The Fact of a Body

by Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich

Before Alex Marzano-Lesnevich begins a summer job at a law firm in Louisiana, working to help defend men accused of murder, they think their position is clear. The child of two lawyers, they are staunchly anti-death penalty. But the moment convicted murderer Ricky Langley’s face flashes on the screen as they review old tapes—the moment they hear him speak of his crimes -- they are overcome with the feeling of wanting him to die. Shocked by their reaction, they dig deeper and deeper into the case. Despite their vastly different circumstances, something in his story is unsettlingly, uncannily familiar.

Crime, even the darkest and most unsayable acts, can happen to any one of us. As Alex pores over the facts of the murder, they find themself thrust into the complicated narrative of Ricky’s childhood. And by examining the details of Ricky’s case, they are forced to face their own story, to unearth long-buried family secrets, and reckon with a past that colors their view of Ricky's crime.

But another surprise awaits: They weren’t the only one who saw their life in Ricky’s.

An intellectual and emotional thriller that is also a different kind of murder mystery, THE FACT OF A BODY is a book not only about how the story of one crime was constructed -- but about how we grapple with our own personal histories. Along the way it tackles questions about the nature of forgiveness, and if a single narrative can ever really contain something as definitive as the truth. This groundbreaking, heart-stopping work, ten years in the making, shows how the law is more personal than we would like to believe -- and the truth more complicated, and powerful, than we could ever imagine.

Genres: Nonfiction, True Crime, Memoir, Crime, Audiobook, Mystery, Biography

352 pages, Paperback

First published May 16, 2017

About the author

Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich is the author of THE FACT OF A BODY: A Murder and a Memoir, named an Indie Next Pick and one of the most anticipated books of 2017 by Buzzfeed, BookRiot, and the Huffington Post as well as a must-read for May by Goodreads, Audible.com, Entertainment Weekly, and Real Simple. Currently out in the US and UK, it is forthcoming in the Netherlands, Turkey, Korea, and Taiwan. The recipient of fellowships from The National Endowment for the Arts, MacDowell, and Yaddo, and a Rona Jaffe Award, Marzano-Lesnevich lives in Boston, where she teaches at Grub Street and Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government.

Reviews

[Colin · Rating 2 out of 5]

As I was nearing the conclusion of this book, I dreaded the prospect of reviewing it. As is obvious to anyone who has read the book, its subject matter and the author's personal experiences make it difficult to criticize. So before going further, I would like to make clear that my dislike of the book is not rooted in the author's personal memoir or her meditations on how her childhood traumas shaped her. I truly hope that this book was cathartic for her and enabled her to find peace. If it did that then it more then justified its own existence.

Nevertheless, I as a reader I did not enjoy it. Now this in and of itself would not automatically preclude a good review. There are plenty of books that were painful to read but I nevertheless recommend because of the ideas contained within. Unfortunately, my dislike of this book went beyond mere lack of enjoyment and when I finished, I could not help but feel that the book felt shallow to me.

This seems really harsh, so allow me to attempt an explanation. Tragedy is really hard to write about. And personal tragedy is sometimes impossible to write about. Here, the author attempts to write about both--one personal, one she encounters as a law school student--and connect the two. This could have resulted in a symbiosis that lead to greater insight into both, but here it just didn't.

I work in criminal justice and have unfortunately encountered a lot crimes perpetrated against children. As such, I have repeatedly encounter a phenomena that I sensed here. People who encounter these events want these events to make sense. They want meaning. They want poetry. They want to look at child molesters and find some deeper reason or explanation for such horrors. Unfortunately, that is not reality. When it comes to people and acts like that, its turtles all the way down.

This is the nagging problem that made me respond so negatively to the book. The author reminded me of so many people that always seem to cluster around these tragedies looking to transpose meaning on an event that is either meaningless or containing a meaning that is far beyond human comprehension. In my more cynical moments, I call it tourism. This is probably unfair, but it is also the reason the book rang so hollow to me.

The author is a victim of a terrible tragedy and deserves understanding for that, but it does not indemnify her from my belief that she took someone else's tragedy and used it for her own ends and desires. She inserts the thoughts and feelings of the participants of this tragedy without ever really knowing them and reconstructs these emotions through, by her own admission, her imagination. This does not appear to be the exhaustive product of countless interviews, but rather her assumption about these people and how they felt. It just seems wrong to me.

This may not make a lot of sense, but its how I feel. There are good books written about these sorts of issues, but this one didn't make it. The author is impaired by her own lens of experience, and, as a result, I never felt like she was able to penetrate the matter in a way that rang true. In the end, all the author seems to conclude that no person is the sum of a single attribute or action. While this is certainly an absolute truth, this conclusion is like the book to me: something that seems a lot deeper than it actually is.

[Mike Scalise · Rating 5 out of 5]

If you are a fan of true crime, this book is excellent. If you are a fan of memoir, this book is excellent. If you are a fan of legal thrillers, this book is excellent. If you are a fan of beautiful language, this book is excellent. If you are a fan of page-turners, this book is excellent. If you are a fan of boundlessly empathetic storytelling and brilliant questions about the meaning of acceptance, this book is excellent. If you are a fan of a scene in which one character manages, maybe, to have sex while in a body cast, this book is excellent. If you are a fan of all of these things together, you have to read this book. It is excellent.

[Diane S ☔ · Rating 4 out of 5]

4+. Powerful and emotionally raw, I have never read anything quite like this before. Pedophiles and the harm they cause, the lasting effects on their victims, whether in family or without, the subject makes this a difficult book to read. As a law student the author comes across a case involving the death of a six year old and the offender, at the time on death row, a young man named Ricky. Although she doesn't believe in the death penalty she is shocked to find how much she wants this man to die. It triggers memories of the abuse within her own family and she sets out to understand​, both Ricky's case and her own family and what lived within the confines of supposed love.

This story is so personal, we feel as if we are travelling with her as she makes her discoveries, witness her pain and anguish, feel with her as she tries to understand. The secrets held in her own family, passed down through generations, and her attempt to understand what makes someone sexually prey on others. The subject matter maybe a trigger for some, it is quite vividly presented, often looked at through the eyes of the child she was, absolutely devastating and heartbreaking.

I do believe stories like these need to be told, not just as a catharis for the teller but as a way to bring these things out in the open, start a dialogue so others are not afraid to speak. Narrative nonfiction, mixed with a memoir and even some fiction writing, but it is done skillfully and honestly.

[Elyse Walters · Rating 4 out of 5]

"The Fact of a body: A Murder and a Memoir".....the title of this book becomes an 'acute awareness' of what this book is about - -the deeper we are pulled into this debut:
This book is about a real murder that happened in the year 1992. A six year old child, Jeremy Guillory, was molested and murdered by Ricky Langley.

This book is also a Memoir. We get a very personal -intimate -' private-as-private-is', up and close 'factual' and 'emotional' account from what author Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich shares with us about her life.

While the 'facts' are being spelled out to us -- a crime investigation over a 10 year period - and 'specifics' about why, what, when, and how things were for Alexandria Mariano-Lesnevich....become much more than 'facts' to us.
Reading this book SHAKES YOU - It RATTLES our insides.

