What do you think?
Rate this book
Darcy's Honor: A Pride and Prejudice Variation
Elizabeth Bennet is relieved when the difficult Mr. Darcy leaves the area after the Netherfield Ball. But she soon runs afoul of Lord Henry, a Viscount who thinks to force her into marrying him by slandering her name and ruining her reputation. An outcast in Meryton, and even within her own family, Elizabeth has nobody to turn to and nowhere to go.
Darcy successfully resisted Elizabeth’s charms during his visit to Hertfordshire, but when he learns of her imminent ruin, he decides he must propose to save her from disaster. However, Elizabeth is reluctant to tarnish Darcy’s name by association…and the viscount still wants her…
Can Darcy save his honor while also marrying the woman he loves?
Darcy successfully resisted Elizabeth’s charms during his visit to Hertfordshire, but when he learns of her imminent ruin, he decides he must propose to save her from disaster. However, Elizabeth is reluctant to tarnish Darcy’s name by association…and the viscount still wants her…
Can Darcy save his honor while also marrying the woman he loves?
171 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 13, 2017
49 people are currently reading
456 people want to read
About the author
Victoria Kincaid
20 books204 followersVictoria has a Ph.D. in English literature and has taught composition to unwilling college students. Today she teaches business writing to willing office professionals and tries to give voice to the demanding cast of characters in her head.
She lives in Virginia with an overly affectionate cat, two children who are learning how much fun Austen’s characters can be, and a husband who fortunately is not jealous of Mr. Darcy. A lifelong Austen fan, Victoria has read more Jane Austen variations and sequels than she can count – and confesses to an extreme partiality for the Colin Firth miniseries version of Pride and Prejudice.
Visit her at www. victoriakincaid. com
She lives in Virginia with an overly affectionate cat, two children who are learning how much fun Austen’s characters can be, and a husband who fortunately is not jealous of Mr. Darcy. A lifelong Austen fan, Victoria has read more Jane Austen variations and sequels than she can count – and confesses to an extreme partiality for the Colin Firth miniseries version of Pride and Prejudice.
Visit her at www. victoriakincaid. com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews
May 7, 2017
4 stars!
Review, Excerpt, and Giveaway at Of Pens and Pages.
This is my third Victoria Kincaid book, and so far, her books haven’t failed to give me something new and unexpected. You can always expect a fresh and riveting story from Ms. Kincaid’s variations. Darcy’s Honor was gripping, heartbreaking and warming, and engaging.
Just when Elizabeth thought she’s done with troublesome men after Mr. Darcy (and the Bingley party) left Netherfield, she’s compromised by Henry Carson, Viscount Billington. She refuses his proposal and becomes a fallen woman, losing the respect of her family—save Jane and Mr. Bennet—and the people of Meryton. Lord Henry continues to pursue her, and Mrs. Bennet and the rest of Meryton continue to judge her.
Mr. Darcy leaves Netherfield to resist Elizabeth’s charms, but when he hears of her misfortunes, he goes back with every intention of proposing. Elizabeth finds an ally in Darcy, something she never imagined would happen. Even as she gets to know the real Mr. Darcy and finds support and strength in him, Elizabeth stands her ground not to marry anyone, not even Mr. Darcy. She has no intention of staining anyone with her ruined reputation, especially not someone who’s become very important to her.
And so Mr. Darcy sees it as his task to prove Elizabeth’s innocence and help clear her name.
In this story, instead of Mr. Wickham, we have Lord Henry as our resident blackguard. He was just as bad, taking advantage of innocent women and doing everything in his power to make things go his way. Mrs. Bennet was constantly on her back, telling her to marry Lord Henry to save the family’s reputation. Mr. Bennet wasn’t any better. He believed Elizabeth was innocent, but he told her rumors will die down soon enough and did nothing to help Elizabeth.
I admired Elizabeth’s resilience and dignity. It’s hard to stay positive when you feel like the whole world is against you, but Elizabeth kept her head up and tried her best not to let it get to her.
I wasn’t a fan of a certain part of the book involving a Darcy cottage, but other than that, I still enjoyed reading this book. The story was a page-turner, and the pacing just right. There were a few surprising allies and interesting twists that added flavor to the story.
As frustrating Lord Henry and the others were, Mr. Darcy and Georgiana made up for it. They welcomed Elizabeth and helped her heal. Most of all, Darcy was steadfast in his love and devotion for Elizabeth and in his dream to make her his wife.
Darcy’s Honor is a novel told in alternating POVs. Fans of Pride and Prejudice and regency era novels will enjoy this fresh and clean story. It was a long and difficult journey for our beloved couple and for Elizabeth especially, but fear not. A happily ever after will always be there for Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth.
*ARC received in exchange for an honest review.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
Review, Excerpt, and Giveaway at Of Pens and Pages.
This is my third Victoria Kincaid book, and so far, her books haven’t failed to give me something new and unexpected. You can always expect a fresh and riveting story from Ms. Kincaid’s variations. Darcy’s Honor was gripping, heartbreaking and warming, and engaging.
Honor is what you know about yourself. Reputation is what others know about you, or believe they know.”
Just when Elizabeth thought she’s done with troublesome men after Mr. Darcy (and the Bingley party) left Netherfield, she’s compromised by Henry Carson, Viscount Billington. She refuses his proposal and becomes a fallen woman, losing the respect of her family—save Jane and Mr. Bennet—and the people of Meryton. Lord Henry continues to pursue her, and Mrs. Bennet and the rest of Meryton continue to judge her.
Mr. Darcy leaves Netherfield to resist Elizabeth’s charms, but when he hears of her misfortunes, he goes back with every intention of proposing. Elizabeth finds an ally in Darcy, something she never imagined would happen. Even as she gets to know the real Mr. Darcy and finds support and strength in him, Elizabeth stands her ground not to marry anyone, not even Mr. Darcy. She has no intention of staining anyone with her ruined reputation, especially not someone who’s become very important to her.
And so Mr. Darcy sees it as his task to prove Elizabeth’s innocence and help clear her name.
In this story, instead of Mr. Wickham, we have Lord Henry as our resident blackguard. He was just as bad, taking advantage of innocent women and doing everything in his power to make things go his way. Mrs. Bennet was constantly on her back, telling her to marry Lord Henry to save the family’s reputation. Mr. Bennet wasn’t any better. He believed Elizabeth was innocent, but he told her rumors will die down soon enough and did nothing to help Elizabeth.
I admired Elizabeth’s resilience and dignity. It’s hard to stay positive when you feel like the whole world is against you, but Elizabeth kept her head up and tried her best not to let it get to her.
I wasn’t a fan of a certain part of the book involving a Darcy cottage, but other than that, I still enjoyed reading this book. The story was a page-turner, and the pacing just right. There were a few surprising allies and interesting twists that added flavor to the story.
As frustrating Lord Henry and the others were, Mr. Darcy and Georgiana made up for it. They welcomed Elizabeth and helped her heal. Most of all, Darcy was steadfast in his love and devotion for Elizabeth and in his dream to make her his wife.
Darcy’s Honor is a novel told in alternating POVs. Fans of Pride and Prejudice and regency era novels will enjoy this fresh and clean story. It was a long and difficult journey for our beloved couple and for Elizabeth especially, but fear not. A happily ever after will always be there for Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth.
