Unfortunately for Stephen Long, I read his Thirty-Eight immediately after reading a book by John McPhee. McPhee is a master of the extended expository essay, and he often tackles topics that involve science, as Long does in this book. McPhee's books are built like Swiss watches and the author is barely visible within the narrative, which creates the odd effect of experiencing whatever events he is writing about, but with subtext. It is like going through life with a voice-over narrator in your head, providing you with all sorts of background information that explains what you are witnessing. While Long may be aiming for that, he seems like too personable a guy to operate with McPhee's controlled remove.
The result is a book about the New England hurricane of 1938 that takes an original perspective—what was the storm's effect on the region's forest?—and presents the voices of a lot of interesting people who either still remembered the maelstrom they had experienced over 70 years earlier or study it (and events like it) for a living. Long leans heavily on the personnel at Harvard Forest in Petersham, Mass., which was badly damaged by the hurricane, but he also speaks with farmers and loggers/millers from New Hampshire and Vermont whose families were directly affected and worked hard to recover from the economic blow.
Eighty or 90 percent of northern New England is forested and the forest-products industry employs a lot of people and generates a lot of income for municipalities throughout the region. Most readers of this book probably don't know this and Long does not really go into it in any detail, so the uninitiated may think this is 300 pages about some esoteric obsession. Who cares about the forest? some might say. What about the people? (That is what a lot of the 1- and 2-star reviewers said, anyway.) In fact, more present-day residents of the this region are more likely to take the forest for granted than did so in 1938. Very little of the population growth in New Hampshire or Vermont has consisted of people who were interested in either forestry as a career or forest stewardship as a duty of land ownership. The forest for most people is just scenery.
Long, who is the founding editor of Northern Woodlands magazine, is at his best when he is writing about forest ecology. Thirty-Eight is an unexpectedly good primer on this topic. He also briefly but clearly describes what the forest was like before European settlement and how that cultural event changed it. The forest that was knocked over in 1938 was a very different one than was hit by the hurricane of 1635 or 1816. He does not, however, describe the evolution of the forest-products industry as fully, which is a shame because much forest ecology was funded in order to create the scientific approach to timber harvest that now characterizes the whole enterprise.
The big player in New England is the eastern white pine, which is the tallest tree in the region's forest. That height and the nature of its canopy means it catches the wind and gets knocked over more easily than hardwoods. White pine is a pioneer species that germinates and grows well in sunshine. This means it became much more common after New England's farmland was abandoned than it was before the land was cleared for agriculture. Sugar maples were also made locally more common because of the historical economic importance of sugaring as a supplementary income. The shallow-rooted maples in their sugar-bushes went over in the 100-mile-per-hour winds too.
Long lives in Corinth, Vt., which was hit hard by the '38 hurricane. Toward the end of the book he does a little of his own research to understand better some of the phenomena he sees on the landscape around his home. This is interesting but he skates through it pretty quickly. It would have been more interesting had he drilled down into this aspect of his narrative and integrated it better with his stories of the farming families that he told us about earlier.
This is a good book, and it is about an event that is going to recur and will probably wreak even more havoc, as Long is at pains to point out in the final chapter, the next time a full-size hurricane (not a tropical storm or a nor'easter) comes through. The author is very clear about the likely consequences. For one thing, the New Deal was in full swing in 1938 and therefore the government managed this disaster well. The timber felled by the storm could have flooded the market and ruined the industry, but instead the federal goverment set up storage areas for the wood, paid landowners for the salvage, and released it into the market slowly. Much of it was used for the war effort three years later. We live in a very different political climate now, even more different from '38 than 2012, when this book was published. When the next hurricane hits, we will be much more on our own. And it won't be pretty.