What do you think?
Rate this book
Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen #2
When You Love a Scotsman
With danger closing in from all sides, Abigail Jenson works tirelessly to protect her small Missouri farm. She doesn't require saving - but a handsome officer appears on horseback just as ruthless marauders set her cabin ablaze. With nowhere else to turn, Abigail allows the soldier with the seductive Highlander's gaze to escort her to shelter in a nearby town.
Matthew MacEnroy was reluctant to join his adopted nation's conflict - until an enemy attack wounded two of his brothers. Bravely doing battle has its price when a proud, independent beauty comes under his watch - no military man can risk the powerful emotions their attraction has unleashed. But when Matthew himself is caught in the crossfire, Abigail leads their long journey home to MacEnroy valley...and her caring touch sparks the promise of a bold future together.
Matthew MacEnroy was reluctant to join his adopted nation's conflict - until an enemy attack wounded two of his brothers. Bravely doing battle has its price when a proud, independent beauty comes under his watch - no military man can risk the powerful emotions their attraction has unleashed. But when Matthew himself is caught in the crossfire, Abigail leads their long journey home to MacEnroy valley...and her caring touch sparks the promise of a bold future together.
352 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published December 26, 2017
157 people are currently reading
1242 people want to read
About the author
Hannah Howell
116 books2,643 followersHannah Dustin Howell is a best-selling American author of over 40 historical romance novels. Many of her novels are set in medieval Scotland. She also writes under the names Sarah Dustin, Sandra Dustin, and Anna Jennet (see below).
She has also used the following pseudonyms:
Anna Jennet, Sarah Dustin and Sandra Dustin
She has also used the following pseudonyms:
Anna Jennet, Sarah Dustin and Sandra Dustin
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 124 reviews
December 24, 2017
4 War and love Stars
******Spoilers*******
When You Love A Scotsman was a good solid read for me. Matthew MacEnroy was yummy, protective and at times playful. Abigail was brave, smart, and had a big loving heart. I thought Matt and Abbie were very cute together. The steam factor was high too. I only had two problems with this book that made it a 4 star read instead of a 5. I will try to relay those issues without giving away a ton of spoilers if possible.
Problem #1 the attitude towards sex in this book and also in book 1 was a little too modern. Let me explain. Women for the most part in the civil war times still had very strict ideas about sex before marriage. As in you don't have sex before you are married. Yes I know it did happen and of course more so if your beau was going off to war. But it wasn't the norm, and it was normally with some courting, a declaration of marriage or love or something. That didn't happen in this book. Matt just takes Abbie for a walk, on what I would count as the equivalent of a second date at best, and just has sex with her. No real build up. No I want to be with you forever Abbie. No I love you. Not even I want to court you. Nothing! He just showed up randomly(every couple of weeks)ask her to go walking, not really talking about much. He did feed her so that was nice, and then he would jump her lol. Now the 2nd or 3rd time he took her "walking" he was kissing her and just without even getting fully undressed had sex with her. Abbie doesn't say a word in protest. No what of my honor? Are you gonna make an honest woman of me? Are we together? Nothing. She just gave her virginity away. Which back then would have been a huge deal, as it would have lower her chance at marriage. Also if she would have gotten pregnant would have had her child labeled a bastard. She just gave it away without a word. I just didn't buy it. Now don't get me wrong I hate the way women were treated back then, but history is what it is and it just didn't feel right when I read it. Still I could overlook it and enjoy the read.
Now for the second problem I had with this book which kinda ties into the 1st one. Problem #2 Matt's attitude towards sex and Abbie. This was the biggest problem for me. It was what bothered me the most. See Matt sat there and slept with Abbie over and over, never giving her words of love, or commitment. He knew he took her virginity, but he just didn't seem to care much. It was like he was just having fun and if he would have walked away she would have been ruined. I needed him to really want to be with her. I wanted him to have deep I'm keeping her feelings, not just having sex with her knowing what was at stake for her. It felt kinda selfish and not a honorable thing to do. It bugged me. It bugged me more that people kept asking Matt if he was "gonna marry the girl" and he just kept saying he didn't know and he was thinking about it. It made me just want to shake some sense into him.
Now even with those two problems the book was still a great read. I loved the civil war setting. It was heartbreaking, as well as beautiful. I think Hannah Howell did an amazing job at showing the truth of the brutishness, cruelty, ugliness born in war times. She didn't paint over the pain and loss war leaves behind. I loved Abbie's courage through the whole book. Every time something knocked her down she would just pick herself up. On top of that she helped everyone. She didn't cry and whine she just jumped in and helped. My favorite type of heroine is the brave, strong ones, and that was Abbie for sure. I loved her so much. I also really loved little Noah (4 year old orphan boy that claims Abbie as his) he was just so precocious and cute. I loved getting to catch up with the whole MacEnroy clan including Mrs O'Neal her children and the Jones brothers. I really loved the epilogue. It gave a nice deep look into the future. I can't wait for the other sexy Scottish MacEnroy brothers to get their books.
https://jessicasoverthetopbookobsessi...
******Spoilers*******
When You Love A Scotsman was a good solid read for me. Matthew MacEnroy was yummy, protective and at times playful. Abigail was brave, smart, and had a big loving heart. I thought Matt and Abbie were very cute together. The steam factor was high too. I only had two problems with this book that made it a 4 star read instead of a 5. I will try to relay those issues without giving away a ton of spoilers if possible.
Problem #1 the attitude towards sex in this book and also in book 1 was a little too modern. Let me explain. Women for the most part in the civil war times still had very strict ideas about sex before marriage. As in you don't have sex before you are married. Yes I know it did happen and of course more so if your beau was going off to war. But it wasn't the norm, and it was normally with some courting, a declaration of marriage or love or something. That didn't happen in this book. Matt just takes Abbie for a walk, on what I would count as the equivalent of a second date at best, and just has sex with her. No real build up. No I want to be with you forever Abbie. No I love you. Not even I want to court you. Nothing! He just showed up randomly(every couple of weeks)ask her to go walking, not really talking about much. He did feed her so that was nice, and then he would jump her lol. Now the 2nd or 3rd time he took her "walking" he was kissing her and just without even getting fully undressed had sex with her. Abbie doesn't say a word in protest. No what of my honor? Are you gonna make an honest woman of me? Are we together? Nothing. She just gave her virginity away. Which back then would have been a huge deal, as it would have lower her chance at marriage. Also if she would have gotten pregnant would have had her child labeled a bastard. She just gave it away without a word. I just didn't buy it. Now don't get me wrong I hate the way women were treated back then, but history is what it is and it just didn't feel right when I read it. Still I could overlook it and enjoy the read.
Now for the second problem I had with this book which kinda ties into the 1st one. Problem #2 Matt's attitude towards sex and Abbie. This was the biggest problem for me. It was what bothered me the most. See Matt sat there and slept with Abbie over and over, never giving her words of love, or commitment. He knew he took her virginity, but he just didn't seem to care much. It was like he was just having fun and if he would have walked away she would have been ruined. I needed him to really want to be with her. I wanted him to have deep I'm keeping her feelings, not just having sex with her knowing what was at stake for her. It felt kinda selfish and not a honorable thing to do. It bugged me. It bugged me more that people kept asking Matt if he was "gonna marry the girl" and he just kept saying he didn't know and he was thinking about it. It made me just want to shake some sense into him.
Now even with those two problems the book was still a great read. I loved the civil war setting. It was heartbreaking, as well as beautiful. I think Hannah Howell did an amazing job at showing the truth of the brutishness, cruelty, ugliness born in war times. She didn't paint over the pain and loss war leaves behind. I loved Abbie's courage through the whole book. Every time something knocked her down she would just pick herself up. On top of that she helped everyone. She didn't cry and whine she just jumped in and helped. My favorite type of heroine is the brave, strong ones, and that was Abbie for sure. I loved her so much. I also really loved little Noah (4 year old orphan boy that claims Abbie as his) he was just so precocious and cute. I loved getting to catch up with the whole MacEnroy clan including Mrs O'Neal her children and the Jones brothers. I really loved the epilogue. It gave a nice deep look into the future. I can't wait for the other sexy Scottish MacEnroy brothers to get their books.
https://jessicasoverthetopbookobsessi...
December 10, 2017
The idea of the plot was better than the execution of it.
Lieutenant Matthew MacEnroy is just trying to survive the war and make it back home when he and his men happen upon Abigail Jenson's home as she's fending off Rebels. Impressed with her bravery, Matthew helps her to the next town when she has nowhere else to go.
The pacing of this story was just bizarre to me. They literally knew each other for a day before he kissed her for the first time and it came out of NOWHERE. There was zero buildup to the attraction. I remember checking to see what percent of the story I was on and if I had missed something.
There also seemed to be very little of a plot here. The plot from the blurb happens in the first 5% of the book. It made for a tedious and boring read.
*I received an eARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
If you like my reviews, please follow my blog!
http://readerandthebeast.blogspot.com...
Lieutenant Matthew MacEnroy is just trying to survive the war and make it back home when he and his men happen upon Abigail Jenson's home as she's fending off Rebels. Impressed with her bravery, Matthew helps her to the next town when she has nowhere else to go.
The pacing of this story was just bizarre to me. They literally knew each other for a day before he kissed her for the first time and it came out of NOWHERE. There was zero buildup to the attraction. I remember checking to see what percent of the story I was on and if I had missed something.
There also seemed to be very little of a plot here. The plot from the blurb happens in the first 5% of the book. It made for a tedious and boring read.
*I received an eARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
If you like my reviews, please follow my blog!
http://readerandthebeast.blogspot.com...
June 16, 2018
Good book. Matthew is a Union officer out on patrol when they are attacked by Confederates. Racing to find a defensible position, they take shelter in a cabin on a small farm, occupied by a couple and their daughter. Abigail has been working to care for the farm since the last attack when her brother was taken, her father beaten, and her mother assaulted. She quickly realizes that these soldiers are her best defense, and joins them in defending the cabin.
The opening scene was a real attention grabber. The danger was obvious and intense, with a real possibility of injury or death. There is also a quick introduction to Abigail's background and the circumstances behind her situation. I loved the way that Abbie joined in the defense of the cabin, and Matthew's reaction. I ached for Abbie when the fight was over, and she had to face the loss of her home and her parents. I liked Matthew's protectiveness, as he insisted on taking her back to the town they were based in, to stay with other women in similar circumstances.
I liked both Abbie and Matthew. Abbie is strong and independent, and also kind and loving. I enjoyed watching her settle in at Beaton House and make friends with the other women. She also wasn't the kind to sit back and moan about her circumstances or ignore things that she thinks are wrong. I especially enjoyed the way that she took the children under her wing - Noah was adorable. I also liked how she quickly became the one that the other women looked to during a crisis.
Matthew was a great guy. He joined the army when two of his brothers were injured by Rebel marauders. He's done his duty, but he's tired of the war and the killing and ready for his time to be up. He's protective of his men and watches out for their interests.
I enjoyed the development of Matthew and Abbie's relationship. There were sparks between them from the beginning. Once they arrived in the town, they began meeting in a fairly traditional way, with Matthew calling on her at the house and taking her walking. I liked how they talked and got to know each other. The attraction between them was strong, and Matthew was pretty quick about making his move on her. I was a bit surprised by how quickly they became intimate, especially for that time. Abbie falls for Matthew, but isn't about to be the first one to say anything about her feelings. Matthew waffles back and forth. He definitely likes being with her, but he isn't sure what he feels. When he and another man are injured close to the end of their enlistments, the commander send them, along with Abbie, to Matthew's home. The journey has its challenges, and also gives Matthew more time to think about what he wants. I loved their arrival at his home, and how quickly Abbie was accepted. I was a bit frustrated with Matthew, as he made it clear that Abbie was with him, but he still couldn't make up his mind about their future. I liked seeing his brothers call him out on his attitude. I liked that Abbie was fully prepared to leave him behind and make her own way. I liked their big moment at the end, especially how Abbie made sure that she got what she needed to be happy. The epilogue was good, with a great look at their married life. There was an interesting twist at the end.
I enjoyed the secondary characters, too. My favorite was Noah, the four-year-old boy who immediately took a shine to Abbie. Some of the things he said were highly amusing and often made me ache for what he had been through. Mrs. Beaton was a woman who was very rigid at the beginning, but as time went on, she loosened up quite a bit. Julia, who was the one that Abbie became closest to. She was an interesting character, and I ached for everything she went through. I liked Matthew's friend and fellow soldier, James. There were some good scenes of him trying to give Matthew advice.
I really liked the setting of the Civil War, which doesn't happen often. It was good to see that the effects of war were not glossed over or romanticized. The frustration of the soldiers over the frequent skirmishes that didn't have any definitive result was clear and realistic.
The opening scene was a real attention grabber. The danger was obvious and intense, with a real possibility of injury or death. There is also a quick introduction to Abigail's background and the circumstances behind her situation. I loved the way that Abbie joined in the defense of the cabin, and Matthew's reaction. I ached for Abbie when the fight was over, and she had to face the loss of her home and her parents. I liked Matthew's protectiveness, as he insisted on taking her back to the town they were based in, to stay with other women in similar circumstances.
I liked both Abbie and Matthew. Abbie is strong and independent, and also kind and loving. I enjoyed watching her settle in at Beaton House and make friends with the other women. She also wasn't the kind to sit back and moan about her circumstances or ignore things that she thinks are wrong. I especially enjoyed the way that she took the children under her wing - Noah was adorable. I also liked how she quickly became the one that the other women looked to during a crisis.
Matthew was a great guy. He joined the army when two of his brothers were injured by Rebel marauders. He's done his duty, but he's tired of the war and the killing and ready for his time to be up. He's protective of his men and watches out for their interests.
I enjoyed the development of Matthew and Abbie's relationship. There were sparks between them from the beginning. Once they arrived in the town, they began meeting in a fairly traditional way, with Matthew calling on her at the house and taking her walking. I liked how they talked and got to know each other. The attraction between them was strong, and Matthew was pretty quick about making his move on her. I was a bit surprised by how quickly they became intimate, especially for that time. Abbie falls for Matthew, but isn't about to be the first one to say anything about her feelings. Matthew waffles back and forth. He definitely likes being with her, but he isn't sure what he feels. When he and another man are injured close to the end of their enlistments, the commander send them, along with Abbie, to Matthew's home. The journey has its challenges, and also gives Matthew more time to think about what he wants. I loved their arrival at his home, and how quickly Abbie was accepted. I was a bit frustrated with Matthew, as he made it clear that Abbie was with him, but he still couldn't make up his mind about their future. I liked seeing his brothers call him out on his attitude. I liked that Abbie was fully prepared to leave him behind and make her own way. I liked their big moment at the end, especially how Abbie made sure that she got what she needed to be happy. The epilogue was good, with a great look at their married life. There was an interesting twist at the end.
I enjoyed the secondary characters, too. My favorite was Noah, the four-year-old boy who immediately took a shine to Abbie. Some of the things he said were highly amusing and often made me ache for what he had been through. Mrs. Beaton was a woman who was very rigid at the beginning, but as time went on, she loosened up quite a bit. Julia, who was the one that Abbie became closest to. She was an interesting character, and I ached for everything she went through. I liked Matthew's friend and fellow soldier, James. There were some good scenes of him trying to give Matthew advice.