*ARC received in exchange for an honest review.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
August 5, 2025
If you have integrity, nothing else matters. If you don't have integrity, nothing else matters. ~Alan Simpson
“This is a distinction my father once made to me. Honor is what you know about yourself. Reputation is what others know about you, or believe they know.”
He cleared his throat. “The people of Meryton think they know what happened between you and Lord Henry. Thus, your reputation has suffered. But you know you did nothing wrong; your honor has not been compromised.”
Elizabeth Bennet has been compromised!
The unscrupulous Lord Henry has maneuvered her into an empty room, torn her gown and been caught kissing her. Elizabeth’s protests of innocence are unheard except by her Father and her sister Jane. Her Mother and younger sisters jump to judge and gossip.
The Bingley shrew can’t wait to share the gossip – and Darcy is determined to come to Miss Elizabeth’s aid.
Quote from the book: “A man who sought only to take advantage of her virtue would flatter her to the heavens rather than criticize her family. How odd that Mr. Darcy’s lack of tact revealed his sincerity. It must be love.”
Laws control the lesser man. Right conduct controls the greater one. ~Chinese Proverb
Mr. Collins visits with his pamphlets of instructions for Fallen Women:
Quote from the book: “Sir, it is very good of you to be concerned with the state of my soul. But as a man of the cloth, do you think you should be exposing yourself to such powerful depravity? Particularly without a wooden stake and holy water at hand?” Lydia and Kitty giggled more loudly while Mrs. Bennet looked confused, and Mary rolled her eyes. Mr. Collins, on the other hand, nodded earnestly. “I did not believe such measures were necessary, although I do have several cloves of garlic in my satchel.”
Elizabeth Bennet leaves for London and anonymity.
Quote from the book: “Elizabeth glanced about to see if anyone else was in the room. Nobody on her right, but she turned her head to the left. A young woman, tall and blonde, was doing embroidery in the chair by her bedside. Elizabeth was reassured. In the novels, kidnappers never embroidered.”
An unlikely (very unlikely) heroine clears the way to HEA.
A pure hand needs no glove to cover it. ~Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Scarlet Letter, 1850
“This is a distinction my father once made to me. Honor is what you know about yourself. Reputation is what others know about you, or believe they know.”
He cleared his throat. “The people of Meryton think they know what happened between you and Lord Henry. Thus, your reputation has suffered. But you know you did nothing wrong; your honor has not been compromised.”
Elizabeth Bennet has been compromised!
The unscrupulous Lord Henry has maneuvered her into an empty room, torn her gown and been caught kissing her. Elizabeth’s protests of innocence are unheard except by her Father and her sister Jane. Her Mother and younger sisters jump to judge and gossip.
The Bingley shrew can’t wait to share the gossip – and Darcy is determined to come to Miss Elizabeth’s aid.
Quote from the book: “A man who sought only to take advantage of her virtue would flatter her to the heavens rather than criticize her family. How odd that Mr. Darcy’s lack of tact revealed his sincerity. It must be love.”
Laws control the lesser man. Right conduct controls the greater one. ~Chinese Proverb
Mr. Collins visits with his pamphlets of instructions for Fallen Women:
Quote from the book: “Sir, it is very good of you to be concerned with the state of my soul. But as a man of the cloth, do you think you should be exposing yourself to such powerful depravity? Particularly without a wooden stake and holy water at hand?” Lydia and Kitty giggled more loudly while Mrs. Bennet looked confused, and Mary rolled her eyes. Mr. Collins, on the other hand, nodded earnestly. “I did not believe such measures were necessary, although I do have several cloves of garlic in my satchel.”
Elizabeth Bennet leaves for London and anonymity.
Quote from the book: “Elizabeth glanced about to see if anyone else was in the room. Nobody on her right, but she turned her head to the left. A young woman, tall and blonde, was doing embroidery in the chair by her bedside. Elizabeth was reassured. In the novels, kidnappers never embroidered.”
An unlikely (very unlikely) heroine clears the way to HEA.
A pure hand needs no glove to cover it. ~Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Scarlet Letter, 1850
June 5, 2017
Dear Reader,
What a delightful,adorable yet angst filled read!!!
Some men,especially those enjoying elevated ranks in society,refuse to accept that when a lady says 'no', she actually,oddly enough,means no!
Pitted against such a man,in the guise of Lord Henry Carson,whose repeated and unwanted attentions leave Lizzy naively unaware of the lengths he will go to to ensure his wishes are fulfilled,she now finds herself in a catch 22 situation.
Seemingly compromised by said Lord,in the eyes of Meryton society,who sadly believe the lies and innuendo centred on one of their own,Lizzy is now faced with the prospect of being coerced into marriage with a spoilt and arrogant man or forever living with the stain of being a fallen woman,one whose virtue was cast aside willingly and with little regard for her or her family's reputation.
Unable to bear the burden of being a social pariah,and fearing future attempts by Lord Henry to 'persuade' her to marry him,she flees to London,with an earnest wish to seek gainful employment.
What will befall her in London,will have far reaching implications for her,our dear Mr Darcy and the fiendish Lord Henry!!!
I loved this story,the endearing way Mr Darcy had our Lizzy's best interests at heart,his unfailing attempts to safeguard her and the slow burn romance that existed between the two.
What a gentleman this Darcy is,having had his proposal rejected by the keeper of his heart,he still goes out of his way to ensure Lizzy's safety,believes in her and remains by her side both physically and psychologically. My hero!!!
Highly recommended to all JAFF fans!!
I won this book on Ceri's blog-babblingsofabookworm.
My sincere thanks to both Ceri and Victoria for such a prize!!
What a delightful,adorable yet angst filled read!!!
Some men,especially those enjoying elevated ranks in society,refuse to accept that when a lady says 'no', she actually,oddly enough,means no!
Pitted against such a man,in the guise of Lord Henry Carson,whose repeated and unwanted attentions leave Lizzy naively unaware of the lengths he will go to to ensure his wishes are fulfilled,she now finds herself in a catch 22 situation.
Seemingly compromised by said Lord,in the eyes of Meryton society,who sadly believe the lies and innuendo centred on one of their own,Lizzy is now faced with the prospect of being coerced into marriage with a spoilt and arrogant man or forever living with the stain of being a fallen woman,one whose virtue was cast aside willingly and with little regard for her or her family's reputation.
Unable to bear the burden of being a social pariah,and fearing future attempts by Lord Henry to 'persuade' her to marry him,she flees to London,with an earnest wish to seek gainful employment.
What will befall her in London,will have far reaching implications for her,our dear Mr Darcy and the fiendish Lord Henry!!!
I loved this story,the endearing way Mr Darcy had our Lizzy's best interests at heart,his unfailing attempts to safeguard her and the slow burn romance that existed between the two.
What a gentleman this Darcy is,having had his proposal rejected by the keeper of his heart,he still goes out of his way to ensure Lizzy's safety,believes in her and remains by her side both physically and psychologically. My hero!!!
Highly recommended to all JAFF fans!!
I won this book on Ceri's blog-babblingsofabookworm.
My sincere thanks to both Ceri and Victoria for such a prize!!
June 21, 2018
Boy, there were a lot of annoying characters I wanted to punch out as I read this! For a change, Mr. Wickham isn't at the top of the list, though he's definitely in there. Caroline Bingley, as always, has a spot in there, as well. Mr. Collins also is annoying, albeit in a more humorous way than most of the others.
