Full review, as promised! ;P
(Some spoilers, enter at your risk!)
Overall Impression
Anyone who knows me even a little bit is aware that Ilyon is my favorite modern (as in written recently) fantasy series. I love the world, the characters, and the story! It's an amazing adventure that I would recommend to almost all readers.
That said, Exiles, though very good, fell a bit short for me. I don't know that this was really Jaye's fault, more of my own personal preferences and the fact that the story had to be divided over so many POV's. (Although there were some things that I think could have used adjustment. Those, I will explain in Plot and Characters.)
I would recommend this book to mid to older teens, adults, and some families. Parent discretion advised for younger children due to several bits of mature/suggestive content. (see content guide at bottom) I didn't feel that any of this was merely for the sensationalism and was handled well, but I would suggest parents skimming through certain parts before handing to any kid under 13, especially those who haven't had the facts of life presented to them yet.
Characters
So, to be honest, it was a bit hard to judge character progression in this book for the very fact that Exiles was laid out way different from the previous three. The rise and fall of this book wasn't my favorite and the large amount of time spent with Anne's POV was really annoying to me.
I don't hate Anne, I just don't like her. In my opinion she is pretty much the flattest character of the whole series. She never really changes. In Exiles a lot of things change around her, but not a whole lot in her. And really, this has been how it is the entire series. Anne never changes. Mostly, Anne enters the scene, says something about how Goler is annoying but dangerous, flirts with Trask, and then steps out of the scene. I have never enjoyed Anne so to have such great amounts of the book focused on her when I felt that much of her screen-time would have been put to better use with Jace, Kyrin, or Daniel was pretty frustrating. It really bogged the book down for me. (Note, to achieve the plot goals there were some necessary times to focus on Anne, so those parts aren't what I'm talking about.)
Daniel was a delight! I was so excited to read his POV. I have been anxiously awaiting hearing more about him since Resistance, so to finally get his part of the story was awesome! I think having him already established in his faith was a good move. Had Jaye taken the time to show us his journey to accepting Elom and Elon it would have elongated the timeline of the story. So to have him a firm believer was a good place to start with. I really enjoyed all the parts with Daniel except for one thing. How in the world did he not see Davira's plot?!?!?!?! I mean, come on! Dude, get your head out of the clouds. I don't think it was completely in sync with Daniel's character to have him just expect that no one was going to resist his plans, he's waaaay to smart for that. But, other than that, Daniel's arc was done well in this book. I really enjoyed his character and hope to see more of him.
Jace's POV was, well, Jace. It was pretty consistent throughout the book, a few places in his heart had grown by the end of the book but there wasn't the emotional struggle that we have been used to. That was good, but at the same time his POV felt a little off to me, perhaps it was just because the layout of the plot was so different, but I didn't enjoy it as much as usual. Still, well written.
Kyrin, was pretty much the same as Jace. Except I think that there was even less changing in her. She didn't evolve or change much through the book. Which is understandable considering how many other directions this book was going. There was a lot that needed to happen, (will talk more about in Plot) and unfortunately, in my opinion, some of our main characters didn't get the screen-time/POV ratios that I would have like. I would have preferred to have 2/3's of Anne's time spent on Jace and Kyrin, because they are really who I care about most.
Also, two thumbs up on Leetra's development! I was so glad to see a softer side of her!
So, the character development in this book wasn't my favorite. There was a lot I liked, but some I didn't like as well. Over all well-written, though.
Plot
I anticipate the numerous cultures in, Exiles, being something that fans adore. I know that I loved getting to so the crete's home, it was so magical. It sounded like a much more impressive Lothlorien. SO gorgeous! The giants were interesting, (Although their sizing and the sizing of things around them was hard to picture, it felt rather inconsistent.) but a bit frustrating to me in their stubbornness! :) One of the most unexpected things for me was seeing the ryriks culture. It was awesome!
The flow of Exiles was far different from any of the other books. It began and ended with a wedding, (who's I won't say! ;P) and it was more of a 'travelling' book. As in, it jumped from place to place. There wasn't as much of a single, focused goal, which wasn't bad for what was happening in the story, but it wasn't as enjoyable of a story for me. I prefer more focused story-lines to travelling ones.
Here's the thing though, while I don't personally prefer the flow Exiles, I don't think it was wrong or bad. In fact, it was good, because it was necessary. Exiles is a turning point. This is the book that moves us from skirmishes and resistance to all out warfare. I am very, VERY excited to see what the next two books will bring. Exiles rose the stakes in unexpected ways.
The climax of the book was very good. Way different from anything in the previous books and very exciting! No matter how many times I read stories with underdog resistances, I love them!
And, y'all, I could not believe some of what happened in the end of this book. I predicted a few things, but overall, I was very surprised. (which is a good thing for me) Readers will be squealing in surprise, horror, and delight at some of the plot twists in this one! Well done, Miss Knight!
One last thing I would say is that I wished there would have been an extra chapter or two at the end. It felt rather abbreviated to me.
So, to sum up all I have said thus far in the review, there were many, MANY things I loved in Exiles. But, at the same time, in my opinion it under-delivered. This will be the first of all the Ilyon books that I rate at 4 stars. Very good, but not my favorite. Exiles is sure to enthrall many Ilyon fans, and will doubtless do well! Good story!
Warnings:
Language/Profanity: None
Violence/Frightening Scenes/Gore: There is an arena scene-not overly gory but clearly violent and horrible, MC's threatened by ryriks multiple times, character is attacked by wolves, a bone is broken, multiple injuries described-not too bad, a bad character tries to drown a main character, multiple battle scenes, a man forcefully kisses a woman.
Sex/Nudity: There is a clear knowledge that an evil character is having bedroom rendezvous with various men, this is not explored deeply nor is it just sensationalism, it is for the purpose of honestly portraying evil. An evil ryrik wishes to rape a woman, she is saved and it doesn't happen. Several comments and places are suggestive of sexual interaction.
I wouldn't recommend this book for readers under 13. Past that it really depends on maturity and personal convictions of readers. For those 13 or under I would run past a parent before reading. The mature elements do not feel purely sensational, they have purpose.
"I received this book free from the author for promotional purposes. No reviews, positive or otherwise, were required. All opinions expressed are purely my own."