I really liked the setting of the Civil War, which doesn't happen often. It was good to see that the effects of war were not glossed over or romanticized. The frustration of the soldiers over the frequent skirmishes that didn't have any definitive result was clear and realistic.
December 23, 2017
When You Love a Scotsman by Hannah Howell is Book number Two in the "Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen". This is the story of Abigail Jenson and Matthew MacEnroy.
This was an emotional drama filled romance that will have you connecting with the secondary characters. Although Abbie and Matt have a slow start to leading into love I thought they did have a fast attraction to each other. Overall I enjoyed their story.
This was an emotional drama filled romance that will have you connecting with the secondary characters. Although Abbie and Matt have a slow start to leading into love I thought they did have a fast attraction to each other. Overall I enjoyed their story.
December 19, 2018
I just can't connect with this author... every story of hers that I read were ..bljah..meh...
February 5, 2022
When You Love a Scotsman
By: Hannah Howell
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Hannah Howell's second book in her new Seven Brides/ Seven Scotsman series is here and will not disappoint anyone who enjoys an easy read with a happy ending. Unlike the majority of Hannah's novels which are placed in the rugged highlands of Scotland this series takes you to the wilds of Missouri in the midst of the Civil War. If you have not read the first book in this series (The Scotsman Who Saved Me) do not be alarmed this novel can be enjoyed as a stand alone read or a build in the series. I typically am not drawn to Westerns in general but started this series as Hannah Howell is a legend in the historical romance world. I will be reading each book as it is released and highly recommend this read to any new or existing historical romance enthusiast!
If you would like to see the remainder of my review please subscribe to my blog!
https://meganily07.wixsite.com/btpbb/...
December 20, 2017
Another damsel in distress and one that is saved by Union soldiers (but she can shoot better than them but if the odds are against you then they just are.)
Abigail was kind, a good shot, had learned medicine from her dad, and well I can not say anything bad about her,
Matthew, oh these brothers, is that how you court a woman? Ask...talk...I really hope the next brother gets a woman who says, nope! We shall talk a bit first. But I mean he is a sweet guy, the best, just, ask man, ask.
The war is raging on, though they do have it somewhat better where they are. Mostly marauders in these hills. But there is fighting, death, mayhem, but also a blossoming romance. Sometimes you just have to go for it among all the rest.
And the epilogue, aye, I liked that.
Narrator: Justine Eyre
I do like her voice, and her Scottish accent, lol, aye it makes me lol. Her range is perhaps not the best but she is so pleasant listening too.
Abigail was kind, a good shot, had learned medicine from her dad, and well I can not say anything bad about her,
Matthew, oh these brothers, is that how you court a woman? Ask...talk...I really hope the next brother gets a woman who says, nope! We shall talk a bit first. But I mean he is a sweet guy, the best, just, ask man, ask.
The war is raging on, though they do have it somewhat better where they are. Mostly marauders in these hills. But there is fighting, death, mayhem, but also a blossoming romance. Sometimes you just have to go for it among all the rest.
And the epilogue, aye, I liked that.
Narrator: Justine Eyre
I do like her voice, and her Scottish accent, lol, aye it makes me lol. Her range is perhaps not the best but she is so pleasant listening too.
November 26, 2017
Hannah Howell is the only reason that I finished this book! Plus, I have her on pre order, however, she makes the Southern Army look like rapist, murderers of little children! It was deserters who behaved like that, if they were caught, they were put in front of a tiring squad! Being from the South made me dislike this book. It is a great read, if you are a Yankee! I will now reconsider my opinion of just buying her books, without looking at them first. The love story could not overcome her obvious hatred of the South!
January 3, 2018
I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for a fair review. When You Love a Scotsman is the second book in Howell's Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen series. It can be read as a stand alone as I haven't read the first book.
Matthew MacEnroy is a Union soldier looking for shelter for him and his group of soldiers to hide from as they are being chased by deserters of the Confederate army. The year is 1864and the second sentence reads, "Fall was here and winter would come with all its misery for a soldier." He comes across Abigail Jenson and her parents cabin. Abigail is taking care of her parents as they were recently attacked that left her dad dying and mom giving up. In the opening shot out, both of her parents die but we never really see her mourn their loss. There was no time and mourning would happen later seems to be the reason.
The book takes them through the end of the Civil War but to me, the timing was off. It was Fall, then Winter kicked in, and Spring was all the sudden upon them. But General Lee surrendered in April 1865, the beginning of Spring.
The characters were two dimensional to me. There was no depth or development in them. For Abigail being so independent, she gave in very quickly. Also, there seemed to be a naiveté that should have been lost after her family was attacked. And for someone who was supposed to be a gentleman in 1864, Matthew sure didn't act it.
It took me a long time to read this book; and for me reading Hannah Howell, it's a HUGE surprise. I usually enjoy her work but struggled this time. There were multiple mistakes, the timing felt off, and the characters two dimensional. As I know this isn't normal for her writing, I did continue and the story and characters grew on me. #WhenYouLoveaScotsman #NetGalley
Matthew MacEnroy is a Union soldier looking for shelter for him and his group of soldiers to hide from as they are being chased by deserters of the Confederate army. The year is 1864and the second sentence reads, "Fall was here and winter would come with all its misery for a soldier." He comes across Abigail Jenson and her parents cabin. Abigail is taking care of her parents as they were recently attacked that left her dad dying and mom giving up. In the opening shot out, both of her parents die but we never really see her mourn their loss. There was no time and mourning would happen later seems to be the reason.
The book takes them through the end of the Civil War but to me, the timing was off. It was Fall, then Winter kicked in, and Spring was all the sudden upon them. But General Lee surrendered in April 1865, the beginning of Spring.
The characters were two dimensional to me. There was no depth or development in them. For Abigail being so independent, she gave in very quickly. Also, there seemed to be a naiveté that should have been lost after her family was attacked. And for someone who was supposed to be a gentleman in 1864, Matthew sure didn't act it.
It took me a long time to read this book; and for me reading Hannah Howell, it's a HUGE surprise. I usually enjoy her work but struggled this time. There were multiple mistakes, the timing felt off, and the characters two dimensional. As I know this isn't normal for her writing, I did continue and the story and characters grew on me. #WhenYouLoveaScotsman #NetGalley
March 11, 2018
** This is a DNF Review **
Review copy courtesy of the publisher via NetGalley.
I couldn't finish this book. I tried several times to get into it and it just wasn't happening for me.
I would have bet money on this being the author's first book. Reading it, it felt like it was being written in a monotone. Conversations between characters didn't flow smoothly. Everything felt disjointed and stilted. No one seemed to feel or have any emotions - about anything.
I didn't give damn about any of the characters. They felt completely one-dimensional. The heroine loses her mother and father in the first few pages of the book and I didn't care then and I never ended up caring. When the soldiers left the house with the heroine, I KNEW that she was going willingly but I couldn't tell from reading it if they were forcing her or if she wanted to go.
I also thought this would be about Scotsmen in Scotsland. Not Scotsmen in the United States back in the Civil War time. I hate war movies and I hate war books and this is smack dab in the middle of the Civil War. How did I not know this? I guess it isn't very clear in the description where or when this book takes place. Had I known, I would have definitely skipped this one.
I don't know. I feel bad for reviewing a book so harshly. This author worked long and hard on this. She's obviously popular since she's written a bunch of books but I just couldn't do this one. The writing was awful and the characters weren't believable.