The honor of first place on my hit list goes to Lord Henry, a Viscount who starts making his moves on Elizabeth Bennet starting right after her argumentative dance with Mr. Darcy at the Netherfield ball. Elizabeth does her best to deflect Lord Henry's overtures, which includes a marriage proposal, but he orchestrates an apparent compromise of her virtue at a ball held at Lucas Lodge celebrating Charlotte's engagement to Mr. Collins.
Next in line on the list would be the rest of Elizabeth's exasperating family with the exception of Jane. All the other Bennet sisters and Mrs. Bennet believe that Elizabeth encouraged the Viscount's compromise. Lydia and Kitty think it's a great joke, Mary expounds judgmental Scriptures, and Mrs. Bennet is alternately insisting that Elizabeth marry Lord Henry and calling for her smelling salts. Even Mr. Bennet, who believes her when she explains the truth of the matter and does not demand that she marry the Viscount, does nothing more than that. He blandly assumes the gossip will blow over. That's because he's so entrenched in his study he doesn't recognize that his wife and daughters are being snubbed by all of their neighbors (who also make it onto my list).
It makes for an angst-y read during the first part of the book. Elizabeth sticks to her guns, though, proclaiming her innocence to anyone who will listen and doing her best to avoid the Viscount. He regularly calls at Longbourn to press his suit and seeks her out elsewhere, telling her that eventually he will wear down her resistance and she will agree to marry him.
Mr. Darcy has gone with Mr. Bingley to London after the Netherfield ball, as in canon, and he cannot get Elizabeth out of his mind. When the gossip about her and the Viscount reaches him (courtesy of a snide Caroline, of course), he quickly heads to Hertfordshire to her rescue. He is certain she will accept his offer of marriage to save herself from Lord Henry. Elizabeth is amazed that Mr. Darcy is one of only three people who believe in her innocence; she expected him to side with a titled gentleman's version of events over hers. His marriage proposal, predictably, leaves a bit to be desired. Regardless of that, though, Elizabeth is determined not to marry anyone unless she can clear her reputation.
Events shift from Hertfordshire to London, and Elizabeth continues to face hardships. Mrs. Haskell, running a boarding house, proves to be another villainess I added to my list.
Darcy is a patient, loving, knight-on-a-white horse throughout the book. He rescues Elizabeth more than once (though she also manages one quick-witted rescue of herself, and she rescues him from a compromise set-up, too). The second half of the book is more upbeat, with plenty of Darcy-and-Elizabeth time and the two falling in love.
There's still the problem of Elizabeth's ruined reputation to be resolved. The pivotal scene is a doozy, featuring Lord Pippinworth (a noted moral authority) and an unexpected ally.
The plot is wonderful, the writing flows nicely, the characters are well drawn (even when you feel like punching them!), and the romance is clean and sweet.
The honor of first place on my hit list goes to Lord Henry, a Viscount who starts making his moves on Elizabeth Bennet starting right after her argumentative dance with Mr. Darcy at the Netherfield ball. Elizabeth does her best to deflect Lord Henry's overtures, which includes a marriage proposal, but he orchestrates an apparent compromise of her virtue at a ball held at Lucas Lodge celebrating Charlotte's engagement to Mr. Collins.
Next in line on the list would be the rest of Elizabeth's exasperating family with the exception of Jane. All the other Bennet sisters and Mrs. Bennet believe that Elizabeth encouraged the Viscount's compromise. Lydia and Kitty think it's a great joke, Mary expounds judgmental Scriptures, and Mrs. Bennet is alternately insisting that Elizabeth marry Lord Henry and calling for her smelling salts. Even Mr. Bennet, who believes her when she explains the truth of the matter and does not demand that she marry the Viscount, does nothing more than that. He blandly assumes the gossip will blow over. That's because he's so entrenched in his study he doesn't recognize that his wife and daughters are being snubbed by all of their neighbors (who also make it onto my list).
It makes for an angst-y read during the first part of the book. Elizabeth sticks to her guns, though, proclaiming her innocence to anyone who will listen and doing her best to avoid the Viscount. He regularly calls at Longbourn to press his suit and seeks her out elsewhere, telling her that eventually he will wear down her resistance and she will agree to marry him.
Mr. Darcy has gone with Mr. Bingley to London after the Netherfield ball, as in canon, and he cannot get Elizabeth out of his mind. When the gossip about her and the Viscount reaches him (courtesy of a snide Caroline, of course), he quickly heads to Hertfordshire to her rescue. He is certain she will accept his offer of marriage to save herself from Lord Henry. Elizabeth is amazed that Mr. Darcy is one of only three people who believe in her innocence; she expected him to side with a titled gentleman's version of events over hers. His marriage proposal, predictably, leaves a bit to be desired. Regardless of that, though, Elizabeth is determined not to marry anyone unless she can clear her reputation.
Events shift from Hertfordshire to London, and Elizabeth continues to face hardships. Mrs. Haskell, running a boarding house, proves to be another villainess I added to my list.
Darcy is a patient, loving, knight-on-a-white horse throughout the book. He rescues Elizabeth more than once (though she also manages one quick-witted rescue of herself, and she rescues him from a compromise set-up, too). The second half of the book is more upbeat, with plenty of Darcy-and-Elizabeth time and the two falling in love.
There's still the problem of Elizabeth's ruined reputation to be resolved. The pivotal scene is a doozy, featuring Lord Pippinworth (a noted moral authority) and an unexpected ally.
The plot is wonderful, the writing flows nicely, the characters are well drawn (even when you feel like punching them!), and the romance is clean and sweet.
October 7, 2017
What If Elizabeth Was Compromised After the Netherfield Ball?
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
Source: Review Copy from Author
While indulging himself in a last glimpse of the unsuitable yet bewitching Elizabeth Bennet at the Netherfield Ball Mr. Darcy makes an observation about the newly introduced Viscount Billington, Lord Henry and the attention he is paying Elizabeth Bennet. Mr. Darcy suspects that the Viscount’s interest aren’t the most innocent or honorable and is pleased to see Elizabeth cleverly maneuver away from him. Despite the yearnings of Darcy’s heart, he leaves Meryton for London, and leaves Elizabeth to fall prey to the devious machinations of Lord Henry! When Darcy learns that Elizabeth’s reputation is ruined and that the Viscount is believed to have compromised her, he knows immediately how he must act. Forget reputation, society, and family – the only thing that matters is Elizabeth, and he must do what he can to save her and secure the happiness and futures of them both.
Unfortunately, Darcy finds himself faced with some resistance to his scheme, and it isn’t for the reasons you think! And so some heartache and trouble ensues… Can Darcy convince Elizabeth to be his wife? Can Elizabeth clear her name and convince others of her innocence? Or will Lord Henry achieve his dastardly scheme of stealing Elizabeth’s virtue?
Oh my! What a situation! This story immediately grabbed my attention and held me captive. Elizabeth finds herself in such a bad situation and with no one to turn to. My absolute favorite part of the story was seeing how deeply in love Darcy is with Elizabeth. Even before the scandal, he is fervently enamored and distracted with daily thoughts of her. I loved so many of Darcy’s scenes with Elizabeth and greatly admired so many of his actions in this story! His desire to reprimand the Meryton vicar, his surprise encounter with Elizabeth in the woods, his actions in London… *sigh* – he truly is the heroic, white knight, valiant rescuer with a heart so full of love it will make you swoon!!! (SLIGHT SPOILER: My heart completely melted into a puddle during the scene where Mr. Darcy acted in a very Colonel Brandon-like manner!)
