Serial K Returns, by Brian Gallagher, delves into the mind of a serial killer who, at times, seems to actually have a conscience. Craig Breedlove, the book’s main character, has begun to feel the urge to kill--and to, in his own warped way, make right a long list of wrongs. Breedlove, assuming a new identity, engages the interest of a select but rather volatile group of men who assist him with his mission to eradicate a long list of priests who ruined the lives of countless young boys in Wisconsin. Paralleling this journey of bloodshed is the search for answers headed up by Ryan O’Callahan and Lea Pucci--two of the FBI’s finest.
Craig Breedlove, known to his new cohort as Milo Van Dolah, is quite the main character. As badly as he wants to accomplish his mission to eliminate the abusive priests on the list he and his partners have created, he feels threatened at times by the overzealousness of some of his band of assassins, and things go haywire. For all his planning, explicit instructions, and constant reviewing of the group’s strategies, Breedlove finds himself, time and again, miffed by his inability to make himself clear. The best laid plans of serial killers and their sidekicks go awry…
This novel, definitely not for the squeamish or faint of heart, builds upon the idea that the priests must be punished--and at the hands of their victims. Gallagher incorporates a great deal of symbolism in Breedlove’s planned killings. Perhaps one of the most unsettling aspects of Gallagher’s writing is the utter shamelessness with which the priests respond the questioning of their assassins. The author, in no uncertain terms, drives home the fact that the priests are depraved and despicable. No amount of gore penned by the author can beat the disgust and raw emotion evoked by their smirks and openness.
Gallagher is more than adept at writing humor in the face of darkness. Ted, a man who, quite literally, would not know to come in out of the rain, provides an element of comic relief even if it is tainted with sadness. His complete lack of understanding in the most basic of situations leaves the reader almost dumbfounded at times, making it easy to empathize with O’Callahan and Pucci’s frustration.
Serial K Returns is steeped in suspense from the first chapter to its conclusion. Gallagher incorporates perfectly-timed revelations as the story unfolds. The plotline surrounding Breedlove’s organization of his own wayward crime family provides ample opportunities for the reader to try to outguess the author.
I give Serial K Returns 4 out of 5 stars. Gallagher has written a piece rivaling any other crime novel out there. The profanity-laced conversations between characters are the main reason I am not awarding a full 5 stars to this novel. Profanity is not something I feel added to the excellent writing and plot of this piece. Aside from that drawback, I found Gallagher’s writing to be engaging, suspenseful, and recommend to any fan of crime fiction. In addition to the intense scenes involving the victims, the author has interwoven bits of true crime events into his plot--always a plus for fans of dramatic crime novels.