Review copy courtesy of the publisher via NetGalley.
I couldn't finish this book. I tried several times to get into it and it just wasn't happening for me.
I would have bet money on this being the author's first book. Reading it, it felt like it was being written in a monotone. Conversations between characters didn't flow smoothly. Everything felt disjointed and stilted. No one seemed to feel or have any emotions - about anything.
I didn't give damn about any of the characters. They felt completely one-dimensional. The heroine loses her mother and father in the first few pages of the book and I didn't care then and I never ended up caring. When the soldiers left the house with the heroine, I KNEW that she was going willingly but I couldn't tell from reading it if they were forcing her or if she wanted to go.
I also thought this would be about Scotsmen in Scotsland. Not Scotsmen in the United States back in the Civil War time. I hate war movies and I hate war books and this is smack dab in the middle of the Civil War. How did I not know this? I guess it isn't very clear in the description where or when this book takes place. Had I known, I would have definitely skipped this one.
I don't know. I feel bad for reviewing a book so harshly. This author worked long and hard on this. She's obviously popular since she's written a bunch of books but I just couldn't do this one. The writing was awful and the characters weren't believable.
May 31, 2018
I thought I loved the couple in the first book in this series, but this one is even better. The story is livened up by taking place during the American Civil War. More endearing children and strong women really add to it.
Hope the author keeps up with this series.
Hope the author keeps up with this series.
December 28, 2018
Hannah Howell has done it again. When danger is closing in from all sides, Abigail Jenson works to protect her family and small Missouri farm from attack. She doesn't require saving from ruthless marauders who has set her cabin ablaze. A handsome officer appears on horseback to save her. Abigail allows the soldier with the seductive Highlander's gaze to escort her shelter in a nearby town. Matthew MacEnnoy was reluctant to join his adopted nation's conflict-until an enemy attack wounded two of his brothers. While doing his duty in battle, a proud, independent beauty comes under his watch. When Matthew himself is caught in the crossfire, Abigail leads their long journey home to the MacEnoy valley, and her caring touch sparks the promise of a bold future together.
June 28, 2018
Yep, that's a 'romance'.
Lots of sex scenes, not certain about consent all the time, set during the American Civil War, but that's only back drop for the romance. Independent young woman with a traditional 'man skill' she can shoot really well. Always hits her target. Handsome Scotsman who is drawn to her. You know what to expect.
Read if you like traditional, historical romances. Ideal summer reading.
Note, go and read Jessica's review. Spot on points!
Lots of sex scenes, not certain about consent all the time, set during the American Civil War, but that's only back drop for the romance. Independent young woman with a traditional 'man skill' she can shoot really well. Always hits her target. Handsome Scotsman who is drawn to her. You know what to expect.
Read if you like traditional, historical romances. Ideal summer reading.
Note, go and read Jessica's review. Spot on points!
January 30, 2018
These romances do not have a lot of tension or build up between the lead characters which is not the norm for most historical romance. But I did mostly enjoy their quiet love story. The story is set in Missouri/ Arkansas during the civil war and focused on the trials and hardships of the characters, which was not completely boring.
January 18, 2019
Had to listen to something light after 38 hours of the Old Testament. Fun, straightforward protagonist.
March 23, 2018
Very nice story set in the Civil War era. Abagail's home was set on fire and Matthew MacEnroy was close enough to save her. He's fighting for the north and tired of the war. He escorts her to the town where he's currently stationed. There's a house filled with women and children who don't know if they'll ever see their families again. One of the children will just steal your heart. No spoilers from me. This is a good story and I recommend it.
December 26, 2017
I received a copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
Abbie lives on a small farm with her parents and brother. It is during America's war for independence that their home is raided by the opposing forces, her father is injured and her brother has been drug off the serve as a soldier.
She meets Matthew when he and his soldier's are on patrol and he ends up trying to protect them when they are once again attacked by the enemy. Unfortunately, Abbie parents die in this attack and Matthew and his group will take her to somewhere she will be safe.
Matthew gets Abbie to town and she finds shelter with a woman who has taken in other women and children. She stays here and helps the Army's doctor with the injured. She and Matthew spend quite a bit of time together and their attraction grows.
Danger is closer to town and all are advised to leave if they can. Matthew is going home as his enlistment is up and he decides to bring Abbie, Noah and the baby with him. You have to read the book to find out about Noah and the baby!. Abbie is hoping she will be able to get a small house for her ready made family and start life again.
Will the war end? Will Matthew and Abbie be together?
Matthew is a really good man but he just doesn't realize he loves Abbie. He knows he doesn't want to be apart from her but can he make the commitment? What if it isn't love? Matthew just wanted everything in black and white but you can't do that with love.
Abbie loves him but she doesn't expect him to take on the responsibility of her and the children. I love that Matthew is appreciative of her strengths and trusts her. She is a strong woman as well as smart.
I have to admit that I am a fan of the author's and have read many of her books. She has written many a story about Scotland and their highlanders but in this series the brothers have come to America. I love the closeness of the brothers and even the arguments! I am ready for the next brother!! I liked seeing old customs brought from their native country to the new land of America.
This is a good read!
Abbie lives on a small farm with her parents and brother. It is during America's war for independence that their home is raided by the opposing forces, her father is injured and her brother has been drug off the serve as a soldier.
She meets Matthew when he and his soldier's are on patrol and he ends up trying to protect them when they are once again attacked by the enemy. Unfortunately, Abbie parents die in this attack and Matthew and his group will take her to somewhere she will be safe.
Matthew gets Abbie to town and she finds shelter with a woman who has taken in other women and children. She stays here and helps the Army's doctor with the injured. She and Matthew spend quite a bit of time together and their attraction grows.
Danger is closer to town and all are advised to leave if they can. Matthew is going home as his enlistment is up and he decides to bring Abbie, Noah and the baby with him. You have to read the book to find out about Noah and the baby!. Abbie is hoping she will be able to get a small house for her ready made family and start life again.
Will the war end? Will Matthew and Abbie be together?
Matthew is a really good man but he just doesn't realize he loves Abbie. He knows he doesn't want to be apart from her but can he make the commitment? What if it isn't love? Matthew just wanted everything in black and white but you can't do that with love.
Abbie loves him but she doesn't expect him to take on the responsibility of her and the children. I love that Matthew is appreciative of her strengths and trusts her. She is a strong woman as well as smart.
I have to admit that I am a fan of the author's and have read many of her books. She has written many a story about Scotland and their highlanders but in this series the brothers have come to America. I love the closeness of the brothers and even the arguments! I am ready for the next brother!! I liked seeing old customs brought from their native country to the new land of America.
This is a good read!
April 12, 2018
I liked both Abbie and Matthew a little bit better, but the writing and construction still reads as old school to me. There was a lot of dialogue and it wasn't always clear who was talking, and oftentimes the dialogue when off on a tangent to whatever action was happening. For instance, Abbie arrives at the MacEvoy home under trying circumstances, but as soon as she's in the gate, she and Emily are bonding over childcare, while the men are rushing around on the wall, defending the home? There were also a couple descriptive paragraphs that gave me deja vu, like I'd read them earlier in the book.
I also have some doubts about the consent between Abbie and Matthew when they are intimate.
There are only two books published now, but I’m not sure if I can hang around for the next five brothers to get their HEA. The spoiler, combined with clunky plotting and some repetitive paragraphs and continuity errors, might have me jumping ship on this series.
I also have some doubts about the consent between Abbie and Matthew when they are intimate.
There are only two books published now, but I’m not sure if I can hang around for the next five brothers to get their HEA. The spoiler, combined with clunky plotting and some repetitive paragraphs and continuity errors, might have me jumping ship on this series.
