4 stars ⭐️ Clean Fiction - YA Fantasy (Non-magical / Historical setting)
I read this book to see more of Ella and Gavin and was not disappointed 🥹 and Kinley and Rylan grew on me as well.
I will say that Kinley was a little too…dramatic? emotional? for my tastes. She often made me wince when she would overreact or lash out. It wasn’t cute and you could tell her age because of it. I like Rylan and found him to be a dear. A very sunshine or golden retriever MMC and I wish we could have had his POV because I think I would have appreciated being privy to his thoughts and actions towards the end.
Being that this is the fifth book in the series, I knew to brace for the impact of angst around 65/70% and that warning bode well for this book as well. I do think she completely overreacted to news about Rylan, so that didn’t endear her to me towards the end. Thankfully all ends well, but I will say that her reaction was over-the-top and the angst felt a little forced compared to the other books in this series.
I do wish we could have seen more of Ella and her sisters, but I wasn’t expecting to because of this book being about Ella’s sister-in-law instead. Overall it was a solid and angst-filled series that I enjoyed—some more than others of course, but it was a good non-magical series. I look forward to reading the author’s other fairytale retelling series that is loosely connected to this series soon!
Series ranking-
1- Just Ella (#1)
2- Missing Lily (#2)
and then Books 3, 4, and 5 are nearly tied because while I'm rating this one higher, I did enjoy #4's story the most of the three but had to dock it due to some heavier kissing moments.
Main Content-
A few mentions of sorceresses; A couple mentions of wicked smiles & enjoyment; A mention of Ella and Gavin’s marriage only happening because of the “grace of a higher power”; A mention of praying (but not towards Whom).
No major language, instead minor phrases like ‘saints above’/saints, and ‘thanks be to heaven’ are said; Kinley does curse someone a few times & there’s also mentions of curses (said, not written); Eye rolling & Sarcasm; Kinley also lies once to her crush; Eavesdropping.
A young man grabs at Kinley twice (in anger) and she fights back each time (it’s not said that it was sexually motivated, but Kinley and another imagine the worse that could have happened (assault) and asks to make sure she wasn’t hurt elsewhere); She sobs partially because of the second time and other things going on; The young man gets pummeled and threatened by both Kinley and the men in her life.
A neighbor of Kinley’s family is an older man who has “delusions” about thieves stealing his chickens or wolves being nearby and causes problems including a fire.
Rylan talks about his father tolerating him and their strained relationship.
A fire, smoke, & grief (a handful+ of sentences).
Mentions of thieves, thefts, & stealing; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of hatred; A few teasing mentions of murdering or killing someone (usually in annoyance); A couple mentions of gambling; A couple mentions of drinking & wine; A mention of a gruesome drawing of a lion eating an antelope.
6 hand/fingers/palm kisses,
2 head/forehead kisses,
2 cheek kisses,
1 nose kiss,
A few not-detailed kisses,
4 kisses lasting a sentence each,
3 kisses lasting a couple sentences,
1 kiss lasting a few sentences,
1 kissing session lasting a few kisses & a couple paragraphs (8+ sentences) in length;
Staring at lips, Remembering kisses, & Wanting to kiss/be kissed (all up to a few sentences).
Touches, Embraces, Dancing, Hand holding, Warmth, Shivers/Tingles, & Nearness (up to a handful of sentences); Remembering touches, embraces, dancing, & nearness (up to a few sentences); Blushes & Flirting; Noticing & Staring (including at muscles, up to 2-3 sentences).
When Kinley adjusts Rylan’s clothing to make him look more like a commoner, he teases her that she’s undressing him; Rylan accidentally says that Kinley looks like his horse when he needs a rubdown (which Kinley asks if he realizes how that sounds and he is embarrassed and apologizes); Kinley thinks at one point that Rylan looks “delicious”; Kinley calls a woman a trollop (due to her jealousy).
A young man has a reputation that he earned by being a philanderer/rake/rogue (called all of these names) and entrapped more than one girl, but he says that will be deserved that reputation, he’s changed and no one believes him.
Many mentions of flirting, flirts, & different young men having reputations of flirting, kissing many girls, and (Kinley’s second brother is known to be a flirt and broken many hearts; She admonishes him often about it); Mentions of kisses & kissing; Mentions of jealousy; Mentions of crushes & blushes; A few mentions of a widower with many children possibly being interested in Kinley; A few mentions of Kinley mooning over a guy; A couple mentions of a man looking like he is womanizing; A mention of a married couple kissing.