This is probably more of a 3 1/2 star book, in my opinion. The strength for me is that it is based very much on the true story about displacement of an African American community during the early 20th century. I'm grateful to have found the book and to have learned about this piece of the shameful treatment of Black Americans. From an historic perspective, Martin does a good job of bringing in many of the issues that arose at that time, including Garvey's return to Africa movement, Jim Crow laws, the interdependence of the Black and White communities, and treatment of women.
The book is well-written in that it maintained tension and interest. What I found less effective was the character development. The characters are broad enough so as to not be stereotypes, but in some cases just barely. There just seemed to be a lack of depth in most of them.
I also found some of the white characters to be just a bit too good-- the amount of interracial love seemed disproportionate, and a couple characters, such as Gleason, just seemed unrealistically dedicated to helping the Black community. The Bells- Andrew and Kizer-- also seemed at points to be just too good to be believed; however, Andrew proves to be a coward and Kizer at one point implores his father to use the 'influence' of the KKK, so that made them a bit more multi-dimensional and realistic for the times.
I was glad that the 'happily ever after' romance I was anticipating did not happen.
The story does a nice job of presenting and explaining the Catch-22 in which Little Jones finds himself, which I imagine was a very real situation for many Black people. All in all, I'm glad to have read the book and to know more about the history of Quakertown and Denton.