I normally enjoy Lawrence Watt-Evans. His Ethshar novels were clever, grounded, and full of the quiet worldbuilding that makes you feel like you’re peeking into a living society. Unfortunately, this collection didn’t land for me the same way.
Most of the stories here feel like fragments of bigger ideas, premises that might’ve grown into great novels but instead stop just as they get interesting. A few are fun or intriguing, but many read more like notes from his worldbuilding journal than finished tales. It’s uneven, and while the imagination is there, the execution often isn’t.
That said, two stories did stand out: “Out of the Woods” and “Best Present Ever.” Both showed real promise and left me wishing Watt-Evans had expanded them into full novels. You can see flashes of his usual wit and craftsmanship there, the same strengths that make his longer works shine.
I’ve been picking at this book for months, reading a story here and there, hoping for one that really clicks. The pacing and tone are all over the place, and I found myself wishing he’d had room to let these ideas breathe.
Still, you can glimpse what makes Watt-Evans worth reading: the dry humor, the logical magic, and the sense that ordinary people matter in extraordinary worlds. Fans of his novels might find some curiosities here, but if you’re new to him, start elsewhere (The Misenchanted Sword or With a Single Spell).
Bottom line: a mixed bag, occasionally insightful, mostly frustrating. It reminded me how much better Watt-Evans is at the long game than the short one.