Other parts of the story I enjoyed were the lighter moments of levity that were peppered throughout the tale – even with scandal looming and Elizabeth’s bleak future, Ms. Kincaid skillfully added some humorous anecdotes and conversations that will be sure to make readers chuckle and smirk. Mr. Collins of course was very instrumental in this endeavor, but also Caroline Bingley and Lady Catherine, who may have a surprise or two up their sleeves!
Some may find the idea of Elizabeth being caught in a compromise like this a little implausible, but it didn’t really bother me. If anything, my wish was for the story to be a tad bit longer. I enjoyed the premise so much and the development of Darcy’s feelings and his admirable actions were so wonderful to witness. However, I wish we learned a little more about Lord Henry and his thoughts during all these events. As a villain, he felt a little incomplete. In addition, while we do spend some time in Elizabeth’s head, I thought her change of heart came about a little too abruptly. I would have loved to have seen a more gradual evolution of her feelings for Mr. Darcy.
Darcy’s Honor is a riveting and romantic tale that spotlights our beloved Mr. Darcy and his honorable and protective nature. I always find so much to enjoy with Ms. Kincaid’s writing – her creative and inventive premises, her beautiful way with words, her humorous characters – I know when I begin one of her stories I will be thoroughly entertained and enthralled!
Austenesque Reviews
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
Source: Review Copy from Author
While indulging himself in a last glimpse of the unsuitable yet bewitching Elizabeth Bennet at the Netherfield Ball Mr. Darcy makes an observation about the newly introduced Viscount Billington, Lord Henry and the attention he is paying Elizabeth Bennet. Mr. Darcy suspects that the Viscount’s interest aren’t the most innocent or honorable and is pleased to see Elizabeth cleverly maneuver away from him. Despite the yearnings of Darcy’s heart, he leaves Meryton for London, and leaves Elizabeth to fall prey to the devious machinations of Lord Henry! When Darcy learns that Elizabeth’s reputation is ruined and that the Viscount is believed to have compromised her, he knows immediately how he must act. Forget reputation, society, and family – the only thing that matters is Elizabeth, and he must do what he can to save her and secure the happiness and futures of them both.
Unfortunately, Darcy finds himself faced with some resistance to his scheme, and it isn’t for the reasons you think! And so some heartache and trouble ensues… Can Darcy convince Elizabeth to be his wife? Can Elizabeth clear her name and convince others of her innocence? Or will Lord Henry achieve his dastardly scheme of stealing Elizabeth’s virtue?
Oh my! What a situation! This story immediately grabbed my attention and held me captive. Elizabeth finds herself in such a bad situation and with no one to turn to. My absolute favorite part of the story was seeing how deeply in love Darcy is with Elizabeth. Even before the scandal, he is fervently enamored and distracted with daily thoughts of her. I loved so many of Darcy’s scenes with Elizabeth and greatly admired so many of his actions in this story! His desire to reprimand the Meryton vicar, his surprise encounter with Elizabeth in the woods, his actions in London… *sigh* – he truly is the heroic, white knight, valiant rescuer with a heart so full of love it will make you swoon!!! (SLIGHT SPOILER: My heart completely melted into a puddle during the scene where Mr. Darcy acted in a very Colonel Brandon-like manner!)
Other parts of the story I enjoyed were the lighter moments of levity that were peppered throughout the tale – even with scandal looming and Elizabeth’s bleak future, Ms. Kincaid skillfully added some humorous anecdotes and conversations that will be sure to make readers chuckle and smirk. Mr. Collins of course was very instrumental in this endeavor, but also Caroline Bingley and Lady Catherine, who may have a surprise or two up their sleeves!
Some may find the idea of Elizabeth being caught in a compromise like this a little implausible, but it didn’t really bother me. If anything, my wish was for the story to be a tad bit longer. I enjoyed the premise so much and the development of Darcy’s feelings and his admirable actions were so wonderful to witness. However, I wish we learned a little more about Lord Henry and his thoughts during all these events. As a villain, he felt a little incomplete. In addition, while we do spend some time in Elizabeth’s head, I thought her change of heart came about a little too abruptly. I would have loved to have seen a more gradual evolution of her feelings for Mr. Darcy.
Darcy’s Honor is a riveting and romantic tale that spotlights our beloved Mr. Darcy and his honorable and protective nature. I always find so much to enjoy with Ms. Kincaid’s writing – her creative and inventive premises, her beautiful way with words, her humorous characters – I know when I begin one of her stories I will be thoroughly entertained and enthralled!
Austenesque Reviews
June 12, 2017
What would happen if the events of Pride & Prejudice went differently after Darcy and the Bingleys leave Netherfield followed by another dark event? Will Darcy lay aside his pride and think of his love instead? That is the question in Darcy's Honor.
The story is a variation of P&P opening at the point of the Netherfield ball, but going down its own path from that point on when a new character, Viscount vies for Elizabeth's attentions.
I enjoy variations on Austen's classic tales which the author does so well so I was glad to get my hands on this one. I thought it would be about a rival for Darcy and instead the theme of this one is a lady's tarnished reputation. How does her family, her community, and others beyond that respond when a young lady who has heretofore shown herself to be exemplary in all ways is suddenly, inexplicably found alone in slight dishabille with a young man? And then instead of doing the understood thing of accepting his hand in marriage, says 'no thanks, I don't like you.'
Looking back, we know from the social custom of that time that it was not a fair thing. Whether they believe her tarnished or not, reputation is worth more than honest truth. Shunned and rejected on all sides though innocent. My modern female heart silently screamed at the injustice of it.
But, it was an occasion for the proud, disagreeable (according to Lizzy) Mr. Darcy to really shine. Which he did. He was so gallant. He puts down the gossip occurring amongst his own set in Town, rushes back to verbally and actively support Elizabeth's version of events and he acts out of love and honor to offer marriage.
I did have a few niggles. One was in the beginning with the set up to the compromise scene. I understand there needed to be some sort of device to get Lizzy into a room alone with the Viscount, but it seemed odd for her to naively be led into the Lucas' drawing room to see a painting that the Viscount stated reminded him of her. Charlotte's her best friend and the Lucas' near neighbors. Surely Lizzy would have known the drawing room and known there was no such painting.
My next niggle was more an annoyance later on when Lizzy accused Darcy of pride and yet her rejection of his suit showed her pride was at more at issue. She said her rejection was to protect him from her scarlet woman image. Her marriage to him would not destroy him (he explains this) and she insisted that she could not accept his name or his help, that she would find employment and lodgings somehow. Going it alone without a guardian, male parent or female chaperone was just as damning to a reputation if not more so than accepting Darcy's proposal and assistance. In fact, in those days, no decent person would hire a woman on her own with no reputation or referral letter and the same goes for lodgings which Lizzy already knew after failing at this earlier in the story. Hair shirt, Lizzy? Not that I didn't enjoy that entertaining grand finale scene near the end when it was her plan that bested the villain as a result of things playing out the way they did.
It was a light story even if hitting a darker subject (men- and women- purposefully compromising and sullying a reputation to gain what they want). I enjoyed it overall even laughing at Caroline's attempt to catch Darcy and Lady Catherine's shocking actions that I absolutely loved. There was a good balance of humor and drama and build to romance with a solid conflict. I can't wait to see what the author produces next and would definitely recommend her novellas and books to those who enjoy variations on Pride & Prejudice.