One of the most powerful-moments for me -- written beautiful- was 'very' personal.
The author had just shared about 'coming out'. She was gay. She was in bed with her partner - in the beginnings of sex. Sex was going terrific- until it wasn't. Alexandria was going under, into a memory. I MUST HAVE READ THIS SECTION 4 or 5 times....
a couple of pages.....I've HAD SIMILAR EXPERIENCES......( I'm not talking about sex - I'm not gay and I've never been molested)..... I'm talking about a memory taking you under: - it's a 'strong- stronger than strong' feeling.
I haven't had that experience in years..... but I've never read ANYONE describe the experience like Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich did in this book:

"Where does the mind go in these moments, while the body trembles? For me it is a white-hot slipstream blank-out, the nothingness I have no time and nowhere and no one. It use to be a feeling, a single concentrated excruciating feeling: ........."
I'm NOT GOING TO SHARE ALEXANDRIA'S SPECIFIC MEMORY IN THIS REVIEW..... it's too personal....

But......here is another 'part' of this past memory. An overwhelming memory can come on strong taking power away from whatever present moment a person finds themselves in:

....."But as the years have blotted the origin out - I am grateful- they have a blotted the sensations, too, as though the film reel of the memory has been played so many times it has gone torn and blotched".

It's very hard to put this book down - it's raw - it pulls on your heartstrings - but after I finished reading it - I went back to the beginning and had questions about this excerpt:
"As such, this is a book about what happened, yes, but it is also about what we do with what happened. It is about a murder, it is about my family, it is about other families whose lives were touched by the murder. But more than that, much more than that, it is about how we understand our lives, the past, and each other. To do this, we all make stories."

"We all make stories"......hm??? So what stories were made up in this book? I don't know. It's this line .... "we all make stories"... that left me with an 'after-thought' about this book. I was definitely 'sucked in' from beginning to end....but I started to wonder if perhaps parts of this book were possibly overstated. I have no way of knowing but doubt began to enter my mind. I still was turning the pages heavily though!

Very unique fusion style of story blending

4 stars

[Brina · Rating 4 out of 5]

Fact of the Body: A Murder and a Memoir is one of the books chosen for the nonfiction book club on goodreads this summer. I enjoy reading mysteries, true crime, and memoirs so I found the concept of this book to be intriguing. In a book that is a mixture of true narrative and personal recollections, Fact of the Body is an intricate web of emotions that come to a nexus when investigating a horrible crime from multiple angles.

Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich had overcome long odds and made it into Harvard law school. After her first year there, she gained an internship at the law offices of Stafford Clive near Lake Charles, Louisiana. The office was the lead defense counsel of convicted pedophile Ricky Langley who had gained a second trial ten years after his first had landed him on death row. Accused of killing and molesting a six year old, Langley's counsel fought to keep him from the death penalty, either with a conviction of life in prison or by reasons of insanity. Marzano-Lesnevich had chosen to enter the law not just because both of her parents were lawyers, but because she was morally opposed to the death penalty; until she became exposed to the Langley case and churned up ghastly images from her childhood.

As a surviving twin in a set of triplets, Marzano-Lesnevich barely made it out of infancy. Then the unthinkable happened-- her grandfather molested both her and her two younger sisters. While the images aren't gruesome they are tough to get through, especially for a parent of girls. Scarred emotionally and physically for life, she could never forget the baggage from her past, while her parents and sisters chose to cover up what had happened and move on. It is not my place to question the parenting skills here, but Marzano-Lesnevich's family appears dysfunctional at best, and she became a loner, and later in life could relate to a convicted pedophile like Ricky Langley.

Langley himself was the product of a fractured family, his parents and surviving siblings overcoming a horrendous car crash which killed two siblings and left his mother severely disabled. Yet they survived as best as they could, living with family in Iowa, Louisiana. Ricky was a miracle baby but was either abused or ignored as a child. One could almost feel sorry for him that is until he admired to molesting children simply for enjoyment from the time he was nine years old. That Marzano-Lesnevich could relate to him on any level was tough to swallow, and the sections about Langley and the crimes he committed were both repetitive and heinous. As a result, I read fast not because I was excited to find out whodunit but because by the two-thirds point I was ready for some of these gruesome memories to be over.

Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich has created a multi-layered, complicated premise for a book combining memoir and fact. Weaving two different instances of child molestation with entirely different outcomes, she attempts for the reader to sympathize with both the offender and the victim. While this might have worked for me when she described her own story, I had little sympathy for Ricky Langley, as tough as his childhood might have been. Fact of the Body might be ushering in a new eclectic genre of book but the fusing of stories here did not work for me, especially with the sometimes gruesome images. I imagine that if this was not a group read I would not have read it. A compelling story nonetheless, I rate Fact of the Body 3.5 stars.

[Barbara · Rating 3 out of 5]

WARNING: This review contains information that's mentioned in many discussions of the book, but some readers might consider the revelations spoilers. So - If minor spoilers bother you - stop reading now.



Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich

"The Fact of a Body" melds the true crime story of child molester/murderer Ricky Langley with Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich's tale of being sexually abused as a child.


Ricky Langley

In 1992, Louisiana resident Ricky Langley killed his six-year-old neighbor, Jeremy Guillory, and - after being convicted by a jury - was sentenced to death.


In 1992 the body of Jeremy Guillory was found in his house


Ricky Langley was arrested for Jeremy Guillory's murder


Ricky Langley was convicted of killing Jeremy Guillory

During his retrial a decade later Langley was defended by Clive Stafford Smith, a staunch opponent of capital punishment whose law firm specializes in death penalty cases. This time Langley got life in prison. (Note: Ricky had yet a third trial, years later, and was once again sentenced to life.)


Civil rights attorney Clive Stafford Smith

After Langley's second trial, in 2003, Harvard law student Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich - who opposes the death penalty - became a summer intern at Clive Stafford Smith's law firm in New Orleans. During her orientation, the intern was shown Langley's taped confession from 1992, in which the murderer - a diminutive man with coke bottle glasses and jug ears - graphically described the crime.....and talked about molesting children: "Sometimes I, you know, rub my penis on them."



Marzano-Lesnevich's mind immediately snapped back to her childhood. She recalled how, from the time she was 3-years-old, her grandfather - when babysitting - would steal into her bedroom. He'd tug up her nightgown, pull down her panties, undo his fly.....and then her mind would go someplace else as she stared at her yellow lampshade.



While Marzano-Lesnevich was watching Langley's tape, she wanted the child molester to die.

After completing law school Marzano-Lesnevich decided not to practice law. Instead, she became a writer, and elected to tell Ricky Langley's story.....and her own.

To make sense of Ricky's life and behavior the author thoroughly researched his history - going all the way back to the courtship and marriage of his parents, Bessie and Alcide.


Bessie and Alcide Langley

The writer learned that Ricky was conceived while Bessie was in a full body cast after a horrific car crash - an accident that killed two of the Langley's small children. Bessie was drinking heavily and taking a cornucopia of drugs while expecting Ricky - and was advised to terminate the pregnancy. Bessie refused, and gave birth to a boy who had problems all his life.

Marzano-Lesnevich narrates the story of Ricky's life. As a child he lived with a semi-invalid mother (her leg was amputated), a hard-drinking father, and four siblings. The Langley's could never make ends meet and had to move in with Bessie's sister and brother-in-law, devout Pentecostals with a strict spartan lifestyle: no music, no television, no booze (theoretically), and lots of talk about God.


Young Ricky Langley grew up in difficult circumstances


The house where Ricky Langley lived

Ricky was an odd friendless child who admits that he started molesting younger kids when he was nine-years-old. Ricky claims that he always knew something was wrong with him, and - as a young adult - tried to get help on several occasions, to no avail. Unable to control his compulsions, Ricky even attempted suicide. Finally, at the age of 26, the misfit became a murderer.

The summary above is the 'nutshell' version. In the book, Marzano-Lesnevich provides (what feels like) a week by week account of Ricky's life, with admittedly fictionalized components, including: descriptions of what people were wearing; what they were doing; what they might be thinking; what they were looking at; conversations they had; what they were drinking; whether sweat was rolling down their faces; and so on. The author also includes a detailed description of young Jeremy's murder, the extensive search for the missing boy, the police finding his body, and - finally - Ricky's arrest and trials.

Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich's personal story is interwoven with Ricky's tale. The author talks about growing up in New Jersey with two lawyer parents and two siblings - one a twin brother.


Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich grew up in New Jersey

The family was upwardly mobile, had a nice home, and went on yearly vacations to Nantucket or more exotic destinations. Young Alexandria's parents had an active social life and - when they went out - would ask the children's maternal grandparents to watch the kids. And that's when grandpa would molest Alexandria or her sister Nicola.

Grandpa would take out his false teeth, make a scary face, and tell Alexandria he was a witch who would 'get her' if she told on him - which terrified the child into silence. Even so - when Alexandria was about 8-years-old - her parents found out about the abuse when Nicola talked about 'sitting on Grandpa's lap.'



The parents learned the truth, BUT NOTHING HAPPENED. The heads of the family didn't call the police, didn't confront the predator, and didn't discuss the situation with the children. Instead, Alexandria's folks pretended nothing had happened. The grandparents still visited frequently, though grandpa was never again left alone with the children.

The molestation - and subsequent silence - scarred Marzano-Lesnevich for life and had a devastating effect on her relationship with her entire family - especially her parents and grandparents.



When Marzano-Lesnevich got older, the memories of abuse also made it difficult for her to sustain romantic relationships or to be intimate with her partners.

Again this is the 'nutshell version.' In the book the author describes her childhood, and much of her young adulthood, in great detail, including the emotional (and physical) damage she suffered - and still endures. It's clear (to me) that Marzano-Lesnevich's mother and father mishandled the situation and compounded the damage caused by the sexual abuse. It's hard to fathom exactly what her parents were thinking, but this kind of 'secret keeping' is probably common within families. After all, to reveal the truth would destroy the grandparents lives. What would your parents have done in this situation? What would you do? (This would make a great topic for book club discussions.)

"The Fact of a Body" has garnered many stellar reviews and has been heralded as a 'must read.' That said, I'm not as big a fan as many other people.

First, I didn't see a real connection between Ricky's story and Marzano-Lesnevich's story. It's true that Ricky abused children and Alexandria was molested, but the situations aren't analogous.....and the author's attempt to segue between the separate crimes doesn't work (for me). It feels like two separate books have been stuck together, somewhat like an old Reader's Digest anthology. Moreover, the fictionalized details of the narratives - especially Ricky's - seem to serve little purpose, and detract from their verisimilitude.

That said, I admire Marzano-Lesnevich's extensive research into Ricky's life and crimes. The author spent years preparing to write this book: she read thousands of pages of documents; listened to numerous taped recordings; interviewed people who knew Ricky; traveled to the killer's homes, jobs, and haunts; and even visited the convict in prison.


Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich with her books

My final thoughts: the book tells two compelling true crime stories and I'd recommend it to readers who enjoy that genre.

You can follow my reviews at https://reviewsbybarbsaffer.blogspot....

[Canadian Jen · Rating 4 out of 5]

A memoir and a Murder. Two separate lives that disturbingly cross over. Two lives that live with past horrific secrets that have hauntingly shaped who they are.

One a murderer. One a law student. Marzano-Lesnevich is a law intern when her path crosses with Ricky Langley, child molester and murderer, on death row. With her own molested past, she seeks to understand this boy child who did to children what was done to her. Rather than hate, which can be done so understandably easily, she chooses to understand why. Seeking answers through his past to help her understand what happened to her. A victim; a predator. An obsession.

This is raw. She puts forth a Herculean effort that most would or could not do. Empathy for a child molester is what she creates. Confronting our own discomforts and emotions.

I share her same conviction “that everyone is a person, no matter what they’ve done, and taking a human life is wrong.” Maybe I would feel differently if someone I loved was harmed by another; if I was harmed. Maybe I wouldn’t live by this ideal. I hope never to find out.
4⭐️

[Susan · Rating 5 out of 5]

It is hard to categorise this book – partly, it is the disturbing story of a murder, but it is much more than that. Part memoir, written almost as a novel, this is a painful, thoughtful account of a crime and how it affected those involved , but also how it changed the life of author Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich. The author is the daughter of a lawyer and, as long as she can remember, she recalls being fascinated by the law. At the age of twenty five, she went to New Orleans to fight the death penalty, by interning with a law firm that represented people accused of murder.

The author believed her views and opinions were set in stone, but then she meets Ricky Langley, who is facing the death penalty for the murder of six year old Jeremy Guillory. Jeremy was the son of a single mother, Lorilei; who was pregnant with her second child when Jeremy went missing. Marzano-Lesnevich entwines the story of Lorilei and Jeremy, with that of Ricky Langley and with that of her own life.

I have no wish to give spoilers in this review and you need to read this book in order to discover the links between those involved. However, this is a book about how the past impacts the present. About how families have secrets and how life is not as clear cut as we imagine it to be. There are grey areas which, unlike in a novel, are not easily wrapped up, completed, finished or put away. We carry our life experiences with us and they colour our opinions, shape our present and influence our future. This is a beautifully written, very moving book, in which every person touched by events are dealt with sympathetically and with respect. I am glad that I read it. I received a copy of this book from the publisher, via NetGalley, for review.

[Emma · Rating 5 out of 5]

Blending the best facets of history and historical fiction writing, this memoir of both the factual and imagined past bring alive the murder of a young boy, Jeremy Guillory, by a confessed pedophile, alongside the author's own sexual abuse by her grandfather. It's not easy reading but it's exceptionally well written. Despite having an opposition to capital punishment that was fundamental to her decision to study law, her introduction to this death penalty case while working as intern led Marzano-Lesnevich to a difficult decision, that she actually wanted this particular man to die. Her personal experience and her obsession with this case interweave as a journey towards understanding.

Above all, the book addresses the complexities inherent in evaluating our own histories and those of others. Truth is a slippery concept, our memories change, stories are modified, facts are chosen for the narrative we wish to present or to hide things we wish to forget. As the author says, where we start the story can affect how we feel about the ending. Ricky Langley admits to killing Jeremy, but does it matter if he didn't mean to? What if he was abused as a child himself? What if he abused Jeremy before killing him? What if he repeatedly asked for help, to be put away or killed before he harmed a child, and never received any help? What if he was psychotic at the time? Do these things change how we feel about his crime? In the law courts each side presents the best version for their case, it's the jury's job to decide which is more true. This book asks us whether this things matter and whether someone should die for the crimes they've committed. It asks whether all the extra bits matter. It demands a personal response: what would we do? What do we think? Fittingly, I had a layered and uncertain response to the complexity the author presents. Ricky Langley's crimes made me feel sick, I can only imagine the pain and confusion of Jeremy's experience. His death necessitates a just punishment. And yet, it would never have happened if Langley hadn't been brushed off by multiple authorities when he asked for help. I think Langley knew what he was doing was wrong, I think he would never have stopped unless someone stopped him, and I think someone should have done it before a child was horrifically murdered. Does he deserve to die for that? Maybe. I don't disagree with the death penalty on principle but I wouldn't want to be part of it myself, and that's more than hypocritical enough to be a problem. I leave the book with more questions than answers, about myself as much as anything else.

While she has constructed her own narrative for the purposes of the book, Marzano-Lesnevich has tried to be as open as possible about the multitude of stories and sources that form the story as well as the limits of memory. In imagining the bits in-between she has given the reader a clearer 'what might have been' than lists of facts could achieve. It has an ancient precedent, Thucydides sought evidence for his work but also used imagined speeches in his History of the Peloponnesian War, filling them with 'what was called for by each situation'. It allows us to think of the life and emotion involved, arguably as important as bare bones detail. It certainly leaves a lasting impression, and makes this one of the most thought provoking books i've read in a long time.

ARC via Netgalley.

[Chelsea (chelseadolling reads) · Rating 4 out of 5]

Maybe a 3.5 but rounding up because this was really well written. I need to sit on my thoughts about this one for a minute before I give a concrete review because there is SO much to unpack in this book.

[Svetlana · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was not a 4 star for me but rather 3.75 **

So.. this took me a while to read.

What I really enjoyed reading about was the murder that was committed and the disputable reasons behind WHY it was committed. This book also hugely focuses on paedophilia and I believe this is an important read because it raises awareness. One wonders, who can you truly trust?

There were times when I had to put my kindle down and contemplate what I had just read, because I couldn't wrap my head around it. Other times I would tear up at the horrific things Ricky Langley (the murderer) had done and the things the author herself went through. It was heart breaking.

Our actions, however small, can have a monumental impact on another person's life. It can shape a person entirely. It's like a chain of events - when a number of actions and their effects are linked together, they result in a particular outcome.

I didn't give it a higher rating because I felt like the author waffled quite a bit. She went on and on with her descriptions and I'd start losing interest.

Nonetheless, I recommend this book.

[Liz Barnsley · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Fact of a Body was less a non fiction narrative and more a work of art – I don’t think I have been sucked into a book in the way this one sucked me in for a good long while. Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich writes with such a beautiful, haunting quality that gets over so many layers of emotional depth whilst still keeping it factual and real, that you can one moment be feeling like you are watching events unfold in real time and the next sobbing like a baby at one small sentence that says everything.

At the heart of it all is not only this killer, Ricky Langley, but also the author herself as she delves into her own mind and her own history in an attempt to understand that which cannot be understood. She takes you along on a journey of discovery, one of unpalatable realities, poignant self realisation and historical influence, it is at turns heart breaking, utterly riveting and melancholy, get ready to be hooked, unable to look away.

The Fact of a Body often reads like a literary thriller, I found myself remembering with a jolt that these were real people living real lives – the author shows the mundane routine of living, alongside the telling events that informed eventual acts, alongside the things that cannot be explained no matter how much we may wish for a reason. Throughout the whole of the telling there are moments of quiet, occasional times you step away from the read and absorb what you have just learned – the historical detail, the absolute compassion with which the author allows the “characters” in this drama to live and breathe on the page is just stunning in its intensity. And we must not forget she is one of them – and does not hide from her own horrors simply lays them bare before us.

This is a tangled, beautiful, intelligently told true story that will surprise you, an unravelling of human nature, a truly incredible look at the power of memory, the influences of life experience and that which we hide from ourselves – as well as that it is a truly compelling and absolutely gripping crime story and family memoir.

I really cannot recommend this highly enough.

[Beverly · Rating 3 out of 5]

True crime and memoir mixed, The Fact of a Body is brutally upfront and honest about the two most heinous acts that humans can do...murder a child or have sex with a child. Neither subject is ever openly discussed when it happens and I think people would rather talk about child murderers than pedophiles, especially when they're in your own family.

Alexandria Marzano was an aspiring lawyer who had to confront her own sexual abuse from her grandfather when she learns about Ricky Langley. She was working as an intern for a group that opposes the death penalty in Louisiana when confronted with the case of the child rapist and murderer. Suddenly, she knew that she wanted Langley dead even though she had always opposed capital punishment.

The only reason I didn't rate this higher is because she fleshes out some scenarios among the people involved in the murder that she made up. She does tell when she does this, but I still felt it wasn't needed. Also, she has a resolution with her dead grandfather that felt off to me. She was brave and confronted him about the abuse while he was alive, but all criminals try to justify their behavior and he did too.

[Imi · Rating 2 out of 5]

"[B]ut over time is starts to feel appropriate, somehow, that I can't find the house. The feeling is like chasing a memory that slips from your mind just as soon as you start to grasp it. Sure, it's dangerous to read metaphor into life; sure, it smacks of a desire to read meaning into cold fact, but doesn't all of this?"

This book made me feel so terribly uncomfortable right from the start. And by uncomfortable I don't just mean in terms of the subject content, which, yes, is disturbing and harrowing to read, and rightly so, but I mean I was uncomfortable with how Marzano-Lesnevich chose to present the so-called facts. If The Fact of a Body had purely been a memoir focused on the author's horrific experiences in childhood, I would have been just as disturbed, but not as uncomfortable. Instead, Marzano-Lesnevich writes about two different families, two different "stories"; firstly, her own family's story of the author as a victim to sexual abuse as a child, and, secondly, an unrelated story about a convicted paedophile and murderer, Ricky Langley. This is narrative non-fiction and Marzano-Lesnevich has tried to create a comparison between the two real life crimes. This fictionalising of real-life people and events (the author writes as if she imagine the internal thoughts, emotions and motives of real life people) is where I have a huge problem. Like I said before, if this had been just a memoir, I could perhaps have accepted this narrative style, although I still think some of her family members may have taken an issue with her writing in this way. Some parts of the "memoir" section of the book were really strong, where I felt huge sympathy for the author and her struggle to come to terms with what had been done to her, and her desperation for her family to acknowledge the crime. However, I really did not like the fact that Marzano-Lesnevich uses the same narrative style while trying to find "meanings" and comparisons in other people's lives, namely, Ricky Langley's and his victim's family's. I'd agree with her own words that "it's dangerous to read metaphor into life", and I'd go as far as to argue that here it feels exploitative. Maybe I am being hypocritical. I've been thinking about it for a couple of days, and it's true that, for example, I've watched "true" crime TV series where an event based on people's real lives has been fictionalised and presented on screen as fact. Is that any less exploitative? Maybe not, but I'm just explaining why I felt so uncomfortable with how this particular book dealt with people's lives while being marketed as non-fiction and "fact". It's tough being so critical about a book that is clearly really personal to the author, and I hope, at least, writing this out has helped her somewhat, but I can't lie about my mixed feelings about it and I am not sure I would have read it at all had I known what I was getting myself into.

[Krystin | TheF*ckingTwist · Rating 1 out of 5]

Book Blog | Bookstagram

Oh no.

I really wanted to like this. I didn’t want to write a negative review for a book that is, in part, detailing the author’s personal experience with molestation. The heavy subject matter makes a negative review seem tacky, to a degree. And I don't want to be that asshole. But, that’s not where this review is coming from. At all.

I applaud the author’s use of writing to work through her trauma and to find an understanding of how trauma shaped her. If this book was a tool for personal peace, then really, any negative review means nothing in the grand scheme of that.

But, I am a reader and reviewer and so I’ll be honest about my reading experience, as I always am, beyond the personal aspects the author shares.

The Fact of a Body weaves two true-life events. One: the re-trial of Ricky Langley, a confessed pedophile who was sentenced to death in 1992 for the murder of his 6-year-old neighbour. In 2003, he was awarded a new trial. The intention of his attorney, Clive Stafford Smith, was to reduce Langley’s death sentence down to life in prison. Clive the Lawyer runs a law firm that specializes in Death Row cases and he is staunchly anti-capital punishment, taking on many cases where the intention is only ever to reduce the sentence, not to prove innocence.

The author begins an internship at Smith’s law firm at the same time the re-trial is starting. During her orientation, Alexandria is shown Langley’s ’92 confession where he talks about his sexual attraction to children and what he did to his victim. Alexandria flashes back to her childhood, where starting from the age of 3, her grandfather would come into her room at night and sexually molest her or her sister.

Alexandria weaves a tangible account of her childhood, her molestation, most of her young adult life and her decision to pursue law (and then not pursue it,) and her conflicted emotions around the death penalty. She talks about the emotional and physical trauma she has suffered, how it has impacted her thoughts and principles and opinions; the strain her secret and revelation put on her familial relationships, as well as romantic ones.

If you’re reading this because of your interest in true crime – as I did – then I would say it's not really that.

My problems with the book begin with the stubborn effort the author goes through to make her own trauma relevant to the case of Ricky Langley, when in reality, they aren’t similar. It’s true that there is a thread of child abuse flowing through the two events, but they aren’t analogous. The effort to present them that way was awkward and uncomfortable. It's like the author so desperately wanted to make sense of her experiences that she was forcing them into the Ricky Langley case to find some kind of meaning. It was like jamming a square into a circle.

While I have sympathy for the author and her experiences, this whole novel read like she was using the murder of a 6-year-old boy for her own purpose: to tell her story.

The fact that the author states that she made up the conversations, feelings and thoughts of those involved in Langley and his victim's lives, is just further evidence of that. Such vast liberties were taken with fictionalizing things for dramatic effect that it doesn’t seem that the author’s priority was what happened to the murdered 6-year-old, as much as it was forcing herself into a real-life tragedy she was not a part of. Like, the author was using a child's murder as a means to an end for her goal, which was to express her trauma.

That felt gross to me, exploitative and I didn’t like being involved in it. If the author had chosen to simply write a memoir, I would not feel as I do.

My other issue with this is that a campaign was waged from the beginning to make the reader sympathetic toward Ricky Langley. The author seemingly uses Langley and his actions as a stand-in for her grandfather. Like, if she can apply some kind of logic to Langley’s pedophilia then she can better understand her grandfather and therefore find closure. I get the impulse, but it was something better explored in therapy, not in a book where you are using the death of a child.

Langley’s pedophilia is presented as a “mental illness” endlessly. At one point, Clive the Lawyer sets up a discussion event where Langley attempts to explain to an audience of everyday people why pedophiles do what they do, and how they feel. It’s Langley and Clive’s hope that they can educate the general public about pedophiles, so that they are still seen as humans; so that the death penalty is off the table.

But, like…. WHO FUCKING CARES? Honestly? Are any of us interested in understanding pedophiles just to exercise our empathy a little bit further?

Maybe I truly am just an asshole, but I couldn’t care any less about being understanding of people who fuck children.

First, of all, even if pedophilia is just a “mental illness” that was somehow treatable, I don’t know of any person dealing with a genuine mental illness who would ever agree it absolves them of the shitty actions they may choose to take. But second, fucking children isn’t a mental illness, it’s a disorder that cannot be fixed. And while I think being “offended” is usually pretty useless, I was fucking offended at this conflation between mental illness and pedophilia.

I’m sorry humans are so fucked up that we breed ones who never get a real chance at a normal kind of life, but it is what it is. They like fucking children. And you can’t fix it. And they can’t be rehabilitated. And the statistics prove they re-offend at alarming rates. They ruin people. Just as they are ruined.

I don’t need to find meaning in this or sympathy in this. It’s a fact of life. It might be dark and sad and fucked up, but it exists and I don’t need to assign any emotions, other than disgust, to that.

This attempt to explain away Ricky Langley’s choices as “oh, but his mama was a drunk and he knew he was different and it made him sad! Please, take pity!” ...



With so much focus on casting Ricky as a victim and finding a tangible reason for his compulsions – told from the perspective of someone who was biased by the result of her own experiences – left the story of what happened to a murdered and sexually assaulted child, once again, as merely a backdrop to the search for someone else’s meaning.

Jeremy Guillory was 6 years old. He was strangled to death by a grown man. Langley led the police to the boy’s body and explained exactly how Jeremy died, in detail. Langley’s semen was found on the boy’s clothing. The author implies that there are unanswered questions around the boy’s death that may absolve Langley, but while there may be unanswered questions, the fact is that Langley sexually assaulted a child who ended up murdered. And he had been sexually assaulting children since he was age nine.

In the end, Clive the Lawyer wins a reduction to Langley’s sentence and the death penalty is taken off the table.

There are some interesting questions and points raised about parenting, trauma and its effects, but on the whole, I found this book to be an uncomfortable experience in projection and borderline exploitation that never truly makes the connections it was so desperately seeking.

I have sympathy for the author and can understand the desired catharsis, but I can’t get behind the way in which it was pursued. It felt wrong and self-indulgent.

I am, however, a dissenting voice when it comes to reviews of this book, so if you’re intrigued by this one, read it. Maybe you'll agree with me, maybe you won't.

⭐½ | 1.5 stars rounded down

[L A i N E Y (will be back)]

If you're one of those lucky people who still have solid faith in this thing called 'family institution', I caution you before picking this one up - the disillusionment may never be undone.

[Jeanette · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is one of the best books I've ever read that cores a murder case which resulted in a death penalty conviction. It's one of the very few which although in the end tone seems to support a strong movement toward making death penalty executions a thing of the past; STILL- it fully reveals the other side of needing and SO wanting that person to be "not alive" for the torture and horror that they initiated, and which STILL echoes throughout numberless lives' "after effects". And especially for those who HEAR the murderer admit they could and will do it again if not contained.

It's a non-fiction memoir and dual bio book that will NOT be recommended for every reader out there, regardless of your age or condition. It just isn't. It's as hard as it gets to read some of this for this kind of "eyes" and cognition of perversions. Not in the foulness of the language, but in the core of the perversion habit itself and how it echoes in the physical and mental souls of the victims throughout their lives. Many good people, much more innocent, maybe more sheltered, and vast numbers too fragile or emotional- may not be able to connote Alexandria's own experiences on a horror scale, let alone the murderer's or the victims'. Yes, the victims are plural. Not only Jeremy, the murdered 6 year old tow head. But the dozens of people in Iowa, Louisiana. And all of those of the past too that Alexandria notes in familial fashion for her own background of locations and ancestry. Those past families that added to, abetted, and didn't "see".

Having done case study work for a degree to counsel- and having also done dispatch in a women's shelter, in which domestic abuse is the main course every single day! STILL! And I use that word- STILL- again! Still, this tale hits the crux of abuse to children in degree more than I heard- as much as it also sees a particular murder in all of its layers to a point that is seldom reached in print. And never within "intake" documents or bureaucratic pages of police procedural, either.

Do I like how Alexandria relates her own case and memory? Sometimes not. But it IS hers and she tells it more harshly in parts and with more specific detail than I would wont to read or hear. So that, quite apart from the murder particulars, is something that should be warned about in this review. This is NOT for the cozy mystery or chick lit reader fare of dysfunction material. Not for those who are offended or sickened by an animal or child neglect episode or some such other retort of profanity squabble related to it. Because this describes and surrounds a human void AND an entire child sexual abuse family pattern of 3 to 4 generations (maybe more?). In real life, as it was. As it covers living people's emotional self-identity now too. And also the system of association (some would say "the village') which has here (and often in my own individual case patterns it was quite like this- THAT exact collective "we think" mentality/ mores) than enables a certain cultural/ habitual "eyes" pattern. A context which has more than a strong occasion to "not see" or "self explain" with considerable rationalization for a quizzical self sensibility when things seem "off" or "funny". Because the everyday looks "normal". And as result? Emotional feelings and love connections of other bonds then overpower for and in a group, extended family or entire surrounds neighborhood- which then holds a tilted scale of skewed moral compass to the truth of what is going on. Blindness in cognition and in actions for something that is too difficult to accept as a connection to the more visible "kind" or "nice" member or bonded beloved of a "friend" group.

It's written in a layered style that is so onion like that I find it hard to describe. You are in dozens of time periods and for at least 4 family groups in all these exact eras and childhoods. And for most of the copy, I would say nearly a third of the copy- you are within child's "eyes". It is usually Alexandria's memory but at times it can also be others who are now adults or ancestors or descendants. Time is entirely fluid. As Alexandria notes again and again- there is no specific "time" that is "now" for her. She is all of the "body" (her body in which she lives) of before and the after effect of the future too- all combined at once. She is never completely present tense.

She is now a writer. And I can't tell you much about her as a young lawyer approaching a career in defending murderers against a death penalty without giving you major spoilers. So I will just say that the read itself may seem hard, confusing, and for some possibly incomprehensible. Because it surrounds humans in conditions that are what I would describe as having/owning vast voids in their entire make up. In both the physical/mental, and psychological make ups. More than having a disease or DSM5 condition or dysfunction. It is what it is only. And what it is, it will ever be. And it's forever embedded too within learned layers of protective disguise for being what it is and wants; there is little of themselves (people of void and failures embraced) that exists apart from it. If you are the person who believes that all humans are redeemable by their very natures or that justice can be approximated in a much larger society? You may be compelled by this read and interested- but I wonder if you would be able to grasp some of its base "conclusions". Or if you will just question them as Alexandria's progression does?

Alexandria made the correct decision about her life's work in the long run. She is an excellent writer. And beyond honest and approaching hero brave core. Unlike her sister, or the murder victim's Mother, she is really able to look directly into the light of the real actions committed. In her case, it is probably a very good thing she can.

This is one of those non-fiction books in which you are THERE with Alexandria. So watch out for scars. And keep your own eyes open for all the details, connotations of giggles, "joking" or any of the stranger or loved one fall out you notice in patterns. Not just in this book, but in your own life, as well.

Some of us have been so lucky in that our birth family, or wider community, or our societal "troop" of our upbringing- was majority offensive blabbermouths. This I do know. Mine was dozens and dozens of people who had common moral compass plus immense aversion to quiet and mannerly or any custom habit of secretive and insular social interchange. That Grandmother who heard that creak of the stairs! Save us all from such positions of dependability on others or from such wonderful 5 or 6 decade length marriages. Please!

It's TWO life stories. But it also is far more.

Lastly, I have to say this as a disclaimer. I believe in the death penalty for two reasons and neither of them are revenge. But the first and strongest is that it ends the course towards MORE victims. It is the only one that does.

[Book Riot Community]

I mention this on the podcast several months ago, but I just want to reiterate how amazing this book is. Marzano-Lesnevich went to Louisiana to help work with prisoners on death row, and instead found herself questioning her opposition to the death penalty when she came across a particularly heinous crime. Her investigation into the case led to reopened memories of her own childhood trauma and forced her to face some painful truths. (This book is fascinating and beautifully written, but please be aware that there are some really brutal, possibly triggering things discussed in it as well.)

Backlist bump: No bump, just advice to mark down After the Eclipse: A Mother’s Murder, a Daughter’s Search by Sarah Perry now, because WOW.


Tune in to our weekly podcast dedicated to all things new books, All The Books: http://bookriot.com/listen/shows/allt...

[Jennifer nyc · Rating 5 out of 5]

Part memoir, part true crime, The Fact of a Body (I love the title) is an elegant treatment of pedophilia. Yes, surprisingly elegant, which makes it easier to tolerate.

The author “meets” a killer via video, during a law school externship and immediately wants him to die. Although she got into law school with a persuasive essay on the atrocities of the Death Penalty, she finds herself wanting to be the one here to apply the injection.

This man has killed his first, a six-year-old boy, who he first violated. Prior to this boy, he’d sexually molested many children. Despite this, the author is able to paint this man’s humanity, to show that his life has value, while not pulling any punches from her revulsion and horror.

While grappling with this case, memories of her own childhood surface, and she shares this excruciating process with us. This work is brave and important, compassionate yet truth-facing. If these difficult topics are something you can tolerate, I think you’ll find this tremendously worthwhile.

I won this from Flatiron Books in a goodreads giveaway, and am grateful to the author for sharing this courageous book.

[Julie · Rating 4 out of 5]

In a braided narrative that weaves true crime with memoir, Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich untangles the notion of proximate cause and the reality of personal perspective, and exposing the law as a mutable animal, born of bias and propelled by coincidence.

Marzano-Lesnevich was a young Harvard law student in 2003, interning for a Louisiana firm that specialized in defending death penalty clients, when she encountered Ricky Langley, convicted of the murder of six-year-old Jeremy Guillory a decade earlier. While viewing a videotaped interview with Langley, who may or may not have sexually abused Jeremy before killing him, the author was overcome by a single thought: she wanted Langley to die for his crime.

Her visceral reaction to a convicted child killer, one whom her law firm was fighting to keep off death row, led to an internal journey which resulted in The Fact of a Body. Marzano-Lesnevich and her sisters endured years of sexual abuse by her grandfather, a fact that was eventually known by her parents, yet never openly acknowledged. The abuse stopped, but the grandfather was not held accountable, his crimes against his granddaughters left a festering wound within the family.

I was fascinated by the author's rendering of the Guillory murder and Langley's journey from childhood to death row. A legal mind and a creative vision melded together to create a story, much of it imagined. The author assumed characters' voices and perspectives, blurring the lines of fact and fiction to tell a riveting story. It is the central premise and irony of this book: proximate cause is ultimately what the law determines as the first domino to fall in any given situation. It is what all storytellers do-determining where a story begins and crafting a plot that seems inevitable. Because so much of Langley's story was reconstructed, fictionalized, it was hard for me to accept much beyond the face value of the story, and this diminished the emotional tie to Marzano-Lesnevich's own narrative—the connection felt strained and overwrought at times. But again, this brings the reader back to the author's underlying thesis: what is the law but the crafting of stories to make a point, to win or defend against accusations in the absence of irrefutable proof.

In examining and exposing her own trauma, Marzano-Lesnevich is victim, jury and judge of a case that will forever be unresolved in the court of her and her family's hearts. The murder of Jeremy Guillory also remains an unfinished story, the truth dying with a child whose voice was silenced by a killer with a story of his own.