January 8, 2018
Visit my blog for more reviews: Sportochick's Musings
I love the Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen series. Each book is so unique and nothing like the other book to the series. The Author Hannah Howell has always specialized in robust characters that draw the readers into the story and this book is no exception. Filled with rich details of the surroundings and scenes one feels like they are back in time.
Matthew is certainly an interesting male character. His heart is a peaceful one and I find it quite rewarding how he survives the civil war as a Lieutenant with his beliefs intact.
Abigail's character is rich and robust. A woman that draws the reader into the story by her strength and ability to be strong no matter what. The author does a superb job of showing her weaknesses without making her weak.
There are many characters in this book each one is fully developed and interesting making a delightful read for all readers. But by far my favorite one is precocious Noah who is four years old going on eighty. He adds the much needed humor to this otherwise serious book. And what I mean by serious is the fact it takes place during the civil war where so many people are lost. He caused me to laugh out loud many times throughout the book and I would love to see what type of man he grows up to be.
I give this 5 STARS for being so well written.
Received an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review.
I love the Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen series. Each book is so unique and nothing like the other book to the series. The Author Hannah Howell has always specialized in robust characters that draw the readers into the story and this book is no exception. Filled with rich details of the surroundings and scenes one feels like they are back in time.
Matthew is certainly an interesting male character. His heart is a peaceful one and I find it quite rewarding how he survives the civil war as a Lieutenant with his beliefs intact.
Abigail's character is rich and robust. A woman that draws the reader into the story by her strength and ability to be strong no matter what. The author does a superb job of showing her weaknesses without making her weak.
There are many characters in this book each one is fully developed and interesting making a delightful read for all readers. But by far my favorite one is precocious Noah who is four years old going on eighty. He adds the much needed humor to this otherwise serious book. And what I mean by serious is the fact it takes place during the civil war where so many people are lost. He caused me to laugh out loud many times throughout the book and I would love to see what type of man he grows up to be.
I give this 5 STARS for being so well written.
Received an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review.
August 11, 2018
Maybe Zero if it was a rating
December 22, 2017
3.5 stars, rounded up. I liked this book, but I didn't love it and I probably wouldn't read it again.
The story opens with Matthew MacEnroy and his men staking shelter from Rebel forces at a farmhouse. The house is the home of Abigail Jenson and her parents. When the Rebels arrive, Abbie races inside to warn her mother and father.
Weeks earlier her family was attacked, her brother was "pressed" into service, her father beaten and her mother violated, Abbie was spared because she had hidden. Her father is near death and her mother is mentally unstable. When she enters the house, Matt and his men are there, but she soon realizes that they are going to help her. Abbie tries to warn her mother, but the woman will not listen. Abbie is a crack shot and impresses Matt with her ability. When one of his men is wounded, she cares for him, but is not able to save her parents. The Rebels set the house afire and there is nothing Abbie can do to save them or her home.
Matt offers to take her to the town where his company is stationed and will no other options, Abbie agrees. When they arrive at the town, Abbie is taken to the "Benton House" which houses various war widows and orphans. Abbie settles in and even begins to assist the doctor. She and Matt do not have a lot of interaction at this point in the book - but they are both attracted to the other. This part of the book focuses more on Abbie's relationship with the women and children in the house, especially her roommate Julia. Julia is in love with Robert, one of the soldiers stationed at the camp and they plan to marry. When it becomes obvious that Julia is expecting a child, Abbie tells her she must marry now. Robert and Julia marry and then tragedy strikes.
Matt and Abbie have been spending time together, Matt knows he is interested in her, but is not sure if he is ready to marry or if what he feels for her is more than lust. When they are alone, the passion between them is undeniable, and they become intimate but they are constantly interrupted. When they slip away together a few days after the wedding, they spot a band of men sneaking up the river. They rush back to town to warn the others and then a battle ensues, in which Robert is mortally wounded. Julia is brought to his side and is inconsolable when he dies. Her grief is consuming and causes her to go into labor. When her son is born, Abbie hopes it will be enough to drag her out of her grief - but it isn't and when the town is attacked again, Abbie finds Julia near death on her husband's grave. She takes Julia home and goes for the doctor. At the medical tent, she asks the doctor to check on Julia and then learns that Matt has been wounded. She tends Matt while the doctor takes care of Julia. Sadly, Julia is dying and she begs Abbie to take care of her son. Abbie agrees and when Julia passes, she has her buried next to her beloved Robert.
Soon after, the company of soldiers is commanded to move south, Matt is told to go home, his commission is almost up and Abbie is recruited to take him home. There is a heart wrenching moment when Abbie must say goodbye to Noah, one of the orphaned children. She promises she will come back for him, but with no home or husband and a newborn baby, she is not able to take him at this moment. Noah is upset and refuses to see her off.
They journey back to Matt's family and he again wonders what his intentions towards Abbie are and she wonders as well. They are attacked by marauders but manage to reach his home unscathed.
Matt's family welcomes Abbie with open arms and they too question Matt's intentions. Matt and Abbie are perfect for one another, but Matt can't seem to decide what he feels for her.
The book was good, but it was a little boring and repetitious. There is no real conflict and nothing keeping Abbie and Matt apart, except Matt's inability to decide what he wants to do with her. I honestly was not very happy with him, he took her virginity and took no precautions to keep her from getting pregnant, but didn't plan to marry her - it seemed dishonorable to me. The story drags a bit due to the lack of conflict and Matt's indecision becomes a little tiresome. But the secondary characters were good and the love scenes were steamy, there are a couple of heart breaking moments and a few surprises as well as a lovely reunion scene for Abbie. All in all not a bad book, but I had hoped for more.
This is the second book in the series, but it could easily be read as a stand alone title.
*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that was provided to me by NetGalley and the publisher*
The story opens with Matthew MacEnroy and his men staking shelter from Rebel forces at a farmhouse. The house is the home of Abigail Jenson and her parents. When the Rebels arrive, Abbie races inside to warn her mother and father.
Weeks earlier her family was attacked, her brother was "pressed" into service, her father beaten and her mother violated, Abbie was spared because she had hidden. Her father is near death and her mother is mentally unstable. When she enters the house, Matt and his men are there, but she soon realizes that they are going to help her. Abbie tries to warn her mother, but the woman will not listen. Abbie is a crack shot and impresses Matt with her ability. When one of his men is wounded, she cares for him, but is not able to save her parents. The Rebels set the house afire and there is nothing Abbie can do to save them or her home.
Matt offers to take her to the town where his company is stationed and will no other options, Abbie agrees. When they arrive at the town, Abbie is taken to the "Benton House" which houses various war widows and orphans. Abbie settles in and even begins to assist the doctor. She and Matt do not have a lot of interaction at this point in the book - but they are both attracted to the other. This part of the book focuses more on Abbie's relationship with the women and children in the house, especially her roommate Julia. Julia is in love with Robert, one of the soldiers stationed at the camp and they plan to marry. When it becomes obvious that Julia is expecting a child, Abbie tells her she must marry now. Robert and Julia marry and then tragedy strikes.
Matt and Abbie have been spending time together, Matt knows he is interested in her, but is not sure if he is ready to marry or if what he feels for her is more than lust. When they are alone, the passion between them is undeniable, and they become intimate but they are constantly interrupted. When they slip away together a few days after the wedding, they spot a band of men sneaking up the river. They rush back to town to warn the others and then a battle ensues, in which Robert is mortally wounded. Julia is brought to his side and is inconsolable when he dies. Her grief is consuming and causes her to go into labor. When her son is born, Abbie hopes it will be enough to drag her out of her grief - but it isn't and when the town is attacked again, Abbie finds Julia near death on her husband's grave. She takes Julia home and goes for the doctor. At the medical tent, she asks the doctor to check on Julia and then learns that Matt has been wounded. She tends Matt while the doctor takes care of Julia. Sadly, Julia is dying and she begs Abbie to take care of her son. Abbie agrees and when Julia passes, she has her buried next to her beloved Robert.