I rec'd this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.
The story is a variation of P&P opening at the point of the Netherfield ball, but going down its own path from that point on when a new character, Viscount vies for Elizabeth's attentions.
I enjoy variations on Austen's classic tales which the author does so well so I was glad to get my hands on this one. I thought it would be about a rival for Darcy and instead the theme of this one is a lady's tarnished reputation. How does her family, her community, and others beyond that respond when a young lady who has heretofore shown herself to be exemplary in all ways is suddenly, inexplicably found alone in slight dishabille with a young man? And then instead of doing the understood thing of accepting his hand in marriage, says 'no thanks, I don't like you.'
Looking back, we know from the social custom of that time that it was not a fair thing. Whether they believe her tarnished or not, reputation is worth more than honest truth. Shunned and rejected on all sides though innocent. My modern female heart silently screamed at the injustice of it.
But, it was an occasion for the proud, disagreeable (according to Lizzy) Mr. Darcy to really shine. Which he did. He was so gallant. He puts down the gossip occurring amongst his own set in Town, rushes back to verbally and actively support Elizabeth's version of events and he acts out of love and honor to offer marriage.
I did have a few niggles. One was in the beginning with the set up to the compromise scene. I understand there needed to be some sort of device to get Lizzy into a room alone with the Viscount, but it seemed odd for her to naively be led into the Lucas' drawing room to see a painting that the Viscount stated reminded him of her. Charlotte's her best friend and the Lucas' near neighbors. Surely Lizzy would have known the drawing room and known there was no such painting.
My next niggle was more an annoyance later on when Lizzy accused Darcy of pride and yet her rejection of his suit showed her pride was at more at issue. She said her rejection was to protect him from her scarlet woman image. Her marriage to him would not destroy him (he explains this) and she insisted that she could not accept his name or his help, that she would find employment and lodgings somehow. Going it alone without a guardian, male parent or female chaperone was just as damning to a reputation if not more so than accepting Darcy's proposal and assistance. In fact, in those days, no decent person would hire a woman on her own with no reputation or referral letter and the same goes for lodgings which Lizzy already knew after failing at this earlier in the story. Hair shirt, Lizzy? Not that I didn't enjoy that entertaining grand finale scene near the end when it was her plan that bested the villain as a result of things playing out the way they did.
It was a light story even if hitting a darker subject (men- and women- purposefully compromising and sullying a reputation to gain what they want). I enjoyed it overall even laughing at Caroline's attempt to catch Darcy and Lady Catherine's shocking actions that I absolutely loved. There was a good balance of humor and drama and build to romance with a solid conflict. I can't wait to see what the author produces next and would definitely recommend her novellas and books to those who enjoy variations on Pride & Prejudice.
I rec'd this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.
Read
April 14, 2017I have a review and a readers' choice giveaway for "Darcy's Honor" today at Just Jane 1813. Come visit to see why I think Victoria Kincaid has written another great story!
https://justjane1813.com/2017/04/14/d...
https://justjane1813.com/2017/04/14/d...
May 2, 2017
I have delayed writing a review for several reasons. There was a lot of hype about this book and when it didn't live up to my heightened expectations I contemplated my impressions and reasoning for a while.
I think the biggest problem I had with the story is that when Darcy has Elizabeth not only living in the house his father's mistress occupied but he also takes chances with her reputation even further when he visit her there...more than once...with no chaperone...and he does embrace and kiss her. Oh, I know they are in love and under a lot of pressure and stress. But with all she has done to maintain her innocence and to walk away with her head held high...WHY? I know how the chemistry between a man and a woman can be so overwhelming but in this story I held them both, to that high moral standard of not allowing any acts to border on being improprieties.
The other event, in the very beginning, that bothers me, is how Elizabeth allowed herself to be drawn into a room by Henry Carson, Viscount Billington. She has known the Lucas family all her life. Charlotte is her best friend. She has been in the house numerous times. So when the Viscount claims that there is a picture over a mantle which resembles her...why on earth would she fall for that "come-on"? She knows the house and I am sure that if there were a picture which resembled her someone in the Lucas family would have drawn her attention to it previously.
Finally, as some others have stated, Elizabeth's resistance to Darcy's pleas, to his offer of marriage seems to be so stubborn, so at times without rhyme or reason. He must then eliminate the standing of the man who put Elizabeth is that position to begin with.
I did enjoy this story but the above paragraphs are my quibbles with the premise. Darcy fights long and hard to win Elizabeth's hand and her objections are all about how if she marries him, his honor will be besmirched by her ruin. The author did come up with a very clever solution in the end. Oh, how the mighty did fall.
I think the biggest problem I had with the story is that when Darcy has Elizabeth not only living in the house his father's mistress occupied but he also takes chances with her reputation even further when he visit her there...more than once...with no chaperone...and he does embrace and kiss her. Oh, I know they are in love and under a lot of pressure and stress. But with all she has done to maintain her innocence and to walk away with her head held high...WHY? I know how the chemistry between a man and a woman can be so overwhelming but in this story I held them both, to that high moral standard of not allowing any acts to border on being improprieties.
The other event, in the very beginning, that bothers me, is how Elizabeth allowed herself to be drawn into a room by Henry Carson, Viscount Billington. She has known the Lucas family all her life. Charlotte is her best friend. She has been in the house numerous times. So when the Viscount claims that there is a picture over a mantle which resembles her...why on earth would she fall for that "come-on"? She knows the house and I am sure that if there were a picture which resembled her someone in the Lucas family would have drawn her attention to it previously.
Finally, as some others have stated, Elizabeth's resistance to Darcy's pleas, to his offer of marriage seems to be so stubborn, so at times without rhyme or reason. He must then eliminate the standing of the man who put Elizabeth is that position to begin with.
I did enjoy this story but the above paragraphs are my quibbles with the premise. Darcy fights long and hard to win Elizabeth's hand and her objections are all about how if she marries him, his honor will be besmirched by her ruin. The author did come up with a very clever solution in the end. Oh, how the mighty did fall.
June 27, 2024
Darcy to the rescue, but the real hero is Lady C. (well sort of, but I actually kind of liked her in this one)
Vile, slimy Lord Henry, boy he really took the cake. I liked Darcy and Georgianna in this story. They were both strong characters. Darcy's waffling was minimal. Elizabeth's thoughts were sometimes shocking and I didn't feel they made sense considering one man was actually trying to force her into the same situation she at times contemplated.
Vile, slimy Lord Henry, boy he really took the cake. I liked Darcy and Georgianna in this story. They were both strong characters. Darcy's waffling was minimal. Elizabeth's thoughts were sometimes shocking and I didn't feel they made sense considering one man was actually trying to force her into the same situation she at times contemplated.
June 22, 2023
Loved It
Great book loved the relationship between Darcy and Lizzy glad very little about Wickham or Caroline. Nice epilogue ,always like stories with epilogue.
Great book loved the relationship between Darcy and Lizzy glad very little about Wickham or Caroline. Nice epilogue ,always like stories with epilogue.
April 15, 2017
Heartbreaking and heartwarming
It's another great story from Victoria Kincaid. I love Darcy the Protector and Elizabeth who tries do stay true to herself. Her stubbornness in refusing Darcy may seem excessive, but I believe she tried to preserve her dignity. And it didn't mean to have been handled over by a man who had ruined her reputation to another man to restore it. Though sometimes I wanted to tell her to allow Darcy save her. But she had to do it hard way.
