Edit: Finishing right now, and I had to pause. For ****'s sake, the author has a real problem with not putting all of his thoughts down on the page. Often times key info is just left out, and you have to guess that something happened. Not so much in a "read between the lines" sort of way, as more in a "the lines are missing" sort of way. It's just supposed to be assumed that (spoilers)...
Alistair still has the dagger? It wasn't mentioned aside from him clutching it before reaching the Shadow King. Are we to assume that his shade carried it to his hand as it absorbed into him? Or, does the Shadow King magically have it. It's needed to make the shade army, so if Alistair still had it, it should have been left with Alster (by the way, I **** hate that their names are almost the same, it gets confusing; and, are they meant to be pronounced alike, or are they how they seem phonetically?).
Also, the plot just seems to move on as it needs, with characters just randomly deciding to go placed when it is necessary.
Edit 2: Palos' end felt particularly cruel, and unnecessary. I know we are supposed to hate him and think his own men should as well, but that is not well set up. We're supposed to find Alster's actions heroic and deserved, but I don't. It also feels very out of place, given that the book is written like a middle grade fantasy, but the ending seems very grimdark; as does the earlier reference to Elsey being young for a camp follower.
Edit 3: Yeah, the rest of the book, though better, was not enough so to raise my rating. I will say that the Epilogue seemed much better written. It must have been written later, after the author had already started writing the next book. Still, after this book, I won't be continuing with the series.
Original review: DNF'd at page 174. I was going to force myself to finish this, but I seem to have misplaced it. If I find it, I'll finish it.
That said, I wasn't enjoying it. I wasn't expecting a story written for middle graders, but that's essentially the level of quality on display. Even then, the writing isn't great, and it could use an editor badly. I was hoping it would get better, because the premise sounded really good, but as of where I got, it had not.