I really liked The Lonely Girl. It was refreshing to find a book about university students that wasn’t set in Stanford or Harvard or Yale. This one was set at Lakehead University – not my alma mater, but enough like it that it brought back memories of those long lost years of residence life, cramming for exams and agonizing over romantic entanglements and hearts broken over slights and missteps, real or imagined.
If you’re a fan of happily ever after romances, The Lonely Girl is not for you. The story Gracie Wilson has crafted (it is technically very well written by the way) is very much a tragedy in the traditional sense, awash in “tragic” characters who just can’t seem to catch a break, it is fraught with miscommunications, mistakes (sometimes fatal) and at least one villain, genuinely evil and driven to madness by a need for revenge.
I can’t say I actually liked our heroine, Becka Potts, but that’s okay. It’s not the first time I’ve been riveted by a story, at least partly because I wanted to grab the main character, give them a good shake, and tell them to get their act together and stop being a victim. It happens often with work by Canadian icon Margaret Atwood (The Handmaiden’s Tale comes immediately to mind) and, for that matter, with Hamlet, Macbeth and most of the classic tragedies I studied back in those university days I mentioned earlier.
Becka’s life has been an ongoing tragedy, with one dead boyfriend, a second prone to violence and an uncanny knack for getting involved with men who can’t fully commit to her alone. It’s like the proverbial train wreck. You know, from the moment she meets Kegan and Jake (it can’t be coincidence that she meets both on the same day) that nothing good can come of this whole situation, but it’s like the proverbial train wreck, or indeed, history’s truly great tragedies. You can feel the sense of foreboding, but you just can’t look away.
In the end, after all she’s been through, it doesn’t come as much of as surprise that by book 2 of the series, she’s gone from being lonely to being The Broken Girl. We can only hope that, like the heroes of so many other multi tale epics, having finally hit bottom she can begin to rebuild her life, and somewhere in future pages, she will find a tranquil and peaceful existence, even if she never finds true love or complete happiness.
I don’t know if the worst is over for Becka, but I’ll definitely be back to find out.