I loved their developing relationship, and tender a and devoted Darcy was the best. The Viscount was a predator who believed that Elizabeth was his for the taking.
The attitude of Elizabeth 's neighbors saddened me, so little regard for a girl who had grown up among them. But unfortunately some people like thinking better of themselves, when they have a chance to besmirch another.
There is a HEA with some help from a couple of unlikely allies.
It's another great story from Victoria Kincaid. I love Darcy the Protector and Elizabeth who tries do stay true to herself. Her stubbornness in refusing Darcy may seem excessive, but I believe she tried to preserve her dignity. And it didn't mean to have been handled over by a man who had ruined her reputation to another man to restore it. Though sometimes I wanted to tell her to allow Darcy save her. But she had to do it hard way.
I loved their developing relationship, and tender a and devoted Darcy was the best. The Viscount was a predator who believed that Elizabeth was his for the taking.
The attitude of Elizabeth 's neighbors saddened me, so little regard for a girl who had grown up among them. But unfortunately some people like thinking better of themselves, when they have a chance to besmirch another.
There is a HEA with some help from a couple of unlikely allies.
August 15, 2017
Another amazing book by Victoria Kincaid
Loved it! Well worth 5 stars! I really liked how Georgiana helped her brother process the necessary changes needed to win Elizabeth. And I thoroughly enjoyed Lord Henry's comeuppance. Yet another wonderful P&P variation by Victoria Kincaid!
Loved it! Well worth 5 stars! I really liked how Georgiana helped her brother process the necessary changes needed to win Elizabeth. And I thoroughly enjoyed Lord Henry's comeuppance. Yet another wonderful P&P variation by Victoria Kincaid!
April 20, 2017
A most entertaining and different "what if?"
A gripping story, it will probably make cry sometimes, but you will find it hard to out it down.
Don't start it if you have pressing things to do or places to be.
A gripping story, it will probably make cry sometimes, but you will find it hard to out it down.
Don't start it if you have pressing things to do or places to be.
October 8, 2017
Lord Henry Carson manoeuvres Elizabeth Bennet into a compromise at Lucas Lodge but she refuses his offer of marriage, and becomes an outcast to the people of Meryton. How can she retrieve her reputation, and how does Darcy marry the disgraced Lizzy he loves.
An enjoyable tale
An enjoyable tale
October 13, 2020
2.5 rounded up. This wasn't my favorite by this author. The first half wasn't bad, but the second half just kept moving further and further into unbelievability bordering on ridiculous. Things that were not logical to me.
1- If Elizabeth was considered "compromised" the remedy to restore her reputation is marriage. Who she married mattered very little, as long as he was respectable- yet here, a big part of the plot is that she can only marry the "scoundrel" or she is ruined. Not true or accurate.
2- The whole story centers around her trying to salvage her reputation and respectability, yet she leaves Longbourn to go to London ALONE. No maid or companion. Seems counterproductive to me.
3- Darcy practically lives in her bedchamber while she is ill. Understandable yes, but again, this alone would destroy any remaining pieces of her reputation.
4- She moves into a cottage owned by an unmarried man she is not connected to. It was even purchased as a "mistress" dwelling. It would not have mattered that she was not his mistress, her living there under those circumstances would have been her ruination.
5- The ending. It was a bit ridiculous to me. A woman's reputation once lost, I doubt would have been able to be rescued in such a fashion anyways. And, Lady C's role and attitude-really? Not believable at all.
There were some good things to enjoy in this book, the idea had merit, but fell short of what it could have been in my opinion. Overall, it was on the lower side of just okay to me and left me feeling disappointed. I don't think I would recommend and I definitely wouldn't read it again.
1- If Elizabeth was considered "compromised" the remedy to restore her reputation is marriage. Who she married mattered very little, as long as he was respectable- yet here, a big part of the plot is that she can only marry the "scoundrel" or she is ruined. Not true or accurate.
2- The whole story centers around her trying to salvage her reputation and respectability, yet she leaves Longbourn to go to London ALONE. No maid or companion. Seems counterproductive to me.
3- Darcy practically lives in her bedchamber while she is ill. Understandable yes, but again, this alone would destroy any remaining pieces of her reputation.
4- She moves into a cottage owned by an unmarried man she is not connected to. It was even purchased as a "mistress" dwelling. It would not have mattered that she was not his mistress, her living there under those circumstances would have been her ruination.
5- The ending. It was a bit ridiculous to me. A woman's reputation once lost, I doubt would have been able to be rescued in such a fashion anyways. And, Lady C's role and attitude-really? Not believable at all.
There were some good things to enjoy in this book, the idea had merit, but fell short of what it could have been in my opinion. Overall, it was on the lower side of just okay to me and left me feeling disappointed. I don't think I would recommend and I definitely wouldn't read it again.
April 11, 2017
In this newest book from Victoria Kincaid Darcy tries to save Elizabeth after she is ruined by an unscrupulous Viscount. I enjoyed how even though Darcy fought with his reservations about Lizzy's family he still kept proposing marriage to her. I felt sorry for him at one point by how many times Lizzy turned him down because she was trying to protect his family's reputation. In between the ups and downs of their relationship help comes from a very unlikely source in restoring her honor.
This book kept me riveted from the time I picked it up until the time I finished it. Like always Ms. Kincaid has penned another winner.
Rating: 4½ stars of 5
*I received a copy from the author, All opinions are my own and shame on you if you think otherwise.
This book kept me riveted from the time I picked it up until the time I finished it. Like always Ms. Kincaid has penned another winner.
Rating: 4½ stars of 5
*I received a copy from the author, All opinions are my own and shame on you if you think otherwise.
May 21, 2024
I love rescue stories either from injury, accident or villains (especially them). And this Darcy was too good. The initial portion of the book was quite angsty but Darcy made up for it in the next half. Very enjoyable!
July 25, 2017
Ms Kincaid’s last book, Darcy’s Honor doesn’t disappoint. By now, we know we can expect angst (Darcy-Elizabeth-Lord Henry), humour (Darcy thinking about how to talk about the scandal, Mr Collins’ appearances), fantastic character descriptions (Darcy, Lady Catherine, Lord Pippinworth, Lord Henry), tasteful – not “Hollywoodish” and unnecessary- twists and turns, interesting inner thoughts (Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s especially), heartbreaking scenes (London- and church scene especially) and more.
There are too many things I love in Darcy’s Honor.
First of all, it has a life lesson:
“Honor is what you know about yourself. Reputation is what others know about you, or believe they know.”
Nowadays not many book touches philosophical or ethical issues.
Secondly, I love how Ms Kincaid is able to provide a wonderful description of a horrible man, namely Lord Henry. You can only hate him with passion. Make sure you have some chocolate at hand. You’ll need it. He is not their only character who has been depicted masterfully, but also Lady Catherine who’s my favourite in this book along with Lord Pippinworth. Have some ice cream when you read this part. � Lady Catherine does not only have crucial part in the solution but I also love the fact -and adore Ms Kincaid’s writing skills- that she was true to her character although the author altered her for good.