Soon after, the company of soldiers is commanded to move south, Matt is told to go home, his commission is almost up and Abbie is recruited to take him home. There is a heart wrenching moment when Abbie must say goodbye to Noah, one of the orphaned children. She promises she will come back for him, but with no home or husband and a newborn baby, she is not able to take him at this moment. Noah is upset and refuses to see her off.
They journey back to Matt's family and he again wonders what his intentions towards Abbie are and she wonders as well. They are attacked by marauders but manage to reach his home unscathed.
Matt's family welcomes Abbie with open arms and they too question Matt's intentions. Matt and Abbie are perfect for one another, but Matt can't seem to decide what he feels for her.
The book was good, but it was a little boring and repetitious. There is no real conflict and nothing keeping Abbie and Matt apart, except Matt's inability to decide what he wants to do with her. I honestly was not very happy with him, he took her virginity and took no precautions to keep her from getting pregnant, but didn't plan to marry her - it seemed dishonorable to me. The story drags a bit due to the lack of conflict and Matt's indecision becomes a little tiresome. But the secondary characters were good and the love scenes were steamy, there are a couple of heart breaking moments and a few surprises as well as a lovely reunion scene for Abbie. All in all not a bad book, but I had hoped for more.
This is the second book in the series, but it could easily be read as a stand alone title.
*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that was provided to me by NetGalley and the publisher*
November 29, 2017
I read this book from NetGalley in exchange for a fair review
This is the second book of a new series by Hannah Howell under the name “Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen”. I had the opportunity to read the first book, “The Scotsman Who Saved Me” earlier this year and even though it wasn’t perfect, I enjoyed it very much and that encouraged me to try the second. I was not mistaken, this book was even better than the first.
Matthew’s and Abby’s story is set in the American Civil War, the few months of it if I am not mistaken. The story begins when Matthew McEnroy, who is a lieutenant in the Union Army, find that some rebels (confederates) are attacking a cabin and that a girl is repelling the attack all by herself. This is the fierce Abigail defending herself and her parents from the same men who once took her brother away. Matthew and his men help Abby kill, wound or drive the rebels away but none of them can stop her parents from dying or the rebels from setting the house on fire. Poor Abby is left with next to nothing and alone in the world so Matthew takes her with them to the village where his company is settled and installs her in a house inhabited by women and children who’ve lost everything in the war. In that house Abby will find her purpose, looking after the wounded and the children… and Matthew fill find love. In Abby.
This is not just a love story, one of the sweetest I’ve read so far; it is also a war story and a story of survival. Matthew and Abby start a relationship in a violent world, one in which they must be vigilant at all times because there is more to lose than to win. Both of them have taken their world under their care, whether to actually protect their lives and keep them from harm or to nurture and give love where it’s needed. After reading this novel and giving it some after thought I found the contrast between the couple’s dynamics and the world around them. Matthew and Abby rarely fight each other, they almost never argue and they always talk when they find disagreements. They always listen to what the other might say and recognize each other’s skills. There is trusting between them, to a point that most of the times they don’t say a word and simply let the other take over the situation when needed. That doesn’t mean that they are not stubborn, which they are, especially Matthew, but that stubbornness is not unreasonable and never gets in the way.
Another good point about Hannah Howell how well she lets the reader into a world of suffering and loss and fear. Almost all of the characters have lost family members, a fact that is especially heartbreaking in the case of the children. The little ones are left to their own devices until Abbie comes in because the women are mourning or suffering too much to look after children that are not their own; I find that children are very important in this series. As I mentioned earlier, one in this beautiful couple of protagonists is the nurturer, and that is Abby. But please do not be mistaken, she has a way with a rifle too; you only need to ask Matthew. Lastly I should add to this point that Howell implies that some of the characters are broken on the inside. Mental issues, and post traumatic stress disorder come to mind when reading about them.
Finally the last third or so of the novel takes place at the McEnroys’ property. I had missed these lovely Scotsmen very much so when Abby takes Matthew home I was happy. Of course they receive them with open arms and the story flows as it should be, smoothly to its happy ending. I can’t wait to read the next book…
This is the second book of a new series by Hannah Howell under the name “Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen”. I had the opportunity to read the first book, “The Scotsman Who Saved Me” earlier this year and even though it wasn’t perfect, I enjoyed it very much and that encouraged me to try the second. I was not mistaken, this book was even better than the first.
Matthew’s and Abby’s story is set in the American Civil War, the few months of it if I am not mistaken. The story begins when Matthew McEnroy, who is a lieutenant in the Union Army, find that some rebels (confederates) are attacking a cabin and that a girl is repelling the attack all by herself. This is the fierce Abigail defending herself and her parents from the same men who once took her brother away. Matthew and his men help Abby kill, wound or drive the rebels away but none of them can stop her parents from dying or the rebels from setting the house on fire. Poor Abby is left with next to nothing and alone in the world so Matthew takes her with them to the village where his company is settled and installs her in a house inhabited by women and children who’ve lost everything in the war. In that house Abby will find her purpose, looking after the wounded and the children… and Matthew fill find love. In Abby.
This is not just a love story, one of the sweetest I’ve read so far; it is also a war story and a story of survival. Matthew and Abby start a relationship in a violent world, one in which they must be vigilant at all times because there is more to lose than to win. Both of them have taken their world under their care, whether to actually protect their lives and keep them from harm or to nurture and give love where it’s needed. After reading this novel and giving it some after thought I found the contrast between the couple’s dynamics and the world around them. Matthew and Abby rarely fight each other, they almost never argue and they always talk when they find disagreements. They always listen to what the other might say and recognize each other’s skills. There is trusting between them, to a point that most of the times they don’t say a word and simply let the other take over the situation when needed. That doesn’t mean that they are not stubborn, which they are, especially Matthew, but that stubbornness is not unreasonable and never gets in the way.
Another good point about Hannah Howell how well she lets the reader into a world of suffering and loss and fear. Almost all of the characters have lost family members, a fact that is especially heartbreaking in the case of the children. The little ones are left to their own devices until Abbie comes in because the women are mourning or suffering too much to look after children that are not their own; I find that children are very important in this series. As I mentioned earlier, one in this beautiful couple of protagonists is the nurturer, and that is Abby. But please do not be mistaken, she has a way with a rifle too; you only need to ask Matthew. Lastly I should add to this point that Howell implies that some of the characters are broken on the inside. Mental issues, and post traumatic stress disorder come to mind when reading about them.
Finally the last third or so of the novel takes place at the McEnroys’ property. I had missed these lovely Scotsmen very much so when Abby takes Matthew home I was happy. Of course they receive them with open arms and the story flows as it should be, smoothly to its happy ending. I can’t wait to read the next book…
April 23, 2023
Matthew and Abigail
*****SPOILER ALERT*****
Audible Premium Plus borrow. While the audiobook narrator didn't specify it seemed like there were at least 5 different POV. This is book 2 of 7 in the Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen series. There were a few times when the story repeated passages, without that it would've been a 4 star read/listen. Narrator Justine Eyre read well and I enjoyed all three of her different accents: American, Scottish, and English. Content warnings: the h parents were attacked and her brother taken; the h witnessed the death of both of her parents before their home was set on fire; the H parents were also k¡lled; war.