[Perri · Rating 2 out of 5]

The murder and the memoir made an odd combination for me. I get why the murder triggered memories for the author, but it wasn't a coherent narrative. I also didn't like how she inserted so much speculation about other people's thoughts and motives. Looks like I'm in the minority of people who thought this book just OK

[Sarah · Rating 3 out of 5]

The Fact of a Body: begins way before Alexandria starts working at a law firm. Her parents were both lawyers and she has always wanted to be one. She begins a summer job in Louisiana to help defend men accused of murder. She is staunchly against the anti-death penalty and thinks her position is clear. But as she is doing research, the moment she sees Ricky Langley's face on the screen, she is overcome with the feeling of wanting him to die.

This book is powerful and emotionally raw. I have never read anything like this. Pedophiles and the harm they cause, the lasting effects on the victims, whether in the family or without, makes this a difficult book to read. As a law student, the author comes across a case that triggers memories within her own family and what lives within the confines of supposed love. She seeks answers.

As we travel with her and witness her discoveries, we also witness her pain and anguish as she tries to understand. The secrets held in her own family, passed down through generations, and her attempt to understand what makes someone sexually prey on others. Th subject matter may be a trigger for some. I trudged through this book, even though it was very well written. It's devastating and heartbreaking, but it is done skillfully and honestly

I do believe stories like this need to be told, not just as a catharsis for the teller but as a way to bring things like this out in the open.

I understand that the author was looking for answers and sometimes you just don't get them from the people you need them from.

I don't understand why a parent or parents would not "do the right thing" in a lot of these circumstances. It can be done

Why would you not want to protect your child from hurt that lasts a lifetime ?

This was by far the most difficult review I have ever written.

[Eleanor · Rating 1 out of 5]

I cannot remember a time when I have been this perplexed about the buzz surrounding a book.

The only reason this one didn't land on my Ditched shelf is down to my curiosity about how Ricky Langley, child-murderer, ultimately fared in the courtroom.

This is really two stories: that of Langley's miserable journey from a childhood filled with tragedy to the crime that ended the life of six-year-old Jeremy Guillory and that of Marzano-Lesnevich's struggle with this case because of her own history. The deep empathy I have for her wasn't enough, though, to overcome the heavy handed way she seemed to attempt to make Langley's story her own.

This ultimately became the worst sort of creative non-fiction. At times it read more like a novel based on a true story.

Not that you need it, but you have my permission to ignore the buzz and skip this one.

[Kelli · Rating 4 out of 5]

I have to say something...so many things...about this, but right now I can’t breathe.

[Dennis · Rating 1 out of 5]

Awful!
This author tries to weave her own horrible experience with sexual abuse with death of unrelated child. She fails miserably. She tells us repeatedly that she was an intern at the law firm that defended the murderer, but she doesn't descibe any legal work on the case, other than viewing a video taped confession.
Her accounts are sloppy, and she freely admits her descriptions are from her imagination.
Finally, her interpretation of the law is just dissorted. The passage on page 282 states: "The law must determine what the story means. That's what a trial's for." First, that is the most poorly written sentence I've ever seen, especially by a Ivy-league lawyer. Second, any first year law student can explain that a trial is about determining facts that are in dispute. He said "x"; she said "y." The trier of fact determines whether it was "x" or "y" based on the evidentary rules.
But in this author's world, the trials, the law, this book, and everything becomes about her. She missed the point. Ricky Langley brutally killed a child. Sorry, Alexandria. That has nothing to do with you.

[Jessica Woodbury · Rating 4 out of 5]

Writing true crime nonfiction is a delicate task. I don't think most authors in the genre treat it delicately enough. I used to be a public defender, so I don't tend to romanticize crimes or criminals, to me they are regular people, not all that different from anyone else. Victims are just people, too. But in true crime sometimes it feels like it is not about real people and instead it's about characters and stories. I have trouble reading that kind of book because I cannot forget that these are real people and I tend to cringe and feel uncomfortable as their whole lives are spilled out for public consumption.

So I was a little skeptical when Flatiron Books sent me The Fact of a Body. But in Marzano-Lesnevich's combination memoir/true crime, every single person is handled with such delicacy and respect that reading about them feels more like an act of connection and communion than bystander gawking.

I read another combination memoir/true crime a few months ago whose title is not worth mentioning. It was such a failure that I wasn't sure what a successful version would look like. But Marzano-Lesnevich has done it. As an intern at a capital murder defense firm, M-L encounters the case of Ricky Langley on her first day. She becomes obsessed with the case, and it seems an unlikely obsession: Langley has killed (and likely molested) a 6-year-old boy. In the book, M-L slowly begins to share stories of her own life, transporting us to what appears to be a happy family with her parents and 3 siblings. It is not spoiling much to reveal that M-L was molested as a child, it is the only real explanation for her particular obsession with Ricky and the boy he killed, Jeremy. But M-L doesn't tell us this for ages, trusting that we'll get lost in the details of Ricky's crime and his own difficult life before we see the uniting thread.

Once we encounter the details of the crime committed against M-L, the book takes on a new level of importance and much of what has been shared with us begins to fall into place. Why it's so important for M-L to recreate the stories of everyone involved in the crime, reimagining them and building them for us to discover. And it explains the care with which she does so. She is looking for herself, of course, looking for the stories from her own life and the lives around her echoed.

For the most part, the author's recreations feel real and emotionally true. And if they fail occasionally, we never lose sight of the author herself and the understanding of what this story is and why she is telling it to us.

This is a devastatingly honest memoir, it's rare a writer opens themselves and their history up to a reader this way.

Readers who think they may not be able to read the story of a child murder or molestation should definitely skip it. The author does not overlook details or try to take a rosy picture and these crimes are central to the narrative. As the parent of a boy around the same age as Ricky Langley's victim there were several moments where it hit me in the gut, even though I have read my fair share of police reports and don't get easily rattled.

[CanadianReader · Rating 2 out of 5]

This is a memoir driven by obsession: the author's obsession with her parents' silence about her and her sister's childhood sexual abuse by a close family member, as well as her intense fixation on a 1992 criminal case in which a twenty-six-year-old pedophile murdered a six-year-old boy. Marzano-Lesnevich’s personal story—the memoir part—I could accept. It’s the murder part of the book that I had trouble with. The author appears to want the reader to consider the perpetrator sympathetically; the child victim of the crime essentially disappears under the weight of detail about the murderer--much of it apparently imagined and presented in a "novelistic” manner.

This book is grim and oppressive reading; I also thought it was far too long, unnecessarily repetitive, and, at times, a bit too forcedly poetic. I initially rated the book a three, but that rating did not sit well with me. On thinking it over, I really had to rate it lower.

The author states that in her mind people remain “persons” no matter what they do. I am less certain. Canadians are well acquainted with the case of 1990s school-girl killers, Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo, who committed heinous sexual crimes against 3 young teens (one of them Karla's sister) that they recorded on video. Bernardo has dangerous offender status and remains incarcerated for life. In spite of her active role in the crimes, Bernardo’s ex-wife served only 12 years in a federal penitentiary-- because of a plea bargain. Since her release from prison, Homolka has married and had children. Some say she is a changed person. I’m doubtful.

A more recent case in Ontario, Canada involved a third-grade child, Victoria Stafford, who was lured from her school at lunch by a young woman and her boyfriend. They sexually assaulted her, murdered her, and then dumped her body in a wooded area miles from where she was abducted.

When animals turn violent, they are “humanely euthanized”. However, it is considered inhumane and barbaric to euthanize psychopathic, compulsive, sexually violent humans. Humans are, it is thought, above animals. But are they?