Lord Pippinworth is a different matter. He is very close to my heart, for a good reason! I still can’t believe that Ms Kincaid -I’m arrogant enough to think- kept him for me (I asked her in my reviews). First, Elizabeth mentioned him in Darcy vs. Bennet, then Darcy was wondering in Chaos Comes to Longbourn “Who the devil Lord Pippinworth was”, and he was a guest at a dinner in A Very Darcy Christmas. And now, he has a story which is not a rushed, slap-dash work, but an actual, satisfying eyes to the detail tale.
Darcy is another gem! Love him! and the fact that I am still surprised that when I think he can’t screw up, he does, is fascinating.
Elizabeth and Darcy’s meeting in London is heartbreaking! Big time! You’ll need lots of tissues. Just thinking about the scene, because I’m writing this review makes me cry. I can only talk in superlatives!!
After The Secrets of Darcy and Elizabeth, this is my second favourite book from the author. Darcy’s Honor is an engaging story with our favourite couple having heartbreaking, soul-shaking scenes sprinkled with humour at the right time and places. Real page-turner, must read!
There are too many things I love in Darcy’s Honor.
First of all, it has a life lesson:
“Honor is what you know about yourself. Reputation is what others know about you, or believe they know.”
Nowadays not many book touches philosophical or ethical issues.
Secondly, I love how Ms Kincaid is able to provide a wonderful description of a horrible man, namely Lord Henry. You can only hate him with passion. Make sure you have some chocolate at hand. You’ll need it. He is not their only character who has been depicted masterfully, but also Lady Catherine who’s my favourite in this book along with Lord Pippinworth. Have some ice cream when you read this part. � Lady Catherine does not only have crucial part in the solution but I also love the fact -and adore Ms Kincaid’s writing skills- that she was true to her character although the author altered her for good.
Lord Pippinworth is a different matter. He is very close to my heart, for a good reason! I still can’t believe that Ms Kincaid -I’m arrogant enough to think- kept him for me (I asked her in my reviews). First, Elizabeth mentioned him in Darcy vs. Bennet, then Darcy was wondering in Chaos Comes to Longbourn “Who the devil Lord Pippinworth was”, and he was a guest at a dinner in A Very Darcy Christmas. And now, he has a story which is not a rushed, slap-dash work, but an actual, satisfying eyes to the detail tale.
Darcy is another gem! Love him! and the fact that I am still surprised that when I think he can’t screw up, he does, is fascinating.
Elizabeth and Darcy’s meeting in London is heartbreaking! Big time! You’ll need lots of tissues. Just thinking about the scene, because I’m writing this review makes me cry. I can only talk in superlatives!!
After The Secrets of Darcy and Elizabeth, this is my second favourite book from the author. Darcy’s Honor is an engaging story with our favourite couple having heartbreaking, soul-shaking scenes sprinkled with humour at the right time and places. Real page-turner, must read!
September 2, 2018
Unappealing characters
A viscount compromises Lizzie. That’s the jumping off point for the story. Her naïveté after the fact is unbelievable. It’s not until 25% into the story that she days “I did not believe he could be that bad.”
No one at home and no one in Meryton believes it was a compromise except her father and Jane. Everyone tells her to just go along with whatever the Viscount wants her to do.
Darcy hears about her ruin and returns to help her. He believes her. But during all this he is thinking about her much as the Viscount does. I will say he doesn’t act on it but he does set her up in a house in London his father had for his mistress. How totally inappropriate.
Finally Aunt Catherine, of all people, gives information that the Viscount had been doing things like this with at least three others women. Evidence is gathered and the big showdown begin. For awhile it looks like no one is going to disagree with the Viscount’s story. But another peer finally does and the good guys win.
I felt depressed how few good upstanding people there were in the story. Not an enjoyable read at all.
A viscount compromises Lizzie. That’s the jumping off point for the story. Her naïveté after the fact is unbelievable. It’s not until 25% into the story that she days “I did not believe he could be that bad.”
No one at home and no one in Meryton believes it was a compromise except her father and Jane. Everyone tells her to just go along with whatever the Viscount wants her to do.
Darcy hears about her ruin and returns to help her. He believes her. But during all this he is thinking about her much as the Viscount does. I will say he doesn’t act on it but he does set her up in a house in London his father had for his mistress. How totally inappropriate.
Finally Aunt Catherine, of all people, gives information that the Viscount had been doing things like this with at least three others women. Evidence is gathered and the big showdown begin. For awhile it looks like no one is going to disagree with the Viscount’s story. But another peer finally does and the good guys win.
I felt depressed how few good upstanding people there were in the story. Not an enjoyable read at all.
May 24, 2024
Mr. Fitzwilliam Darcy will never give up his hope for having Miss Elizabeth Bennet as his wife.
The ball, at Netherfield Park , should have been wonderful, but instead, it has ended up a disaster for Miss Elizabeth due to the lies and machinations of one Lord Henry Carson. The entire neighborhood , even her own family, save her sister Jane and her father believe his tale of compromising her virtue. Mr. Darcy knows her well enough to be sure this is a falsehood. Returning to Hertfordshire specifically to offer for the woman he has come to love. Miss Elizabeth refuses his proposal. She is unwilling to accept, for she doesn't wish to endanger his reputation nor that of his sister. It would take time and much effort to put an end to the Viscount's sheme, and help comes from a most unexpected source. Sit back, relax with a cuppa , and enjoy this wonderful story.
The ball, at Netherfield Park , should have been wonderful, but instead, it has ended up a disaster for Miss Elizabeth due to the lies and machinations of one Lord Henry Carson. The entire neighborhood , even her own family, save her sister Jane and her father believe his tale of compromising her virtue. Mr. Darcy knows her well enough to be sure this is a falsehood. Returning to Hertfordshire specifically to offer for the woman he has come to love. Miss Elizabeth refuses his proposal. She is unwilling to accept, for she doesn't wish to endanger his reputation nor that of his sister. It would take time and much effort to put an end to the Viscount's sheme, and help comes from a most unexpected source. Sit back, relax with a cuppa , and enjoy this wonderful story.
June 1, 2025
4/5 stars! I doubt there's any version of Pride and Prejudice that I wouldn't like. As long as Mr Darcy is just like the Mr Darcy I know and he falls in love with Elizabeth Bennet in the same gentlemanly, awkward manner, I'd love the book. This book was also a delight to read. My only complaint would be Eliza's willingness to take things forward with Darcy but continues to refuse Darcy's proposal.
June 2, 2017
worthwhile twist
While I found that this variation (like many others) needed a strong hand at editing and proofreading (for example: the anachronism of giving the London landlady use of the durative be), I did find the twist involving Lady Catherine entertaining.
While I found that this variation (like many others) needed a strong hand at editing and proofreading (for example: the anachronism of giving the London landlady use of the durative be), I did find the twist involving Lady Catherine entertaining.
January 26, 2025
an interesting premise
A good story, well told. I found there to be a bit too much dithering - honestly, why is Elizabeth so obstinate about marrying Darcy, when Darcy himself got over it? - but it was settled well, and the twist at the end was unforeseen but fun to read.
A good story, well told. I found there to be a bit too much dithering - honestly, why is Elizabeth so obstinate about marrying Darcy, when Darcy himself got over it? - but it was settled well, and the twist at the end was unforeseen but fun to read.
April 1, 2019
This felt a bit like a parody. Though well written, and quite innovative at the end, there were so many implausible scenarios and actions that I couldn’t properly relax and enjoy it.