Abigail Jenson (I think she's 23; American) has survived a recent attack on her family's home that left her father near death, her mother forever changed, and her brother taken to serve in the war raging around them. Matthew MacEnroy (30; Scottish) is the second of seven boys and currently serving in the military. Matthew and his men assist Abigail when her home his attacked. Sadly during this attack her parents are k¡lled so Matthew insists on taking her to a nearby town where she'll live in a home for women and children. Everyone in the home is suffering emotional trauma from the war but Abigail does make a few friends and is compelled to take care of the 4 young children there. Abigail bonds with a talkative 4 year old boy who she eventually comes to raise. One of her female friends falls for a soldier, gets pregnant with his child, marries him but she becomes deeply depressed when he dies from his gunshot wound. Not long after his death she gives birth to a son and the town is attacked. Her friend begins to bleed heavily and the succor isn't able to stop the bleeding. Before her death she asks Abigail to raise her newborn and Abigail agrees. Matthew was injured in the attack. His Major sends Matthew home because he's injured and his enlistment ends in 10 days. Knowing he is still unwell Abigail is sent with him to take care of him. Abigail takes the newborn but leaves the 4 year old behind until she can secure a residence. Their travel to Matthew's home isn't without incident but they do make it. Not long after her brother returns and brings her the little boy who is now 5 years old. Matthew finally comes to his senses and asks Abigail to marry him. A few years after they're married they welcome their first child: a little girl. JP
Spice rating 3 out of 5.
1st listen 04-22-23
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 23, 2017
When You Love A Scotsman by Hannah Howell
Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen #2
This series in which Scottish men who have immigrated to America will each have the story of how they find their brides told. In book one of the series each brother is met and a bit is told about him and it then tells the story of the eldest, Iain McEnroy, and the woman he finds to settle down with. In this, the second book, Matthew’s romance with Abigail is shared.
Having read and enjoyed one of this author’s historical romances set in Scotland I was eager to begin at the beginning of this new series. I wrote in my review of that first book that it was okay and predictable but that it had great characters. This book was less enjoyable than the previous one and I am not sure if it is the issue of the American Civil War and the way it is portrayed or if it was my inability to really relate to or care about many of the characters other than very young orphaned Noah. I was unable to see what Matthew and Abigail saw in one another and wondered why Matthew was so gun-shy…at least when it came to marriage. I couldn’t understand how the two fell into a physical relationship so easily and without seeming to really love one another. I felt there needed to be more of something. Perhaps since it is a war story it needed more military action or since it is a romance a bit more actual wooing and emotion or since the McEnroys are from Scotland a bit more of the culture from there as it was incorporated into their life in America. So, I was left feeling ho-hum and so-so about this book and wondering whether or not I want to continue with the series. I think it will depend on who is next up for their story to be told and what the plotline is going to be. I did note that there were a lot of new characters added at the end of this book that could star in books of their own so this series could be just as lengthy in number of books as Howell’s Murray Family series.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books-Zebra for the ARC – This is my honest review.
2-3 Stars
Seven Brides for Seven Scotsmen #2
This series in which Scottish men who have immigrated to America will each have the story of how they find their brides told. In book one of the series each brother is met and a bit is told about him and it then tells the story of the eldest, Iain McEnroy, and the woman he finds to settle down with. In this, the second book, Matthew’s romance with Abigail is shared.
Having read and enjoyed one of this author’s historical romances set in Scotland I was eager to begin at the beginning of this new series. I wrote in my review of that first book that it was okay and predictable but that it had great characters. This book was less enjoyable than the previous one and I am not sure if it is the issue of the American Civil War and the way it is portrayed or if it was my inability to really relate to or care about many of the characters other than very young orphaned Noah. I was unable to see what Matthew and Abigail saw in one another and wondered why Matthew was so gun-shy…at least when it came to marriage. I couldn’t understand how the two fell into a physical relationship so easily and without seeming to really love one another. I felt there needed to be more of something. Perhaps since it is a war story it needed more military action or since it is a romance a bit more actual wooing and emotion or since the McEnroys are from Scotland a bit more of the culture from there as it was incorporated into their life in America. So, I was left feeling ho-hum and so-so about this book and wondering whether or not I want to continue with the series. I think it will depend on who is next up for their story to be told and what the plotline is going to be. I did note that there were a lot of new characters added at the end of this book that could star in books of their own so this series could be just as lengthy in number of books as Howell’s Murray Family series.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books-Zebra for the ARC – This is my honest review.
2-3 Stars
December 22, 2017
This is a voluntary review of an advanced copy.
I have enjoyed many of Hannah Howell's highlander books and was intrigued about this new series set in American during the civil war. I did not read the first book and after hearing some of Emily and Iain's story, I would like to read that book, and this book was great at being a standalone in case you have not read the first book.
I loved Abbie and how she was such a strong woman and so caring even after losing her family. It was great that she made a great difference in the household when Matthew brought her to stay with the stranded women. She showed such great care for the children that most of the women ignored.
The only probably I had with Abbie was she seemed so quick to end up sleeping with Matthew when she saw what happened with Julia! You would think that seeing the results of this unplanned pregnancy would be a good reminder!
Matthew was hard to like when all he seemed to care about was getting Abbie to the point where she was ready for sex with him. He didn't seem to care that she was a virgin or she might get pregnant and only seemed to care if she stayed his lover. He kept "overthinking" if she might matter more to him than a lover and was so glad that other men kept calling him on this!!
There were some pretty heavy parts to this book when so many people were killed and families lost. War is not a fun subject to read about and this book had enough to make me feel like there was a war but not too much to really overwhelm the senses. While there were many injuries and some deaths, there were happy times when someone returns alive, and when families unite.
It will be fun to read about the other brothers and where they find their brides!
I have enjoyed many of Hannah Howell's highlander books and was intrigued about this new series set in American during the civil war. I did not read the first book and after hearing some of Emily and Iain's story, I would like to read that book, and this book was great at being a standalone in case you have not read the first book.
I loved Abbie and how she was such a strong woman and so caring even after losing her family. It was great that she made a great difference in the household when Matthew brought her to stay with the stranded women. She showed such great care for the children that most of the women ignored.
The only probably I had with Abbie was she seemed so quick to end up sleeping with Matthew when she saw what happened with Julia! You would think that seeing the results of this unplanned pregnancy would be a good reminder!
Matthew was hard to like when all he seemed to care about was getting Abbie to the point where she was ready for sex with him. He didn't seem to care that she was a virgin or she might get pregnant and only seemed to care if she stayed his lover. He kept "overthinking" if she might matter more to him than a lover and was so glad that other men kept calling him on this!!
There were some pretty heavy parts to this book when so many people were killed and families lost. War is not a fun subject to read about and this book had enough to make me feel like there was a war but not too much to really overwhelm the senses. While there were many injuries and some deaths, there were happy times when someone returns alive, and when families unite.
It will be fun to read about the other brothers and where they find their brides!
August 9, 2020
I really struggled to finish this book. Most of it is just war, killing of innocent people, caring for the wounded and fighting for survival.
Lieutenant Matthew is just about done with the war between the union army and the confederates when he happened upon Abigail, who was fighting rebels trying to save her family. After the rebels killed her parents and burned her home, she has no choice but to go with Matthew to his army base where they have a house for the widows of soldiers killed in the war. There, she met with other women and she and matthew developed somewhat of a courtship. When matthew is wounded, she is then left with no choice again but to accompany him to his home to help him heal.
There is really no time for love in this story. Danger is abound everywhere and the romance is quickly done. Also it is always interrupted by someone or the other due to something.
There were too many unnecessary secondary characters taking up space that could have been used to solidify the romance between Matt and Abbi.
I feel there were too many responsibilities placed on abbi's shoulder as the heroine; looking after Julia and the kids at the widow house, being given guardianship for Julia's child after she died, helping out with the wounded soldiers, adopting noah, taking care of matt after he was wounded. Too many things going on at the same time. Not to forget the war waging all around her.
It failed to keep my interest.
Lieutenant Matthew is just about done with the war between the union army and the confederates when he happened upon Abigail, who was fighting rebels trying to save her family. After the rebels killed her parents and burned her home, she has no choice but to go with Matthew to his army base where they have a house for the widows of soldiers killed in the war. There, she met with other women and she and matthew developed somewhat of a courtship. When matthew is wounded, she is then left with no choice again but to accompany him to his home to help him heal.
There is really no time for love in this story. Danger is abound everywhere and the romance is quickly done. Also it is always interrupted by someone or the other due to something.
There were too many unnecessary secondary characters taking up space that could have been used to solidify the romance between Matt and Abbi.
I feel there were too many responsibilities placed on abbi's shoulder as the heroine; looking after Julia and the kids at the widow house, being given guardianship for Julia's child after she died, helping out with the wounded soldiers, adopting noah, taking care of matt after he was wounded. Too many things going on at the same time. Not to forget the war waging all around her.
It failed to keep my interest.
May 9, 2018
3.5 actually. My attempts to broaden my reading with the Romance genre continue despite my first encounter with the odious "My Kind of Wonderful". Despairing of reaching my goal; to read seven Romance titles, I chose the "Scotsman" sub genre in an effort to survive this endeavor. Although I'd snickered at materials featuring the plaid skirted he men, I found Hannah Howell's "When You Love a Scotsman" a much more engaging and enjoyable read even though it was set in *ahem* the American South.
I was a bit disappointed that although it featured a lusty Scotsman, "When You Love a Scotsman" is actually the story of Abigail Jenson, a young Missourian who loses her family to Confederate marauders. Saved by Matthew MacEnroy (the Scotsman), she joins a group of refugee women and children under the protection of Matthew and his Union soldier cohorts.
Matthew takes Abby out "walking" and soon makes history of her virginity. Abby also assumes responsibility for two young orphans, one an infant and one four year old Noah. As danger closes in, Matthew and Abby must make some difficult choices to survive.
So this is no "Gone With the Wind" but it's a tolerable read with mildly titillating-excuse the pun-sex.
I was a bit disappointed that although it featured a lusty Scotsman, "When You Love a Scotsman" is actually the story of Abigail Jenson, a young Missourian who loses her family to Confederate marauders. Saved by Matthew MacEnroy (the Scotsman), she joins a group of refugee women and children under the protection of Matthew and his Union soldier cohorts.
Matthew takes Abby out "walking" and soon makes history of her virginity. Abby also assumes responsibility for two young orphans, one an infant and one four year old Noah. As danger closes in, Matthew and Abby must make some difficult choices to survive.
So this is no "Gone With the Wind" but it's a tolerable read with mildly titillating-excuse the pun-sex.
June 1, 2018
What a good book. A good sequel to Iain and Emily's story, "The Scotsman Who Saved Me." I hope that the author writes about the other 5 MacEnroy brothers; it would be a shame not to. I love how close the brothers are and how they're there for each other.
Hannah Howell writes a lot of romances featuring Scottish heroes and I love them. I love the way they talk.
Abigail is a great woman for Matthew. She likes him and she likes the times they spend together while they were at the camp. I liked how Matthew bragged about Abigail. he was so proud that she was a crack shot and helped them with the muraders who attacked them. And, it seems that the whole family took to her. They accepted her as Matthew's mate.
I just love Noah. he was a 4 year old who was orphaned. He took to Abigail when she was living in the same house. Abigail felt sorry for the 4 children who were orphaned and living in that house. All the other women ignored then because, Mrs. Beaton, the woman who owned the house. She felt that children should not be seen or heard. But Abigail started to read to them and then the other women started to take an interest in them. The other women realized that the children needed interaction with the adults that lived in the house.
Hannah Howell writes a lot of romances featuring Scottish heroes and I love them. I love the way they talk.
Abigail is a great woman for Matthew. She likes him and she likes the times they spend together while they were at the camp. I liked how Matthew bragged about Abigail. he was so proud that she was a crack shot and helped them with the muraders who attacked them. And, it seems that the whole family took to her. They accepted her as Matthew's mate.
I just love Noah. he was a 4 year old who was orphaned. He took to Abigail when she was living in the same house. Abigail felt sorry for the 4 children who were orphaned and living in that house. All the other women ignored then because, Mrs. Beaton, the woman who owned the house. She felt that children should not be seen or heard. But Abigail started to read to them and then the other women started to take an interest in them. The other women realized that the children needed interaction with the adults that lived in the house.
July 7, 2018
Set in the midwest during the Civil War, this is not the usual romance from this author. It starts with Abigail Jenson holding off Rebels who are attacking her small Missouri farmstead, killing her parents and setting her home on fire when Union officer Matthew MacEnroy and his small company happen upon the scene and help her to drive the Rebels off. With nothing left, Abigail accompanies the group to the nearest town and safety, taking up residence in a house where there are single/widowed women and orphaned children and run by an uptight widow who owns the house. During her stay there, Abigail and Matthew become close which is the central theme of the story but Abigail also befriends several women and children at the home, changing their lives. Matthew, himself, is an immigrant, part of the family which came from Scotland during The Clearances and loves his adopted country. When he's injured, Abigail has to lead him home to MacEnvoy valley where their future awaits.
This author is one of my favorites and I've read countless of her books. This one unfortunately, isn't one of my favorites despite the Civil War setting. It dragged in many places and some storylines just didn't seem likely. It won't stop me from reading other books by this author though.
This author is one of my favorites and I've read countless of her books. This one unfortunately, isn't one of my favorites despite the Civil War setting. It dragged in many places and some storylines just didn't seem likely. It won't stop me from reading other books by this author though.
January 3, 2018
Abigail Jenson has had enough. Soldiers have already taken most of what is precious to her and she is not going down without a fight this time. Fortunately, some daring Scots come to her aid. Still, with her home a loss, Abigail must leave it behind and seek out a new shelter.
Matthew MacEnroy lends help to a woman who is all alone and means to move on. Fate has other plans though and Matthew finds himself remaining at Abigail's side. They must journey to his home and the road is loaded with danger. The more time Matthew spends with Abigail, the more he comes to care for her. Could Abigail ever return his affection?
I'm a big fan of author Hannah Howell. She is one of my favorite historical romance writers. Her characters and plots are always very driven and inspiring. Her latest novel, WHEN YOU LOVE A SCOTSMAN, is just okay for me, however. No offense to her writing, but this just isn't a favorite time period of mine. I took a chance on it and it is entertaining. Readers who love the war time or historicals centering around America are sure to enjoy WHEN YOU LOVE A SCOTSMAN.
Rated 3.5!
Matthew MacEnroy lends help to a woman who is all alone and means to move on. Fate has other plans though and Matthew finds himself remaining at Abigail's side. They must journey to his home and the road is loaded with danger. The more time Matthew spends with Abigail, the more he comes to care for her. Could Abigail ever return his affection?
I'm a big fan of author Hannah Howell. She is one of my favorite historical romance writers. Her characters and plots are always very driven and inspiring. Her latest novel, WHEN YOU LOVE A SCOTSMAN, is just okay for me, however. No offense to her writing, but this just isn't a favorite time period of mine. I took a chance on it and it is entertaining. Readers who love the war time or historicals centering around America are sure to enjoy WHEN YOU LOVE A SCOTSMAN.
Rated 3.5!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 124 reviews