According to Marzano-Lesnevich’s book, before Ricky Langley was born, doctors wanted to abort the fetus. His mother had been in a body cast for months after a car accident that killed two of her children. She was impregnated while in this cast. Ricky had been exposed in utero to innumerable x-rays and a multitude of likely neurotoxic drugs. His mother had also abused alcohol. I cannot help but think how much better it would have been for all if this child had never been born.

In light of the Canadian criminal cases I’ve cited above, I was not well-disposed to going over and over the details of a crime the author of this book was plainly obsessed with. The Fact of a Body is competently written. It is also sensational. The author's decision to meld the story of her own abuse by a pedophilic relative with a criminal case that she took certain liberties with—embroidering and fictionalizing aspects of it for psychological and dramatic effect--is questionable. Strangely, although she concludes her book by describing her arrival at Angola--the prison where Ricky Langley is incarcerated--only her greeting of him is described. She tells nothing about how her meeting with him went. A cop out. She also sheds little light on how her understanding of the death penalty may have evolved as a result of her personal investigation into his crime. (In childhood, she says, she was vehemently opposed to capital punishment, yet when she first learned of Ricky Langley’s crime, she did not want him to live.) All we know at the end is that she finds his being sentenced to life imprisonment for second-degree murder an “elegant” solution that somehow addresses the complexity of the situation.

Marzano-Lesnevich, who trained as a lawyer but decided against going into practice (it would have been interesting to know why), says she "fell in love with law" years before because it allowed the making of a story, “a neat narrative of events,” that “finds a beginning, and therefore cause.” “But,” she says, “I didn't understand then that the law doesn't find the beginning any more than it finds the truth. It creates a story. That story has a beginning. That story simplifies, and we call it truth.” I would say this is a fair bit of fancy intellectualizing. Many of us are under no illusion that the law is linked with or leads to the truth. It's an intellectual game in which attorneys have been known to quibble over the meaning of the word “is”.

What is clear is that Jeremy Guillory, a six-year-old child, died because he was strangled--asphyxiated. Ricky Langley could lead the police to the child’s body and explain exactly how the child died. Ricky’s semen was found on the boy’s shirt. That is the truth. What to do with the humans who do these things, many of them remorseless, simply unable to be rehabilitated, statistically certain to re-offend, is the bigger question. Is warehousing them for life the answer?

[Purple Country Girl (Sandy) · Rating 4 out of 5]

I received a copy of The Fact of a Body from the publisher, Flatiron Books.

Honestly, The Fact of a Body is not the type of book I usually read and I probably would never have considered it if I hadn’t been sent a copy by the publisher. I don’t like reading about pedophiles or about any type of abuse or violence against children. I’m not really into true crime and I rarely read memoirs, especially those dealing with abuse. The book is a combination of all this and more - part memoir, part true crime, part legal thriller. There is also a bit of fiction as the author recreates moments from the past where there is no record of what happened and where she was not present.

The main focus of the book is the author, Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich, and a convicted child murderer and pedophile named Ricky Langley. Alexandria grew up the child of two lawyers and became a lawyer herself. She is adamantly anti-death penalty and when she starts an internship in Louisiana at a law firm that specializes in death penalty cases, she is shown Langley's video-taped confession. When she sees this man confess to doing horrible things to children, she flashes back to her traumatic childhood and she knows that she wants this pedophile and murderer to die. Her beliefs are turned upside down and she decides to delve into the case files and into this man’s childhood. In doing so, Marzano-Lesnevich’s past comes into play and it definitely affects the way she looks at Ricky Langley.

In looking into Ricky’s past, the book takes a bit of an almost historical fiction tone as Marzano-Lesnevich has to fill in missing pieces and create dialogue and inner thoughts for Ricky and the people in his life. While what she creates is believable, I found it a bit odd in a memoir/true crime book. I understand her reasons for using this method to tell Ricky’s story but something about it bothered me.

It’s an extremely personal story for Marzano-Lesnevich as she recounts the trauma of her youth and the lack of supportive parents. I was angry a lot when reading the sections about her childhood. I was repulsed by Ricky at pretty much every turn. Overall, I was really uncomfortable reading The Fact of a Body. It's definitely a powerful book and Marzano-Lesnevich does a great job of bringing these two stories to life, even if they are both incredibly disturbing.

While I didn’t always agree with the fictionalizing of some of the events and people and I didn’t always feel the two stories truly connected, I think The Fact of a Body is a well-written piece of true crime and a very personal and brave memoir.

[Emily]

I'm leaving this unrated because while it was in many ways a beautiful book, it's also the most upsetting book I've ever read.

Obviously, content warnings abound. This book contains child molestation, sexual assault, murder, abuse, among other things.

Because Marzano-Lesnevich contrasts the child molester and murderer with events in her own life, there is an intimacy throughout the story. I've read true crime before, I've seen true crime documentaries, but because this book's structure it felt so much more personal, and therefor so much more horrifying.

Marzano-Lesnevich writing feels quiet. It's this quiet that left me feeling so devastated.

I'm not sure if I would recommend this. It's beautiful, but it has left me unsettled in a way that no other book has.

[Matt Quann · Rating 3 out of 5]

I finished The Fact of a Body audiobook late last week, but I've been putting off writing the review for a whole weekend. This book was difficult for many reasons, but largely because of the disturbing topics with which it deals. A trigger warning then: this is a nonfiction novel that deals with sexual assault, murder, and pedophilia in overwhelming detail. This is not to say that it is not well-written, or that it does not provide a challenging examination of abuse; however, it does not deliver the Serial-like mystery its synopsis suggests.

Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich has written a book that is so raw that I was only able to listen to it at first in 30-minute bursts. Anything longer seemed to drag down my mood with its heavy subject matter. The book is follows two stories: that of the author and the murder trials of known pedophile Ricky Langley. In addition to the harrowing nature of Langley's crimes, Marzano-Lesnevich also details the abuse she suffered at the hands of her grandfather.

Though the two narratives seem at odds with one another, Marzano-Lesnevich describes her aims later on in the book. Roughly, can Marzano-Lesnevich understand her own familial trauma through the lens of Ricky Langley and the peculiarities of his case?

It is here that the book failed to come together into something that I wanted to come back to on a daily basis. In addition to the dissection of multiple incidences of pedophilia and the awful fallout that comes of them, there's the sense that the author will never be able to find the answers for which she searches. Trying to wrangle and weave all of two histories into an emotionally comprehensible whole is an ordeal on its own, but by tackling such intense subject matter, the story is further complicated.

It's my opinion that this is partly the author's intent: life is messy and doesn't give you proper answers, so why should narrative nonfiction that is true to life be any different? In theory, I agree with this approach, but practically, it made me feel a bit like I was a fly on the wall of someone's therapy sessions. Additionally, I was a bit put-off by some of the liberties the author takes in order to put a more poetic spin on some of the players' perspectives. This will bug some of you less than me, but it is my belief that nonfiction should rarely decide to dip its toe into interpretation of a person's inner monologue.

One can't help but feel churlish in writing a review that takes aim at what is such a personal outpouring of emotion, thought, and belief. For some readers, I can see this being a book that will challenge and further the discourse for survivors of sexual abuse. I'm glad for the insight it has provided me, but I would be lying to say it was an enjoyable listening experience. It wasn't for me, but it might be for you.

Finally, I commend Marzano-Lesnevich's courage and candour in the writing of this book, and I hope that she has found some solace from its writing.