April 23, 2019
Interesting
Another interesting variation inspired by author Jane Austen’s classic Pride and Prejudice by Victoria Kincaid. A darker storyline than usual but enjoyable
Another interesting variation inspired by author Jane Austen’s classic Pride and Prejudice by Victoria Kincaid. A darker storyline than usual but enjoyable
January 30, 2023
Victoria Kincaid is one of the best authors of Pride and Prejudice variations.
June 29, 2020
This was a really good book and I enjoyed the plot and seeing how Elizabeth and Darcy's relationship developed as he helped her but I didn't enjoy reading about how badly Elizabeth was treated by some of her family and the rest of Meryton as much. Lady Catherine was also not as bad as in many books so that was a nice change. I look forward to reading more by this author in the future.
April 20, 2017
After the fun and frolics of Chaos Comes to Longbourn and A Very Darcy Christmas, Ms. Kincaid has returned to a somewhat more serious tone for this latest foray into the world of Jane Austen Fan Fiction. Don't worry though, there's still a leavening touch of humour as always.
This one deviates from canon at quite an early stage, at the Netherfield Ball in fact. Darcy and Elizabeth have had their somewhat disastrous dance and afterwards, he sees Henry Carson, Viscount Billington behaving towards Elizabeth in a manner that she appears not to appreciate and Darcy certainly doesn't! However, it doesn't stop Darcy heading off back to London as "he must forget her fine eyes and anything they promised". Oh Darcy, really? Not a chance dear boy!
In London, news reaches him by way of a snide remark by Caroline Bingley, that Elizabeth has been caught in a compromising situation with Lord Henry but had refused his offer of marriage. Darcy is convinced, rightly as it happens, that it's Lord Henry who's at fault and trying to trick Elizabeth into marrying him. After a walk in Hyde Park, Darcy decides to return to Meryton to try to save the day for Elizabeth and even pictures her face "alight with surprise and delight when he made his offer". Oh dear, he's got a shock coming there!
In Meryton, Elizabeth has become something of a social pariah due to her "ruined" reputation. The rest of her family, apart from her father, also believe she must have been complicit in the "compromise", but her father does nothing to counteract this. Even the local vicar is making pointed sermons that can only be aimed at her. As a result of all of this, her family's reputation is also starting to suffer. She's shocked when the man she loves to hate turns out to be one of those few who do believe her. In a conversation with Elizabeth shortly after his arrival back in Meryton, Darcy makes this wonderful explanation of the difference between honour and reputation:
"This is a distinction my father once made to me. Honor is what you know about yourself. Reputation is what others know about you, or believe they know.” He cleared his throat. “The people of Meryton think they know what happened between you and Lord Henry. Thus, your reputation has suffered. But you know you did nothing wrong; your honor has not been compromised.”
What was his Hunsford proposal from canon is instead made on Oakham Mount, near Longbourn, and it goes down just as well since he still takes the opportunity to disparage her family and situation. However, Elizabeth does not rip him to shreds with her reply here. Instead, she refuses him in order to save his reputation. In fact, she refuses him numerous times during the course of the story.
Later in the book, Elizabeth wakes in a strange bed (spoilers will abound if I say why and where) and she observes "A young woman, tall and blonde, was doing embroidery in the chair by her bedside. Elizabeth was reassured. In the novels, kidnappers never embroidered.” Just one example of the humorous touches sprinkled throughout.
We meet all of the usual suspects. Caroline Bingley, Williams Collins, and Lady Catherine de Bourgh but Lord Henry is the true villain, replacing George Wickham, that every reader is going to love to hate. In fact, this Lady Catherine is an interesting departure from canon. You'll have to read it yourself to find out why. The same goes for the resolution of the main problem, Elizabeth's reputation, which comes about in a very interesting, surprising and ultimately satisfying manner.
As with all of Ms. Kincaid's books, there is romance aplenty, some angst, but it is suitable for anyone to read. There are love scenes, of course, but no sex or anything explicit. I heartily recommend it to any fan of Ms. Kincaid's and Jane Austen Fan Fiction in general.
This one deviates from canon at quite an early stage, at the Netherfield Ball in fact. Darcy and Elizabeth have had their somewhat disastrous dance and afterwards, he sees Henry Carson, Viscount Billington behaving towards Elizabeth in a manner that she appears not to appreciate and Darcy certainly doesn't! However, it doesn't stop Darcy heading off back to London as "he must forget her fine eyes and anything they promised". Oh Darcy, really? Not a chance dear boy!
In London, news reaches him by way of a snide remark by Caroline Bingley, that Elizabeth has been caught in a compromising situation with Lord Henry but had refused his offer of marriage. Darcy is convinced, rightly as it happens, that it's Lord Henry who's at fault and trying to trick Elizabeth into marrying him. After a walk in Hyde Park, Darcy decides to return to Meryton to try to save the day for Elizabeth and even pictures her face "alight with surprise and delight when he made his offer". Oh dear, he's got a shock coming there!
In Meryton, Elizabeth has become something of a social pariah due to her "ruined" reputation. The rest of her family, apart from her father, also believe she must have been complicit in the "compromise", but her father does nothing to counteract this. Even the local vicar is making pointed sermons that can only be aimed at her. As a result of all of this, her family's reputation is also starting to suffer. She's shocked when the man she loves to hate turns out to be one of those few who do believe her. In a conversation with Elizabeth shortly after his arrival back in Meryton, Darcy makes this wonderful explanation of the difference between honour and reputation:
"This is a distinction my father once made to me. Honor is what you know about yourself. Reputation is what others know about you, or believe they know.” He cleared his throat. “The people of Meryton think they know what happened between you and Lord Henry. Thus, your reputation has suffered. But you know you did nothing wrong; your honor has not been compromised.”
What was his Hunsford proposal from canon is instead made on Oakham Mount, near Longbourn, and it goes down just as well since he still takes the opportunity to disparage her family and situation. However, Elizabeth does not rip him to shreds with her reply here. Instead, she refuses him in order to save his reputation. In fact, she refuses him numerous times during the course of the story.
Later in the book, Elizabeth wakes in a strange bed (spoilers will abound if I say why and where) and she observes "A young woman, tall and blonde, was doing embroidery in the chair by her bedside. Elizabeth was reassured. In the novels, kidnappers never embroidered.” Just one example of the humorous touches sprinkled throughout.
We meet all of the usual suspects. Caroline Bingley, Williams Collins, and Lady Catherine de Bourgh but Lord Henry is the true villain, replacing George Wickham, that every reader is going to love to hate. In fact, this Lady Catherine is an interesting departure from canon. You'll have to read it yourself to find out why. The same goes for the resolution of the main problem, Elizabeth's reputation, which comes about in a very interesting, surprising and ultimately satisfying manner.
As with all of Ms. Kincaid's books, there is romance aplenty, some angst, but it is suitable for anyone to read. There are love scenes, of course, but no sex or anything explicit. I heartily recommend it to any fan of Ms. Kincaid's and Jane Austen Fan Fiction in general.
April 29, 2017
Gah, I love her! I love all her books - but this one is up there with one of her best! A true gem, though I found it a bit (too) heart-wrenching that ODC always seemed to be so close, yet so far from finding happiness (it was frustratingly fabulous, and at times I had to pause and take deep breaths)! After an exhausting week, I went to bed early last night... and ended up reading until midnight, it was just too good to put down. Highly recommend.
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews