I first watched Tales from the Darkside on a sick day home from high school. I was browsing daytime cable, bored, when I flipped to the Sci-fi Channel. At the time (and maybe to this day; I don't know, I don't watch cable anymore) the Sci-fi Channel had a habit of airing old episodes of The Twilight Zone in between other scheduled programming. When I saw the opening credits of "Halloween Candy," I immediately felt the same genuine curiosity that the old TW episodes gave me. The episode was effectively creepy and left a serious impression on me, but I could never remember the name of the show.
Years later, I did some research, ordered the complete series, and started watching. I've always loved short stories, and a good anthology series is basically the equivalent of a good collection of short stories. Barring some stinkers, Tales from the Darkside was generally a strong series!
Unfortunately, this collection is not. Joe Hill has his heart in the right place, I think, but the attempts to connect the stories to a larger mythology are just... lame, I guess? One of the best things about the original series is its discrete nature! Of course, the narrator references a general thematic connectedness, like Rod Serling did in the original Twilight Zone, but it never went so far as to establish a "Darkside-verse," and it was better for it.
A missed attempt at connecting the stories could be fine if the stories themselves were memorable, but unfortunately they come off as trite and generic. The art (by Gabriel Rodriguez) is generally good, but not exceptional. So, ultimately, we're left with a lacking collection. I did really enjoy the interview with Hill and Rodriguez at the end of the collection--they clearly have a passion for the original show. It just makes it all the more disappointing that it didn't come together as something better than this.