Jennette Fulda bites the bullet, changes her lifestyle, eating habits, and exercise habits, and loses 200 pounds, not because she hates fat people, but because her fat is making her sick. She's concerned about dying from all the medical risks brought through being obese. She's living with her mom, and can't walk across a parking lot without getting winded. It takes a few years, but she reaches her goal, learns to love herself, and chronicles the entire journey in her blog, pastaqueen.com.
My primary issue with this book is that it is about 150 pages too long. Her lifestyle changes were based on "eat less, move more" philosophies, so the book is *not* a "magical cure" for obesity - I get it. I agree. It's a memoir. It's about her feelings through the weightloss journey. Oftentimes, I felt like she had blog disease of the mouth -- too much emotional processing with too little context. I felt like this book was another great example of what happens when blogs become books without a really strong editorial hand. We like blogs because they are quick, egalitarian, timely. We do! Well, I do! I look for different things in a book.
Fulda struggled with the Fat Acceptance community online especially. In some circles, trying to lose weight can be seen as selling out everyone else who's not trying to lose weight. It can be taboo to even talk about the changes you are making - what if you don't reach your goal? What if other people feel alienated as your weight comes off? It seems she made some enemies and got banned from a few messageboards, and had some nasty comments left on her blog. It was exhausting to read. I missed her online spats, and I don't know about her history in the FA/weight-loss communities, so I don't know the other side of the story, but I was left certain that there IS another side.
A lot of the questions Fulda explores are worth asking - how to accept and love your overweight body without becoming complacent or endangering your health? How to lose weight and not friends? How to explain that different things work for different people, when everyone wants to know your "magic secrets"? How to learn to cook and enjoy your food in moderation, develop healthy cooking/eating/shopping habits without adopting a fad/yo-yo diet? Some people know these things, other people don't. Fulda was defensive half of the time, and just rambling for the other half.
This review could go on forever, so I'll try to keep it short. I felt like the book was too long. Since there was no "magical" solution to Fulda's health issues, there is nothing concrete you could replicate in your life. Fulda spends so much time with self-deprecating humor and repeating over and over that she doesn't want to be an inspiration to other people -- by the end of the book, it's like, why did you write this, then?
I spent at least the last 150 pages punching myself in the face trying to finish this, and it is only because of my willpower that I was able to get through it. The final introspective moments in the last chapter were insightful but it was too-little-too-late to redeem the rest of the tedious book.
I wish I kept better track of where the recommendations I get come from, so that I could let someone know that this was a F for FAIL.