. Gerald Ogle hoped to revive his mother by his gift, but her life dwindles and so does his dream of restoring what has been lost. A disparity of hearts torn with anger brings this family to ruin.
Choice. Bitterness or forgiveness shaping a life affects those distant or near. Lives interwoven bring release or bondage by their presence. Walton Grubbs has never given up hope of restoring what is his. As he travels the hillsides, he becomes beloved by those he meets and is trusted. This has a lot of bearing on the story as being associated with him brings you into places that would not be opened to you without his proven character.
Step out on the porch early in the foggy morning. So vividly written, I enjoyed the characters who displayed remarkable insight into receiving another. The assurance of God's presence in their midst enables them to move ahead to remarkable outcomes of mercy and grace.
***Thank you, Kregel Publications, for inviting me on this book tour for Cindy K. Sproles' novel, Liar's Winter, and sending me a copy. This review was written in my own words. No other compensation was received.***
Displaying 1 - 30 of 134 reviews