Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Digital Love: Romance and Sexuality in Games

Rate this book
Scholars and professionals from all over the world, across experience levels and the gender and sexuality spectrum, share experiences and analysis of romance and sexuality in video games.

Whether discussing casual sex in the Star Wars universe; analyzing various Otome games; examining "the gaze" in various games; player romance behavior in games; or exploring the ethical ramifications of sexuality in virtual reality and other emerging technologies, this book discusses what players want in video game romance, and how developers can best deliver it.

Key



Examines the past, present, and future of romance in single-player, role-playing games

Discusses common presentations of romance in single-player, role-playing games― both in the category and game mechanics that drive romance

Discusses research on how players define a satisfying game romance and what specific steps narrative designers can take to design satisfying games

Explains the notion of the empathic game and explores its importance in relation to romance in game design

316 pages, Paperback

Published November 14, 2017

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Heidi McDonald

17 books1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
3 (33%)
4 stars
4 (44%)
3 stars
2 (22%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
Profile Image for attronoctis.
19 reviews
January 7, 2026
4.5 stars.

This book deepened my appreciation for the immense work that goes into narrative-driven game development. I have previously read books about the storytelling, design, and social play aspects, all of which illuminated different facets of the whole. I read these books more out of curiosity than as part of any serious scientific inquiry, so my review is colored by that. As the book itself is an edited volume written by researchers of different areas and levels of expertise, I'll focus on the concepts that grabbed my attention and made me ponder, specifically in terms of narrative-driven video games.

Despite what the title might suggest, the book investigates several issues: self-concept, identity, immersion, and social effects, among others, through the lens of romance.

There is a chapter that mentions how the limitations or the absence of avatar customization affect immersion and self-experience. I personally have a recent example of this happening, in Dragon’s Dogma 2. The original game allows adjusting the avatar’s height, which is not a widespread feature. This matters to me as a short woman: being able to play a physically small but competent character makes the fantasy more accessible. In the sequel, however, the minimum height was raised to 160 cm to prevent the creation of “childlike” avatars. This soured my initial experience, as my body was not only treated as invalid but also indirectly compared to that of a child. This perfectly illustrated to me how even minor design choices can activate self-doubt and damage immersion, and I could emphasize with the author who shared a similar experience. Of course here we could speculate whether such breaks in immersion are amplified by underlying self-confidence or body-image issues (and vice-versa), or whether a sufficiently solid self-concept could remain unaffected by such constraints. This is exactly what I enjoyed most about this book: it raises questions and opens them up for reflection.

Another issue concerns the line between user freedom and authorial or historical constraints. My personal experience with this happened in Medieval Blacksmith. The game lets you choose whether to play as a male or female character. The settlement where the game takes place features a “brothel” that contains only female dancers, and there is a Steam achievement tied to “spending time” with one of them. The interaction is not explicit at all, but it is unavoidable if one wishes for 100% completion. The player’s gender choice is acknowledged through dialogue, but completely ignored in this scenario. This left me wondering: when should developers expand options to respect the agency of the player, and when should they restrict the number of choices to preserve realism or narrative intent? Which one should take higher priority? I do believe this is a “damned if I do, damned if I don’t” issue for the developers, where either choice will inevitably alienate a part of the audience.

A related issue that was mentioned in the book appears in Dragon Age: Inquisition, where romance options have their sexual preferences: while some of them are pansexual, others are gender-locked or even species-locked. However, community made mods exist specifically to remove these constraints. This raised further questions in me: should NPCs be “allowed” to reject the player, or does that violate an unspoken assumption of role-playing games? Should the choice to restrict the player be respected? Is it self-serving of the community to change these intended preferences simply because they want them to be different? I find this to be another intriguing conflict between player agency and a simulated social reality, especially due to how the newest RPGs (Baldur’s Gate 3, Veilguard, the latest expansions of SWTOR, etc.) feature fully pansexual romance options. This phenomenon has since then been mockingly termed “playersexual”, and a part of me understands.

Talking about user agency, one chapter introduced a view of dialogues that had never truly occurred to me before. Some players experience conversation options as the internal thoughts of the player character: all available choices already exist within the character, and selecting one is simply deciding which thought becomes action. From this perspective a missing choice is not a design limitation, but rather something that never occurred to the character at all. Apparently this can cause outrage in players as they can consider their character “dumb” for not thinking of a specific scenario or choice, damaging immersion. And I found this to be such a wild notion, because it stands in direct opposition to how I experience dialogues. I rather see options as externally imposed directions I can steer the character towards, and I interpret missing choices as flaws in the design. The alternatives I do not select are not thoughts my character suppressed, but rather choices I was never meant to make, my character never “wanted” to make. Reading this section opened up some perspective into how others might think, and how fundamentally different interpretations of a feature can exist.

My favorite chapter, “Designing Video Game Characters for Romantic Attachment,” presents the results of a survey in which players could detail how and why they form attachments to characters, and what they find most important. The discussion treats these parasocial bonds without mockery, in a mature and non-judgmental way, which I found refreshing. The one finding that especially stood out to me was the following (and I paraphrase): players who are primarily physically attracted to NPCs tend to do so out of escapism and generally remain outside fan communities, while those with emotional attachment are more socially embedded into the fandom. This directly contradicts the lazy assumption I have seen on forums that women only like certain characters due to them being “conventionally attractive”. I suspected this to be a reductive reasoning aimed at ridiculing others, but now I also find solace in it having been disproved by the conclusions of this study. And what I most appreciated in this chapter, apart from the survey results, were the ample references and the details about how the responses were evaluated. As someone with no background in social science I never heard about the methods of narrative analysis, and through the references provided I found it to be an intriguing concept to dive into.

There are several chapters that do not center around RPG video games but visual novels, in-person play, VR… Those chapters are similarly informative and thought-provoking, but as they did not fully align with my interests, I have not much to say about them.

I do, however, have one major criticism. One that almost made me deduct stars, though I recognize that would be petty even by my own standards. There is a chapter where catering to a more inclusive gaze is shown through the male romance options in Dragon Age: Inquisition. And one of the options, namely Blackwall, is completely missing from this analysis. In fact, across the entire book (that has frequent references to Dragon Age characters,) there is one single mention of Blackwall, and even that in a negative context. Which, frankly, part of me understands, as he is a divisive character in the fandom. But I do believe his case could have been educational to mention, if nothing else then through the symbolism of emotional nudity and the lack of thereof… but I digress.

On another note, it also made me realize how inconsistent the index is: some characters appear in the index, some appear twice, others don’t appear even though they are featured in the book.
Finally, I kept thinking about how the options in Baldur’s Gate 3 and other recent RPGs could provide a wealth of new material for similarly focused studies, given the breadth of user agency and the cast of fleshed-out and complex characters. Since then I already found a PhD-dissertation-turned-book on this topic that was just recently published, so I will have my sustenance for a little longer.

The treatment of romance in games and how players engage with it reveal a wide range of unresolved issues and open questions, and this book does an amazing job at bringing many of them into focus.

And now I have to close this review on principle: I'll forever be a Blackwall apologist. Sorry, not sorry. ; )
Profile Image for Matthew.
96 reviews27 followers
Read
November 3, 2025
Until I play mass effect I can’t write about video game romance these are the rules
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews